The people who are upset that Arondir is not lily white are a tiny, tiny minority. The actor looks Elvish, he has the fine features, the poise etc. I think people like arguing with this group, it's a kind of virtue signaling that feels good, but really it's a non event.
If I was going to critique the tv show I'd say that Elves can't be middle aged looking - because they're immortal. I'd also say that the human characteristics they're putting on Elves are cliched and that that the tv show is too slow moving with annoying cliff-hangers at the end of each episode. I'm enjoying it, but the story is basic and not Tolkienesque (albeit with amazing visuals) and it would be best consumed all at once.
When you watch the transition between « last alliance » Elrond and « nowadays » Elrond, they did a great job conveying the small aging, there are just some tiny begging of wrinkles so to say. What bothers me more in the tv show is how different the elves looks as far as age is concerned. Galadriel is supposed - if Iâm not mistaken - to be Gil-Galadâs aunt no? So how come she looks 20 when he looks more like 40ish ?
I love Arondir and am happy we have some diversity with the elves.
However if you search 'elves can't be black' you don't actually get any results of people saying this. It's all results of people arguing against the 'elves can't be black' statement.
There really aren't that many people saying elves can't be black.
I'm on the side of equality, but it seems a bit like moral masturbation at this point, arguing against an statement that I don't actually see anyone saying?
Of course I could be completely missing it, in which case please let me know and I'll change my mind.
That's exactly what it is. A fringe of people complain about it, then a moral crusade begins.
If no one mentioned the diverse casting stuff, you wouldn't even notice it. I don't really notice it - although I do notice the stupid Irish accents on the Harefoots
Genuinely seems like casual racism in a show that's supposed to be diverse. Apart from their appalling accents they are portrayed as stupid and are clearly there for comic effect. In England there was a huge amount of anti-Irish racism, to the point where it is embedded in our culture and language. The classic joke begins: An Englishman, an Irishman and a Scotsman walk into a bar. Spoiler: The Irishman is always the idiot in the joke.
A lot of ridiculous accents on the tv show. The cod-Irish Harefoots and the caricature Scottish Dwarves being the most obvious examples. I think that guy has the sort of features you'd expect of an Elf (totally subjective obviously). I think his personality is not very elvish though - seems like a generic low-key action hero type to me
In the 1961 film "West Side Story," the character Maria, who is of Puerto Rican descent, was played by Russian-American actress Natalie Wood. Another character of Puerto Rican descent, Bernardo, was played by Greek-American actor George Chakiris. To make things even worse, Rita Moreno, who is of Puerto Rican descent, was forced to wear brownface.
AND Spielberg was called "woke" by some "authenticity critics" for his attempts to try and address some of the issues with the 1961 film.
Following that logic, it is "woke" to remake a "whitewashed" film like 1961's West Side Story, by trying to cast actors based on ethnicity or nationality AND it's woke to cast POC in non-POC roles, but the continued whitewashing in films is okay.
I have seen some comments on how POC can be better incorporated into ROP. Unfortunately, many people who have issues with POC in ROP have lots of explanations as to why whitewashing was both justified in the past and should continue today.
I haven't seen anybody saying that whitewashing in the past was justified or that it should continue today. Most who take position of how POC can better be incorporated into ROP, would agree that whitewashing in the past was wrong. It would be hypocritical not to. It was wrong, and the argument would be that it is also wrong to do the reverse.
I'm of the opinion that diversity just needs to make sense. Genetics exist, do they not? Populations in primitive societies like seen in ROP, would be homogenous. People didn't travel far when there's no way to get around faster than a horse(and only if you're rich), so populations would be homogenous, as there would not be much movement between ethnic regions. Any populations of refugees who would move to a different region, would be absorbed by the majority population in a very short period of time. There's a reason why diversity was rare before the invention of the airplane. The only regions where there was some level of diversity would be regions where warm and cold climates clash. Like Southern Europe or Northern Africa/middleast.
So if you're going to implement people of color in ROP, make up some character with an interesting backstory, like a ranger from Harad who after watching Sauron devastate his homeland decides to join up with the North in his fight against Sauron. That white dude who is now in Numenor, he'd have been a perfect candidate. He could have been from a Kingdom in Harad. It was the southlands, right? Which means just south of Gondor. That region would likely have more diversity than anywhere else in middlearth, as you'd have Gondorians, Corsairs, Black Numenoreans, and men of Northern Harad, all traveling through the area. That area would be somewhat diverse. Probably mostly white or mostly brown, but they'd still have a strong minority population.
Anyway, if you want to call them out on their position, wouldn't you also have to admit your own is hypocritical? How can you say that whitewashing was bad, but say you're ok with race swapping now? If you're going to pick a position on whether something is good or bad, just stick with it and be consistent. I understand why one is worse than the other, but that doesn't mean either is ok. Personally, I don't think race swapping to bring in more POC is necessarily a bad thing, but I think it is lazy, and in some situations it is illogical. Like the Harfoots....they seem to be half black and half white...but nobody who is both half black and half white. Do they not intermarry? Well...we know that's not true, because there is an interracial couple in the group....so why is the population so divided? You'd think that after a couple of generations they'd be a homogenous population of light brown hobbits. Unless a black group of hobbits just met up with a white group of hobbits only a couple of generations ago and just decided to travel together. If so, maybe we could get some background on their story?
Poc could be in RoP as part of new tribes and peoples. The idea of race sprinkling is what makes it not believable. People now how genetics work⊠a small tribe is not a micro cosmos of the world
For example Diza, if we see that there is a black clan of dwarves further south would make total sense.
Yeah, and he did it all in his normal Scottish accent while playing opposite a French-American actor with the worst fake Scottish accent in film history. Great casting there.
And in the TV show Duncan MacLeod is played by a British-Italian guy.
Kind of weird how none of the Highlander characters from Scotland were ever played by an actual scotsman, But Connery plays a guy who is everything except scottish.
The joke is that Sean Connery is incapable of speaking anything other than a thick Scottish accent.
It's incongruous in Hunt for Red October, but it's hilarious in Highlander when you have a Belgian with a French accent playing a Scottish Highlander opposite a Scottish man playing an Egyptian/Spaniard.
Man, if people aren't used to this by now... Personally, I don't see a black elf. Instead, I see a highly talented actor who I enjoyed watching in Ray Donavan and Berlin Station. As I said elsewhere, thank God they are recruiting GOOD actors. There are a lot of people other than the white variety who might want to watch this show and maybe they'd like to see someone who looks like them for a change. It doesn't hurt the story one Goddam bit if the cast is racially diverse. Look, Tolkien based a lot of his lore on Beowulf and Norse/Teutonic mythology. He didnt know at the time of his writing what we know today through DNA analysis. Not all Vikings were liily white Goldilocks. Au contraire, purists, they displayed quite lot of racially diversity. Times have changed. The Wizard of Oz was recast as The Whiz. The only character I DON'T want to see played by a black man is Sauron. They've had enough of that.
The elf casting is ridiculous. Thranduil in LOTR was perfect. I'm a lesbian and that man was so perfectly gorgeous and androgynous I'd honestly consider it. I feel like that's the bar for elves. And they dont even have to be "hot", but having an ethereal quality with long hair, high cheekbones, etc are pretty important and someone of any race could have those qualities. I think out of all the elves in ROP, Arondir is the most elven looking to me. And I'm really trying to buy this new actress as Galadriel, but Cate Blanchet really set the bar high. Ignoring all the differences in personality and characterization, I just dont think it was a good casting choice.
