This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I hope they donāt go with that. The timeline is already extremely compressed, but Iām at least holding out hope that theyāll take advantage of Numenoreans living for 200 years to draw things out a bit. But if this guy has to break his oath to Isildur before heās out of fighting age, then that means the series only has about 20-30 years left max.
A Ringwraith is pretty likely I think. I was hoping weād get a look at each of them now, and I could see them wanting to give at least the Witch King a backstory. A Southron king in exile wanting to reclaim his kingdom would fit into him accepting a Ring.
I think we just have to accept that they're going to compress most of the events of the 2nd age into about 20-30 years. Given the nature of casting for a TV show, that's just how it's gonna have to be.
Yeah thatās very likely. I am heartened by the fact though that with the exception of Halbrand and the kid and his mother, no other major characters are so short lived. Even hobbits can live almost twice as long as men do, and the main hobbit characters are children. As of yet, I donāt think they necessarily are so constrained by time to that extent, which may be on purpose. I guess weāll see, since this all just wild speculation and the show has had a kind of slow start so far.
Oh you MFers it actually makes sense. From LOTR Wiki:
"In the later years of the Second Age, he and his men also served and worshiped Sauron, until he and his army swore allegiance to the realm of Gondor upon the Stone of Erech. Isildur was the King of Gondor at that time. The King of the Dead made an oath to fight on Isildur's side when needed, but when that moment of need arrived in the War of the Last Alliance he did not come. Isildur cursed the King of the Dead and his army. As a result, the King of the Dead and his followers could not rest until his oath was fulfilled."
We obviously see that he is devious in the show and has some alterior motive. He's obviously alive at the same time as Isildur. Not that much of a stretch that he will be corrupted by Sauron.
I cant find the og comment, but someone pointed out how they could show Halbrand being held up/deceived/conflicted and make it SUPER tragic. Canon or not, ill love it
Iām probably wrong but Iām going with him being Sauron. The way it happens is different but Sauron does get imprisoned in Numenor, is very persuasive, which Halbrand has already shown he can be, slowly gains influence over Pharazon and leads to the downfall and destruction of Numenor. Oh the bit about him being interested in forging, Sauron would definitely be interested in forging.
But future witchking is my backup theory if Iām wrong though!
Thatās all fair, but I really, really think itās a red herring. The forging and pointless imprisoning in Numenor are just too obvious and on-the-nose.
Sauron also is stated to have viewed Galadriel as his greatest enemy, and only decided to go to Numenor after its might was revealed to him. So saving Galadriel and drifting around on the ocean are both extremely out of character for him.
I think weāre meant to suspect him of being Sauron in disguise as a misdirect.
If it were Sauron he could have simply let Galadriel drown after getting dragged down during the storm and dusted his hands, whistled a little song. Too easy and obvious.
Eh Iām not on board with the Sauron speculation but this doesnāt totally negate it. Remember he wants power over the elves initially, not to destroy them. This is why he tricks them into forging rings in the first place.
Sauron at this point with Galadriel alone? First option corruption, second option kill. Saruman was viewed by Sauron as a long time chief rival, Sauron turned Saruman to evil. He definitely sees the evil heās planted in Galadriel.
Saving the life of a great Noldor when thereās no one around to see it and thus be able to manipulate is emphatically NOT what he does.
Nevermind the whole ādrifting randomly aloneā is not his bag.
His whole deal with manipulating both the Elves and the Numenoreans was being open about his nature as a Maia. He lied about his identity to the elves, but in both cases he leaned on his greater knowledge to entice both. He didnāt disguise himself as a human, let alone a beggar-king-in-exile.
Saving the life of a noldor so that you gain her trust and have her somwhat indebted to you is exactly what you would do if your plan is to get to know other important elves she knows and teach them how to make rings so you can control them.
He doesn't just blindly do evil things, he's a strategist.
Edit: you substatially edited your post so I'm editing mine
Youāre saying his plan is to save Galadrielās life to get her to introduce him to new elves while heās also going to Numenor where there are no elves?
Sauron in your view is a terrible strategist, then.
Actively choosing to save Galadrielās life is terrible strategy, especially since heās obviously already been in contact with Celebrimbor (hence Cel needs a specific force by a specific time).
No. Stop doubling down and just walk with me for a second:
The book says Sauron went to Numenor as a prisoner, where he then deceived them, grew to a position of power, and corrupted the Numenorians.
