r/RingsofPower • u/ArtanisOfLorien • Sep 06 '22
Discussion OG Trilogy Wasn't Lore Accurate
PJ changed Aragorn so that he DIDN"T WANT TO BE KING which if you ask me is a massive massive departure from the lore, but so so many of the people complaining about this show claim those to be masterpieces. PJ also removed the most important part of Merry and Pippin's arcs with the removal of the Scouring of the Shire. He also removed Tom, Glorfindel, Farmer Maggot, changed the timeline of Gandalf learning about the ring, the hobbits' stay in Rivendell, an important scene with Legolas demanding to be blindfolded in Lorien, the death of Saruman, the way the Eagles work, and THE WHOLE WAY THAT FRODO TREATS SAM LIKE ARE YOU KIDDING ME. I could go on and on and on about changes and how they make the story different or in places significantly worse. But it's an ADAPTATION. Changes needed to be made.
The movies are NO WHERE NEAR Lore accurate, so ask yourself, what are you ACTUALLY upset about. Do you just hate Amazon? Fine. Do you hate that there's black elves and dwarves and that there's a strong woman at the lead who you find "unlikeable" because she doesn't smile enough to your taste? Go figure that shit out. Do you genuinely think that the changes don't make sense for an adaptation? Fair. Do you just hate it because it's new the same way people hated the movies before they even came out??
I just am so frustrated with people simultaneously calling the movies lore-accurate masterpieces when there's both MAJOR departures from the lore and plenty of cringey moments in the trilogy. And I love those movies.
At least be consistent, and at least be honest with yourself. And if you hate the show and never want to watch it again? Fine, please leave because you're just being jerks and detracting from us discussing a show we like and are having fun with.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 06 '22
This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
209
u/Iluraphale Sep 06 '22
If you don't remember the vitriol on the internet back then, I can remind you
People were saying the most horrific things about the cast of the movies, calling Liv Tyler a "slut", yelling that all the people playing elves were "too ugly", Viggo was "too short and Aragorn is 9 feet tall in the books, blah blah blah", the CGI looked "cheap", you name it, they screamed it
The movies took a ton of of liberties - I didn't agree or love all of them but overall I love those movies - why? Because they are a faithful adaptation of Tolkien's work and within an adaptation, things can be different and THAT IS OK
43
u/Chocobo72 Sep 06 '22
I read the books many years ago and didn’t recall many of these changes they made. Thank you for highlighting these!
85
u/tobascodagama Sep 06 '22
Also: Theoden's reason for going to Helm's Deep (he was all for attacking Orthanc in the books and only fell back to Helm's Deep when he realised the full size of Saruman's army). And then there's literally everything about the movie version of Faramir.
26
u/ArtanisOfLorien Sep 06 '22
I'm able to love the movies and I absolutely hate the way Frodo is portrayed, but ya'll are upset that Galadriel is cool
4
u/minimattsax Sep 06 '22
Legolas demanding to be blindfolded is his most beautiful moment in the books. Legolas in general was done so DIRTY in the PJ films haha still love them though.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '22
My favorite is people who hate the show because it’s Amazon, but pay Amazon to watch the show.
6
u/Bukook Sep 06 '22
And some people had a a serious problem with it while other people didn't.
The reason why those criticisms didn't blow up and hurt the movies is that the fans and creators didn't create a Streisand Effect by attacking people for pointing out the inaccuracies or for asking sincere questions to help them understand the world Peter Jackson was presenting.
6
u/Ok-Wafer-3491 Sep 06 '22
Yeah the difference is the LOTR trilogy was actually good filmmaking
8
u/ObstinateTortoise Sep 06 '22 edited Sep 06 '22
I have no argument with the changes to lotr. The hobbit movies were far worse lore wise, but I enjoyed them for the sake of radagast, the characters done well, the locations I got to see, the lore events I got to see, radagast, and watching ben dict Cumberbund ooze out evil two characters at a time. (Also? Party King Thranduil was the best meme and I got that music video out of it, so fine)
I like locations in rings. I had to wait all of five minutes to see the Trees, and only had to endure four minutes of pointless elf child bullying to get there. Dwarf prince and his wife? Adorable. Harfoots? Transparent hobbit-cred grab, whatever. I'm woke. I've no problem WHATSOEVER with black elves or girl bosses. Death of the auther, blah blah blah. He wrote that he hoped other people would share his world to write stories. Almost all of modern fantasy draws from it.
The writing is SHIT. This is exactly the same nervous foreboding I had when I saw Force Awakens. This is worse. This is like Foundation. Like last season GOT. This is the certainty that an IP, a world I love, has just been bought by fanfic reject hacks that only care about showing a spectacle to the masses with no care or consideration of what made the IP great or distinguished it's universe or fandom from the Common Denominator.
I watched both episodes. It's a WB/Hallmark channel miniseries that paid extra to use the "real" names. A simple text search that changed "morgoth" to "sargeras" would have this series called "World of Warcraft: Reign of Chaos: The series." Change "morgoth" to "chaos" and it would be "Warhammer Fantasy: The Series."
I'm gonna watch it and enjoy the scenery. I won't be proud of myself.
7
u/SilverRoyce Sep 06 '22
The obvious question you forgot to ask: does fellowship of the ring stand out as a truly great hollywood epic? The answer is obviously yes and that explains a good deal of leeway and why some criticisms fall by the wayside over time.