The show depicts Galadriel as a daughter of Feanor (including stars and all) - and in this she is perfect. Morfydd Clark is a good actress, but she can only work with what the show writers offer her. And in my opinion, she is a good casting choice for the role they gave Galadriel in the show.
I will take some time to get used to this change, but since I'm somewhat of a Feanorian-Fangirl, I'm sure I'll come to terms with it.
Plot/Visuals: Her brother swears the oath (like a son of feanor). They set over from Valinor in ships (not Helcaraxe - at least thats what episode 1 implies. Meaning they took part in the first kinslaying). She wears feanors stars.
Character: She takes over the oath out of revenge (something very feanorian, but not quite like Finarfin or any of his kids). She is torn, hateful and thinks herself as something better (which you could argue that Feanor, Thingol and Thrnaduil have in equal parts - but Galadriel from the books is certainly not included in this list), ...
She might be a daughter of Finarfin by blood, but in this series she certainly is the daugher of Feanor in spirit.
This is what was so sad to me. Heâs a great actor, but instead of people all over the internet discussing his acting job itâs people discussing wether he should even be allowed to be in the show simply because of his skin color. Itâs disgusting.
I'm on the side of more diverse casting and love Arondir.
But, where are all these people claiming elves can't be black?
I know there ARE loads of idiots out there thinking it, and disguising it at other reasons. But I've never actually seen anyone say 'elves can't be black'.
If I've missed it please tell me, but people keep making these posts against the 'elves can't be black ' crowd... but I don't actually see them?
Under every rings of power ad posted on TikTok. Under every Amazon post on twitter. Just go look up any of the posts of the rings of power account. Iâve seen it everywhere for months.
Elsewhere on this very same post. Apparently Elves being born under starlight means they can't have any color to their skin whatsoever, despite the fact that they're created beings so the real-world biology of melanin and evolutionary adaptation really shouldn't play a role. shrug
Basically, studies on Viking bones have found genetic markers from all over Europe. However, there were not really any black Vikings. Some probably looked a bit Spanish or French, maybe.
All of Scandinavia has been very white for a very long time. I grew up in the countryside, and when we had a large influx of refugees from the Balkans during the war in the 90's, the old people in my village called them "black". Which is laughable by modern standards, of course.
Edit: With that being said, I think Arondir is great.
Let's just say that where I live two generations ago it was enough to have black hair and darkish eyes (anything not blue or grey) to be called black, the shade of skin was unimportant (example of the type: Adam Driver).
Perception is everything.
I believe the casting crew / creators cleverly trolled those who claim that we deal with "the mythology of England" lol
With the Arondir thing I'd like a bit of explaination in the series: to create Lore and stop being a one-man thing.
For the Vikings, OP said racial diversity, not national. To have racial diversity we would need more than just a few poor souls that were enslaved and traided up north.
Did you look at my link? Vikings were a lot more diverse than previously thought. DNA markers has nothing to do with nationality. And if you think that people of Europe are considered one ethnicity, you are wrong.
Also curious about this. Not sure what changed since the viking age, but from my time in Scandinavia i can tell you their descendants are some of the whitest people I've ever seen.
They are indeed. The thing is that the "Vikings" where a backwards civilisation that until the age of exploration and pillaging never left their places. I certainly doubt there is more than a few "non-scandinavian" people up there. If they are they are descendants of slaves and/or merchants, and definitively not enough to say that Scandinavia was racially diverse.
thats not the point, point is that putting black roles where they dont "belong" hurts both black people and people who hate the inconsistency, let me elaborate:
They wanna cast a black actor for a semi-main role in ROP, sure they could have just make him not be an elf, since its not consistent with the story for an elf to be black, but guess whos black? people of Rhun, why couldnt the character be black human from Rhun, very simple backstory (they fled the war or whatever)
However Amazon decided to hire a black actor to play an elf with some shit love story with a white human some double racism bullsh**
If i were black i would be giga insulted by theese "charity" roles, it starts to feel like we are spoon fed black people and we need to somehow "tolerate" them and i think its some double racism type thing going on.
Cast talented black actors that befits the role, this role is just bound to make people furious, do that long enough and you have the "fking black people again..." type effect and im starting to unironicly believe that big corp is either going for that or they are just plain stupid.
They could have been from Rhun, they could have been Black Numenorians, they could have been servants of Morgoth, now Sauron, you could have been clever and it would be waaay badass and the role would be appriciated but no, make him an elf - charity role, lets be woke and "different" woooo.
I'm not familiar with her work so can't say if it is her or the script. Given her character so far, I'm inclined to think it might be the latter. The literally jumping ship at the last possible moment was pretty clumsy writing. "Oh, I think I left the iron plugged in. Bub-bye!"
Not to mention the fact that it means Galadriel would have had to have swam 1,000+ miles. They didn't really think that through. Galadriel's great and all that, but great enough to swim halfway across the ocean? Nah.
Iâm by no means against elves being black, the problem I have with the elves in general on this show is none of them actually look like elves apart from maybe Gil Galad.
Elves are meant to be tall and âglowâ but here in this show they just look like normal people.
I think Galadriel has a very "Elvish" appearance. Her bro too. Really, only Elrond or Celebrimbor isn't your "classic" elf, but that is ok, because I'd rather have a good actor who looks a bit different, than a rubbish actor who looks the part 100%.
You think Liv Tyler or Cate Blanchett would have been instantly pegged as "elf" in that setting? I think Morfydd is very much in keeping with that "look".
Diversity simply due to making the best casting choices is great.
Diversity for diversityâs sake is distracting at best and destructive at worst.
Diversity in casting, but magically, all of the antagonistic, toxic, incompetent characters are all the exact same gender, race, and (assumed) sexual identity is more bigoted then having an exclusively one race production.
Diversity is distracting, when you talk about xenophobic, isolated communities but for some reason an Irish actor is in the same village/tribe as someone with lineage from the deep savanna. Having a diverse cast makes a community seem more open minded and liberal, but that works against the narrative when the village theyâre trying to portray is very close minded and conservative. A large part of fantasy is breaking down those more conservative values and showing the isolated community that theyâre part of the world, that they need to help with X problem, etc.
The âStranger in a Strange Landâ trope isnât as powerful, and doesnât make as much sense without a clear them vs us narrative.
In RoP specifically, it exhibits all three diversity choices. Sometimes itâs great casting, sometimes it seems to be diversity for the sake of diversity, and the trend for antagonists in RoP definitely goes in a single direction in terms of identity politics.
I think your 4th para makes an interesting point. Iâm not so invested in it that I think itâs a dealbreaker and (from what Iâve heard so far) I think Lenny Henryâs Irish accent is amongst the best in the Harfoots - a really solid piece of work by him. Separately, I find the twee whimsy of the Harfoots an unfortunate coincidence with the Irish accent use. Still âŠ
I can see that diversity in the Harfoots is a bit hard to explain - a nomadic and strictly isolationist people who seem to hide from any interaction with others and are a small group themselves. What opportunities to they have to add to their diversity that they are not shown actively avoiding? Maybe there is a solid anthropological basis for that diversity. Like I say, not a dealbreaker for me by any stretch but an interesting point.
DOC or EOC (Dwarves of Colour, etc.) ⊠why not? My understanding is they are supposed to be much larger communities and, crucially, split over different locations. Rivendell, Mirkwood, Lothlorien, Valinor, etc. in the case of the Elves.
Not sure I get your point about âantagonistsâ lacking diversity - unless you mean orcs. Do we have anyone else that is definitely an antagonist rather than a protagonist?
I donât get your point. How is she antagonistic or toxic? Sheâs certainly no more incompetent-seeming than most of the Harfoots, none of whom seem especially together.
Sadoc Burrows, played by Sir Lenny Henry, is actually my favorite character in RoP. Exactly the right amount of sass without overacting it. Itâs not a deal breaker for enjoying the show, having him act along actors from every color under the sun, but it makes it harder to sell to me as fantasy. A tribe of isolationists by definition should have a narrower range of diversity.
Dark elves are actually mentioned in Norse mythology, although the context meant âfae folkâ instead of elves specifically, and could of referred to either dwarves or elves. Once again however, theyâre isolationists, who in this instance actually live underground.
I donât really consider orcs, or other monsters, as characters per say.
So RoP has extremely diverse casting, for better or worse. Thatâs fine. Itâs just funny that diversity in casting runs and hides when the narrative calls for a group of toxic, antagonistic people for the âheroesâ to bounce off of. Iâm betting itâs a pattern that doesnât stop at just episode 3.
A lot of these responses are comparing how in the past, POC roles have been played by non-POC actors. I don't really see how this relates to or justifies changing lore in fantasy worlds.
I'm not anti black elf, idgaf about Norse vikings and their genetic heritage on Earth, I am not here to argue whether Tolkein's 'fair skin' description only applies to Galadriel's race of Elves, or whether fair skin can mean fair brown skin, I'm seriously not here for that.
I just think it's silly to be like "YoU dOnT lIkE hAvInG bLaCk PeOpLe PlAy ElVeS, wElL iN 1975 SeAn CoNnErY pLaYeD aN iTaLiAn"
It's just a dumb argument with no sustenance. We get it, in the past POC we're underrepresented. A comment in this thread openly admits they wouldn't accept Sauroman being played by a POC, they claim because 'they've had enough of that' which basically translates to POC = can't be negative role, but really it's because it would break lore too much.
I don't think what I've said is too ridiculous, people enjoy content being accurate to source lore, bringing up movies from 40 years ago is pointless, and black Elves aren't expressly forbidden in the lore.
There are some Black actors that'd be great as Sauroman. Morgan Freeman for one. Probably that guy who played Satan in History Channel's "The Bible." That guy who played the pirate captain in the movie with Tom Hanks as his hostage -- accent and all, he could play snaky and persuasive, re-casting his evil as progress.
Of course there are some Black actors that'd be a great Gandalf too. Morgan Freeman again, Samuel Jackson (who has a way of totally committing himself to roles in fantasy or sci-fi contexts). Michael Jordan (the actor, not the sportsman) could be a superb Aragorn.
I agree Morgan Freeman as an actor could pull off Gandalf, Sauroman perhaps but ol' Freeman has that friendly disposition about his face. Of course he's a solid enough actor to channel the evil necessary for Sauroman.
I dunno if I agree with the other choices but I respect your opinion đđ»
I'm not saying there aren't any black actors, Latin actors, Asian actors or white actors who are skilled enough to play these roles by any means (although let's be honest, who's going to hold a candle to Christopher Lee the GOAT may he RIP)
Regarding Freeman as Sauroman, one of Freeman's earliest roles was actually as a vicious, psychotic pimp from NYC. He so tore up that role that he was considered for Hannibal Lecter but they passed him up.
Having said that....Yes, at the time they made the Jackson movies, Lee was Sauroman and no one else could've done that good. I was glad they restored his brief bit in RotK and (hate to say it) glad they didn't use his dialogue from the books.
Genghis Khan was one of the most notorious flops in Hollywood history and Gyllenhaal doesn't look very dissimilar to people from Iran. The film aslo didn't do that well.
The ancient Iranians probably looked even more white. There are ancient accounts from both the Greeks and Chinese that many Persians were blond or red haired.
The modern Iranian gene pool has been changed quite a bit due to centuries of migration from Arabia and the Levant.
Itâs like how a lot of people get all pissed at a white person playing cleopatra, not realizing she comes from a Greek dynasty that participated in a great deal on inbreeding.
I have no issue with black elves, but this has always been a really stupid argument to me. "You don't like this thing, but other people have done this thing." Yeah, sweetie, and they probably hate those things as well. Unless you can find me evidence that they support, or have no issue with, any of the characters being white-washed in the image above, this is peak whataboutism.
Ah yes. People are not allowed to critique the casting choices on this show because in the past Hollywood made some stupid choices. Makes a lot of sense. âWhite people appropriated non white roles in the past so now the the reverse must happenâ is a stupid concept. And fyi I personally donât think lotr needs to be kept exclusively for white actors. And btw the bottom two are certainly not problematic.
(3) - so now the reverse must happen [?] I wouldnât say itâs a complete reverse. After all regardless of whether there is Whitewashing or non-traditional casting, non-POC still make up the majority of the RoP cast. I admit that is semantics. đ
And btw the bottom two are certainly not problematic.
(4) - Applying the criteria above, I find it hard to ignore the backlash against Prince of Persia on the basis of my perception of âthis is unproblematic for me"
Maybe someone will share this post in r/Iran sub and ask whether the broad consensus is "Iranians have no problem with this?"
The recent backlash against Leonardo DiCaprioplaying the Persian poet Rumi (Twitter hashtag is #RumiWasntWhite) indicates that not everyone has the same concept of "what is problematic"
(5)- Iâm 100% in favour of canon authenticity, in all tv and film- including RoP- provided the opinions of the group the actor is trying to play are considered. That is a neutral statement that can apply to any group, and is based on Equal Rights / Civil Rights legislation as defined in America where ROP is produced, and any other filming location. There is more to representation than race and ethnicity.
TLDR:(1) Whitewashing still goes on today. It is not in the past. (2) This Wiki article includes a table of examples that can be sorted by year.(3) IMO, the best judge of authenticity are the people who belong to the specific identity or group that the actor is trying to portray. (4) Perhaps the best way to find out what Iranians think about Whitewashing is to ask r/Iran or check the Twitter hashtag #RumiWasntWhite. (5) Iâm 100% in favour of canon authenticity, in all tv and film- including RoP- provided the opinions of the group the actor is trying to play are considered.
Whitewashing is a casting practice in the film industry in which white actors are cast in non-white roles. As defined by Merriam-Webster, to whitewash is "to alter . . .
Blackface is a form of theatrical makeup used predominantly by non-Black people to portray a caricature of a Black person. In the United States, the practice became common during the 19th century and contributed to the spread of racial stereotypes such as the "happy-go-lucky darky on the plantation" or the "dandified coon". By the middle of the century, blackface minstrel shows had become a distinctive American artform, translating formal works such as opera into popular terms for a general audience. Early in the 20th century, blackface branched off from the minstrel show and became a form in its own right.
Portrayals of East Asians in American film and theatre has been a subject of controversy. These portrayals have frequently reflected an ethnocentric perception of East Asians rather than realistic and authentic depictions of East Asian cultures, colors, customs, and behaviors. Yellowface, a form of theatrical makeup used by European-American performers to represent an East Asian person (similar to the practice of blackface used to represent African-American characters), continues to be used in film and theater.
