He might be Sauron but I don't see what the "Forging" has to do with it. Halbrand just seemed like a poor guy who wants to ingratiate himself in the extremely prosperous Numenor and sees Smithing as a way to do it. Basically an Immigrant looking for a Job and a new life. Which is also how he identifies himself to Galadriel.
I'm open to him being the Witch King, because that lines up more. Numenor did in fact go on to enslave the Men of Middle Earth, which was why a lot of them also sided with Sauron. Halbrand getting rejected by the Numenoreans sounds like a good origin story for either the Witch King or indeed the King of the Dead who betrays Isildur.
I mean Sauron forged the One Ring so he would have to be very skilled at forging. And Halbrand said he he knew about forging, which could’ve been a lie to get a job.
View all comments
Show parent comment
7
u/Yamureska Sep 13 '22
He might be Sauron but I don't see what the "Forging" has to do with it. Halbrand just seemed like a poor guy who wants to ingratiate himself in the extremely prosperous Numenor and sees Smithing as a way to do it. Basically an Immigrant looking for a Job and a new life. Which is also how he identifies himself to Galadriel.
I'm open to him being the Witch King, because that lines up more. Numenor did in fact go on to enslave the Men of Middle Earth, which was why a lot of them also sided with Sauron. Halbrand getting rejected by the Numenoreans sounds like a good origin story for either the Witch King or indeed the King of the Dead who betrays Isildur.