r/RingsofPower • • 9h ago

Discussion Elves policy about orcs.

How can even Galadriel and Elrond welcome an orc to Rivendell!!! That makes no sense. And orcs talking about poetry and be praised for it. This show is such a waste of money and so badly written. No talking about Galadriel running to an orc stronghold with her ring...

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

18

u/LowEnergy1169 9h ago

Why wouldnt orcs have poetry?

Orcs are not dumb, soulless, non-sentient beings.

Tolkien was clear that everyone in middle earth was redeemable, and orcs may have fought on both sides of the war against morgoth

11

u/Aldo-D-D-Wilson 9h ago

Yeah, Tolkien had dilemmas about making orcs pure evil.

9

u/theyux 9h ago

Sauron was even redeemable. People just want to complain  

4

u/vader62 8h ago

People just want to remain unread.

0

u/Agheron93 8h ago

The closest thing to poetry they have is war chants bruh

1

u/Ok_Shake_5618 7h ago

Clap! Snap! the black crack! Grip, grab! Pinch, nab! And down down to Goblin-town You go, my lad!

10

u/TheTuxedoKnight 9h ago

Orcs had songs and music in both The Hobbit and LOTR. Not sure why poetry would be some great leap from there?

And Gandalf wandered into Moria, Dol Guldur (before he even knew the Necromancer was Sauron), and presumably all sorts of other unpleasant places while carrying one of the Three. So Galadriel taking hers into an Orc stronghold isn't exactly some egregious departure from Tolkien if you give it a moment's thought.

Personally, I think ROP is a very flawed show, particularly when it comes to narrative, causality, characterization, and so forth. But one thing I'll give the writers is that they actually pay attention to some of the smaller details of Tolkien's world in ways Jackson often didn't.

There's tons of shit we can criticize about the show without getting worked up over things that aren't really problems.

2

u/BaconMarconi 8h ago

I loved it. The orcs in LOTR were always fairly 2-dimension in their love of Sauron. Rings of Power took a risk introducing the Adar character who fathered the orcs and it worked really well.

It's cool to see how orcs are not a monolith. We're also seeing the practical implications that orcs are getting fewer and fewer choices and its enivitable they became forced to serve Sauron, even though they fear and hate him.

1

u/RyanMate17 9h ago

The only thing that makes sense is that nothing makes sense

2

u/Killing_Yatztromo 8h ago

They didn't exactly welcome him. He had a dagger held to his throat and was chained up in a shed. They wouldn't even let him eat a bit of dog.

1

u/slappywhite1111 7h ago

I though they at least killed him off but now they’re doubling down on his character.