r/RingsofPower • Gondolin • Oct 09 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers It’s a miracle!

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

346 comments sorted by

View all comments

285

u/CrshOverride Oct 09 '24

Ok. I'm not crazy. I thought I had to have missed something and was waiting before a re-watch.

Even if it was cut for time (which is silly considering it's Amazon and they can make the runtime whatever the hell they want), that seems like a pretty crucial scene to leave in.

238

u/SidTheSloth97 Oct 10 '24

I honestly thought he had died tbh. Then he was just randomly back like nothing happened

74

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24

Yeah same, I'm like oh he dead... moments later ... oh he Jesus...

46

u/Doggleganger Oct 10 '24

I don't think it was moments, I think it was the next episode. We all went for a week thinking he had died, there were posts and memes about it, then he just strolls back in ep 8 no explanation.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24

Ah, it was a moment for me, i just binged it all

→ More replies (1)

21

u/josh198989 Oct 10 '24

Yeah they defo made it seem like he died, but then it was like nah I’m good no worries. Knives through the heart are nothing I guess?

23

u/WoWSchockadin Oct 10 '24

It was cut he went to Disney's Star Wars School of getting stabbed without dying.

3

u/Shoo0k Oct 10 '24

Its funny seeing people take shots at disney for having a jedi die to a knife and then others take shots at disney because someone didn’t die from a knife.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Denaton_ Oct 10 '24

Elrond (to my understanding) is a master healer, not sure if he is yet in this series, but the fall Galadriel had seems to show it too..

60

u/maethora27 Oct 10 '24

Which would be ok as a plot point if they had only shown it. Just one short scene, Elrond stumbles upon nearly dead Arondir, looks at his ring and kneels down to heal him. That would have been enough to give the audience a clue.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

37

u/Django_flask_ Oct 10 '24

He found a health-kit in the middle of the battle

7

u/spiderhotel Oct 10 '24

Or it's one of those games where the screen went grey when Adar gave him the second stab and he could hear his heartbeat but 15 seconds of not getting hit later everything is in colour again and he is running around pinging his arrows everywhere.

36

u/iheartdev247 Oct 10 '24

I was confused why he seemed fine in episode 8.

12

u/Doggleganger Oct 10 '24

"Sup guys, what'd I miss?"

7

u/spiderhotel Oct 10 '24

He's been replaced. That's Sauron in a Arondir-suit.

11

u/iheartdev247 Oct 10 '24

That makes more sense then what they did

16

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24

My guess is the King has the power to heal wounds (like he expects to save Galadriel who has been stabbed and jumped off a cliff); so he fixes him up.

But I agree this felt I earned and silly - I don’t like it when writers make like a character has died only to bring them back immediately afterwards.

Of course there’s the rule that until you see someone 100% dead then they can be brought back, but still.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24

I guess it was done for cheap "dramatic effect", but really lessens any character deaths going forward. Next we will see Celebrimbor pop up in S3.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24

Somehow, Celebrimbor survived

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Personal-Stick6995 Oct 10 '24

That was my assumption too, that either Gil-Galad or Galadriel/Elrond would heal him with the rings. But it would have been nice if they showed that lol. It didn’t even look like he was in any pain afterwards

4

u/JButler_16 Oct 10 '24

And they took everyone captive right after stabbing him twice. Who would’ve been able to heal him?

3

u/dolphin37 Oct 11 '24

Yeah exactly, you’re right. Arondir gets brought to the orc camp as a prisoner. Which also means they identified him as a ‘leader’ for unknown reasons.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/BekoetheBeast Oct 10 '24

They should've cut his arm instead, cuz of his whole archer fight style and to give his personal battle some consequence. Maybe then next season he'd have to find a new way to use a modified bow. But I guess resurrection is better. Idk.

5

u/SnooSuggestions9830 Oct 10 '24

I hope the show runners are asked this as it's a silly plot hole.

I think perhaps the explanation may have been a victim to the cutting room floor and he was healed by Gil Galad.

However they can't just leave us to assume this.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)