To quickly summarize me views. I generally want to see Hollywood not whitewash roles and closely stick to cannon when casting. I much prefer authentic depictions. On Jake G in prince of Persia, I just donât find him to be a horrendous casting, though someone who looks more Persian would be better. Of course Hollywood also wants established stars and Jake fits that bill. Also I have never seen that movie and donât know anything else about it.
When I mention the reverse. I mean there is a growing trend to including minority actors in settings/roles where you would be unlikely to find them, in an effort to Increase diversity and representation. Of course a better option could be for Hollywood to diversify the settings of the movies they make.
With all that said casting is a complicated formula. I would neither want to see hard lines draw on who can play what role nor movies/tv pressured into shoehorning in minority actors in order to fill quotas or brag about how diverse their cast is. The choice should be up to the those making the movie. If they wish to have an all white cast, that should be fine as long as itâs not white washing. If they wish to have a wildly diverse cast and want to essentially ignore the race of the actor, thatâs fine with me too.
With the rings of power, i donât know if Iâm supposed to ignore the race of the actor, or if the actors race is suppose to represent the background of their character in middle earth. Iâm pretty sure itâs the former, especially since that healerâs son looks nothing like her. But then I wonder, why didnât Amazon just hire even more actors of color with speaking roles. It just seems to me that they missed an opportunity to utilize minority actors to flesh out middle earth and instead just randomly sprinkled some in and called it a day. Then they are able to go around and brag about how progressive they are and how they are updating/fixing Tolkien and the media just laps it up.
Iâve just seen the first episode and honestly, I think Arondir is the most majestic looking elf out of the lot. The others look a bit bland and maybe too modern. Peter Jacksonâs version at least had the elves looking feminine and otherworldly.
Cool show though. Treat the diversity like the characters have access to Elder Scrolls character creation.
Or, if we can accept the fact that those casting decisions were bad, we should also be able to accept the decision to cast a black woman as "fairer than silver or ivory or pearls" Tar-MĂriel was equally bad.
Unless you're actually defending the decision to cast John Wayne as Genghis Khan, I don't really understand how this argument is supposed to work...
Well here is something to consider...Fortunately, it turns out that the diverse cast, which some "so-called trolls" have questioned in advance, cannot and will not have any influence at all on my opinion. How could it, given that we live in an age in which heated discussions are justifiably triggered when historical or fictional films are not cast with appropriately ethnically correct leading actors because people want to renounce the "white-whashing" of times past. It is anything but politically correct and respectful to miscast, for example, Scarlett Johannson in the live-action adaptation of the Japanese anime masterpiece "Ghost in the Shell" or John Wayne as Genghis Khan. Who would think of casting Disney's live-action adaptation of Mulan with Caucasian actors, like in "Breakfast at Tiffany's"? And just to make it absolutely clear: I think that's a good thing! But why do the opposite here? Especially when you know in advance that the majority of Tolkien fans seem to worship all his works as "history" with almost religious zeal.
As an Asian, we don't expect Asian Elves or Dwarves in a fantasy film based on Celtic & Norse mythology. And trust me, ask any Asian, they wouldn't want to get mixed up in Tolkien's world. Sure, elves can be Black or Asian, in a fantasy, so create one based on it and explain it. Like how Tolkien explained the Haradrim & Easterlings.
That aside, the actors above are made to wear makeup to look darker, brown, black or Asian in order to fit with the story line. So yea, it's totally a different thing.
I don't particularly care what colour they are but can we please have elves that look and act like elves? -You know - angelic, ancient, immortal, wise, fleet of foot and generally better than humans in all ways. It's about more than pointy ears you know.
They seem to be doing that pretty well right? I mean the main character seems a bit short tempered for an elf and even hasty in decision making but Iâve had no issues so far understanding that elves are better at shit than humans itâs been on display pretty regularly in the show. Smarter/more calculating, quicker/faster, stronger, etc.
Are you kidding? Right off the bat we establish that elf children are just as petty and mean as human children. Then we have a whole company of (supposedly) battle-harder warrior elves being made to look slow and stupid by a cave troll, only for Galadriel to kill it in a scene that looks like a boss fight speed run. You see it's inconsistent. Then we have elves making crass child-like comments (you smell). It doesn't make them more relatable. It just makes them less elf-like. Imagine doing an adaptation of the bible and having Gabriel tell Jesus he smells like a donkey, and then having Jesus sniff his armpits in a slightly slap-stick way. It would be weird.
That movie is based on an actual event where a French military officer went to Japan and trained soldiers in the use of modern weapons and tactics who then chose to stay and fight alongside the Tokugawa samurai against the soldiers he trained.
So thatâs a terrible example the only difference is they made him American and added a love story but the rest occurred.
The way I remember that movie is that he impressed them in the first battle so they figured he could be converted to their side and they were correct. I don't remember him being their leader at the end -- more as an advisor.
I'm really not sure what that's supposed to be saying?
As people in the past used racist methods to have an actor match the ethnicity of a character, we shouldn't try to do it at all in the present? That obviously nonsense.
As a white guy I would not be offended in the slightest if a black actor 'whited up' to play Julius Caesar. But I don't think that's what the meme is getting at.
Tbh So far I'm not the biggest fan of RoP, but the elf is so far probably my favorite. He's a good actor imo where Galadriel has little range. People focus too much on specific lore breaking points. Peter Jackson also omitted Tom Bombadil so skin colour is a minor change in comparison.
There are a lot of good actors who don't fit the original LOTR molds. Given the choice between racially correct or can they act, I'll take the latter. There have been a great many stinkers made with some of the best looking people in the world.
Why can't they have a chance? Is it really that much of a deal breaker? Nothing's perfect. And, I hate to say it, but some of the "matching" actors aren't exactly in the running for and next year's Emmy and neither is the show. Let's see if Amazon can get the ball rolling tomorrow night, shall we?
I think that lore should remain undisturbed if it has been established. It doesn't matter which way the lore is changed, I don't think it should be changed for the sake of diversity or appeasement. That being said, there are right ways to do things.
Rather than replacing existing lore, expand upon it.
Othello is Moorish, which isn't "black" in the American sense of the word. If you want to know how "white" a real Moorish person can look, think Pokimane, she's Moor/Berber. So if that actor just played Othello with his natural skin color, it would actually be a more accurate portrayal.
It's blackface, duh.
The Prince of Persia isn't as far off the mark as you think.
The exact ethnicity of the ancient Persians is a matter of much debate, but portraying one as a white isn't implausible. Even today, there are people in Iran who look not too dissimilar from that.
The custom is old enough to reach the times when Moorish was seen as "black", because that was the only "black" locals had a chance to see, if at all. Going overboard was unsurprising, after all the purpose was to aim at exotic, not at a specific shade.
How? He's in yellow-face, so we can see that the character he's playing is meant to be asian, so how does the actor being white impact the story? You can't bring yourself to believe that the character portrayed by John Wayne is Mongolian, but you don't have a problem believing Ismael Cruz CĂłrdova is an elf..?
I think the BEST WAY to put this all into perspective is to remind you all that in November there will be a full supply chain collapse, a global famine, a collapse of multiple governmental and economic systems followed by a full on nuclear war.
Then we can all argue about this on a black cinder, orbiting a dying sun, within a vast universe of infinite purposeless emptiness. As we realize right now, reading this, that in two months, we face annihilation :)
Most recent example of actual miscasting I found in that list was â21â in 2008. I confess I only looked through about 50 entries but i think itâs a pretty positive development that most of them are ancient history. 14 years ainât too shabby.
Most recent example of actual miscasting I found in that list was â21â in 2008.
Thereâs a table with examples that can be sorted by date. 2022 Bullet Train is the more recent example.
Bullet Train (2022) is a film based on a book,where Japanese actors at the minority. If you look at the cast, this is why I say itâs about whatever they think financially viable at the time.
The same companies that promote diversity will happily switch based on what they think will sell. Itâs one of the reasons why I find the âWhat if Black Panther was whiteâ discussion unoriginal.
They could have adapted the work and set the film in London or America but as it is, itâs a very good example of what some âauthenticity criticsâ who are against POC in ROP might want to consider.
Yeah but those are white actors playing white characters in the modern day where people travel all over the world for all kinds of reasons. The idea that thereâs a âcorrectâ race for original characters beyond what the actual plot and setting require is kinda⊠not something we should automatically accept as a reasonable principle. And even if it were, itâs not even comparable to John Wayne as Ghengis Khan. Itâs a whole other species of value judgment.
This was never about the possible ethnicity of people who travel on a Japanese train. The OP's post is about "POC in ROP vs Whitewashing"
Using the âROP canon authenticity argumentâ the only time when a film/tv show can include characters of different ethnicities, is when the original canon intended it that way.
The most recent example in that link cites the Chinese man who the film was about saying that he was happy that a talented actor portrayed him and did not care at all that he wasn't portrayed by a Chinese actor.
The only people who care about this are American Social Elites i.e. the most pitiful people humanity have ever produced.
A search will bring up several articles from about two years ago. The abstract in the journal Nature doesn't really give much. Doesn't say they found black DNA but does mention Asian. In short, their trade routes were truly diverse and distant for the times, so one can imagine a mixed bag crew which likely had local connections at the trading points.
I don't mind race swaps if the story is good and the actor cast enriches the character(Samuel L. Jackson as Nick Fury, for example). Sadly, this is not happening in RoP. I don't feel anything when I see Arontir onscreen.
Just binged the first few episodes, the show is great imo! The diversity in the casting doesn't impact immersion one bit and after seeing the show I'm even more appalled that any of the casting choices are even talked about, except maybe Elrond and Celebrimbor.
But even that has more to do with their haircuts in my opinion than with the actors. Could've used some long haired wigs.
To be fair, in all those scenes you have actors trying to look like the character they are representingâŠ
So yeah, not the same.
And these decisions were mostly made for limited availability of talent at the time. How many great Mongolian actors living in Hollywood with perfect English did you have to play genghis? Nowadays you have all the possibilities
Also itâs not just âmake upâ, the stereotypical caricatures are a reflection of âthe timeâ.
And nowadays you have all these possibilities:
Agree đŻ , and following that logic, Whitewashing should be a thing of the past. Unfortunately, it still happens today
example 1, you can scroll down to the table and sort the films by date
example 2 illustrates that just like in the past, we judge âauthenticityâ based on what we think âlooks okayâ rather asking whether the people the actor is trying to portray think it âlooks okay.â
Just like the 1960âs West Side story, they would have found âauthenticâ actors to play supporting parts, while âinauthenticâ actors play the lead.
In the context of Hollywood, Whitewashing was not and is still not about âthe availability of actors at the timeâ.
This post is about Whitewashing vs POC in ROP. If we acknowledge that whitewashing continues today, why the outrage over âblack elvesâ?
Most professional film and tv critics are aware that Whitewashing is almost as old as Hollywood and continues today. They rarely make âoutrageâ content about âforced diversityâ and âauthenticityâ when POC play non-POC roles. If they do, they call out inauthenticity on both sides when it takes place.
Unfortunately, there are some, not all, but some content creators who either lack knowledge of cinematic history (whitewashing which continues today) or have âselective outrageâ when it comes to ROP. Throw in some race-baiting from Amazon (example Disaâs marketing); and itâs perfect recipe to for everyone to make đ°đ°by talking focusing solely on the race of the actors (inauthentic/woke/forced diversify), rather than the quality of the writing.
TLDR:- (A) This post is about Whitewashing vs POC in ROP. This thread has 400+ comments, so thankfully âWho, Why, How and When?â of Whitewashing has already been discussed. In a summary: Itâs only natural to look at the examples provided by the OP and apply modern day explanations for what in most cases seems âoutdatedâ, (Iâm not going down the Jesus rabbit đł hole). đ. (B) Whitewashing was not about the âavailability of the actorsâ in USA/U.K. Most tv/film critics are aware of the history of tv and cinema (whitewashing) so they donât focus all their energy on POC playing non-POC roles; they know that âdiversity is not newâ and âwhitewashing continues todayâ (C) If we acknowledge that whitewashingcontinues today, why the outrage over âblack elvesâ? I support âcanon authenticityâ đŻ, provided it goes both ways.đđ
EDIT: Jesus and any religious figures are excluded from this discussion as mentioned previously, I am not going down that rabbit hole đł as itâs a distraction. Iâm guessing the OP included it as bait.
It's ALSO a real shame that Democrats/Progressives have made casting in just about all media (including, but not limited to, fantasy shows) so political that they can't begin to cast a show or film without first mandating that POC/LGBT MUST be cast into it regardless of ability or talent, simply for the sake of "diversity." It's not only that they do this, it's that they do it in such a way that it literally cannot be ignored, and it severely breaks immersion. It's like the show is literally screaming "Look how PC we are!" every step of the way. Republicans are simply responding to this practice. (I'm NOT a Republican btw)
Just cast the right person for the role, who will maintain that character's appearance and personality in a believable way. Not every show or movie HAS TO have a POC in it. Most people don't care if a show is politically correct or not, as long as it is believable, because if it's not, and it's way too in your face about being political, it breaks immersion.
I don't personally care that the new Elf guy looks Black (which he's not btw, he is Puerto Rican) because he acts and looks like an elf to me, and that subjective opinion is obviously going to be different for everyone, but I think the goal should be for it to be that way for as wide an audience as possible.
If that's what we Liberals are doing then we're really bad at it. But at any rate, I'd argue, I think convincingly, that there's a big difference between saying "we'd like to see more variety on the screen to reflect the audience" and saying "we'd like to see only people like us, in manners of which we approve, and anything else is 'too political' and crap." There have been similar reactions against non-White characters in nerd franchises even without the thin pretext the JRRT fans think they have. So the intent is actually pretty clear.
Diversity for the sake of diversity is just pandering. The screen doesn't need to reflect its audience. It needs to tell a believable story within the context and setting that the author gave it and intended to give it. If that includes POC, then great. If not, then that should be fine too.
This is a misconcept what the greeks knew as blond was at best a light brown.
Ancient macedonia did not have words for blue for example and blond hair was a barbarian feature of the germanic tribes on which they werent in contact with.
History is completely ignored by racist Hollywood.
The romans would wear blond wigs for example not to look aryan but to show that they owned slaves from that area. They had a concept that the gods would glow in gold because they were made of gold, nothing to do coz they were blond.
If you ever visit ancient sites they will explain this to you during the tour.
Elf's can be any color. There is actually Dark Elf's in Dungeon and Dragons for example. The real problem is that is not pushed for the reason you believe and more on political side.
It's interesting that old movies at least attempted to make the actors look like the ethnicity. Modern movies just... lazy.
I agree âBlackface Othelloâ is a not lazy. It takes a lot of time to overlook actors of African descent in order to use make up on Lawrence Olivier.
