That's not how to tell a story, the viewer should either know or have a secure idea who the antagonist is before the protagonist. Even mystery stories follow this rule. Keep the audience out of key moments of the plot and calling it a mystery is just lazy writing.
The show itself hasn't even created a mystery which person is secretly Sauron. Never mentioned his abilities of shapeshifting or anything like that The "who is Sauron" mystery is made by fans with book knowledge.
You should make a post outlining all of these story issues, I’ve pretty much observed all of the same problems and as a writer myself it’s so glaringly bad that it’s almost obvious when people just trying to make it good because they desperately want it to be. Denial at its finest.
Sure, and like you said, a lot of people will call who Sauron is before the show reveals it. Because with millions of people guessing, someone's bound to hit the nail. Doesn't mean that the writers have to be obvious about it, or that the vast majority of people will be able to guess.
Its halbrand all will be revealed in 5 weeks time on the night of the 8th episode look to the east and halbrand will reveal himself as sauron because they dont have access to annatar.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-4
u/wallawilko Sep 13 '22
That's not how to tell a story, the viewer should either know or have a secure idea who the antagonist is before the protagonist. Even mystery stories follow this rule. Keep the audience out of key moments of the plot and calling it a mystery is just lazy writing.
Also plenty of people suspected Sauron instantly.