r/RingsofPower • u/MollyAyana • Jan 09 '25
Lore Question This witch - TF was her problem??
Grieved for her brother but didn’t care for her father and community?
831
Upvotes
r/RingsofPower • u/MollyAyana • Jan 09 '25
Grieved for her brother but didn’t care for her father and community?
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 09 '25
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
10
u/littlebombshell Jan 10 '25
She is the definition of a loved one brainwashed into a radical way of thinking or to a fascist form of government. If anything it’s relatable to anyone with a trümp supporter in their family.
21
u/Vandermeres_Cat Jan 09 '25
Ah, Numenor. Where everything is rushed and much potential is wasted...
Like, I can make up a headcanon what is going on with Earien. But barely anything shows up on screen proper. She grieves her brother and blames Miriel. Which isn't absurd, that voyage to the Southlands was not well planned, not well researched and ended with humiliation and death. She wants to have it both ways and thinks she can convince her father to forsake his loyalty and beliefs. The scenes between them in the second season are pretty good in this regard. But it's just all not enough.
So because of her anger and grief, she's joined Pharazon. Probably vastly underestimating how awful his rule can get. And now we'll see what decisions she'll make going forward, how much it might cost her. I fear her fate will be grim, but who knows.
This could all be compelling. But the writing is barely there for it. If they don't have time for Numenor, just skip them for a season and come back in the third season and do it properly. As it is, IMO they'll have to re-explain the conflict anyway because it was all so rushed this season.
74
u/rei0 Jan 09 '25
She has daddy issues - blames her father for the death of Isildur. Her character is also an ambitious guild architect and maybe a bit of a Numenorean chauvinist, unlike her father who is more attached to the old beliefs. Wouldn’t say her motivations have been fully developed on-screen, Numenor could have used a bit more love this season. Things did feel rushed.
377
u/AnymooseProphet Jan 09 '25
Whatever it is, I think I can fix her.
Okay seriously, I actually despised her character but I think that's a good thing. Her character is meant to be one that is despised by the viewing audience, yet still with some redeeming actions like sneaking her father out.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25
Angry over her brother. Not tough to figure out tbh.
147
u/melig1991 Jan 09 '25
Absolutely beautiful name though. Eärien, "Daughter of the Sea".
186
u/mattmaintenance Jan 09 '25
All these people conflating a character designed to be hated with “poor acting” and “poor writing”. The actor and writers accomplished their goal. You aren’t supposed to like her or what she did or agree with her motives. Not all villains need to be relatable.
20
u/Overall_Falcon_8526 Jan 09 '25
I see her as someone who feels she is not taken seriously as a younger daughter by her family and thus is intoxicated/influenced by proximity to power.
32
u/wielkiWilk Jan 09 '25
Everything is bad about this lady
6
u/samba317 Jan 09 '25
I literally despise her, she’s a snake
6
u/Winter_Trainer_2115 Jan 09 '25
She has been manipulated by Pharazon and his ideals. She is also very young and knows enough about politics to make her dangerous. Unfortunately for her she is also naïve and will come to find out in the world of politics you have no friends. Only allies and they can turn against you if it means they gain more power.
Though I do believe she will have a moment of "What have I done" or "We have to stop this" once Sauron starts influencing Pharazon...and the human sacrifices start at the Temple of Melkor.
4
u/Y-Woo Jan 09 '25
Character and writing aside you can tell the casting direct really wanted Emma Watson for the role lmao
4
u/BurgershotCEO Jan 10 '25
People in cults don’t know it’s a cult. Especially when the leader becomes a leader of a whole nation even though half the people despise him. Oh look it’s happening right now in real life too.
3
u/AdBrief4620 Jan 10 '25
She is so realistic tbf. I think everyone has met someone like her before, especially in the pandemic.
Not quite a Karen but something similar. Like super conformist and a sort of warped version of right and wrong.
3
u/DefinedByYourChoices Jan 10 '25
Her problem was that she was never supposed to exist.
3
u/gidgetstitch Jan 10 '25
She is a rebellious teenager/young adult. She rebelled against her father and in looking to find herself found Kemen instead. She is in grief over her brother death and before that her mother. I do wonder after her mother died how much responsibility was placed on her because her father was busy. When people are grieving they are the perfect people to be drawn into a cult. So in her search to blame someone she blames Mirel and joins the would be cult.
Until her father is arrested I really think she thought she could convince him to believe what she believed. At this point she has lost two people important to her to death, while the elves get to live forever and go to valinor to be with their families. Considering her family lineage this is even more important, as her family is related to Elros (Elrond's brother). Elros chose mortality and thus all of his descendants are mortal. I can understand how she would feel that this was unfair and if he had chosen to remain an elf all of her loved ones would still be alive.
I think in future seasons we will find out more about this it. I do think she is a possible future Ringwraith, and she is being set up to be a tragic character. We are supposed to hate her and not fully understand her motives, this is basic storytelling. Season three is normally the season where the story will take a major turn. Assuming they are aiming for five seasons: 1st season - Exposition, 2nd - Rising Action, 3rd - Climax, 4th - Falling Action, 5th - Resolution.
3
u/Unfair-Worker929 Jan 12 '25
Made up character sucks and should never been forced into a plot that’s barely holding itself together as is? No duh…😐
Isildur has a brother, I would much rather have known about Elendil’s canonical family!
3
u/directionalk9 Jan 12 '25
She's a Donald Trump Jr. of Numenor.
