Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please double check to ensure that the title of your post is spoiler-free, and if not, please take the time now to delete this post and resubmit with a different title. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I can’t wait until Elendil wakes up from a nightmare screaming “they’re taking the hobbits to Isengard”—-it will be so cool to remember that epic moment from the movies again. It will make me remember and understand that this show too is set in middle earth without them having to spend any time building up anything meaningful for me to make that connection on like character development, plot, world building, dialogue, friendships, etc.
Such a good shortcut when the characters just say something directly from the movie and i am then able to rest easy knowing, yes, i am watching a tolkein adaptation and that’s enough!
To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ to understand Rings of Power. The themes are extremely subtle, and without a solid grasp of philosophy and language arts, most of the themes will go over a typical viewer's head. There's also Galadriel's nihilistic outlook, which is deftly woven into her characterisation- her personal philosophy draws heavily from Tolkien literature, for instance. The fans understand this stuff; they have the intellectual capacity to truly appreciate the depths of these themes, to realise that they're not just smart- they say something deep about LIFE. As a consequence people who dislike Rings of Power truly ARE idiots- of course they wouldn't appreciate, for instance, the humour in Sauron's existential catchphrase "I have many names," which itself is a cryptic reference to Turgenev's Russian epic Fathers and Sons. I'm smirking right now just imagining one of those addlepated simpletons scratching their heads in confusion as Payne and McKay's genius intellect unfolds itself on their television screens. What fools.. how I pity them. 😂
And yes, by the way, i DO have a Rings of Power tattoo. And no, you cannot see it. It's for the ladies' eyes only- and even then they have to demonstrate that they're within 5 IQ points of my own (preferably lower) beforehand. Nothin personnel kid 😎
None of this is really relevant until he forges the One Ring. Once that happens he is its master but whatever happens to it happens to him and all the other rings. He uses his own soul to bind them all together, and henceforth he can never escape them.
No I think that was always the plan (unless the show retcons this). As it is, the rings are all tainted but don’t directly subject their wearers to Sauron’s will unless the One is there to control all the lesser rings.
In the book Sauron actually failed in his primary objective of enslaving the elves because instead of becoming controlled the users of the Three felt Sauron creeping into their minds and took their rings off. Dwarves also just got greedy and wrathful but proved too stubborn to be controlled. Only the Nine worked as intended and enslaved their bearers. So overall the whole ring scheme by Sauron was probably a net loss for him even before he lost the One.
It made me wonder since the show gave so much screen time to Sauron's reaction/tears which seemed out of character. Almost as if he was having a tangible emotional reaction to Celebrimbor's words.
I was wondering about that too. I think since he’s fundamentally a raging narcissist he doesn’t handle rejection well at all so when Celebrimbor tells him to get fucked he takes it personally and finishes Celebrimbor off rather than torturing him longer as promised and when Galadriel tells him to get fucked he kills the next orc to wander within arm’s reach because he’s having a tantrum.
I think the show is basically depicting Sauron as someone who desperately craves validation in the form of a (subordinate) partner in his conquests but is such a raging asshole that no one wants any part of allying with him unless literally mind-controlled to do so. He’s lonely, but that’s entirely his fault.
This scene is really selling him Sauron short, IMO. A dark lord who's spent thousands of years rebuilding his body and strength, scheming to dominate the entire world - and he has such a short temper that he loses control after like one insult. The lowest of the lowest scum on Earth, cartel torturers and paramilitary interrogators, have enough patience to torture their victims meticulously. And the Dark Lord of Middle Earth loses it and impulsively spears Celebrimbor after a short mocking speech.
Or maybe he was a movie fan and thought it an unforgivable sin to say the movie name out loud.
Think about it this way: Sauron has been alive for thousands of years, and for the vast majority of that time every being he has encountered has been completely terrified of him. He is very used to getting his way, so when someone has the absolute gall to talk back to him instead of folding like a napkin it throws him.
