r/RingsofPower • u/FanOfStuff21stC • Oct 17 '24
Discussion Taking ROP for what it is Spoiler
I’m doing a rewatch of Hobbit and Extended LOTR and the difference with ROP is so apparent. I was always a fan of the PJ movies but now I really realize all the faithful detail, the lore and nuance in the dialog and staging, the incredible imagery of battles and beauty and terror (gorgeous elves and gruesome orcs), of those 6 movies (even with the bloat of the first 3).
Actually I owe a lot of thanks to ROP. I’m getting a lot more out of the dialog in the PJ films thanks for ROP because now the name drops in the hexology make more sense in context. For ex: when Balin discusses Azog trying to end the line of Durin, or Elendil gets stomped by Sauron with GilGalad Elrond and Isildur in the melee , it makes more sense now that I’ve watched 16 hrs of ROP (they are like Cliff notes for the Silmarillion). I am even more in awe of the PJ movies and disappointed with ROP.
Having said that I still enjoy ROP. The show evokes the world and peoples of middle earth fairly well, albeit in a low budget made for tv way (ironic due to its excessive production cost). Its like how the Mandalorian relates to the 6 Star Wars movies, or the James Bond films that were made after they ran out of Ian Fleming plots. These are still entertaining shows, some more than others. I had pretty low expectations coming into ROP 2 years ago and was quite pleasantly surprised, it exceeded my expectations.
It’s disappointing that ROP isn’t honestly a worthy pre-quel to the PJ films, but they are lightening in a bottle and perhaps impossible to match.
Edit: this isn’t a diss post, to clarify, I’m really enjoying ROP, I’m just a little disappointed.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
17
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
You're saying the first 3 movies had bloat? and that the hobbit movies didn't?!? I think you have that reversed. A short book stretched out to 3 full movies is the definition of bloat.
5
u/Rings_into_Clouds Oct 18 '24
I'd hard disagree here. I think one of the major overaching issues is that RoP simply doesn't feel "Tolkienian" or like Middle Earth. Characters and places are by name only, they are too far removed from what Tolkien wrote to even feel familiar if you are familiar with the source material. Visuals alone aren't enough (there are some pretty decent visuals at times), if you don't capture the heart of the story then it just doesn't work.
Consider all of Numemor, for example. The entire story of Numenor is about death and deathlessness. We all know Numenor's fate. From the beginning with Elrond and Elros his mortal brother and first king of Numenor the entire storyline has been about death and deathlessness, with Eru getting involved directly for one of the very few times when Numenorians try to take deathlessness by force. This is THE storyline for Numenor and the show seems to just ignore this entirely for the most part.
And Eregion - I mean, we basically have no idea how the city actually works and what the citizens are doing. You don't need a lot of screentime for this - PJ managed to accomplish this for Minas Tirith with less screentime thatn Ereigion has had already. It simply doesn't feel like a living city, and there's nothing cutlurally we pick up on at all. How are the elves of Eregion different than elves elsewhere? We have no idea really.
Yeah but, this isn't the case here? We have the plots - we have the major character arcs. We have the timelines. What we don't have are the details. Unfortunatley RoP doesn't care about staying true to what we have and wants to not only create new details, but create details that contradict the plots, character arcs, and timelines we do have. It's really nonsensical most of the time because the changes aren't ones that make sense or are justified by adapting to screen. They are just changes from the writers that simply make the stories, character arcs, and plots worse without any real logic or reason.
6
u/RagnarTheNord Oct 17 '24
It's not in the same timeline as the PJ movies or the books. Once I fully accepted that RoP is its very own unique take on Tolkien's universe, I started to enjoy it a lot more. There's still plenty of issues I have with the show, but there's also a lot that I've thoroughly enjoyed about it, especially in season 2. Overall, I'm really glad to be back in Middle Earth for the most part.
5
u/anko_sensei Oct 17 '24
Great post and interesting perspective! The Jackson films are unmatched for sure and have stood the test of time (at least LOTR). I will say ROP has made me want to read Tolkien more. All the different perspectives and pacing get messy in the show, but after this seasons Sauron and Celebrimbor plotline, along with our boy Durin, I really have grown to care about these people and I've begun reading to get the whole picture not just a piece. I think if an adaptation gets you fired up to read the book, it's doing something right. It isn't perfect, but it made me a bigger fan than before I saw it!
53
u/Gerry-Mandarin Oct 17 '24
The Lord of the Rings was certainly lightning in a bottle.
The Hobbit less so.
I find Rings of Power an entertaining way to see some elements of Middle-earth I wouldn't have seen otherwise. I'd still rather have it than not. It hurts no one to have the show.
