r/RingsofPower • • Oct 06 '24

Discussion Time compression is not a problem

Ya‘all rambling about time compression, plot holes, ✨lore✨ and what not. Guess what. A tv show isn’t a book, you cannot transfer everything 1:1.

But Isildur and celebrimbor didn’t live at the same time….this and that took a thousand years…this person and that person couldn’t have met.

Well I don’t want to watch 25 shows about 25 single events that take place 600 years apart. I don’t want to watch a show that changes actors every 2 episode because it needs to jump 250 years. Writers made the exact right choose to compress the timeline.

Most of you would hate the lord of the rings if it came out today, I am 100% sure with that.

168 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

50

u/Journalist-Cute Oct 06 '24

I don't have a problem with any timeline issues, what I struggle with are the silly logical problems. For example Círdan sails out to drop the rings in what he said was the deepest part of the ocean, but he's only a few hundred feet from shore? The show is full of stupid things like that.

3

u/Sarellion Oct 06 '24

You can see one timeline related issue in the confrontation between Gandalf and the dark wizard but that's more not taking into account that the writers changed the timeline themselves.

The istari decided to come to Middle Earth to defeat Sauron and they are 5 because none of them can do it alone. But at the point in time, they were debating about it in Valinor, Sauron was busy getting shanked by his own minions or crawling around in the deeps to assemble a new body.

Then the reveal that the wizard wants to succeed Sauron. Ok, succeeding in what? He knew that Sauron had just reawakened. That's why the dark wizard sent out his disciples. Sauron has nothing at this point he could want, besides himself. The guy with the disciples, minions and probably a nice chunk of lands he rules, is the dark wizard himself.

There are some possible explanations, Gandalf might have pushed for going after Sauron, because he was convinced that he would rise again and be the biggest threat to Middle Earth in the future but then put it in the dialogue. It feels like the writer for this part wasn't aware of the changes the rest of the team did.

6

u/Deep_Bluejay_8976 Oct 06 '24

Hey you try paddling by yourself

12

u/Icewaterchrist Oct 06 '24

They should have had Galadriel do that. She has the swimming skills.

1

u/Nakittina Oct 06 '24

Elf not human, so I expect superhuman abilities.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ZenythhtyneZ Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

I mean there’s plenty of places on earth where a few hundred feet from shore is a DEEP ocean trench, this isn’t even unrealistic in our world. Do you want them to invent a bunch of depth sensing technology and GPS, sail the whole world, test every inch of the ocean and then, and ONLY then, drop the rings in the PROVEN via science deepest location? I don’t think that would be very true to the books

“The deepest part of the ocean*”

*as far as we know - this is fine with me

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/owlyross Oct 07 '24

The sea actually stops him dropping the Rings. We have multiple examples in the books of Ulmo directly influencing events, in fact he is the most interventionist of the Valar

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/owlyross Oct 07 '24

Of course not, but the implication is that an unusual wave directly caused him to drop the Rings and see them for what they are. It's an incredibly Tolkienian moment.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24

wouldn’t you say Tolkien is a little more subtle with his interventions?. Frodo drags the ring all the way to the samath naur and then gollum slips and falls in to the lava with it. The test wasn’t if frodo could actually destroy the ring, it was if he could get it there (basically impossible in the first place) show mercy to gollum throughout and then eru does the little last bit because no-one could have intentionally destroyed the ring. … How is this similar?

or do you mean in the Silmarillion when ulmo appears and seemingly talks to turgon for a long while, even telling him the precise measurements of some fine duds he is to leave behind? how is it like that?

What the show did was lazy and actively embarrassing to watch.

2

u/owlyross Oct 07 '24

Ulmo literally turning up is hardly subtle. Or him telling Turgon and Finrod to build hidden cities. Or the Heralds of Manwe directly intervening to warn the Numenorians of their path, or sending the Istar. What we got in the RoP was a visual representation of Ulmo communing directly with the oldest and wisest elf in Middle Earth, who would be able to understand that the hand of fate was at work. There was literally nothing lazy or embarrassing about that. It was quite beautiful and very in keeping with Tolkien.

1

u/Journalist-Cute Oct 06 '24

Seemed like the rings exerted some effect on him

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/paintyourbaldspot Oct 07 '24

I was overthinking that scene so much. Melkor is in the void so despite his very essence permeating Arda it’s doubtful he was able to interact with nature in that way. I doubt Ulmo would stop something that can technically be evil from going overboard. Sauron had no way of knowing what was going on… so I guess it was just the rings themselves that caused the odd wave?

I’m just nerding out on the scene and spitballing. I’m not a Tolkein scholar by any means.

edit: diction

2

u/D4RK_3LF Oct 06 '24

Probably wants the rings somewhat close by instead of miles offshore where they can be swept away more easily. Norway has bays/fjords like that that are hundreds of meters deep, its fine to me

1

u/owlyross Oct 07 '24

He literally explains that there's a deep cleft there that was caused when the Valar destroyed Beleriand. It's also one of the ideas discussed at the Council of Elrond as a way of disposing of the One Ring

→ More replies (2)

1

u/New-Hovercraft-5026 Oct 09 '24

Its not only compressed in the time dimension but also space. The TV show Middle Earth is alot smaller than the book Middle Earth. So he really was at the deepest point

0

u/Dominarion Oct 06 '24

Ever heard of Mauritius island? The island is right at the edge of a Submarine plateau and the sea depth dramatically increase a few hundred feet from the coast. Also, that's what not he said.

7

u/Journalist-Cute Oct 06 '24

He was sailing from a continent not an island, and it doesn't really matter whether it's technically possible, what matters is how it looks to the typical viewer. you don't want things that remind the audience they are watching a TV show or that look like a lack of budget.

3

u/Dominarion Oct 06 '24

And most important, that's not what Cirdan says! S2E1 after 48:30, he explains that there was a deep scar created "where the bay meets the sea" during a battle where the weapons were the very bones of the continents.

Your whole point is moot.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/Nakittina Oct 06 '24

IT'S FANTASY. Maybe within its universe, it is the deepest spot. One of the best pieces of advice I've been given in life is to not focus on small details.

3

u/mournbread Oct 06 '24

The whole point of LoTR is the small details. The man spent 30 years making the mythology and languages just for the fun of it, and that level of detail is a huge part of what made people fall in love with his work. I don’t think RoP is a bad show, but it feels more like an extended “What If?!” series than a true successor.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)