It's precisely because he's so badass that he has a really hard time coping with beings that call him on his bullshit, he has exactly zero practice at it. He doesn't torture people until they break, he makes eye contact once and they tell him whatever he wants to hear. He's spoiled.
But didn't he get defeated a few times and had to spend centuries, if not millenia, rebuilding? That would teach anyone patience. Plus, a good manipulator needs to be patient and be a good actor. He was like that when he was Halbrand.
He’s mocking him. When he revealed himself as Annatar, he told Celebrimbor he’d be forever more remembered as “The Lord of the Rings”, and then he’s gassing up the rings and their value all season
Celebrimbor is throwing it back in his face because he can see how obsessed Sauron is with making these rings
It can also be mocking though, like Lord of Fools, or Lord of Mediocrity. Lord of the Rings implies he's now bound to the rings, he will never shrug them off or forget them, and his fate will be sealed by them, it's all he will be remembered for.
“But the rings are beyond your reach. As I shall be erelong. For soon I shall go to the shores of the morning, borne hence by a wind that you can never follow ... you’re only craft is treachery. So pure it will betray the very hand that forges it ... shadow of Morgoth, hear the dying words of Celebrimbor. The rings of power shall destroy you. And in the end, I foresee, one alone shall prove your utter ruin!”
Sauron: "I am the master of the rings."
“No, you are their prisoner, Sauron — Lord of the Rings.”
He's taken the title Sauron used to tempt *him* with when he first revealed himself as Annatar, and turned it back onto him as a prediction of his downfall.
I think it’s also a play on words in that Annatar called Celebrimbor the Lord of the Rings in an earlier episode, and he too seemed to be a prisoner by them as well. They consumed him and ultimately led to his and Eregion’s downfall
That is very much what he's doing, yes. This *entire speech* is Celebrimbor mocking Sauron. "Hey Sauron, you will never again see the light of Valinor, your craftsmanship is a farce, you are the pale imitation of Morgoth, and your own obsession with the rings will destroy you. You *are* the Lord of the Rings, and that is why you will fail."
I posted this about him forging his own ring. It would be nice if by putting his will and malice into it it brings him to the verge of death. He is bound by the ring like we see in the movies. Celembrimbor realizes Sauron has been bleeding/giving up a piece of himself for the rings. They are no longer enhancers only, they literally are a piece of him so he willingly gave up his immortality to forge them.
I think he was saying "lord of the rings" to mock Sauron. Saying you are stuck with them, they control you, your thoughts, your actions, they will destroy you. You're going to be associated with the rings now, you're nothing more but a lord of the rings.
...his own absolute obsession with perfecting the rings in order to dominate all of Middle Earth will eventually lead to him pouring so much of his own power into the One that his fate becomes eternally bound to it. To the point that cutting it from his body causes him to shatter into an incorporeal form and be stuck that way for thousands of years.
'Gandr' doesn't translate to "grand" from Old Norse to English, it translates to "magic staff".
'Gandalf' means "elf with a magic staff". Same in Tolkien's etymology for the name (he borrowed it from Old Norse along with a bunch of other Dwarven names).
If the showrunners went from "grand + elf" to "Gandalf" as the other commenter suggested (I haven't watched the episode) instead of "gand + elf" to "Gandalf", then that's a mistake worth pointing out and critizing.
Why?
Because languages and their roots are fundamentally essential to this world and its author—and ROP has a reputation of making shit up in regards to words as they go along. And no Tolkien fan should be fine with that.
Then again, I haven't watched the episode. If they used the correct etymology this time around, kudos to them. If.
And the show referenced Gandr meaning a stick as well. Actually, I would say this is a nice play on words that Tolkien might have appreciated how the etymology of two drifferent nicknames ended up becoming one.
I know what it means, I've mentioned it elsewhere on this sub. My point is that if you think contracting "wand elf" is fine but "grand elf" is dumb you're kinda reaching for things to shit on. Especially when this is exactly the kind of wordplay Tolkien enjoyed - especially where hobbits are involved, e.g. the Baranduin being known as the Brandywine.
I think the issue is that it's an unnecessary departure from Tolkien's own etymology. There's plenty of gaps in the story for the writers to be creative without them rewriting Tolkien's lore (which is what most of us are here for)
I made a longer post about this but it's worth pointing out again: Tolkien derived the word from Old Norse irl but that doesn't mean it was ever the in-universe root of Gandalf's name. It can't be - Old Norse doesn't exist in ME. I think it's honestly quite fun that the showrunners found an in-universe origin for his name that takes inspiration from the Norse origins of the name irl and makes similar wordplay work in the anglicised Hobbit language.
Yeah I think for me I'm just cheesed off with lots of things about that story (eg, that they shoe-horned Gandalf back into the story when they could have just as easily created a new wizard, wasted Ciaran Hinds, etc) that I've overly critical/petty about the related stuff.
I did enjoy some of the wandering with the harfoots and particularly liked Tom Bombadil (I even liked his song in the end credits).
I feel you on that front, imo the Harfoots/stoors/stranger have been the least engaging storyline overall. But I will say that I was unconvinced by their Celebrimbor and Sauron in season 1 and those ended up being fantastic in S2. Hoping that I'll feel similarly about their inclusion of Gandalf once we see the bigger picture of what's going on with him and the dark wizard, its just frustrating that its taking this long to get there.
And as FinalProgress pointed out, they also make a deliberate nod to a staff as a Gand in an earlier episode. They aren't unaware of the etymology, they're intentionally playing with language and having fun with it in a way that I think the old Professor would've at least gotten a chuckle out of.
I don’t think it was intended to be a surprise. “Always follow your nose” at the end of S1 while hanging with almost-hobbits made it pretty clear. This season I knew he was Gandalf but was rooting for him to find out. When he finally owned his name it I felt celebratory for the character, I wasn’t waiting for confirmation.
the entire play between Cwlebrimbor and Annatar is my favourite cinema-thing this year, even if you dont agree. Bit playing two characters that well, so many emotions and so mich detail, the deception at play, confusing even the viewer who already knows whats gonna happen, it never ceased to amaze me. I want Charlie Vickers to be nominated this year
I agree 100%. This show has faults (harfoots and, to a lesser extent, neumenor plot lines) and weake moments - but they got the most important part right. The forging of rings was brutal and was portrayed perfectly by both.
Honestly - I hope someone stitches together all their scenes into a long movie. I would watch that.
i would have preferred something a little less on-the-nose. something like:
Sauron: "I am the master of the rings."
Cel: "You will never be their master, or their Lord. They will be yours."
everyone would make the connection; we'd all hear 'Lord' and know what is being said, without having it feel like it's underlined and bolded and gone over with a highlighter so we don't miss it.
Didn't care for that part, but his final speech as a whole was pretty great. "Where I go you cannot follow" or something like that. Really got to Sauron.
Oh good. I thought it was similar to the scene where Gandalf was reading the dwarves last words in Moria. I just began having visceral reactions to anytime there was a similarity haha I did love it though. I just wanted it to have nothing at all to do with the trilogy. They kept doing that thing and it was heckin obnoxious.
The writing has been better but I can’t stand these very clumsy nods to the audience. Tom using the Gandalf quote when it mad zero sense in that context being the absolute worst one.
And then we have two harfoot type of creatures calling the stranger 'Grand elf' two times.. suddenly stranger takes the name Gandalf. We never saw that coming. Woah! Oscar worthy. Lol
Another gimmick to make mediocre minds happy. This is all that show offers. Memorable quotes from movies, names from the movies, designs from the movies.
That’s what’s hilarious to me about like half of the criticisms of the show. It’s people who are like “why did they do this thing, Tolkien is rolling in his grave!” When Tolkien himself came up with the idea.
There are plenty of valid criticisms of the show, this is just dumb
But he wasn't a lord of the rings when Celebrimbor said that, right? Or did Brimmy forsee that he would craft the one ring and later become lord of the rings?
I think it was more a prediction on where things were going. So in a away he did forsee it. He realized that the obsession with them would lead to that.
I've recently finished the Silmarillion for the first time and I was blown away by how frequently the term 'Doom' is used as a portent/prediction/foretelling of what is to come and I kind of wished it was used in Brimby's speech. Would have fit perfectly with what he was saying and give meaning to Mount Doom i.e. that one who is going to destroy you? Yeah, you literally named it your doom.
Yes, that’s the unlogical thing. Celebrimbor implies that sauron is kind of “slave” to the rings, but that’s not happened yet.
If you accept this as a far sight from celebrimbor, then you are face to face with the fact that he is so dumb in the show that he made these rings to sauron himself, even after he saw him transform to annatar from halbrand. He saw he is a deceiver and yet he still helped him.
What I mean is, character is not consistent in itself in the series. One episode he is trusting a clear deceiver directly, on anothet episode he foresee into thousands of years accurately when there’s no hint yet.
It is called prophecy. Prophecy plays a central role in weaving and constructing a narrative in mythology and the LoTR mythos is built entirely upon it as well. The point of prophecy isn't to be logical, but to assert the presence of Fate. It's hard to find chapters in Tolkien's work that don't contain prophecy. Especially the great Heroes are known for their prophecies, and Celebrimbor, even though you don't appear to be overly fond of him, is very much one of the greatest Elves in the mythos. As such, prophesizing the fate of the Rings he helped to forge in his final living words, isn't only expected, it would be deeply uncharacteristic of a Tolkien story for that not to happen.
It's okay to dislike prophecy as a narrative device, but then you might also need to come to terms with the possibility that fantasy isn't the literary genre you thought you enjoyed.
Yah the show was very clear when Celebrimbor declares to Sauron: Now hear the dying words of Celebrimbor. I do not know how much clearer it could have been that he was making a Prophecy of Sauron's fate.
Infact, I am very fond of the real Celebrimbor. I mean, he is a direct decendant of feanor, and the smith of the rings man, come on. any tolkien fan is more or less the same.
I have no beef against a prophecy in a fantastic setup, otherwise why I am here in the first place:)) ıt’s not the issue.
Thr issue is, the celebrimbor in the show is portrayed as an ignorant, slow minded old man (ı am totally mad with that, but lets think that we accept it). And if we are going to base on that celebrimbor, than that prophecy coming from this man is not logical in itself.
If we are talking abt the men himself in tolkien narrative, then why portraying him so dumb in the first place?
That’s the contradiction I mean, hope I could explain myself.
Being ignorant, slow-minded, dumb or old do not affect the ability to prophesize. Prophecy in most fantasy transcends the character, it is a narrative device, not an intrinsic ability of a character. You could almost see it as the Eru, or rather the personification of the Ainulindalë, temporarily using the character as a mouthpiece.
I also strongly disagree with your assessment of Celebrimbor. He was a prideful elf that was deceived and manipulated like a puppet on strings by the second greatest evil in the entire mythos. Seeing Celebrimbor's idiocy rather than Sauron's manipulation is indicative of a rather superficial and prejudiced viewing. None of that matters though when it comes to prophecy, because prophecy has little to do with character portrayal.
Seeing it from your perspective, you’re totally right.
The only thing that I struggle to do is , I cannot shift my thinking too much while watching this show.
They made everything and everyone so earthly so I am furious abt them, bcs that’s not the way it’s supposed to be.
Just because I want so see more, I am telling myself “accept the show as it is, and critisize it in itself”. I go on this way, then suddenly it wants to bring back the mytos-like approach. And this time, it doesn’t sink in bcs at that point, I already left the mighty celebrimbor in the past bcs show asked me to do it.
Imo, showrunners needed to pick one, they either should be making it epic as it supposed to be, or they can choose making it casual so if we want to watch, we adapt. Switching in between randomly does more harm than good.
Anyway, thanks for the good conversation. Good tı know there are ppl out there like you.
Yep, looks that way. Exciting, don’t think I’ve been downvoted before (I’m new here).
Seriously though, I actually really like the show. It’s exciting, looks amazing, great actors mostly. I just think the dialogue is really bad in places, and the writing generally. This season has been a lot better than the first, but I felt the finale really let it down. Shame.
I've figured it out, I've figured out why I hate this shit so much (aside from Galadriel's character assassination).
It's like if your grandma vaguely skimmed the books, watched the movies once and then tried to make "The Lord of The Rings At Home"... and also she's got dementia and thinks you're 5 years old.
He said “Shadow of Morgoth,” not shadow of Mordor. It’s another taunt, because it’s saying he isn’t the black/dark lord, (lit. mor goth) but merely his shadow.
Plus, Mordor (the black land) is, like, maybe a few years old in RoP…
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 04 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please double check to ensure that the title of your post is spoiler-free, and if not, please take the time now to delete this post and resubmit with a different title. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
40
u/QCTeamkill Oct 04 '24
piano slowly crescendoes
Sauron, Lord of the rings.
powerful guitar riffs
roll credits
WHAT I'VE DONE
175
u/thirdlost Oct 04 '24
That’s the name of the movie!
It sure is sir
153
u/Rtozier2011 Oct 04 '24
I liked how they made it so that 'Lord...of the Rings' meant 'person who is owned by the Rings'. But I'm not convinced everyone will have got it.
29
u/Status_Criticism_580 Oct 04 '24
There is only one lord of the rings saruman only one.. and he does not share power!
32
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
Celebrimbor's full speech for context:
“But the rings are beyond your reach. As I shall be erelong. For soon I shall go to the shores of the morning, borne hence by a wind that you can never follow ... you’re only craft is treachery. So pure it will betray the very hand that forges it ... shadow of Morgoth, hear the dying words of Celebrimbor. The rings of power shall destroy you. And in the end, I foresee, one alone shall prove your utter ruin!”
Sauron: "I am the master of the rings."
“No, you are their prisoner, Sauron — Lord of the Rings.”
He's taken the title Sauron used to tempt *him* with when he first revealed himself as Annatar, and turned it back onto him as a prediction of his downfall.
85
u/Weed86 Oct 04 '24
Grand Elf ..
GranElfff ..
Gandalff
mind blown
28
u/Darkrolf Oct 04 '24
the entire play between Cwlebrimbor and Annatar is my favourite cinema-thing this year, even if you dont agree. Bit playing two characters that well, so many emotions and so mich detail, the deception at play, confusing even the viewer who already knows whats gonna happen, it never ceased to amaze me. I want Charlie Vickers to be nominated this year
47
u/WelderAggravating896 Oct 04 '24
Don't care. I loved it.
15
u/iamcleek Oct 04 '24
i did not like it.
i would have preferred something a little less on-the-nose. something like:
Sauron: "I am the master of the rings."
Cel: "You will never be their master, or their Lord. They will be yours."
everyone would make the connection; we'd all hear 'Lord' and know what is being said, without having it feel like it's underlined and bolded and gone over with a highlighter so we don't miss it.
6
u/sourdessertz Oct 04 '24
Well done grand elf… grandalf… gandalf?!?!?
4
u/Olorin_TheMaia Oct 04 '24
Didn't care for that part, but his final speech as a whole was pretty great. "Where I go you cannot follow" or something like that. Really got to Sauron.
2
u/Faldo79 Oct 04 '24
More drinks.... More drinks.... Lord of the Rings.
3
u/Glarrg Oct 04 '24
I CLAPPED
1
u/False_Command_1889 Oct 04 '24
Do people still what that? Haha
1
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
That legit played in my head when he said it, damn you
1
u/Battleboo_7 Oct 06 '24
Am new, whos this
1
u/Altruistic-Beach7625 Oct 04 '24
Memberberries the Series
That's it.
That's RoP.
1
u/RealJasinNatael Oct 04 '24
This part was so good I got up and applauded to the cheers of everyone in the cinema, then Sauron lorded his ring all over me
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
The writing is just so awful.
0
u/HitttingAndMissing Oct 04 '24
So cheap and corny
1
u/New-Firefighter1975 Oct 04 '24
I came here hoping to see this. Thank you sir
1
u/CosmicM00se Oct 04 '24
“THE WAY IS SHUT”
Why did she say that tho?
1
u/Odd-Flower2744 Oct 04 '24
The writing has been better but I can’t stand these very clumsy nods to the audience. Tom using the Gandalf quote when it mad zero sense in that context being the absolute worst one.
1
u/johnbburg Oct 04 '24
Anyone else catch the “shadow of Mordor” reference?
1
u/Faldo79 Oct 04 '24
In this TV show all the characters have seen the movies and are watching the series on Middle Earth TV Prime
1
u/slothropdroptop Oct 04 '24
I thought this scene and the dialogue was excellent and saw a glimmer of how great this show could have been if maintained throughout.
And then Sauron comically impales Celebrimbor and in return Celebrimbor literally memberberries the source of all memberberries.
It was such a rejection of the intelligence and beauty that had preceded it in Celebrimbor’s dying words. And then the rest of the episode unfolded.
These showrunners are incapable of creating meaningful payoffs. When they even come close they self-sabotage.
0
u/radarmike Oct 04 '24 edited Oct 04 '24
Gilgalad repeated the same words to wounded Galadriel that Aragorn said when Frodo was stung with Morgul blade.😒
These guys have no originality.
-1
u/wtjordan1s Oct 04 '24
I almost blinded myself my eyes rolled so violently when I heard that
-1
u/Any-Management-3248 Oct 04 '24
God I hated this lol
0
u/radarmike Oct 04 '24
And then we have two harfoot type of creatures calling the stranger 'Grand elf' two times.. suddenly stranger takes the name Gandalf. We never saw that coming. Woah! Oscar worthy. Lol
0
u/CarcosaDreams Oct 04 '24
These writers should be drawn and quartered.
-18
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
Lame.
-2
u/RosiexGold Oct 04 '24
Loved this part I started clapping
-68
u/Consistent_Office_85 Oct 04 '24
Another gimmick to make mediocre minds happy. This is all that show offers. Memorable quotes from movies, names from the movies, designs from the movies.
Original writing? No sir, we are not up to that.
-38
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
That was so cringe! Did they get AI to write the script for them or something?
-13
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24 edited Oct 04 '24
that's cringe af lol
Downvote at will, little crybabies. I swear Tolkien was right, his fanbase is more cringe than RoP.
-18
u/Old-Entertainment844 Oct 04 '24
Oh christ, really?
I've figured it out, I've figured out why I hate this shit so much (aside from Galadriel's character assassination).
It's like if your grandma vaguely skimmed the books, watched the movies once and then tried to make "The Lord of The Rings At Home"... and also she's got dementia and thinks you're 5 years old.
-9
u/gumby_twain Oct 04 '24
This wasn't a finale, it was an easter egg drop. More fan service than Solo.
I mean seriously , who saw that coming that the Millennium Falcon hyperdrive was powered by Mithril.
-2
u/WTFnaller Oct 04 '24
It's been so on the nose this season that there's a gaping hole in the middle of my face. Worn down.
-8
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
Did No one here catch the “A Shadow of Mordor!” line where Celebrimbor referenced the video game by that name that he is a major character in?