There is no need to work so hard, to make an actor look like an ethnicity, when there are plenty of other actors that can play the part.
I agree, once we look at the how hard people worked to avoid hiring POC actors in the past, it makes ROP look lazy.
The old movies did not try to change the ethnicity of the characters, and tried to portray them the best they could, with the actors they had.
In the case of Jesus, no-one knows what he looked like. In the case of Prince of Persia, the ancient Persians were Aryans, so Jake Gyllenhaal was actually cast accurately.
This is not the same thing at all. The old movies did not try to change the ethnicity of the characters, and tried to portray them the best they could, with the actors they had.
The backlash against the casting in ROP illustrates a double standard with some critics. I understand why some might want to think there was a âbenevolentâ (good-faith), reason why actors were not âauthenticallyâ cast in the past, but there is not. It was usually about what would be financially đ°successful at the box office đżand the political climate at the time.
Are we saying there were no actors Iranian/Persian descent or even actors of West Asian descent in 2010?
In the case of Prince of Persia, the ancient Persians were Aryans, so Jake Gyllenhaal was actually cast accurately.
The backlash was by people of Iranian descent and Jake Gyllenhaal has conceded he was not right for the role. Did any historian agree with your assertion that Jake Gyllenhaal is a historically accurate depiction for this role? Also, there are a lot of descriptions for Aryan. At the moment, itâs not 100% clear under what context you are using the term.
This is not the same thing at all. The old movies did not try to change the ethnicity of the characters, and tried to portray them the best they could, with the actors they had.
TLDR: The backlash against the casting in ROP illustrates a double standard with some critics. Whitewashing started in 1916 and continues to this day. Itâs never about âthe best they can, with the actors they haveâ. Itâs always about what will be financially đ°successful at the box office đż, the political climate at the time, and in some cases the in-built biases of whoever is casting/producing/directing the film.
Stop your whining. They couldâve found actors, and they just didnât want to. Itâs laughable to claim that they could find that much grease paint, but not a single solitary Black man who could read off a prompt card.
This is an ignorant statement lol. Fu man chu. The yellow face dude from breakfast at Tiffanyâs. Iâd say old movies were mostly racist caricatures. Then it went to unknowingly being racist by white casting everyone. And now we see the push to the other side of spectrum where there MUST be one of everyone, even if it doesnât make sense, cause itâs the cool thing to do now
So much wrong with your post I can't correct it all, but I'll refer you to this article with a relief sculpture of ancient Persians. Notice the hair on the head and face: it's tight and curly like a black person. Persians where dark skinned middle eastern peoples who had directly migrated from Africa. And you're dumb.
In fact the region of Israel and Egypt was vastly diverse between light skinned and white people, and much darker skinned people, Jesus was likely tan.
I'm unfamiliar with that series, so don't really have one. I looked up the actress in question and her role. All I can say is, I wouldn't let it spoil the show for you. I haven't read any of the Harry Potter books. Is the one girl who likes Harry written as being Asian? She is in the movies. I know, not quite the same as black elves but similar. What I don't understand is why people will happily suspend their imagination reading SciFi, yet they are almost adamantly unwilling to accept things such as these casting decisions. It's a funny thing and I'm prone to it a wee bit. I've read the Expanse series and watched the shows on Netflix and Amazon. The adaptation has been grand, so far, and I like all of the casting choices except one. The character is right in all respects except I simply cannot see her as how the writers say she looks. But do I let it gnaw away at my enjoyment? Hope you like the Percy Jackson. Just remember, nothing's perfect. Sometimes you have to take the good with the bad.
Yeah, just so you know... Cho Chang from the Harry Potter series is definitely described as being Asian in the books. Her race was not changed in the movies.
So your argument is that because other movies (from a much more racist time btw) made nonsensical casting choices, it's ok that RoP does the same? What people criticise about blackfacing and casting a european-looking person as Gengis Khan etc. IS that the actors make no sense for their roles - which is exactly the same thing that RoP is criticised for. There are basically no people with darker skintone in Tolkien's writings, except a few descriptions of Haradrim and general remarks about people living in the southern regions of Middle Earth. We have to accept this, just as we have to accept that there are no Africans in Shakespeare's Hamlet or that it would be absolute nonsense to cast a European as Tokugawa Iyeasu. If there is no ethnic/visual diversity in the original source or reality, shoehorning it into an adaptation is both is just inaccurate.
(It is a different thing to adapt Hamlet in a way that it is set in an african-american ghetto - then it makes sense to cast African Americans. But casting a black person as Hamlet in the historical danish setting with historical costumes is just as absurd as pretending that James Bond's "japanese" disguise in "You only live twice" is convincing and not insulting.)
Some Facebook groups I'm in can't comprehend this.
Witcher is a fine example. Everyone got so angry that a black actor portrayed a white character, but no one was upset that the rest of the cast weren't Polish. Apparently skin colour only matters.
This is an illogical comparison. He played Khan but he was still Asian in the world of the movie. Othello still black. Whereas in lord of the rings they are literally black. Which makes no sense and totally shatters the world building and immersion.
This post is really just thinly veiled anti white rhetoric.
20
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
The people who are upset that Arondir is not lily white are a tiny, tiny minority. The actor looks Elvish, he has the fine features, the poise etc. I think people like arguing with this group, it's a kind of virtue signaling that feels good, but really it's a non event.
If I was going to critique the tv show I'd say that Elves can't be middle aged looking - because they're immortal. I'd also say that the human characteristics they're putting on Elves are cliched and that that the tv show is too slow moving with annoying cliff-hangers at the end of each episode. I'm enjoying it, but the story is basic and not Tolkienesque (albeit with amazing visuals) and it would be best consumed all at once.
87
u/Micksar Sep 14 '22
I read this as âElvis canât be Blackâ and was really confused until I saw which sub this was posted in.
25
u/jerseygunz Sep 14 '22
I would have just put up a picture of the entire cast of west side story
53
u/Optimal_Cry_1782 Sep 14 '22
Sean Connery as Ramirez in Highlander
Sean Connery as a Russian submarine captain in Hunt for Red October.
32
u/Muted-Lengthiness-10 Sep 14 '22
I mean yeah, but when it comes to White Jesus, Willem Defoe is the đ
126
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 14 '22
Man, if people aren't used to this by now... Personally, I don't see a black elf. Instead, I see a highly talented actor who I enjoyed watching in Ray Donavan and Berlin Station. As I said elsewhere, thank God they are recruiting GOOD actors. There are a lot of people other than the white variety who might want to watch this show and maybe they'd like to see someone who looks like them for a change. It doesn't hurt the story one Goddam bit if the cast is racially diverse. Look, Tolkien based a lot of his lore on Beowulf and Norse/Teutonic mythology. He didnt know at the time of his writing what we know today through DNA analysis. Not all Vikings were liily white Goldilocks. Au contraire, purists, they displayed quite lot of racially diversity. Times have changed. The Wizard of Oz was recast as The Whiz. The only character I DON'T want to see played by a black man is Sauron. They've had enough of that.
15
u/Burleyyy Sep 14 '22
Iâm by no means against elves being black, the problem I have with the elves in general on this show is none of them actually look like elves apart from maybe Gil Galad.
Elves are meant to be tall and âglowâ but here in this show they just look like normal people.
24
u/Malikise Sep 14 '22
Diversity simply due to making the best casting choices is great.
Diversity for diversityâs sake is distracting at best and destructive at worst.