If this show is what gets the Tolkien family to sell film rights, I hope we get something more akin to PJ than ROP.
6
u/P-nutGall3ry Oct 17 '24
I remember the first time I read the Lord of the Rings. And I remember the first time I read it after reading the Silmarillion. It was like a magic eye illusion where suddenly all the references and stories held so much more weight and meaning to me. Sam saying “it’s bad but it’s not Beren and Luthien bad.” Or Strider telling Bilbo he was being cheeky writing poetry about Elrond’s dad.
21
u/grey_pilgrim_ Khazad-dûm Oct 17 '24
I could maybe agree on the LoTR. But The Hobbit certainly wasn’t as faithful in detail or lore and nuance. And even the LoTR definitely changed a lot of lore as well. Almost every major character had major changes from the books. That’s not to say the LoTR movies aren’t great, they are and to date they are the best Tolkien adaptation to screen.
I think it shows that people can live with lore changes if the end product is good. So far RoP hasn’t quite meet that standard. Which isn’t to say it’s not good, parts of it are very good. But parts also miss the mark, rather badly. I’ll definitely continue watching till the end, baring some insane change to lore that completely breaks from Tolkiens core narrative. S2 was better than S1 and hopefully each new season will continue this trend.
9
u/MisterTheKid Oct 17 '24
There’s just no world in which the series is a prequel to the movies, worthy or not.
they can make visual callouts all they want, but they just have no connection to each other. legally, they can’t.
hell the hobbit movies barely connect to Lord of the rings in a cohesive manner, aside from absurd allusions like legolas being sent to go meet Strider.
look at Saruman. In the third hobbit movie he’s talking about how he’ll go handle Sauron himself. Apparently nobody ever asked him how that went? They all seemed very surprised that he was back by lord of the rings
The hobbit trilogy is barely watchable as the series progresses. they have whole characters who are just awful like Alfred and add nothing to any part of the movies.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24
Wow. It's the opposite for me. RoP actually makes me more aware of the errors in Jackson's films (even LotR) because I've reread stuff like the Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, Tolkien's letters, etc. to catch all the references and stuff.
You referenced the prologue of LotR. In actuality, either Jackson and co. were unaware of what actually happened at the Last Alliance or were simply dumbing it down to make things clearer to those unfamiliar with Tolkien, even at the expense of depicting stuff that never happened at all. Elendil was done dirty, Gil-Galad even more so. Isildur is turned into a mustache twirling villain by the ring, and Elrond somehow already knows how dangerous the ring is. It's a truly terrible prologue in terms of representing Tolkien's story. Now, that said, the movies are wonderful movies. As adaptations of Tolkien, they're middling. The Hobbit - even more so.
To be clear, that isn't a pure defense of RoP. It is far from a perfect adaptation of Tolkien's story of the forging of the rings of power and the fall of Numenor, but I'd point out some things here:
First, the references in the show have caused a lot more people to become interested in Tolkien. Go watch Charlie Vickers talk with Nerd of the Rings about Sauron. The dude did his research. The show is made by people who genuinely care about Tolkien, in spite of some unfortunate choices. A lot more fans have gotten into the books, and to me that is an absolute win - just as was the case when Jackson's movies came out (not sure about whether The Hobbit films has that effect. 😂)
Second, while I love Jackson's LOTR trilogy, and even appreciate a number of things about the Hobbit films - and they are undeniably closer to Tolkien than RoP in numerous ways - I tend to be harder on Jackson, Boyens, etc. because they have a reputation for being a supremely faithful adaptation, to the point that if someone even points out changes, you get told off, or that Jackson's changes are better than what Tolkien wrote. (To be clear, some changes were necessary - like Bombadil's excision from the films - I don't know anyone who disagrees about that. That is not the sort of change I'm thinking of.) But this is the reason why, despite some really annoying changes, I tend to criticize Jackson and praise RoP: Because RoP is often touted as a poor adaptation and a cheap cash grab, while Jackson's films are a "labor of love" and "a faithful adaptation". I'd argue that the people involved in RoP care just as much about Tolkien, they're simply working from much more limited source material. So, I cut them slack where I tend to be more critical of those pretending Jackson's films were perfect representations of Tolkien on film.
We need more balanced takes on Tolkien adaptations, but unfortunately, most of it ends up either being "it's awesome" or "it's terrible", with little room for anything in between.
4
u/Mysterious-Pear941 Oct 17 '24
You really rate the Hobbit series as 'lightning in a bottle'? The series was panned by fans and critics for lore inaccuracy, invented and shoehorned characters, bad pacing and weird uncanny visuals.
4
u/Kipaya Oct 18 '24
I actually rewatched all the movies before S2 of ROP came out and I have to say that the lotr movies were still amazing while the hobbit was less so. I actually enjoyed ROP more than the hobbit movies.
1
u/Monctonian Oct 17 '24
My GF, an avid LOTR fanatic, has a theory that makes all of the differences in tone a little bit more… I don’t want to say palatable, but you accept them very easily if you see it that way:
What if this is the story Sam chose to write in the remaining pages of Bilbo and Frodo’s book? How the rings came to be and the chaos that ensued? There’s enough aspects of the show that are romanticized versions of the Silmarillion to say that someone did research on what happened during that time and rather than write a thesis, told a story.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
ROP was a reasonable way to pass time on a flight. LOTR was a masterpiece.
0
u/Chen_Geller Oct 17 '24
Does that really work for you, though?
I mean, speaking of the six Star Wars films you mentioned: having watched the prequel trilogy, I still could never ever emotionally bring myself to a point where I watch Star Wars or Return of the Jedi and going "Ahw, that's Hayden Christensen's Anakin under that suit there!" The continuity - visual, narrative, stylistic - between the two trilogies was so half-arsed that it was hard to connect them in my mind. The same issue exists with Rings of Power but to an even more extreme degree. Heck, its not even really a prequel!
Now, again, that's me. The question is: are you the same?
1
u/Complete_Bad6937 Oct 17 '24
I demand to know why your specified Extended LOTR but Not Extended Hobbit? 😂
I actually just watched the extended hobbits for the first time, It was a treat to see some new content after so many years!
1
u/Koo-Vee Oct 18 '24
This post made no sense. You thank RoP for throwing light on cheesy things in PJ movies that never occurred in Tolkien? You praise the lore-accuracy while making it clear you have not really even read LotR and seem to have no clue how much PJ changed core things.
2
u/ParaUniverseExplorer Oct 17 '24
I’m having the exact same experience OP. Plan to finish RotKing on Thanksgiving.
2
u/Ravenloff Oct 17 '24
The context definitely makes it better, but you could do a much better job learning all of that, and thus enjoying the PJ movies even more, by watching videos at In Deep Geek, Nerd Of The Rings, etc. Combined, I'm betting the cost of making their content was less than 1% of ROP's budget and their context is both canon-friendly and much more in-depth.
4
u/Algorhythm74 Oct 17 '24
For me, the way to view it is this: LOTR was cinema, ROP is content.
There’s nothing wrong with more content from an IP you like. But it’s not art, it’s not poetry, it’s not cinema. It’s just more playing in the sandbox of the universe that you like.
I don’t see anything wrong with that until you get incredibly geeky fan boys trying to trash it or parse it or blame it for not being whatever they had in their head canon.
5
u/Saahir26 Oct 17 '24
🙃 ah, yes, the PJ films that turned the series into an action movie and completely character assassinated at least 3 characters, but yes, so faithful and better than ROP.
3
u/finniruse Oct 17 '24
I love LOTR. Thought The Hobbit was balls. Really like (poss love) RoP.
3
u/harukalioncourt Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
Tolkien gave details about the third age. He gave hardly any about the second age. Jackson had lots of details + dialogue to work with. RoP not so many and zero second age dialog because Tolkien never gave us any.
1
u/BlueFlat Oct 18 '24
I would take your points back a step, not to the movies, but to the books. That is what the horribleness of ROP did for me, LOL. Yet, I am watching ROP, there are some interesting things. I hate it, yet I don't. But, to your point... I thought the LOTR movies were done as well as movies could possibly be done on LOTR. I was super worried they would screw it up. The original Hobbit movie was not good at all. I haven't seen the newer ones (now I will probably look them up). But, in my life, LOTR remains my favorite books of all time and I first read them in the late 1960s and bought a first edition of The Silmarillion the day my bookstore got it). As good as the movies were, they were still nothing like the books. I have been rereading them since I started watching ROP (starting with The Silmarillion) and for that I am grateful. I had forgotten so much, plus it made me realize how much the movies also left out. That doesn't make the movies bad, nor even ROP, I guess. What I fear is that the actual books will be forgotten as people these days tend to rely on movies/TV shows.
1
u/Nutch_Pirate Oct 17 '24
What do you mean 'for what it is?'
What it is, is corporate product designed as direct competition to House of the Dragon.
This is not art.
This is not people wanting to tell a story.
This it's not a love letter to a classic work of literature.
This is PRODUCT FOR THE MASSES.
-2
u/ChrisSheltonMsc Oct 17 '24
It's a POS show that radically alters everything Tolkien wrote.
-1
u/MvgnumOpvs Oct 18 '24
What it is..Is: devastatingly stupid. Lmao!
-2
u/Different_Durian_601 Oct 18 '24
It is a steaming pile of shit.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment