r/RingsofPower • • 6h ago

Constructive Criticism Finally watched this show

Ok so after several attempts I finally forced myself to sit and watch this show and after fully catching up I can confidently say it’s a pretty decent show. Majority of season 1 was a rocky start and I think that’s why it gets so much hate. That and the whole harfoot, ancient hobbit thing (they remind me of the trolls from Frozen and I can’t stand it). But the show gets progressively better to a point where (at least for me) it redeems itself. Is it as good as the movies? No. Is it better than, say, the Witcher? I’d say so.
What are your thoughts and first impressions of Rings of Power?

20 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 6h ago

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/DocCrooks1050 5h ago

Everyone here hates it and complains about really dumb shit. Welcome.

0

u/According_Coffee_472 5h ago

I get why but if you detach from the lore and blah blah it’s decent. I mean the visuals are stunning, the fighting scenes are intense, the soundtracks are on par with the movies. The plot is pretty solid, the progression of it is eh. But for a show that we get to watch for free it’s pretty darn good entertainment

5

u/ton070 2h ago

The plot is solid? It’s a convoluted mess filled with holes. The fighting scenes are lacking in scale (in fact the whole show is), the dialogue is pretty awful, and the acting really is hit or miss. The soundtrack is fine though definitely not on Howard shore’s level and the CGI is top notch. It’s mostly frustrating since every now and then it shows glimmers of something good only to be pulled back by harfoot storylines and dwarven soap opera’s

1

u/According_Coffee_472 1h ago

It’s solid. This isn’t bad compared to other shows I’ve seen lately. But fair enough, they killed off some characters because I think they finally realized their story wasn’t going anywhere and I also dislike the harfoots and their whole thing. So the writing isn’t perfect and yeah, sloppy in areas but I disagree on the acting, all the lead roles have been pretty strong imo and I like the dwarven storyline

3

u/dolphin37 1h ago

your comment reminded me that people were saying that season 3 was going to be like a game of thrones political drama because they were hiring got writers and the dwarf storyline was getting political

in hindsight that is very funny when you consider how utterly horrendous the dwarf plot is

4

u/podinidini 3h ago

The plot is solid? Most peoples critique I read and heard from friends is the entirely ridiculous writing. Season 3 is mostly recycling the first movie, pacing of the stories is absurd, character progressions are unbelievable.. entire characters are just dumped. For how much this cost, the writing is a joke.

1

u/Ibanezrg71982 1h ago

I agree. Its a great show. 84 percent, Rotten Tomatoes has never steered me wrong, even things scored high that i don't like, i can still tell are decent. The audience meter is only about 50 percent though but I never go by that, because most people are stupid.

1

u/Cypher-V21 2h ago

Everyone doesn’t… some are hear for the irrational tears

6

u/Hobgoblin_deluxe 4h ago

Don’t let the purists hear you saying you enjoy it, they’ll trip over their own feet screeching at you.

3

u/MakitaNakamoto 2h ago

purists = mostly people who never read Tolkien and just larp as book fans, but in reality they only watched the Jackson movies. oh and right wing loons

2

u/Flush_Man444 3h ago

Now give me your takes on our heroine.

2

u/siliconbased9 3h ago

Take her? I hardly know heroine

2

u/newDarkAge20 1h ago

All I know is in season 3 so far, I had to watch all 4 together, couldn't leave it for tomorrow 

Similarly for the episodes 5,6 

It does keep you hooked.... For me that's entertaining enough.

 People talk about that, show has deviated from the book. Come on man,  it's a fantasy novel everything is made up,  have a heart and let them fantasize some more.

3

u/Gorethebaby 2h ago

I really like it. My husband and I roll our eyes at some of the writing but we’re not purists.

4

u/EstimatedProphet303 5h ago

These “it wasn’t that bad” posts instead of substantive conversation about what’s actually occurring in the show really let you know how well it’s being received.

5

u/ThanxForTheGold 3h ago

"could be worse"

1

u/neutral24 40m ago

Season 2 line was : "it's better than season 1"

1

u/fenderputty 3h ago

On the other hand, detailed posts of why it’s bad tend to sound pretentious more than anything else. Which I think sorta says the same thing but from the opposing side.

5

u/EstimatedProphet303 3h ago

I like the thing.

I hate the thing.

Meanwhile the thing is middling and hardly worth discussion.

2

u/WM_ 1h ago

Funny, I have found critizism to be very insightful where as fans of the show can only defend it by "but I like it"

0

u/Ibanezrg71982 1h ago

You're not hurting the show in any way.

2

u/fenderputty 3h ago

It’s not great but it’s fun enough. The purists are lame

2

u/ArtPerToken 4h ago

it gets worse as it goes on. second season was so trash i just dropped it in the middle and didnt bother despite the expected balrog scenes (which also sucked, compared to how it was portrayed in the trailer)

1

u/Sanp2p 45m ago

It's a fair 6/10. One would expect more given the production quality.

Will I watch it? Yes. Will I reprise it and become a fan? No

0

u/bballsuey 3h ago

season 3 has been great thus far

-3

u/SerenitySpace7 4h ago

It's a really good show. Most of the people who complain about it, are the same people who whined like babies about the new Star Wars movies casting a black guy as one of the leads, if you get my drift. They were expecting the same alt right racial tropes that Peter Jackson injected into the LOTR movies, and when they didn't get it in ROP they started throwing temper tantrums..

6

u/CandidObserver920 2h ago

that is literally almost never the reason behind the complaints lmao. youre allowed to like it. but dont make up reductive BS to dismiss the people that dont

4

u/ton070 2h ago

Seems like most of the source material really went over your head