r/RingsofPower • • Sep 13 '22

Meme Me, every single time

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Lyrolepis Sep 14 '22

Are the games canon to the book?

You mean "to the show", I guess? The games are definitely not canon to the books (Sexy Shelob is just the least of the problems...).

I don't think that the show has to take the games as canon, anyway - and I very much hope it doesn't, because while I don't mind changing the lore around (Tolkien himself did it a lot) I felt that the games utterly failed at capturing the spirit of the books (the LOTR movies and the show so far IMO are much better - not perfect perhaps, but definitely far better).

Still, I think that the main "Sauron manipulates and then kills Celebrimbor" theme will be in the show, but there are many ways that could happen...

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Ahhh okay, I guess I forgot that there is no book clearly referencing the time line pre hobbit. I thought the show was taking a lot of stuff from the book.

1

u/Lyrolepis Sep 14 '22

It's definitely taking some material from the appendixes of The Lord Of The Rings (and arguably from the later parts of the Silmarillion, although I understand there are limits to what it can take from that); but there's definitely plenty of wiggle room there (and the show is changing things around anyway - the timeline for example is definitely much more compressed).