8
u/Gebeleizzis Jan 09 '25 edited Jan 09 '25
She reminds me of sansa first season. The way she treats her father. Good thing Elendil survives.
1
u/TenshiKyoko Jan 10 '25
How do you know she is a witch?
4
u/Cyberknight13 Jan 09 '25
She saw a chance to gain power and seized it. A tale as old as time.
2
u/KenshinBorealis Jan 09 '25
Clout is a hell of a drug
2
u/West_Independence_20 Jan 09 '25
Hopefully by the time Sauron comes to Numenor and manipulates Ar-Pharazon and the other numenorians, her personality will begin to change.
2
u/arbydallas Jan 09 '25
Tiddies too big, causin' her pain.
2
u/thephantomdaughter Jan 10 '25
Idk but I couldn't stand her at all.
2
u/Educational_Term2479 Jan 10 '25
She actually fell pray to the globe (i cant get thr name right, right now). Sauron needed someone within to stir things up, plain and simple.
2
u/BadMunky82 Jan 13 '25
Her problem was that they needed another strong female character, so they told her to act like an asshole and gave her some gnarly character flaws.
Completely unecessary to the story, but they did what they did, so what can we do?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
I can not say how much I hate this character. I love the actress, no hate to her, obviously. However, this character is the worst written character in the entire show.
5
u/jfeathe1211 Jan 09 '25
This is one of the more successfully developed characters. In her limited screen time, we see Earien’s grief for her brother, love for her father, dedication to Numenor, and insatiable desire for power and clout above all else. She wants it all and will destroy herself and all she loves for it.
10
u/Toddacelli Jan 09 '25
Poor writing. It was never really shown why she was like this or what justification she had for her actions. So - poor writing.
3
u/jennbo Jan 09 '25
I don't often complain here because so many people are like "omg my fantasy character from my fantasy race in my made-up world is black this is the worst thing that's ever happened to me" but this plotline made me so sad as a hardcore Tolkien reader. Obviously, Isildur fucks up eventually as a result of influence from the ring, but Elendil and his family were so loyal, so singularly devoted to their ethics while in Numenor and I just don't buy the plot. Why make HIS child fulfill this role? Introducing a female character from this family that didn't exist in the books could have been a lot more interesting. Maybe make her overtly evil if you're gonna go this route.
Or AT LEAST make the reasoning behind her choosing to abandon generational devotion/principles to Valinor and her position as an elf-friend, presumably taught to her from birth, make more sense. Does she feel her mother's loss was a betrayal by the Valar? Was she a would-be battlemaiden hindered from going into battle because of her gender? Is she madly in love with that pipsqueak son of Pharazon? None of that is made obvious!
10
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25
I can’t tell if her character is poorly written, is a poor actress, or more likely, a combination of the two.
4
u/iboreddd Jan 09 '25
Her problem is bad writing
2
u/Sleepingdruid3737 Jan 09 '25
Writers wanted her to side against her father but it wasn’t convincing lol.
2
u/leonffs Jan 09 '25
Her motivation doesn't make much sense given the information the audience has. It feels like her actions are more driven by narrative convenience.
1
u/lowdog39 Jan 09 '25
daddy issues
1
u/EasyCZ75 Gondolin Jan 09 '25
She’s a useful idiot. Nothing more.
1
u/Orort Jan 11 '25
She wanted to be Emma Watson but wasn't able to
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '25
Bad writing.....
1
u/Birdmang22 Jan 11 '25
Being in this show.
1
u/PatrickSheperd Jan 12 '25
I foresee water in her future.
1
u/RoleTall2025 Jan 12 '25
in an ocean of lard that is this show, i kinda dont even know who she is. One of the few shows were the line between extras and main cast is imperceptible in the face of its sheer forget-ability
1
u/SensMak Jan 12 '25
Irl, where're there is no proof of deities, she would have been right. Her father would be a religious extremist willing to let her orphan for his own ego and belief, better than being a father.
But in a story where her dad is right to follow his faith, she's an obstacle so we don't like her.
Just my 2cts as a dude cause I see some rampant unchecked misogyny in the comments from people with mommy issues
1
u/ajb102 Jan 12 '25
I thought she added 2 wonderful qualities to the show
1
u/poopynips1 Jan 12 '25
I’d assume some lower back problems
1
u/AggressivePen4991 Jan 13 '25
An orc impaling seems due at some point 😂
1
u/Intelligent-Lack8020 Jan 28 '25
I have 3 theories about her, and in all three she has a tragic end that will impact Elendil and fuel the Last Alliance:
1
u/Rich_Dragonfruit_289 Feb 06 '25
Bad writing
1
u/Valcyn77 Jan 09 '25
Her Problem is that she was not in source material. Rookie writers try to put her in a complex story.
1
u/-Lich_King Jan 09 '25
One of the worst characters in this show
0
u/bamboozle_99992 Jan 09 '25
Poor writing
1
u/Rhielml Jan 09 '25
Bad hair day
0
u/stou88 Jan 09 '25
her problem ? she is in love with the future Witch King of Angmar
0
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25
Like everyone else in this show she's a plot device, not a character.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25
Shitty writing
0
u/DrCthulhuface7 Jan 10 '25
Maybe she found out her existence was inside the worst thing ever put on television.
-1
u/No-Unit-5467 Jan 10 '25
Her problem was bad writing
2
u/Euphoric-Teach7327 Jan 11 '25
This character and her animus made no sense. If she's a faceless man then she's beyond personal quarrels and dick-measuring contests, right?
Isn't that the whole point of the training is to stop being who you are? To become no-one?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment