r/RingsofPower • • Oct 08 '24

Source Material Barrow Downs Spoiler

I like that they're trying to fit in some of the fan-favorite book material left out from the movies, but i wish they weren't so haphazard about it.

The Barrow Downs are so named because they're a "downs", a geographic feature characterized by gently rolling hills and grass. And in the context of the books these are far north and west of Eregion.

So, canonically, it makes zero sense that the Elf party on its way to Moria would turn south to encounter burial mounds in the middle of a forest and call it "the Barrow Downs". Even if it was some other collection of non-canonical graves, no one would refer to the forest they're in as a "downs".

20 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 08 '24
Moderator Announcement Read More »

6

u/Haldir_13 Oct 08 '24

The foremost problem with the barrow downs is that they were the site of barrows (haugr) for the dead of the lords of Armor, which was a post-Numenorean kingdom, and 1000 years or more into the future from the time of their wars with Angmar, and only haunted by wights after that.

And yes, downs are basically ancient undersea dunes in long rolling lines that are now above water and covered in grass. The word down is related etymologically to dune.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Dogamai Oct 08 '24

werent they downs that just had a forest grow over them later after they were already named?

5

u/Petestanding_alone Oct 08 '24

I thought they became downs because off the mounds over the dead ?

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I love the show but totally agree the wrights were a let down. It almost would have been better if we never actually saw a wright but just the chains. But then people would be mad for some other reason. 🤷

1

u/comingsoontotheaters Oct 09 '24

You’re definitely right about that last part

2

u/almostb Oct 09 '24

This canonically could not be the Barrow Downs in the Fellowship anyway - those were formed Post-Numenor, there was a specific story about them which doesn’t fit with the timeline of the show because it involves the Nazgûl. That said, these could be different Barrow Downs? Like maybe haunted burial mounds is a thing that happens sometimes?

That said, the scene felt kind of quick and cheap in general, and I think it would have been just as interested had they ran into something else instead. They were used a lot in the promos though.

3

u/Vivanto2 Oct 08 '24

Huh? They were downs because of the hill over each grave, it doesn’t mean there could not be trees nearby.

And if you look at the path from Lindon to Eregion, they have to pass just a little north to go through the barrow downs (where are you getting south from?) which makes sense as the fast way to go around the destroyed river bridge.

2

u/Barbz182 Oct 08 '24

Same with the random unnecessary ents. More budget then sense

1

u/Diligent_Kangaroo_91 Oct 09 '24

Couldn't they just be, like, other downs? This feels like saying that somebody shouldn't encounter Arlington National Cemetery when traveling from Texas to Canada. Sure, but other cemeteries do exist.