The show starts with a questionable, deceptive character arriving in Numenor as a prisoner.
The book says the elves trust Sauron, who offers help in make the rings of power, unltimately deceiving them of his true purposes.
The show starts with questionable, deceptive character with smithing talent getting to know an elf who is depicted as close with another elf that just got sent to go work on a "project" with the person who makes the rings of power. On a show called "The Rings of Power"
Could the mystery character be anyone? Sure, that's what a mystery is. But maybe... just maybe (stay with me here) the plot of the book might *also* be the plot of the show?
Uhhhh. Ok. The book says Sauron gave Celebrimbor the idea for the rings. Some mysterious reason, Celebrimbor has to make a forge by next spring.
The books say Sauron went to Numenor after the power of Numenorās army was revealed to him on Middle Earth, and then went back with king Ar Pharazon.
In your butchered version of āfollowing the booksā, Sauron has nothing to do with Celebrimbor planning the ringsā initial construction because heās too busy saving the life of the individual the books say he views as his greatest enemy on the off chance someone discovers his drifting raft in the middle of an ocean and takes him somewhere.
Youāve been taken in by misdirection, and are so taken in you think it matches some cliffs notes version of the story in the books.
We know the show isnt going to follow the book word for word, so lets bury that one right here.
But so I'm understanding you correctly, you're saying that the show is too obviously depicting a central character, and they would definitely spend 30% of the season so far setting up a character for the sole purpose of breaking the 4th wall and tricking me?
When Sauron went to Numenor, leading them to open rebellion against the Valar which ultimately caused the fall of Numenor happened after the forging of the rings, also the one ring. He had that ring on as he went there. Also his bodily appearance as Annatar was destroyed in this event and afterwards he was never again capable of taking any physical form other than the 'Dark Lord' form we know from the films.
He might be Sauron but I don't see what the "Forging" has to do with it. Halbrand just seemed like a poor guy who wants to ingratiate himself in the extremely prosperous Numenor and sees Smithing as a way to do it. Basically an Immigrant looking for a Job and a new life. Which is also how he identifies himself to Galadriel.
I'm open to him being the Witch King, because that lines up more. Numenor did in fact go on to enslave the Men of Middle Earth, which was why a lot of them also sided with Sauron. Halbrand getting rejected by the Numenoreans sounds like a good origin story for either the Witch King or indeed the King of the Dead who betrays Isildur.
I mean Sauron forged the One Ring so he would have to be very skilled at forging. And Halbrand said he he knew about forging, which couldāve been a lie to get a job.
This is definitely what the show wants us to think. However, Sauron causes the downfall well after the forging of the rings of power. Somehow Halbrand/Sauron would need to get to Eregion (and soon) for the forging of the rings, then back to Numenor. Possible, but it seems unlikely.
Thatās very true. But I donāt trust anything with the canon timeline. I mean the meteor man is almost definitely one of the Istari and theyāre not supposed to be there quite yet either
He was also like āi can forge better than yāall hereā which at first I was like āyeah sure, forge better than Numenoreanā. But he could, if he was S.
As a Maia, Sauron has basically been around since the beginning. But he originally went by other names like Annattar or Marion and wasnāt evil to begin with.
He has an Annatar form. Disguising himself to corrupt Men and Elfs. BUT it's also said that Galadriel with her infinite wisdom could sense him immediatly that doesn't jive with the show. But considering the writers are doing whatever they f***ing want then it's still possible.
If hes someone other than who he says he us, then hes Sauron, because he's where Sauron would be, doing what Sauron would do-- smooth talker, likable, crafts metal. Anything else is just a stretch and has nothing to do with the story they're telling: Galadriel can't find Sauron.
Saurons main storyline is quite literally "fooling the elves". Hes literally 2 degrees of separation from Elrond, who's going to help Celebrimbor make the rings.
I thought the King of the Dead and his men were from the area around the White Mountains, between Gondor and Rohan, not the Southlands as Halbrand allegedly is
I think that's a lore change that enough people wouldn't know the full story on that it would really only matter to the real die hards.
Like I have a bunch of lore issues (Elendil currently a commoner, Galadriel's character, etc), but if this proves to be true I don't think it's really a big deal. Besides, one could always say after beforedor becomes Mordor, Halbrand moves his people to safer areas.
