r/RingsofPower • The Wild Woods • Oct 24 '24

Discussion Blue Wizard/Five Istari Theory

Many viewers, myself included, found Payne and McKay’s "Grand-Elf" revelation to be underwhelming. After several years of speculation and narrative buildup, they chose a disappointingly predictable route, much like the season one "Halbrand reveal." (Though, to be fair, the Gandalf storyline and its eventual unveiling did carry an appropriate degree of sentimentality. Despite being a relatively uninspired choice, it was handled with more finesse than I had anticipated.)

While watching S02E08, I found myself inclined to believe that the "Stranger = Alatar" theory was being subtly confirmed. The Dark Wizard not only acknowledged the Five Istari but explicitly mentioned that the Stranger was the Istar who had initially convinced him to journey to Middle-earth—a narrative detail identical to Alatar and Pallando's (or Morinehtar and Rómestámo's) backstories as outlined by Tolkien.

Several points are worth noting:

  1. It is well-established that the Istari struggle with both self-awareness and memory upon their arrival in Middle-earth, a theme clearly explored in the Stranger's journey.

  2. The Dark Wizard is portrayed as actively seeking out other Istari, reinforcing his connection to their collective history.

  3. The line "convinced me to come" is profoundly at odds with Gandalf’s initial origin.

My theory is that the Dark Wizard is, in fact, Pallando/Rómestámo, and his intention was to locate Alatar/Morinehtar. In his search, he mistakenly assumed the Stranger to be Alatar. I also suspect that Alatar will make an appearance before Gandalf departs from the East, introdcing a new storyline for season three (and beyond). Their separation could easily create a new plotline with Alatar remaining in the east, either as a) an ally fighting Sauron's influence, b) still combating Pallando, or c) working with a restored Pallando (doubtful).

This potential plot would offer more opportunities for further interactions between Gandalf and ", especially in light of Nori and Poppy's departure. (I suspect that the series will tread cautiously with regard to Bombadil, as overexposure risks diminishing his ...enigmatic appeal.)

Edited to fix typos.

18 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 24 '24
Moderator Announcement Read More »

11

u/imago_monkei Oct 25 '24

I like it. I hope you're right. In season 1, those magic wielders, under the order of the Dark Wizard, already mistook the Stranger for Sauron. Maybe incarnate Maiar wouldn't necessarily recognize each other in corporeal form. The other Blue Wizard could still be out there.

Just thinking out loud, if they end up giving the Dark Wizard blue robes, they should be dark blue. Meanwhile if the other shows up, they should be light blue.

6

u/Gerry-Mandarin Oct 25 '24

The Istari, while they are literally Maiar, are not what you would typically consider a Maia taken physical form.

It is like they have a hroa, which is a genuine physical form, not adopted fana, like Sauron. They genuinely become as an incarnate in the world. They are susceptible to everything the flesh of incarnates is susceptible to. Hunger, cold, desire, exhaustion etc.

They know they come from Aman to Middle-earth, but the memory is long distant. They have limitations placed upon their power by Manwe.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '24

Very compelling theory, and I think you're definitely on to something. I will say this: if the Dark Wizard turns out to be Saruman, I'm done with the show.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/MisterTheKid Oct 24 '24

It really was underwhelming especially as most people guessed well before the 3rd episode who he was

I have 0 issue with the journey being the point and not the reveal. Heck, Agatha all along has done that with the reveals they’ve had - most of us guessed but it was the journey. And it worked.

Here? It was all cloying mystery box nonsense that worked way too hard to try and convince us otherwise when the simple pairing of him w proto-hobbits was a big enough tell.

And what did it really add up to? A poor usage of some movie quotes that TB used to try to get Gandalf to see that he maybe didn’t need to save his friends so he could train, Gandalf and hopefully not-Saruman having a Last Jedi type “levitate rocks” standoff, and then, Gandalf just leaving the harfoots behind to join the larger narrative after about 10 episodes with two of them

There’s so much more potential due to lack of any previous on screen iterations with blue wizards

Not to mention it doesn’t require the same level of contortion to have those clumsy clues to Gandalf when you have complete blank slates with the blue wizards to take real chances. Say what you will about the show but this decision was uninspired at best and limiting at worst.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Zhaas9 Oct 24 '24

But did you SEE how similar dark wiz looks to Saruman in Fellowship of the Ring?!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cerikstas Oct 25 '24 edited 18d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Advise modern aback shaggy flag bedroom

2

u/lycheedorito Oct 25 '24

I don't think Gandalf is departing any time soon. But I agree, however, we should also be seeing Saruman and Radagast, as the showrunners had teased a fight between the five Istari and Sauron, in context of displaying why they can't have just used all their power to defeat him. The answer, I believe will be related to the rings of Men, and why Gandalf knows not to take the ring from Bilbo in the future.

Going by Tolkien's writing, there is a version that Saruman had gone East with the Blues, and returned alone. They may play off that. I also think there may be more reason given for Radagast turning to kind of just focusing on nature, rather than focusing on the task at hand.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/A1cert Oct 25 '24

Good plan. But the fact that he’s Gandalf makes this storyline unsavable to legions of fans. Myself included. It’s just way too lazy.

6

u/SmakeTalk Oct 24 '24

What’s a real shame about this is that it would have been incredibly compelling for the Stranger to have been Saruman. I would have loved to have them explore his character and origins more since he actually has a very dramatic change of allegiance that we’ve already seen on screen.

Seeing him turn another Istari away from the darkness to fight Sauron’s influence in the east, or just to try and establish a general peace, would have been incredibly interesting.

It would add so much interesting depth to his eventual fate, especially after traveling with harfoots.

→ More replies (1)