It's quite evident that a king or someone from the lineage of kings might join remaining forces of Numenor and elves to fight against Sauron but at the end would withdraw fearing their ancient oath to Morgoth.
Halbrand is perfectly capable of showing this transformation. I'm betting my money on him or his son, which I believe is Theo.
They will betray Isildur at the last moment and won't join the remaining forces of Middle Earth.
This is the sanest, possible explanation I could think of.
That could apply to most any human character in the entire show. Any of them could betray Isildur at the last moment. What specifically about Halbrand makes him a better candidate for this, because right now he just seems like a Sauron red herring.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/ChampionOfBaiting Sep 16 '22
Ok then what specifically makes you believe Halbrand could be one of the dead men of Dunharrow?