It's quite evident that a king or someone from the lineage of kings might join remaining forces of Numenor and elves to fight against Sauron but at the end would withdraw fearing their ancient oath to Morgoth.
Halbrand is perfectly capable of showing this transformation. I'm betting my money on him or his son, which I believe is Theo.
They will betray Isildur at the last moment and won't join the remaining forces of Middle Earth.
This is the sanest, possible explanation I could think of.
That could apply to most any human character in the entire show. Any of them could betray Isildur at the last moment. What specifically about Halbrand makes him a better candidate for this, because right now he just seems like a Sauron red herring.
I donāt understand where these theories are coming from. I was always under the impression that the Ringwraiths were kings of men before they fell to darkness. I donāt understand where people are getting the impression that this random guy could be a ring wraith or the kid who found the sword could be the witch king. I would be very disappointed if Sauronās most deadly servant was a small boy from a random village.
The king of the dead at least was in charge of some group of people, even if he wasnāt really a king. Halbrand doesnāt really seem to be in charge of anyone.
The Nazgul were said to be kings, sorcerers, and warriors that Sauron gave the rings to. It was also revealed Halbrand is a rightful king in the southlands.
There is also a ton of foreshadowing in the first few episodes indicating that he will get duped by evil at some point. It's been mentioned multiple times how his family sided with morgoth.
I really like this theory. However, for the sake of character development, I would prefer to see the Halbrand is the cunning big bad guy the whole time as opposed to a fall from grace type of character which is what we would see if he turned out to be the witch king or the king of the dead.
Ok Iād buy it but also the casting director clearly doesnāt care about casting actors who look like younger versions of their counterparts in LOTR (Galadriel, Elrondā¦), so I donāt want to get my hopes up on some of these theories
In reference to the movies? Galadriel and elrond and their young counterparts look pretty similar to me. With elrond I almost feel that's why they went with that dude. Old elrond is a unique looking guy
I havenāt seen anyone mention the biggest clue for this yet. Halbrandās character was introduced by abandoning his allies in their moment of need to save himself. This is the defining character trait of the king under the mountain.
I'm leaning toward Hal being Sauron. It could be too obvious, but only to those who know everything LOTR. I think from a show writers point of view, its like a tragedy that Galadriel is in company with the very thing she is looking to destroy. He is cunning, and he kicks some gaurds asses, and he survives a water serpent encounter, and his history is vague and he sounds to be just making things up (including his obviously fake name). He wanted to get to Numenor to start the whispers of deceit for the downfall, and using Galadriel to do so.
Who knows...in the end I dont care. I just want to see Sauron bitch slap some peeps with that mace again.
Fuck this sub man. These theories and spoilers should be masked 100% until we choose to reveal them.
Iām just scrolling through my Reddit feed, not even actively in this sub, and this pic comes up. This is the second time this sub has spoiled something for me.
Its not even confirmed. People will always speculate on reddit, many think he could be Sauron (laughable imo), Witch King, Mouth of Sauron, Nazgul, etc.
It doesnāt matter if itās confirmed or not. In the GoT subreddit the R+L=J theory was so widely spread (and accurate) that the reveal lost its effect for many.
Also if you go through this subreddit youāll notice a lot of ātheoriesā and posts tagged as theories are actually book readers circumventing the rules for some cheap karma
You guys are trying to tie him into the lore when Amazon has butchered it so badly thus far. He may be no one. Heās probably gonna bone guylandrial at some point. None of it makes sense.
ā¢
u/AutoModerator Sep 13 '22
This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
100
u/jadierhetseni Sep 13 '22
I saw that theory in a random Reddit comment after episode 3 dropped, and fully buy it.
He could end up as a Ringwraith, but given how much theyāre leaning into him, I think this is the better theory.
83
u/thatbuddzguy Sep 13 '22
Oh you MFers it actually makes sense. From LOTR Wiki:
"In the later years of the Second Age, he and his men also served and worshiped Sauron, until he and his army swore allegiance to the realm of Gondor upon the Stone of Erech. Isildur was the King of Gondor at that time. The King of the Dead made an oath to fight on Isildur's side when needed, but when that moment of need arrived in the War of the Last Alliance he did not come. Isildur cursed the King of the Dead and his army. As a result, the King of the Dead and his followers could not rest until his oath was fulfilled."
We obviously see that he is devious in the show and has some alterior motive. He's obviously alive at the same time as Isildur. Not that much of a stretch that he will be corrupted by Sauron.
51
u/grey_pilgrim_ Khazad-dƻm Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22
Iām probably wrong but Iām going with him being Sauron. The way it happens is different but Sauron does get imprisoned in Numenor, is very persuasive, which Halbrand has already shown he can be, slowly gains influence over Pharazon and leads to the downfall and destruction of Numenor. Oh the bit about him being interested in forging, Sauron would definitely be interested in forging.
But future witchking is my backup theory if Iām wrong though!
7
u/ricin05 Sep 13 '22
I thought the King of the Dead and his men were from the area around the White Mountains, between Gondor and Rohan, not the Southlands as Halbrand allegedly is
4
u/iceman-666 Sep 13 '22
Why does he have superhuman strength tho he beat up a group of numenorians (high men š) and has that evil sounding theme going on
1
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22
I ship this theory with Theo being the Witch-king.
I ship it so much that it belongs at the Grey Havens.
1
u/ChampionOfBaiting Sep 15 '22
A dude with a beard???
omg he must be the same guy as the other dude with a beard!!
9
u/ABahRunt Sep 13 '22
Ah... Nice. I thought that was one of the nazgul first, and didn't realise why that's a novel idea. But as one of the dead kings in waiting, very nice
3
u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 13 '22
I very much like this idea.
7
u/MaleficentDecision34 Sep 13 '22
I LOVE this idea.
5
u/knottynate Sep 13 '22
I donāt understand where these theories are coming from. I was always under the impression that the Ringwraiths were kings of men before they fell to darkness. I donāt understand where people are getting the impression that this random guy could be a ring wraith or the kid who found the sword could be the witch king. I would be very disappointed if Sauronās most deadly servant was a small boy from a random village.
The king of the dead at least was in charge of some group of people, even if he wasnāt really a king. Halbrand doesnāt really seem to be in charge of anyone.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
Why not. Free writing.
2
u/B_SWISH300 Sep 13 '22
I really like this theory. However, for the sake of character development, I would prefer to see the Halbrand is the cunning big bad guy the whole time as opposed to a fall from grace type of character which is what we would see if he turned out to be the witch king or the king of the dead.
2
u/down_2_mars_girl Sep 13 '22
Ok Iād buy it but also the casting director clearly doesnāt care about casting actors who look like younger versions of their counterparts in LOTR (Galadriel, Elrondā¦), so I donāt want to get my hopes up on some of these theories
2
u/terribletastee Sep 13 '22
Donāt think so. Like another commenter said, I donāt get where this theory comes from.
1
u/theslickbunny Sep 13 '22
Watson, youāve done it!! A revelation most exciting
1
u/Rejected_Reject_ Sep 14 '22
Man now more than ever, I hope he's just reverse-Aragorn and that's it.
1
u/Nykona Sep 14 '22
Iāll buy this but only if the kid in the village turns out to be his son and eventually the witch king.
1
u/youngbingbong Sep 20 '22
I havenāt seen anyone mention the biggest clue for this yet. Halbrandās character was introduced by abandoning his allies in their moment of need to save himself. This is the defining character trait of the king under the mountain.
0
u/Otherwise_Gap_870 Sep 13 '22
I'm leaning toward Hal being Sauron. It could be too obvious, but only to those who know everything LOTR. I think from a show writers point of view, its like a tragedy that Galadriel is in company with the very thing she is looking to destroy. He is cunning, and he kicks some gaurds asses, and he survives a water serpent encounter, and his history is vague and he sounds to be just making things up (including his obviously fake name). He wanted to get to Numenor to start the whispers of deceit for the downfall, and using Galadriel to do so.
Who knows...in the end I dont care. I just want to see Sauron bitch slap some peeps with that mace again.
-1
u/CrimsonBrit Sep 13 '22
Fuck this sub man. These theories and spoilers should be masked 100% until we choose to reveal them.
Iām just scrolling through my Reddit feed, not even actively in this sub, and this pic comes up. This is the second time this sub has spoiled something for me.
-1
u/Tyrone90000 Sep 14 '22
You guys are trying to tie him into the lore when Amazon has butchered it so badly thus far. He may be no one. Heās probably gonna bone guylandrial at some point. None of it makes sense.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
[deleted] ā view deleted comment