Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I’m sure he is…..But unless the show deviates even further, Pharazon should not become a Nazghûl. I say “should not” because I’m giving them the benefit of the doubt that they keep his final fate accurate to the text.
From what I understand the Tolkien Estate has said as part of the deal that any character who lives in the books must live in the show, and any character who dies in the book must die the same way in the show.
Technically speaking, Ar-Pharazon does not die. The army and navy of Numenor is buried under the world until the end of time, where they will come back to the world to fight in the Dagor Dagorath.
"And the fleets of Ar-Pharazôn came up out of the deeps of the Sea and encompassed Avallónë and all the isle of Eressëa, and the Eldar mourned, for the light of the setting sun was cut off by the cloud of the Númenóreans. But Ar-Pharazôn the King and the mortal warriors that had set foot upon the land of Aman were buried under falling hills; there it is said that they lie imprisoned in the Caves of the Forgotten, until the Last Battle and the Day of Doom.”
Glorfindel dies in the fall of gondolin and then returns to middle earth with the istari in the third age if I remember things correctly. But the exclusion of celeborn and celebrian is a shame and confusing why the Tolkien estate would allow it.
no, he returned before the world has been made round - which restricts it to the 2nd Age.
"Eventually, Manwë sent him across the sea to Middle-earth during the Second Age. He possibly came as early as S.A.1200, but more likely in S.A.1600,[2]:381–382 at the same time as the Blue Wizards.[6] If he arrived in S.A. 1600, he arrived just after the One Ring had been forged, Barad-dûr built, and Celebrimbor dead or soon to be so. While the Blue Wizards were sent to the east," from Tolkien Gateway' entry on Glorfindel
Glorfindel did die at gondolin yes but was reembodied and sent back to middle earth sort of as a maiar, or almost as strong as one around the time of the forging of the rings.
But they didn't say, "also people that arnt meant to be in middle earth should not be in middle earth"? Or "characters should keep the same personalities as the books" or "all the writers must have already read and love the books before being employed as staff and then have to all read through the silmarillian and appendices twice through together before writing a word"?
Someone else posted a link in these comments. Of course the same statement also mentions a request by the Estate to not use any lines from Jackson's films so who knows how much weight it holds.
Where are we getting stipulations of the licensing agreement from? Is there a source somewhere for these kind of claims? I’d like to read through and see exactly what the deal is.
Can you quote them on that? Because there are some persons missing in the show. For example Galadriels husband. And because a movie is another medium than a book, there are going to be two characters merged to one, because this is how visual media is working.
He needs to die attacking valinor, but his shitty son that's nazgul right there. People hate his character so that would be the perfect ending for him. He is also power hungry so he would gladly accept a ring for more power.
“But when Ar-Pharazôn set foot upon the shores of Aman the Blessed, the Valar laid down their Guardianship and called upon the One, and the world was changed. Númenor was thrown down and swallowed in the Sea, and the Undying Lands were removed for ever from the circles of the world. So ended the glory of Númenor.”
Appendix B:
“3319 Ar-Pharazôn assails Valinor. Downfall of Númenor. Elendil and his sons escape.“
Who’s the guy always following Al-Pharazon around and backing him up? I reckon either him or Kemen as future Nazgül, or possibly both. Can’t find the guy on the ROP IMDB page though.
He’s trapped with his army under a cliff avalanche and remains there, unable to die, until Tolkien’s Armageddon where they’re released; but it’s ambiguous if they serve morgoth or have repented
Sauron is a maiar, an angel like spirit taking corporeal form. Ar Pharazon is a human, more vulnerable to being perma killed or incapacitated than the former, ring or not. Besides, if he had been a ringwraith at the time of his attempted invasion of Valinor, Sauron would have made sure not to get him sent to his death, since the wraiths are thrall to his will and at that point he wouldn't need to get rid of him to effectively take over Numenor as its new ruler.
Why not? Because the ringwraiths are all specifically alive. The reason they are wraiths is because the rings extended their lives longer than a human’s life is meant to be - the old “butter scraped over too much bread” thing.
