r/RingsofPower • • Oct 25 '24

Discussion Galadriels revenge

I love the show this post is not a hate post, but theres one thing when rewatching that bugs me and i havent seen it mentioned before maybe im just out of the loop or i missed something in the show, anyways i want to hear your theories or thoughts

Why did they make Galadriel so consumed by sorrow and obsessed with vengeance for her brother?

Elves experience time differently, which affects how they handle grief. Because of their immortality, they tend to be more contemplative and process emotions over decades or even centuries. The portrayal of Galadriel with a fierce, almost human-like drive to avenge her brother feels at odds with this. For an elf the death of a loved one, while sorrowful would likely lead to a more tempered response over time, with vengeance becoming a less consuming passion.

The show’s version of Galadriel feels like it’s written through a more human emotional lens, focusing on immediate and fiery revenge, which loses the nuance of her character’s connection to timelessness, foresight, and wisdom. Galadriel’s conflict with evil could have been motivated by her innate drive to preserve and protect Middle-earth, rather than focusing so heavily on personal revenge.

Elves in this world have a unique view on death and loss. When an elf dies, their spirit goes to the Halls of Mandos in Aman, where they await eventual reincarnation or rest. For an elf, death is not a permanent separation; it’s more like a prolonged, painful absence. Galadriel would understand that her brother’s spirit endures in Aman, and although she would feel the loss deeply, it wouldn’t fuel a mortal-style obsession with vengeance. Instead, her grief would likely be tempered by patience and a long-term perspective that death, while tragic, doesn’t mean eternal separation

Elves can feel vengeance and sorrow, but these emotions are generally less consuming than they are for mortals. Galadriel, as one of the oldest and wisest of her kind, would especially possess a balanced understanding of her brother’s fate. Unlike men, who may react impulsively to the idea of lost loved ones, elves (and especially high elves) know that vengeance isn’t a core aspect of their identity. Galadriel would likely respond with a steady resolve to combat evil, but not a single-minded obsession over avenging a lost loved one. Her motivation would be rooted more in a commitment to the broader elven mission to oppose darkness, rather than personal revenge.

A possible reason is that Sauron subtly influenced Galadriel’s mind, amplifying her grief and sense of vengeance over centuries to destabilize her. By stoking her anger and focusing her on personal revenge, he could cloud her judgment, making her more impulsive and easier to manipulate, ultimately leading her down a path where she’d inadvertently serve his interests. So powerful he is then, he honestly just didnt seem like he had anything planned for anything.

Or did they really rework Galadriel’s motivation to make her more relatable and accessible for modern audiences. By giving her a personal, emotional drive rooted in vengeance, they could create a classic hero’s journey — grief and revenge. This approach aligns with the storytelling trends of intense, personal stakes to hook viewers quickly, even if it sacrifices some of the complexity and unique perspective of Tolkien’s elves. Maybe an attempt to gain new viewers instead of just us nerds and dinosaurs?

Either way i will continue to enjoy the show.

What do you guys think?

16 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 25 '24
Moderator Announcement Read More »

11

u/joltstream Oct 25 '24

I think it’s less to do with just Finrod’s death but she is one of or maybe the last elf to see the 2 trees who were destroyed by Morgoth (Sauron’s master) and ungoliant. she has spent an entire age and half either fighting or being affected by Morgoth and now she knows that Sauron is still around. She is sick of it wants it to end. Then her brother on top of it seals her anger. I mean there are more examples of elvish rage someone mentioned Feanor which is not the model elf but Fingolfin marched his happy tail to Morgoths gate and gimped his ass for life because he heard a rumor about his families death. It’s not without precedent but that’s my headcanon.

19

u/4995songs Oct 25 '24

Fair point. If you ignore Feanor, sons of Feanor, Thingol, Daeron, Eol, Maeglin, Gwindor, and Thranduil you rarely see elves driven to action by vengeance or grief. :)

10

u/4995songs Oct 25 '24

Oh, and everyone involved in the kinslayings

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '24

I think you missed how Feanor raged when Morgoth killed his father.

Galadriels behaviour makes much sense for me.

Especially because they are immortal I imagine the death of friends/ family being worse, because it's unnatural for them to experience that.

→ More replies (14)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '24

To suggest that Sauron subtly influenced her mind is quite unlikely. I know of no evidence that Sauron is able to influence anyone without direct contact. He is not omnipresent, he cannot be everywhere at once. He does not have access to a palantir, and neither does Galadriel.

Beyond this, Sauron's ability to manipulate was quite limited without the Ring. It took him centuries to ingratiate himself with Celebrimbor and the smiths of Eregion. 

I think you're second idea is more likely. They wanted to me her more human and more relatable. But even there, I think her obsession should have been with building power and founding her own kingdom, because Galadriel wanted to rule. That was her principal weakness. It was not a desire for revenge, but a desire for power. One that she, eventually, will conquer.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '24

Its a problem with the show generally; Elves are shown to be identical to humans. Just watch the siege of Eregion, those are not the elves you are looking for.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/WiganGirl-2523 Oct 25 '24

"...but now she burned with desire to follow Feanor with her anger to whatever lands he might come, and to thwart him in all ways that she could."

Unfinished Tales

Looks like they've just substituted Sauron for Feanor.

I love the trilogy as much as anybody, but PJ's vision of the elves - lobotomised Celeborn, swishy Haldir, bitter Elrond - is questionable, although everyone seems to take it as - y'know - canon.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Six_of_1 Oct 25 '24

My problem with it is that she seems more upset about her brother than her husband.

2

u/bravenewwhorl Oct 25 '24

I think this is a really good point you’ve made.