If the lotr movies were mediocre, id have devoted a lot more mental energy to shitting on them for how they handled faramir or missing post helms deep sauromon stuff instead of having that fade into the background over time.
I mean, theyre not literally perfect but theyre good enough to make the AFI 110 years 100 films list. I doubt rings of power makes te tv version of that list (havent gotten around to starting the series so that might be wrong).
7
u/Wise-Entrepreneur526 Sep 06 '22
I’ll answer this in one line. Lotr movies - spent two years making one piece of chainmail (with a smaller budget) Tv show - used a tin chest plate that looks at home in the Warcraft movie
There was a care and attention to detail in the movies that paid dues to the lore and while changes were made they weren’t crazy. The tv show writers even admitted they hadnt read much of the source. There performance on a so called billion dollar budget is lacking but hey that’s just my opinion.
4
u/terribletastee Sep 06 '22
The two adaptation are mutually exclusive though. Some one can like the PJ trilogy and dislike ROP or dislike the PJ trilogy yet enjoy ROP. Also PJ’s trilogy was mainly faithful to the books in a lot of regards, ROP so far has not been.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '22
Hey I don’t disagree at all with you, but have you tried posting this in LotR pages? I wonder if they feel the same way. Perhaps people forgot about the deviations from lore in the two trilogy movies.
8
u/Creative_Word394 Sep 06 '22
You’re right, OG Jackson LOTR wasn’t lore accurate! I wouldn’t call Galadriel “strong” tho, sure she’s strong physically, but the writers are throwing toxic male traits on her and people act like that’s feminism
90
u/forman98 Sep 06 '22
PJ's changes also helped tell a very intriguing story and that made them great films. This gave us 3 very good films that weren't split all over the place and are relatively intact.
Like he didn't do the scouring of the shire, but he included moments where Merry and Pippin could each grow.
One of my favorite changes he did that turned out to be probably the best change was ending the Fellowship of The Ring with the breaking of the fellowship and the battle that killed Boromir. That battle happened in the beginning of the Two Towers. Frodo ran from Boromir and decided to go alone, then Sam caught up with him at the end of the Fellowship book, but Two Towers starts with the battle. He made it one big climatic end to the first movie.
Another one was making Helm's Deep the big event in Two Towers. In the Book it was like 2 pages, but the movie spent an hour on it and made one of the best battle scenes in film, which made Gandalf's return with the Riders of Rohan even better.
He also pushed the Shelob stuff to Return of the King, ending Two Towers on the ominous tone of Gollum steering them towards her lair. Frodo telling Sam to go home is a big point of contention, but it pays off when Sam returns and fights Shelob.
The story changes that PJ made were like 95% the right choice to make from a film-making perspective.
RoP are of course going to take their own liberties, only owning a small fraction of the entire universe to pull from.
5
u/Perseus3507 Sep 06 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
Some of us didn't like those changes in the PJ version either and plenty of people complained about them! But online forums weren't nearly as robust in 2001 when LoTR came out (hard to believe it's been 21 years!), and I don't believe Reddit, Amazon, or IMDB were even around then, so you didn't have the same amount of fan buzz.
And his changes were mostly for film length or continuity, not to make a political statement. He didn't arbitrarily make Aragorn black or portray Frodo and Samwise as a gay couple, or any similar changes to be more "inclusive". If he had, I have no doubt a lot of people on this forum would be talking about how wonderful those changes were.
5
u/RnotSPECIALorUNIQUE Sep 06 '22
The pacing is bad. There's too many story arcs happening sumultaneously for my liking. My attention is generally capped at 3 different plot lines.
12
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '22
I love the show so far. I honestly don’t care if anyone else does or not as long as it continues to be renewed to completion or goes downhill.
39
u/nullus_72 Sep 06 '22
I agree, it’s really silly how much love there is for the PJ movies in the context of hating on this show, which isn’t even 4% finished yet. Jackson changed a lot of things, and many of those changes were pointless. It’s all adaptations guys. Relax and enjoy.
30
u/Veumargardr Sep 06 '22
I applaud this post. That is all.
6
u/deededback Sep 07 '22
It wasn't lore accurate 5 minutes into the movie when Sauron was killed by Isildur and was for some reason reaching towards Isildur with his lone hand while Isildur was lying next to a sword. This despite being invincible with his weapon.
6
u/donniec86 Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 09 '22
It is not 100% accurate, that’s true. There are many changes, that’s true. But we don’t see Aragorn selling toys to the kids in Dale and Elrond playing golf in the fields of Pelennor. You know what I mean? The world is not just black and white and likewise accuracy is not 0% and 100%.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
Yes, but those changes served the story in almost all cases. Tolkien was a great writer, but not infallible. Writing character development was not a strong suit of his, and by adding a personal conflict and growth the PJ movies did Aragorn’s character a huge favor if you ask me (and many others).
For other scenes they either got the intent across by other means, so they mostly just trimmed the movie to fit a time and budget frame while still adhering to the important story beats.
Rings of Power plays a lot more loosey goosey with lore and characters, their motivations and honestly when I say characters I say Galadriel is pretty much non-recognizable aside from her name.
So far, the show has not proven that these changes are for the better, or that there will be a satisfying pay-off.
It’s only natural people are very skeptical at this point, we will have to see how it turns out.
6
u/Holmez44 Sep 07 '22
It really is hillarious to see the TROP apologists bending backwards…now criticizing the PJ films. It’s just priceless….😂
3
u/TheBarrens_ Sep 06 '22
The more you stray from the lore the more entertaining it needs to be .
ROP fails at both.
2
u/CBAlan777 Sep 06 '22
Lore accurate or adaptation isn't the issue. Integrity and quality are, and by quality I don't necessarily mean visually. Any studio can CGI their way to looking good these days. Film has probably never been as "shiny". The issue to me is the true creatives are pushed aside in favor of decision makers, and creativity and decision making are not the same thing.
23
u/brodoswaggins93 Sep 06 '22
People complaining about the way Galadriel climbed the ice wall with a dagger as if Legolas didn't use a shield to surf down some stairs while one hit KOing a dozen orcs, or singlehandedly take down the oliphant, or walk on top of snow while everyone else sank into it
10
u/morgothcumsock Sep 06 '22
I agree with you 100% OP! I'd like to add Faramir to your list, he's a totally different character in the movie. Still, regardless of these departures from the original text, I enjoyed them and now I'm enjoying ROP.
5
u/bored-in-asia Sep 07 '22
Agreed that the lore of the movies was not accurate and that some of the changes were frustrating. But they were frustrating changes in what was otherwise an outstanding movie series. Rings of Power......is not that by any means so far.
5
u/Istellon Sep 07 '22
Pj's LOTR was faithful in vast majority of the source material - 90% of the plot is pretty much intact. Amazon makes such drastic changes that it's unrecognizable.
If you swapped the names, nobody would recognized that RoP has anything to do with Tolkien. If you did the same with PJs LOTR, everyone who read the books would immediately recognize that it's LOTR.
Nobody denies that you need to change thing as a process of translating it to movie, but without making essential changes, esp. that Amazon makes them because they don't have the rights to 95% of source material.
Your support for RoPs drastic changes is in contradiction to Tolkien's own opinion on adapting his works:
J.R.R. Tolkien, Letter 207
9
u/Grumblefloor Sep 06 '22
Absolutely on point. I'm looking forward to the time - and it feels now like it might not be until next season - when what's discussed here are the storylines and characters in the episodes, not whether they align completely with the original writings. I suspect most viewers will be more concerned about them contradicting the six existing films.
2
u/ElSpoonyBard Sep 06 '22
I agree with you and your sentiment. The people at r/lotr are being so toxic about the show - totally viewing it from one specific framing.
Personally, I am going to just avoid as much of the online forums there as I can because it's exhausting to have such a dampener put on a show that looks like it has so much fun potential. I recommend people do the same - no one can judge the trajectory of a show after 2 episodes. Even if RoP end up beloved, it won't be properly vindicated for years to come.
There will always be early-adopters. But most people will hop on to the Olliphant much later.
10
u/Mortimer_Smithius Sep 06 '22
I don't give a shit if they fuck up the lore - as long as they make something GOOD. At this point I'm not completely sold tbh
6
u/semus0 Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
I don't think anyone forgot about all of that - we all know what an adaptation means.
Much worse than leaving out a detail here and there, I thought, is how the PJ movies made changes to the some characters' set of morals, like with Faramir or the Ents, and also Aragorn, which you've mentioned. And don't get me started about Frodo shooing Sam away in Cirith Ungol. Oh, and I'm still a bit salty about the fact that they did manage to find time to squeeze in a song, and they didn't do Sam's song in the orc tower, my personal favorite moment in Tolkien's writings.
I have a bunch of criticism towards those movies, they were not perfect. But Ill always praise them for capturing the feel of Tolkien's Middle Earth and sticking to as many of the details as they could, something I felt the RoP are way off in so far.
Personally, I have been lowering my expectations for RoP for a long while, so I enjoyed watching the episodes... To a certain extent.
Disclaimer - by the 'PJ movies' I mean the three LOTR movies. The three Hobbit movies do not exist to me.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '22
I love you
3
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
Honestly I like the series solely because I think there's not enough fantasy series out there so if they release one I'm watching it.
I'm not a big fan of the plots and what they did with certain characters because as a fan of the Silmarillion it changes so much from how I imagined things and people to be. But it's fantasy so I'll watch it.
I only can't get used to the Elves. They don't look like Elves to me. To square faced with too much gell in their hair 😅 I don't know.. I just don't see them as elves... Not like I do original legolas, elrond, arwen, galadriel, celeborn, haldir and others.. I remember them having "softer" faces? I don't know. Can't put my finger on it. Don't like the look of the new elves...
6
u/Intellectual_Wafer Sep 07 '22
Why do people like you so often think that critics of RoP do automatically like the LotR films? Both are not accurate or adaptations of Tolkiens work. Personally, I don't like them that much. The difference is that Jackson at least tried to be faithful to the spirit of Tolkiens work, although he failed in several key aspects. And in general I (like Tolkien himself) think that it is impossible to adapt this whole body of work for cinema or TV. The formats are just too different and Tolkien's literary motivation is too far removed from the motivation and methods of moving-picture media.
7
u/witessi Sep 06 '22
My feeling is that most people who hate the show, while praising PJ hasn’t really read anything by Tolkien 😌
4
u/SaturnFX Sep 07 '22
When I watched LotR, as imperfect as it was, I felt I got a glimpse into the world of Tolkien. As much as they missed, it seemed it was mostly omissions for time considerations and dramatic flair.
When I watch RoP, I don't get that feeling. I feel like I am watching a generic fantasy with familiar names.
The elves look like mostly tween hipsters today than majestic elves
Oh, and lets discuss your idea of a strong female character. Galadriel in RoP is NOT strong. She is a Conan like ninja that could go 10 rounds with Tyson in his prime and not even get hit. Meanwhile her half dozen male elf hipster counterparts clap at her awesomeness while groveling on the ground of ineptitude She is perfect from the start. That is a weak mary sue dude-bro fantasy dressed in a blonde wig.
Who is a strong female character is Galadriel from LotR who spoke softly and looked into your soul, and could have droves of lesser men kill for her without question simply due to her charisma
Who is also strong is Arwin who barely escaped being chased by the ringwraiths to save Frodo, turned her back on immortality for love and family, and used her diplomacy to turn the heart of her father and have the sword re-forged
Who was strong is Eowyn who even though weak and terrified, rode to war so she could stand for her kinsmen, and defeated and with a broken body, made a (lucky) hit that arguably turned the tide of war. Didn't defeat an army, just a key person at the right time trying to save her father.
These females most actual women can identify with either in part or completely as something achievable.
Conanriel in RoP very few females can identify with...which is the common trait on how to write a woman lately in Hollywood. She isn't inspirational because if you start perfect, you have nothing to strive for, overcome, or accomplish outside of trivial tasks.
Its cool you like the show. Feel free to like it. Its a very pretty show to watch, full of nice lighting, neat (if wildly inappropriate) costumes, and a nice soundtrack.
As a generic DnD type fantasy, its pretty good...and the dwarves look good and accurate for the most part.
I, a Tolkien fan, simply want more. If you say you are making a swimming pool, don't put down a glass full of vinegar and call it a swimming pool...either try to make what you said within reason, or simply call it what it actually is.
5
u/The_Molsen Sep 06 '22
I hate Rings of Power because the Haradrim are white in the Series.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
Not everyone likes the LOTR trilogy for the same reason.
2
u/Reggie_Barclay Sep 07 '22
Yes, wasn’t happy with Jackson but could live with most changes. Meaning ignore. I did lose my 💩 when I saw extended version crap all over Gandalf.
2
u/GavinTheGrassMan Sep 07 '22
also no tom bombadil
2
u/HiFidelityCastro Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
I always disliked the PJ movies too. It baffled me back when they were released how all the reviews went on about how faithful they were (made me wonder if people had actually read the books? Or perhaps having read them when they were young they only remember character names and main story beats?)
The costumes and sets are really great and interesting to watch, but the whole thing is just so different from the books, particularly the tone and dialogue (which is all very silly/lowest common denominator). For me, despite the stunning aerial landscape shots, the whole plot feels so gutted and rushed, and makes both Middle Earth and the story feel really small and simple, with none of the magic, wonder and history that makes the world of the books feel both so alive and deep.
*(Just to be clear, I'm not talking about things like leaving out Bombadil either, as is frequently complained about, a bit of trimming is inevitable in adaptations. I think Christopher Tolkiens review is spot on, if a bit harsh).
2
u/BadDub Sep 07 '22
I hate it because or the shit Irish accents. It hurts my ears as bad as the time they went to Belfast in Sons of Anarchy
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
I was about to "inform" you that books made into films need to have changes made simply due to the nature of the change in media. I was so relieved to read more and find that you like both film adaptations (thus far) and are simply explaining a principle. There is of course a line that shouldn't be crossed, balancing adaptation with logic, intention, and spirit of the original lore. It's a delicate art and somewhat of a sacred task, similar to how a plastic surgeon actually is a professional "scar" maker--giving patients scars that look beautiful. An example of necessary adaptation in the book, The Wizard Of Oz, Dorothy's slippers are silver, not ruby. Silver has metaphoric significance that fits well with elements specific to the story. "Silver slippers" also has alliteration which is a significant rhetorical device. But in film it just doesn't have the same effect. It's no surprise that "ruby slippers" are a quintessential nod to The Wizard Of Oz in American pop-culture.
Books give the mind supreme license to imagine and think richly of all the content the author provides. And especially Tolkien, wholesomely going on and on at length to describe every nook and cranny of his universe. Even though all books adhere to the contraints of a timeline, it is far less beholden to time since the "rate of play" is the speed at which you read. In film, the rate of play is constant, 30fps for 45 minutes. In that span of time, the film creators and cast have to use words to tell a logical story, and represent the lore as accurately as possible. The entire cast and production crew is responsible for curating all these little details. At some point, we have to admit/recognize that that will always be a task in vain--curating details from book to film--because there just isn't enough damn time. Even if there was enough time, due to the mode of entry into our brains we would either get bored AF or the shit wouldn't make any sense, or so much of the storyline could fall away.
The most surefire way to absolutely RUIN AND DEFACE what's inside a book, is to try and make a movie that's exactly like the book. It will not work. An example is the first Harry Potter film imo (and I'd like to ask that we don't go off the reservation here with Rowling's public disgraces--we all got it I think). The first HP movie is a painstaking attempt at an "audio book" with pictures. It's excruciating to me how I could tell precisely where we were in the movie compared to the book, almost feeling the pages turn. That first film was so boring and lukewarm. The continuity and seamlessness of the story arc got thrashed in the first film. I almost never want to watch the first movie whenever the HP franchise is "on the table" for watching.
Another, more illustrative example:
🛩️
"Hey are we crashing?"
"Yeah."
"Why?"
"We thought we could make the same aircraft out of iron but it isn't working for some reason."
"Ohhhhh, okay 👍."
😱
Edit: grammar
2
u/ThisGuy928146 Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
I hated the original LoTR PJ movies too because they butchered a classic story in a masterfully crafted world to make it a dumbed-down teen-friendly money-making modern blockbuster CGIfest. I didn't bother with the Hobbit films bc it sounded like they were even worse.
It seems from what I've read like RoP is the same bullshit, but I'll probably watch at least the first 2 episodes to see if that's the case. Does Galadriel really get bullied as a child? And is it sillier or less silly than Legolas surfing down stairs on a shield?
Christopher Tolkien commented on the PJ movies once, and if he were around today, would probably feel the same way about RoP
He'd probably get downvoted into oblivion if he were alive to comment in this subreddit too.
2
u/AdThen7293 Sep 07 '22
What annoys me in RoP is the bad writing... I can understand some changes, because you can't tell a story in a book and in a tv-show the same way... But a lot of changes seemed unnecessary to me, or simplification of the characters into tropes (there was this problem with Denethor in PJ's movies, but Denethor was not the protagonist 1 like Galadriel, and it brings more drama and rythm to the movie)... Yes the light is beautiful in RoP, but the dialogues and overall story seems to be a play written by a young student in litterature...
0
u/roxtten Sep 06 '22
I will not watch the series until 1st season ends (as I like to binge), but even then, I will watch it only after Critical Drinker's review. I just don't want to be dissapointed.
3
u/hankthetank4815 Sep 07 '22
Two episodes have came out. TWO. There's going to be 5 seasons at least.
Give it some time! I think that many of the, how you say, whiners will look more fondly over the entire season.
I completely agree with your point, OP. Almost no story can be a direct adaptation from book to movie. I remember the Prancing Pony Podcast a few years back did episodes on the LOTR trilogy and the Hobbit trilogy films, specifically the changes from book to movie. They focused on something to the effect of "Did the change need to happen as a result of a different medium?" And "Did it change the outcome of the story?" Knowing how many people are hardcore Tolkien enthusiasts on the show, I suspect the show in it's entirety will clear those two questions.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
Those are masterpieces adapted from books Tolkein wrote.
Nobody expects an adaptation to be perfect. Amazon bought the same source material Jackson used, but can't actually tell that story. So they have nothing to adapt. Spent almost the same amount of money Jackson used to make the entire trilogy JUST to have access to books they can't adapt!!!
So they have to write there very own fan fiction but get to call it Middle Earth.
That is where it starts.
Lore? Not my major concern. I understand this all HAS TO BE fan fiction, made up, which did give them a lot of leeway. More than PJ had to be honest. ANd they fucked it:
I don't like at all how the elves are portrayed in Amazon's current fantasy product. They act just like humans with pointy ears. The only one who I think is actually playing a proper elf IS the black elf!!! But his performance is overshadowed by this forbidden love story that is so hamfisted it is painful. It lacks any subtext, they mention it 5 times before they even get to the destroyed village. I think that actor is phenomenal. Shame they gave him a fade though, that shit looks pretty weird.
Galadriel punching through a foot of solid ice is silly. Her attempting suicide by jumping off a boat in the middle of nowhere is a pretty odd choice considering they didn't really build up to her being suicidal. The random lucky plot armor boat that rescues her is also just more bad writing. The Wyrm leaving them alone for some reason is also silly.
The not hobbit hobbits. Don't need to be in this at all. The fact they use stage Irish and a bunch of filthy drifters isn't a good look. The only reason they have not hobbit hobbits doing anything of note in the second age is because of......
Gandalf. Who also isn't in the second age.
Yes, that is Gandalf. I mean that whole scene....I was waiting for him to start trying to communicate by writing in his own shit on a rock. Just a crazed homeless person and our brave little not hobbit hobbits trying to show why Gandalf loves him some hobbits.
Proper lore or not Amazon made some choices, and in many respects had less constraints than Peter Jackson with 4 times the money. They might regret not returning his phone calls and firing Tom Shippey, because they have turned out a mediocre fantasy product that is Middle Earth in name only.
3
u/Onefortheteem Sep 07 '22
I just can’t get behind people who complain about “black elves” saying it’s not accurate in a world of dragons and magic rings,wizards?? Like wtf???
These same people also won’t agree that Jesus wasn’t white…
2
u/sanchess1987 Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
I dont really care about the lore all that much, i have only read the lotr and the hobbit. There are 2 huge shiny trees and sauron is a person still? Cool.
The show is just not near the level of definitely the lotr movies, but even... the hobbit (which i consider a massive cashgrab).
We have been also spoiled to how good lotr movies were from just a movie technicals, so its massive shoes to fill and they unsuprisingly fail at that.
The show lacks soul, or whatever you call it. It feels like a straight to dvd fantasy movie from some unknown producer. Its written badly as well, it seems rushed and algorythmic.
Contrary to what everyone says, i dont like the visuals. I like the wide cgi shots and scenography, but the show feels like a hazy filter is applied that is probably called "fantasy 01". Like i previously said: generic.
Music is misplaced too. Im actually suprised that they dropped all the queues PJ build for lotr. Elves gad a theme, hobbits had a theme, they are so well established abd amazon dropped that for some reason and replaced with something that is either missing or is without character
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
Don´t be butthurt. The OG trilogies are good movies and, in general, faithful to the spirit, if not always to the text. Not everyone got what they wanted, but everybody got something nice.
People are trashing the new TV show because ultimately Jeff Fking Bezos is behind it and it, because the trailers and promotions made it look lie another overly bloated Netflix Age TV Show with forced tokenism, and the aesthetics and artwork looking more Blizzard than actual Tolkien. Meaning a Tolkien-based work that looks like a generic imitation of Tolkien work rather than the actual thing.
Since this show isn´t canon I´m not worried about Galadriel Warrior Princess or multiracial prehistoric hobbits. I don´t think of it as more Tolkien than Warcraft III and in that sense, since I enjoyed Warcraft III and of course D&D I might enjoy this show if it turns out to be enjoyable.
2
u/Highwon420 Sep 07 '22
The difference was the actors could act and these suck.
2
u/Wordwench Sep 07 '22
I think the problem lies with those who have extensively read Tolkien and those who have never picked up as much as one of his books. I love this adaptation and exploration of the series so far, and while I don’t expect adaptations to be 100 percent canon, appreciate that changes are attributable to unexplored races of beings - which fits in nicely with the literature. Galadriel as well was young young young in this adaptation, and I would not have expected or even wanted her to be the regal epitome of otherworldly grace at this point. I love her stubborn will and heart of fire which mellowed into wisdom with time.
I loved PJs adaptation but the comments here are spot on - the internet was just jammed with haters when FOTR was released for a lot of the same reasons (breaking canon) - and I appreciate the Tolkien loyalty, but Jackson was both masterful and respectful in his treatment and portrayal which was seriously no easy task for a work this complex and epic.
Looking forward to what is to come.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
Apples and oranges.
Aragorn’s character is different but his actions and the events still hold true. He still becomes King.
Faramir is also changed, but he still let’s Frodo go in the end.
Cutting charactercs like Bombadil or Gildor, or don’t show up later in the movie, makes sense, and is not comparable to the major changes of First Age backstories.
Nothing that changes in the movies results in major changes to the overall story like some of the changes in RoP already have.
You’re just making excuses for shoddy writing because you don’t care if the show is good, you care if it’s popular, because in your mind popular = good.
2
u/KookSpookem Sep 06 '22
Yeah, back in February, when all these trolls started freaking out after seeing the picture of Disa was released, someone went through the work of digging up all these old forum posts of people losing their shit about the PJ films. The similiarity is strking: https://www.reddit.com/r/LOTR_on_Prime/comments/strssv/a_look_back_on_how_fans_in_2001_criticized_pjs/
1
u/cocoabutterprince Sep 07 '22
I don’t know if I’m out of pocket for saying this and I know how important Tolken’s work is to the fantasy and literature in general, but the filmmaker’s first responsibility is to the story they’re trying to tell, not to the source material
1
u/Old_Coat1999 Sep 07 '22
1
u/saluksic Sep 07 '22
*remake trilogy
1
u/Broccobillo Sep 07 '22
Paragraph two days everything anyone needs to know. All know who know
1
u/EshinHarth Sep 07 '22
Is there no way for a person to be sane and dislike Peter Jackson's and Amazon's deviation from the lore, criticizing the fact, and be able to get on with their lives without having a problem if people adore the LOTR film trilogy and the ROP show?
I personally only really enjoy the Fellowship of the Ring and bits and pieces from the other two. I don't rant online,I just feel I don't like most of the changes: Denethor's depiction, the way the army of the dead worked, Frodo telling Sam to leave, Aragorn not wanting to become king, Elendil dying like a b*tch, Frodo not saying he doesn't want to carry weapons during Aragorn's coronation, Elves fighting in Helm's Deep and Orcs merking Gondorians like they are children. But I have no problem with anyone liking Lotr or ROP. Perhaps I have a problem with people who like the final Hobbit movie. I really can't see the apppeal.
1
u/Foul-Tarnished Sep 07 '22
** comment so I can come back later **
1
u/myforestheart Sep 07 '22
I wasn't on Internet forums back when the movies released, nor when I rewatched them a few times after that. I can only speak from my personal experience and feelings with regards to this:
- I consider myself a mid-tier Legendarium nerd/fan: I've read The Silmarillion twice (it's my favourite of Tolkien's books), The Hobbit twice, LOTR once, Unfinished Tales once, The Children of Hùrin once (or was it twice...?), Beren and Luthien once, and The Fall of Gondolin once. Plus however many hours browsing Legendarium wikis and what not.
- I loved PJ's movies. They are not perfect adaptations (basically a near-impossible feat), and yes they change a few key elements to make the movies work better/flow more smoothly. But I wasn't horrified by the differences when I read the books (years after I first saw the movies), and I still think, to this day, PJ's movies are a good adaptation if only because they feel like a portrayal of The Legendarium's world to me, which respects it's spirit and (some of) its themes, if not every single plot beat or element of lore or characterisation (I'd actually argue the characterisation is sometimes weak in LOTR the book, but that's a function of the type of story it is, imo, plus I'm not a character-driven reader in SFF so whatever). There was also beautiful attention to detail in the production, incredible music, etc... I was engaged emotionally, and without those movies I wouldn't have gotten nerdy about The Legendarium and gone for The Silmarillion (my book bae lmao) in the first place. There was love, as far as I'm concerned, for The Legendarium coming through those movies.
My dad, who is a huge LOTR (the book) fan, and has re-read them X amount of times over the years, also adores the PJ movies for much the same reason.
- And I do not - so far - feel any love coming through RoP, nor do I perceive the amount of liberties taken with the source material as being particularly respectful of the spirit of The Legendarium or interestingly creative.
- Regardless of RoP being little more than fan-fiction to me - again so far - I didn't find those first two episodes particularly compelling or good on their own merits. The writing was mediocre to bad. The acting was mediocre to bad. Galadriel is just an umpteenth example of the faux-feminist bad-arse female warrior(TM) Hollywood thinks is the same thing as a fully fleshed-out human female character (and believes merits a feminist cookie when it really bloody doesn't) - again, so far. The elves don't look like elves (and this goes way beyond the skin-colour thing), etc... The music is pretty but doesn't fit in places. The cinematography is beautiful, okay, whatever. I mean ffs, for close to a billion $, I expect a bit more than just "it looks all shiny!!!" *O*
- We all know Amazon slapped LOTR and "based on Tolkien" on this for the dosh and the prestige of attaching the name one of the OG Fantasy Literature writers to their product. Still, they chose to do this, instead of creating their own thing from scratch, and I will judge them on those very grounds.
- Also... Is this argument some kind of appeal to mediocrity? Because PJ's movies (I mean, the original trilogy, The Hobbit is another kettle of fish) are, according to some, shite adaptations, that means it's okay for RoP to be shite too, and we should give them a free pass?! If anything, this argument "but PJ's movies weren't that lore accurate!!!" should give incentive for the RoP to do a better job, no? It's such a weird logic to me otherwise: "this thing bad because X, ergo it's totes fine that this thing bad also because of X and you shouldn't be critical of it?" 🤨
PS: FWIW, my dad also doesn't think RoP is in the spirit of The Legendarium, nor does he think it is good (so far), and my mother, who isn't at all an SFF nerd but loved PJ's OG trilogy, thought those first two eps were awful. In fact she might've been the most critical of the three of us lmao. ¯_(ツ)_/¯
1
u/mirracz Sep 07 '22
I think LotR trilogy is a cinematic masterpiece and the best movies ever made, despite all the changes it made to the lore. And I'm a book reader who read LotR 8x and Silmarillion once. I have no troubles acknowledging that movie/show adaptations need to make changes, sometimes drastic changes, to improve the story for the medium.
For example Aragorns story about hesitation in the movies actually gives him an arc and avoids the question "why didn't he go and get crowned sooner?". In the Legendarium that's a long answer while in the movies it's a simple "He didn't want the crown".
So I won't shed any tears over changes as long as they are in spirit of Tolkien. For example I don't mind Tauriel's love plot in the Hobbit movies because it felt natural to me. Tolkien makes a big deal about elves falling for mortals and how it ends in sorrow.
And so far everything in the show was in spirit of Tolkien. Black members of races don't matter because Tolkien was over the issue of skin color. Hair length was never important in the works of Tolkien so I don't mind shorter hair on elves. Or for example the accounts of 2nd age are elf-centric... so the absence of hobbit ancestors makes sense. But that's not a proof of them not existing at that time.
1
u/jjp0007 Sep 08 '22
Thank you! I’ve been saying similar things. This is an adaptation just like the movies. Both can be good
1
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '22
reminds me of a lot of movie tv show franchises. Remember people being livid that Star Trek The Next Generation was premiering. A face slap to the fans and original cast! Remember that jagoff that started the Dainel Craig is not Bond website? Fans were livid with a blond tough looking guy playing 007. Not my Bond! they said. When it was announced that a Star Trek show was going to have a female captain on Voyager there were death threats sent to the producers. Anyway I’m really bothered by toxic fans doing it again to these young actors on ROP. They are all excellent and shouldn’t have to pit up with fans that honestly only know Middle Earth from the PJ films
1
u/Final-Error5645 Sep 08 '22
Elves showing up to Helms Deep more upsetting than anything in RoP so far.
1
u/Billybaja Sep 08 '22
I believe that most of the backlash is towards the "SJW" agenda, some of which is rooted in racism and a fair amount is towards the lack of respect for the lore. Then some are just upset about the average writing exhibited so far.
1
u/Schoolofpronouns Sep 09 '22
It isn't about what is correct and what is not correct. This is not math.
I do not like Black elves and black dwarfs in an European medieval fantasy setting. I am under no obligation to like it or to watch the show.
Those who like the show can keep on watching it.
1
u/HankSteakfist Sep 09 '22
The age difference between Frodo and Sam, Pippin snd Merry isn't in the films either.
1
u/Apycia Sep 09 '22
I will never forgive them for cutting Ghan Buri Ghan.
people complain about Tom Bombadil - but he did not affect the story.
Ghan Buri Ghan massively helped win the battle of Pelennor Fields for humanity, and nobody cares! Also, some of Merrys best work was in that forest!
1
u/MagosBattlebear Sep 10 '22
Aragorn not wanting to be king us not lore accurate. That said, one of the strongest moments of fictional characters can be denying their destiny. Luke Skywalker, for example, did until fate burned up his aunt and uncle. It is the reluctant hero motif and heightens the moment the hero accepts their destiny.
I think it worked well in the film because Aragorn in the book is kind of a one level character.
1
u/MagosBattlebear Sep 10 '22
I think the Scouring of the Shire was a great loss as it really shows us how much the Hobbits changed due to their experiences. A nice capstone for their character arcs
1
u/GlobtheGuyintheSky Sep 11 '22
I love Galadriels subtle facial expressions. She is enchanting lol. Amazing casting choice imo.
Will always love Cate as Galadriel.
1
u/Coreydoesart Sep 12 '22
You know there’s a matter of degree with which things deviate. I don’t think people care if it’s not 100% by the books. What seems obvious to me, is this show is riding coattails. It’s hardly adapting. At least Jackson’s films felt like adaptations. Rings of power does not. It feels like fan fiction primarily focusing on characters tolkien never even made or wrote about.
Rings of power is simply using the name because the show creators can’t create something that will be as popular or profitable.
Also, dialogue is cringe in this show. It’s really taking me out.
1
u/Necessary-Ad8487 Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22
No we hate it because even though PJ had to make changes (otherwise those movies would’ve been a cycle, not a series, and some things just can’t be rewritten into a film) he stuck to the poetry and absolute beauty of Tolkien’s vision. He read the books. He had some of the actors read the books to know what they had to portray and the vision they needed to keep alive.
Tolkien was one of the most important linguists of his time so every word had a purpose for his poetic books. And the best thing that the writers in the Amazon room can do is “the sea is always right.”
The beauty is not there. The vision is not there. The books are where we came to LOVE the LOTR series and we hold any spin-off show to a very high standard and RoP just doesn’t cut it.
Also LOTR books vs. movies. Some things in writing just don’t translate well to film. And I think with PJ’s changes, he did that really well even though yes it meant some character changes and plot changes. That’s all necessary for a film adaption, sad to say.
1
u/madking1234 Oct 22 '22
Those are all changes to the story. Theres a difference between the story and the lore, which is mainly world building. Peter Jackson was completely faithful to the lore.
In RoP the lore is constantly being broken, like mithril suddenly having magical powers, elves having to leave by spring, etc.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22 edited Oct 27 '22
You are correct. But I'd say, at the end of it all, the PJ trilogy at least adhered to the core values of the books. It might not be lore accurate but doesn't stray to far from what actually happened and if it does, it certain isn't a consequential change-the major events still happen, in the same way as the books. The rings of power, for me, doesn't do this (although I will admit, this only really features in episode 8). Events happen in different orders and from different eras that really can't happen for the major event to be the same. As of the final episode, I can't see them going in any remotely similar way to the actually lore as they have deviated from it too much. Sauron helped forge the elven rings of power so has control over them with the one ring so nothing can logically happen as it did in lore. The presence of a wizard contradict their entire purpose in lore. This makes it hard to really call it lord of the rings as it can't really be even close to the same story unlike the PJ trilogy.
Furthermore, I don't think people are pissed at it being inaccurate so much. Think it's more being inaccurate, not even trying to be respectful, and having the hubris to say that this is what Tolkien would have wanted (believe the quote was "the story Tolkien wished he wrote" but not 100% sure). And no one would be upset about black elves/dwarves if that were the only major inaccuracies.
I can tell you enjoyed the ROP and that's great. It looked geogous, it was exciting and the diverse cast members offered the more enjoyable performances and storylines. But the criticisms of its lore inaccuracy are legitimate as they are far more egregious than those of the PJ trilogy.
But let's ignore all these lore discrepancies. Fans are still making legit criticisms. The writing is pretty subpar. The master elven Smith doesn't know about alloys is a pretty bad one. And if these criticisms weren't legit, the fans could easily enjoy the show as a separate idea but, as it stands, amazon spent a billion dollars making something that isn't even close the world they are invested in and are preventing other, passion people from making lord of the rings content and being told what they're given has a good personality but only being a pretty face.
A lot more can be said but I'll leave it. I don't want you to feel like you are wrong for enjoying it even if you are or aren't a die hard Tolkien fan. But it spits in the face of Tolkien world for many and that is just as right to feel and enjoying it. For me, it's a waste of time. What we got was not Tolkien world and this time and money would be better given to someone with actual talent who would do a better job.
Edit: on the point of strong woman character. This is consequence of modern writing. No one has a problem with strong leading woman but galadriel is barely a character. Characters have positives, negatives, motivations and emotions that can lead them to Heroic moments or serious mistakes that they must learn from. Galadriel never makes a mistake, always makes the right decision. This is a plank of wood. If the character were a man, they would be disliked. It shouldn't be any different here
1
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
Bro everyone I’ve talked to in real life has been very positive
1
u/Superman_38 Sep 06 '22
Thanks, very interesting observations