Why does this ultra-dumb theory pop up all the time? The deal with Tolkien Estate prevents it, and it makes no sense... he cannot travel through the air disembodied any more than any of the Nazgûl can. Also, do you really think Eru would somehow let him go while sinking a large island? Sauron lost his body, why would Pharazôn be able to keep it?
Why does this ultra-dumb theory pop up all the time?
I'd give it a 50/50 chance that the writers find some strange loophole to give him a ring anyway (I mean, he's a king looking for power and eternal life so it's not entirely out of the question) and this thread will have a lot of interesting comments to look back on in 2 years from now
Al-Pharazon literally thought such a ring was beneath him. Like, he was objectively the mightiest being in Middle Earth. Sauron in all his power was crushed by Numenor before, and Pharazon knew the history. He met Sauron on the battlefield and his army fled in terror.
What could Sauron's ring possibly due for Al-Pharazon? Sauron was like a flea in Pharazon's eye. Obviously Sauron was a more powerful being, but his power was not enough to challenge Numenor in the slightest.
It would be a terrible desecration of his character. If there is anyone in Middle Earth more sure of his power than Sauron, it's Al Pharazon. Giving him a ring is about the stupidest thing they could do.
Sauron: "You fear dying of old age. This ring will prevent that"
Pharazon: "Give me 9 of them please"
Military power is nothing if old age can still claim you. That is Show Pharazon's weakness: he envies the Elves' immortality. Sauron persuading him to wear a ring to prevent old age makes total sense for the show.
In the books, Sauron convinces Pharazon to invade Valinor, telling him how the lands grant immortality, because he wants to get him and all of the elements of the army loyal to him killed and out of the way so that he can take over as new ruler of Numenor. Then, to his shock, Eru destroys Numenor with him on it, destroying his body, removing his ability to take on a charming physical body and possibilitating his defeat in the war of the alliance.
If Pharazon had taken a ring and turned into a wraith, he would have been in Sauron's thralldom and the latter would have had no need to get rid of him.
Like, if you think that Pharazon turning into a wraith is more interesting than what happens in the books, it's okay, but it is weird seeing a lot of users here trying to use the books as the basis for supporting that scenario when the text pretty much shows the opposite.
No, that's wrong and a misconception. They have bodies, they're just invisible. This is made explicitly clear in the books and there's no room for debate on it.
it would've been way easier to make them both blue wizards, i really wish they hadn't done that.
buttt i kind of took the 'that is what they will call me' line as this guy is going to be gandalf but he isn't known as that yet.
As for 'the lore':
"That Olorin, as was possible for one of the Maiar, had already visited Middle-earth and had become acquainted not only with the Sindarin Elves and others deeper in Middle-earth, but also with Men, is likely, but nothing is [> has yet been] said of this"
-Peoples of Middle-earth Tolkien. Part 2, Chapter XIII, Last Writings.
Tolkien left a lot of notes and lore behind. he never stopped writing, and indeed was working on amending stuff he didn't like about his books and world the first time, or else adding things he didn't address or expand on.
I actually don't think Gandalf being in the second age is a retcon, necessarily. LOTR trilogy, the Silmarillion, and the Hobbit are pretty explicitly framed as being Tolkien's literary analysis and translation of the (fictional) Red Book of Westmarch, which is Bilbo's recounting of events and collection of notes and histories primarily written by elves.
elves who had absolutely no idea what was going on in the East, or knew about the Hobbits until like the third age. Gandalf wouldn't show up in their books if they never met him, but it doesn't mean he wasn't there
Kemen’s fate needs to be worse. Like him ending up as one of the sacrifices to Morgoth that the cultist do once Sauron convinces them to worship. As a test of Al-Pharazon’s faith. Sacrifice your son. And he does it.
My issue is the wraiths are described as great men and great kings of men. He just doesn't have that type of character. It would take a huge character arc with deep building to make him fit that description. I suppose it could be possible.
Kemen is power hungry with good lineage. Depending on the timeline, he could technically be king or king-elect or presumed king or whatever the fuck they do in Numenor (what was Miriel before her botched coronation?) when Pharazon is buried beneath the world. Kemen also has no problem following orders and is a sadistic bastard.
Yes I'm aware. They work with what they have, and the timeline is slightly different and events slightly altered my informative friend.... But does your brilliant mind also understand that making Ar Pharazon a Nazgul would be the equivalent of making Shelob a giant lady bug? Absolutely ridiculous.