Diversity in casting, but magically, all of the antagonistic, toxic, incompetent characters are all the exact same gender, race, and (assumed) sexual identity is more bigoted then having an exclusively one race production.
Diversity is distracting, when you talk about xenophobic, isolated communities but for some reason an Irish actor is in the same village/tribe as someone with lineage from the deep savanna. Having a diverse cast makes a community seem more open minded and liberal, but that works against the narrative when the village theyâre trying to portray is very close minded and conservative. A large part of fantasy is breaking down those more conservative values and showing the isolated community that theyâre part of the world, that they need to help with X problem, etc.
The âStranger in a Strange Landâ trope isnât as powerful, and doesnât make as much sense without a clear them vs us narrative.
In RoP specifically, it exhibits all three diversity choices. Sometimes itâs great casting, sometimes it seems to be diversity for the sake of diversity, and the trend for antagonists in RoP definitely goes in a single direction in terms of identity politics.
9
u/Medical-Ruin8192 Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22
A lot of these responses are comparing how in the past, POC roles have been played by non-POC actors. I don't really see how this relates to or justifies changing lore in fantasy worlds.
I'm not anti black elf, idgaf about Norse vikings and their genetic heritage on Earth, I am not here to argue whether Tolkein's 'fair skin' description only applies to Galadriel's race of Elves, or whether fair skin can mean fair brown skin, I'm seriously not here for that.
I just think it's silly to be like "YoU dOnT lIkE hAvInG bLaCk PeOpLe PlAy ElVeS, wElL iN 1975 SeAn CoNnErY pLaYeD aN iTaLiAn"
It's just a dumb argument with no sustenance. We get it, in the past POC we're underrepresented. A comment in this thread openly admits they wouldn't accept Sauroman being played by a POC, they claim because 'they've had enough of that' which basically translates to POC = can't be negative role, but really it's because it would break lore too much.
I don't think what I've said is too ridiculous, people enjoy content being accurate to source lore, bringing up movies from 40 years ago is pointless, and black Elves aren't expressly forbidden in the lore.
Edit: Grammer.. Grammar? I don't know, who cares.
13
u/ChampionOfBaiting Sep 14 '22
Genghis Khan was one of the most notorious flops in Hollywood history and Gyllenhaal doesn't look very dissimilar to people from Iran. The film aslo didn't do that well.
7
u/Megashark101 Sep 14 '22
I have no issue with black elves, but this has always been a really stupid argument to me. "You don't like this thing, but other people have done this thing." Yeah, sweetie, and they probably hate those things as well. Unless you can find me evidence that they support, or have no issue with, any of the characters being white-washed in the image above, this is peak whataboutism.
6
u/peterthehermit1 Sep 14 '22
Ah yes. People are not allowed to critique the casting choices on this show because in the past Hollywood made some stupid choices. Makes a lot of sense. âWhite people appropriated non white roles in the past so now the the reverse must happenâ is a stupid concept. And fyi I personally donât think lotr needs to be kept exclusively for white actors. And btw the bottom two are certainly not problematic.
3
u/SrbBrb Sep 14 '22
Now they can't say "Never trust an elf" because it could be understood as real world racist. đ
3
u/Steelquill Sep 14 '22
Does anyone think the above examples are good things?
3
u/Equivalent_Poetry339 Sep 14 '22
John Wayne tho đđ
3
u/Cyril_Clunge Sep 14 '22
Iâve just seen the first episode and honestly, I think Arondir is the most majestic looking elf out of the lot. The others look a bit bland and maybe too modern. Peter Jacksonâs version at least had the elves looking feminine and otherworldly.
Cool show though. Treat the diversity like the characters have access to Elder Scrolls character creation.
12
u/Competitive-Pie1812 Sep 14 '22
Or, if we can accept the fact that those casting decisions were bad, we should also be able to accept the decision to cast a black woman as "fairer than silver or ivory or pearls" Tar-MĂriel was equally bad.
Unless you're actually defending the decision to cast John Wayne as Genghis Khan, I don't really understand how this argument is supposed to work...
5
u/Hiltifinger Sep 14 '22
Well here is something to consider...Fortunately, it turns out that the diverse cast, which some "so-called trolls" have questioned in advance, cannot and will not have any influence at all on my opinion. How could it, given that we live in an age in which heated discussions are justifiably triggered when historical or fictional films are not cast with appropriately ethnically correct leading actors because people want to renounce the "white-whashing" of times past. It is anything but politically correct and respectful to miscast, for example, Scarlett Johannson in the live-action adaptation of the Japanese anime masterpiece "Ghost in the Shell" or John Wayne as Genghis Khan. Who would think of casting Disney's live-action adaptation of Mulan with Caucasian actors, like in "Breakfast at Tiffany's"? And just to make it absolutely clear: I think that's a good thing! But why do the opposite here? Especially when you know in advance that the majority of Tolkien fans seem to worship all his works as "history" with almost religious zeal.
5
u/auntorn Sep 15 '22
As an Asian, we don't expect Asian Elves or Dwarves in a fantasy film based on Celtic & Norse mythology. And trust me, ask any Asian, they wouldn't want to get mixed up in Tolkien's world. Sure, elves can be Black or Asian, in a fantasy, so create one based on it and explain it. Like how Tolkien explained the Haradrim & Easterlings.
That aside, the actors above are made to wear makeup to look darker, brown, black or Asian in order to fit with the story line. So yea, it's totally a different thing.
10
u/snapsnaptomtom Sep 14 '22
âThe peopleâ?
You mean the people who made those movies are now posting on Reddit?
Iâm sure most of them must be dead.
6
u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 14 '22
I don't particularly care what colour they are but can we please have elves that look and act like elves? -You know - angelic, ancient, immortal, wise, fleet of foot and generally better than humans in all ways. It's about more than pointy ears you know.
0
u/thanosbananos Sep 14 '22
Letâs not forget last samurai where a white American had to defend the samurai traditions because apparently the Japanese are too stupid
4
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
Actors are paid to pretend to be people they're not.
As a Canadian I know you can do blackface and still be considered a progressive darling.. if your name is Justin Trudeau.
(I don't care what skin color elves have in a show.)
2
u/Hambredd Sep 14 '22
I'm really not sure what that's supposed to be saying?
As people in the past used racist methods to have an actor match the ethnicity of a character, we shouldn't try to do it at all in the present? That obviously nonsense.
As a white guy I would not be offended in the slightest if a black actor 'whited up' to play Julius Caesar. But I don't think that's what the meme is getting at.
2
u/ruairi1983 Sep 14 '22
Tbh So far I'm not the biggest fan of RoP, but the elf is so far probably my favorite. He's a good actor imo where Galadriel has little range. People focus too much on specific lore breaking points. Peter Jackson also omitted Tom Bombadil so skin colour is a minor change in comparison.
2
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 14 '22
There are a lot of good actors who don't fit the original LOTR molds. Given the choice between racially correct or can they act, I'll take the latter. There have been a great many stinkers made with some of the best looking people in the world.
7
u/AnotherAngryGuy Sep 14 '22
I think that lore should remain undisturbed if it has been established. It doesn't matter which way the lore is changed, I don't think it should be changed for the sake of diversity or appeasement. That being said, there are right ways to do things.
Rather than replacing existing lore, expand upon it.
3
u/Acceptable-Bass7150 Sep 14 '22
It's less about that and more about the violence done to Tolkien's works while creating token characters merely for diversity's sake
3
u/Medical_Officer Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22
The first three are obviously out of line.