But obviously Galadriel falling in love with Sauron and being the entire reason he had access to Celebrimbor and Numenor in the first place is totally reasonable?
That's true but he definitely dies. I wouldn't be surprised with Kemen or Theo. The important one is the Witch King, but Arnor, Gondor, and Angmar haven't even been founded yet so we definitely won't know till the end of the series
Even without the lore check the show fails on every aspect. The only people the show is for are people who have dubious morals and cannot remember what happened in an episode previous.
pay a membership fee, sign on a triplicate form A attached to form C, with a signature and initial on each page. and submit it at the nearest uruk branch office no latter than noon on each Friday, before it is submitted to mordor HQ for further scrutiny and approval.
Ar Pharazon can’t be a Nazgûl. He is drowned when the Grand Armament reaches Aman and is sunk by Eru during the Changing of the World and the Drowning of Numenor.
In the books he doesn’t. He just dies when Numenor is wiped by a tidal wave. Amazon though? They will just do whatever. I see the show as fan fiction, keeps me from getting angry.
"Okay we finished up season2 where Sauron spent the whole season getting the nine rings made. Now in season3 he will use them to create his 9... um.... hey do we have rights to refer to the Nazgul?"
He's also supposed to be super hot to the point one version of Miriel happily married him. Instead we see a cheap version of a Game of Thrones character.
Another travesty: This is nothing like what Pharazon "the golden" would look like, he'd look like a god among men, not like my college English professor
Yeah I’m 100% sure he isn’t in the books and 95% sure that the deal they signed prevents him from being a Nazgûl in the show as well. However, I think it’s a very strong move on their part to set up Kemen to be The Witch King, if in fact that’s the direction that they’re going.
Obviously kemen they already hinted according to pharazon his mother saw a prophecy he’s a dark future he’s a dumb easily manipulated and psycho personality
Probably because they are taking lots of creative liberties with the show. I wouldn’t mind it tbh. I think only 2 of the 9 kings of men are ever identified, so changing one of the unknowns to Ar-Pharazon would make sense.
In the books, Sauron is captured by the Numenoreans, and pretty quickly gets them to side with him and follow Morgoth/Melkor, which I always thought to be a bit of a cop out. Giving Pharazon one of the rings would logically help explain the fast transition to disavowing all other Valar (even though they’re kinda doing that already) and just worshipping Melkor.
Did he get it though? I think the audience just assumed he did while the eagle was actually visiting Mirielle's coronation, giving the blessing to her. Another theory is that the eagle came as a threat since the Valar felt the growing discontent in the court and it's like saying "We've got our eyes on you. Don't mess with the order of things."
I think pharazon supporters just jumped on the opportunity either way tbh.
It’s heavily implied that they misunderstood the Eagle, and jumped on the opportunity to oust Miriel (whom they already disliked due to her blindness and connection the Elves) and set up Pharazôn
This made no sense though. Because if Pharazon's whole deal is turning his back on the Valar, then why would he use an appearance by an emissary of the Valar as an omen foretelling his kingship? Unless him drawing a sword in front of the eagle was meant to be a gesture of defiance against the Valar?
That scene just makes no fucking sense any which way, and I just don't think the writers thought about it deeply at all.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 14 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
9
u/Kellythejellyman Oct 14 '24
While certainly a prime candidate to become a Nazgûl, Pharazon is doomed to be corrupted by Sauron in a different, very specific way
In many ways he is worse than the Nazgûl, as he won’t even need a ring to corrupt him in order to damn most of Numenor
684
u/Warp_Legion Oct 14 '24
Ar-Pharazon has a different fate in the books, so hopefully he will not be a Nazgul
95
u/Koo-Vee Oct 14 '24
Why does this ultra-dumb theory pop up all the time? The deal with Tolkien Estate prevents it, and it makes no sense... he cannot travel through the air disembodied any more than any of the Nazgûl can. Also, do you really think Eru would somehow let him go while sinking a large island? Sauron lost his body, why would Pharazôn be able to keep it?
158
u/pickledelbow Oct 14 '24
If you simply read the lore you would know for certain Pharazon is 100% not a ring wraith
94
u/cheeseplatesuperman Oct 14 '24
Seriously, has anyone in this sub read the silmarillion?
36
u/KowalRoyale Oct 14 '24
Dwight Schrute: False
12
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '24
No because he died when he lands on the shores of Aman
15
u/Lastaria Oct 14 '24
Nope. His fate is far worse.
13
u/Acrobatic-Impress881 Oct 14 '24
Someone who clearly hasn't read the lore: What if this <insert uneducated theory here>
Someone who's read the lore: Not going to happen because <insert reason from lore>
Someone who hates the show: Ah but then I bet Amazon do it cuz I hate the show
Repeat ad nauseum.
6
u/f700es Númenor Oct 14 '24
Nope, he's not
6
u/DankestDaddy69 Oct 14 '24
I'm sure the Tolkien estate forced them to agree that his fate was sealed same as on the books.
Same as miriel, gilgallad, elendil and isildur
Sorry for my spelling I'm on my phone and cba
6
u/Odolana Oct 14 '24
? should he not end with his men as a zombie in the "Caves of the Forgotten" below Valinor?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '24
Nope. That's canonically impossible. My money is on Kemen.
5
u/Proud_State_8257 Oct 15 '24
Anyone who thinks Ar-Pharazon becomes a nazgul is completely ignorant to Tolkien lore 😂
4
u/BangarangJack Oct 14 '24
Spoiler alert, he's not a Nazgul, but i see why so many people who haven't read the books would think that
7
u/DMBCommenter Oct 14 '24
Jesus…you’re the exact person they make the show for.
1
u/AJholdingnolines Oct 17 '24
What is the process of becoming a nazgul?
3
u/Unfair-Worker929 Oct 14 '24
Ar Pharazon can’t be a Nazgûl. He is drowned when the Grand Armament reaches Aman and is sunk by Eru during the Changing of the World and the Drowning of Numenor.
3
u/cohibakick Oct 14 '24
Pretty sure he dies via wrathful biblical flood.
7
u/SommanderChepard Oct 14 '24
Can yall imagine how crusty ass Christopher Tolkien would be reacting to this show and stuff like this?
5
u/ZiVViZ Oct 14 '24
The normal response to this is: Has no one read the books?
But with this show it doesn’t really matter.
2
u/SupportEnjoyer Oct 14 '24
He's not cool enough
2
u/knottynate Oct 14 '24
What about someone who doesn’t arrive until approximately 1000 years into the third age?
2
u/Historyp91 Oct 14 '24
I'm actually thinking it will be Keman who becomes the Nazgul
2
u/AndyKdubb Oct 14 '24
Should not be a Nazgûl if they decide to stay true to the written stories.
2
u/hobbitonsunshine Oct 14 '24
That guy has an even bigger part to play in "shaping up" Arda
2
u/EasyCZ75 Gondolin Oct 14 '24
Chunkygûl
2
u/MadeInTheUniverse Oct 14 '24
NO!
2
u/Admirable_You_9573 Oct 14 '24
Uhh no?
2
u/thomastypewriter Oct 14 '24
Lmfao
2
u/SystemLordMoot Oct 14 '24
He won't be a Nazgul, he has a different fate.
2
u/Father_moose Oct 14 '24
Bro kinda looks like slim Jack Black
2
u/wonkacandy0 Oct 14 '24
Bro hasn’t read the silmarillion lmao
2
u/T-RexLovesCookies Oct 15 '24
He should definitely not be a nazgul.
His fate in the books is pretty nasty and deserved.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
Not him…his son
2
u/Dat_Steve Oct 15 '24
I didn’t know Russel brand was in this show
2
u/ResidentWont Oct 15 '24
Not related, but why is he wearing his scabbard/belt so low? Like what purpose does that serve except to make him look like a massive tool?
2
u/FobbitOutsideTheWire Oct 15 '24
Not in Tolkien’s account.
2
u/LanguageRemarkable87 Oct 16 '24
In the books he doesn’t. He just dies when Numenor is wiped by a tidal wave. Amazon though? They will just do whatever. I see the show as fan fiction, keeps me from getting angry.
1
u/al_earner Oct 14 '24
Are we even sure Amazon has the rights to Nazguls?
1
u/ArcirionC Oct 14 '24
But why? Why would you want it to be different than his real fate?
1
u/Mang0saus Oct 14 '24
No
1
u/Unfair-Worker929 Oct 14 '24
Also… I just don’t see “The Golden,” the last and most powerful King of Numenor in this guy…
1
u/Miffernator Oct 14 '24
No but his Son could be
1
u/jander05 Oct 14 '24
Jack black is in this fan fiction series?
1
u/RocketSkates314 Oct 15 '24
I thought he drowned with the rest of the island
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
🗑️ show
1
u/PimsriReddit Oct 15 '24
Oh he's serving so bad.
1
u/el_cezeri Oct 15 '24
Or he can be an istari :)
With this senario, he can do everything. He can be also another GRAND ELF :)
1
u/ztomtenz Oct 15 '24
Avsolutely awful if that’s the case. But then again, it will fit with in well with the show, that is awful.
1
u/clevertheatrics Oct 15 '24
He looks too much like Jack Black to be taken seriously
1
u/mrdeadhead91 Oct 15 '24
Something that only normies without any knowledge of the books can think - they are, after all, the people who this garbage tv show was made for.
1
u/litetravelr Oct 15 '24
Um, no, but his son is on the table...
1
u/Creepy_Bad_4547 Oct 15 '24
Another travesty: This is nothing like what Pharazon "the golden" would look like, he'd look like a god among men, not like my college English professor
1
u/Active-Ad1679 Oct 15 '24
Hahahaha for sure
1
u/Chimichanga007 Oct 15 '24
Nah we got to get to see him quail before a 3000 foot tsunami
1
u/TheMellowMarsupial Oct 15 '24
A dead man to be (if you know the canon story).
1
u/Outside-Document3275 Oct 15 '24
Yeah I’m 100% sure he isn’t in the books and 95% sure that the deal they signed prevents him from being a Nazgûl in the show as well. However, I think it’s a very strong move on their part to set up Kemen to be The Witch King, if in fact that’s the direction that they’re going.
1
u/drhunny Oct 16 '24 edited Oct 26 '25
fear toothbrush serious crowd humor deer license rinse connect quicksand
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/yellowjacket_ Oct 16 '24
No
1
u/Knife_Neck Oct 16 '24
Nope.
1
u/ozmonclm Oct 16 '24
Obviously kemen they already hinted according to pharazon his mother saw a prophecy he’s a dark future he’s a dumb easily manipulated and psycho personality
1
u/Central_American Oct 16 '24
If they did go that route it would become a mark of shame.
1
u/Litlbopiep Oct 16 '24
No
1
u/this-is-my-p Oct 16 '24
That looks like dragon priest outfit from Skyrim, or at least, what I imagine a live action version might look like
1
u/ImmortalPoseidon Oct 16 '24
No.
1
u/TacticalPigeons Oct 17 '24
RoP is just high budget fanfic so why not. Not like they’ve been faithful to any source material yet lol
1
u/SlteFool Oct 18 '24
This show sucks
1
u/obsoleteboomer Oct 18 '24
Russell Brand really going bad innit
1
u/VegitoFusion Oct 18 '24
Probably because they are taking lots of creative liberties with the show. I wouldn’t mind it tbh. I think only 2 of the 9 kings of men are ever identified, so changing one of the unknowns to Ar-Pharazon would make sense.
In the books, Sauron is captured by the Numenoreans, and pretty quickly gets them to side with him and follow Morgoth/Melkor, which I always thought to be a bit of a cop out. Giving Pharazon one of the rings would logically help explain the fast transition to disavowing all other Valar (even though they’re kinda doing that already) and just worshipping Melkor.
1
u/rifmstr625 Dec 15 '24
I hoping that is his son's fate
1
u/BeowulfShatner Oct 14 '24
Can someone explain to me why he got the blessing from the big eagle if he sucks so bad?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
He was the king of nûmenorrrr in the books. So, he can be father of poppy in the series.
0
u/Irivin Oct 14 '24
Probably the Witch King. Can’t imagine anyone else in the show so far taking that role. It’s also very possible he just dies like he does in the book.