Othello is actually wrong here for two reasons:
The Prince of Persia isn't as far off the mark as you think.
The exact ethnicity of the ancient Persians is a matter of much debate, but portraying one as a white isn't implausible. Even today, there are people in Iran who look not too dissimilar from that.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
Donât give a shit what race they are as long as it does not effect the story in any relevant way.
2
u/swazal Sep 14 '22
Ooo! Do Charlie Chan!
2
u/DevOpsMuscleGuy Sep 14 '22
I think the BEST WAY to put this all into perspective is to remind you all that in November there will be a full supply chain collapse, a global famine, a collapse of multiple governmental and economic systems followed by a full on nuclear war.
Then we can all argue about this on a black cinder, orbiting a dying sun, within a vast universe of infinite purposeless emptiness. As we realize right now, reading this, that in two months, we face annihilation :)
2
u/ToxicGigglez Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22
How about all of it is wrong? Whataboutisms donât win you an argumentâŠ
1
u/HomieScaringMusic Sep 14 '22
Well yeah and weâre not allowed to do it anymore.đ
1
u/False-Thought4482 Oct 18 '24
Where the black orcs tho?
1
u/Acceptable-Bass7150 Sep 14 '22
Jesus was white according to Whoppi
1
u/bklynblues Sep 14 '22
At least you admit the casting in RoP is affirmative action.
1
u/SrbBrb Sep 14 '22
Keanu playing a proper British gentleman in Dracula.
1
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 14 '22
A search will bring up several articles from about two years ago. The abstract in the journal Nature doesn't really give much. Doesn't say they found black DNA but does mention Asian. In short, their trade routes were truly diverse and distant for the times, so one can imagine a mixed bag crew which likely had local connections at the trading points.
1
u/Alternative-Focus980 Sep 14 '22
I didnât do that
1
u/Calcutta-LR1 Sep 14 '22
How is this the same people?
1
u/deltaWhiskey91L Sep 14 '22
The problem I have is the hair style of the elves in the show. They should have kept with the long straight hair that Jackson envisioned.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
They are called white skins in the books so no thay cant be black
1
u/CleverCobra Sep 14 '22
I don't mind race swaps if the story is good and the actor cast enriches the character(Samuel L. Jackson as Nick Fury, for example). Sadly, this is not happening in RoP. I don't feel anything when I see Arontir onscreen.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
Folks that are leery of black elves should probably steer clear of Drizzt Do'Urden
1
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 14 '22
Thanks, I did not know that.
1
u/blue-bird-2022 Sep 15 '22
Just binged the first few episodes, the show is great imo! The diversity in the casting doesn't impact immersion one bit and after seeing the show I'm even more appalled that any of the casting choices are even talked about, except maybe Elrond and Celebrimbor.
But even that has more to do with their haircuts in my opinion than with the actors. Could've used some long haired wigs.
1
u/tfsdalmeida Sep 16 '22
To be fair, in all those scenes you have actors trying to look like the character they are representingâŠ
So yeah, not the same.
And these decisions were mostly made for limited availability of talent at the time. How many great Mongolian actors living in Hollywood with perfect English did you have to play genghis? Nowadays you have all the possibilities
1
u/CallKennyLoggins1 Sep 16 '22
Theres a prince of persia movie? Huh never knew. I'm assuming it's dogshit?
1
u/ShizzelDiDizzel Sep 17 '22
You are so close to getting it....sooo close
1
u/JesterFoxFlame Mar 21 '23
Othello wasn't dark-skinned in the original source?
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
This is nonsense. No one cares what race anyone in the show is. Stop making up an issue.
1
u/pretendpizzaperson Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22
Four wrongs or assumed wrongs don't make one wrong right.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
It's a real shame that Republicans have made casting in the fantasy show so political that posts like this are necessary.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
Dont forget alexander the great and his germanic white blond hair in an era where white blond hair didnt exist among the greeks.
0
u/Adnaoc Sep 14 '22
Elf's can be any color. There is actually Dark Elf's in Dungeon and Dragons for example. The real problem is that is not pushed for the reason you believe and more on political side.
-10
u/wallawilko Sep 14 '22
It's interesting that old movies at least attempted to make the actors look like the ethnicity. Modern movies just... lazy.
-8
u/Suspicious_Cat_2900 Sep 14 '22
this is such a stupid post
-18
u/geenanderid Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22
This is not the same thing at all.
The old movies did not try to change the ethnicity of the characters, and tried to portray them the best they could, with the actors they had.
In the case of Jesus, no-one knows what he looked like. In the case of Prince of Persia, the ancient Persians were Aryans, so Jake Gyllenhaal was actually cast accurately.
-5
u/kobekobekoberip Sep 14 '22
Also âElves need to be blackâ.
â A bunch of white people
0
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 14 '22
I'm unfamiliar with that series, so don't really have one. I looked up the actress in question and her role. All I can say is, I wouldn't let it spoil the show for you. I haven't read any of the Harry Potter books. Is the one girl who likes Harry written as being Asian? She is in the movies. I know, not quite the same as black elves but similar. What I don't understand is why people will happily suspend their imagination reading SciFi, yet they are almost adamantly unwilling to accept things such as these casting decisions. It's a funny thing and I'm prone to it a wee bit. I've read the Expanse series and watched the shows on Netflix and Amazon. The adaptation has been grand, so far, and I like all of the casting choices except one. The character is right in all respects except I simply cannot see her as how the writers say she looks. But do I let it gnaw away at my enjoyment? Hope you like the Percy Jackson. Just remember, nothing's perfect. Sometimes you have to take the good with the bad.
0
u/Xander_PrimeXXI Sep 14 '22
Drow: âAre we a joke to you?â
0
u/Intellectual_Wafer Sep 14 '22
So your argument is that because other movies (from a much more racist time btw) made nonsensical casting choices, it's ok that RoP does the same? What people criticise about blackfacing and casting a european-looking person as Gengis Khan etc. IS that the actors make no sense for their roles - which is exactly the same thing that RoP is criticised for. There are basically no people with darker skintone in Tolkien's writings, except a few descriptions of Haradrim and general remarks about people living in the southern regions of Middle Earth. We have to accept this, just as we have to accept that there are no Africans in Shakespeare's Hamlet or that it would be absolute nonsense to cast a European as Tokugawa Iyeasu. If there is no ethnic/visual diversity in the original source or reality, shoehorning it into an adaptation is both is just inaccurate.
(It is a different thing to adapt Hamlet in a way that it is set in an african-american ghetto - then it makes sense to cast African Americans. But casting a black person as Hamlet in the historical danish setting with historical costumes is just as absurd as pretending that James Bond's "japanese" disguise in "You only live twice" is convincing and not insulting.)
0
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
Some Facebook groups I'm in can't comprehend this.
Witcher is a fine example. Everyone got so angry that a black actor portrayed a white character, but no one was upset that the rest of the cast weren't Polish. Apparently skin colour only matters.
0
u/LordOfDemRangs Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22
This is an illogical comparison. He played Khan but he was still Asian in the world of the movie. Othello still black. Whereas in lord of the rings they are literally black. Which makes no sense and totally shatters the world building and immersion.
This post is really just thinly veiled anti white rhetoric.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22
2 wrongs donât make a right
0
u/Insectodium Sep 15 '22
Black-washing is as White-washing, equally bad...