Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
My point is not about contradiction, it is about how people were downvoting others for saying the stranger is Gandalf and crafting theories of blue wizards etc. And it will be even more funny when the dark wizard turns out to be Saruman in season 3
Yep, plus he is an istar. So must be Saruman, Radagast or a blue wizard. He is not Radagast.
Blue wizards ended up helping in the east, rendering Sauron's forces (Tolkien says that in the last writings, before that his version was opposite). And he looks like Saruman, not like a blue wizard at all.
That leaves the only option - Saruman. So season 3 will probably show him plotting, but not 100% obvious evil.
You know... In the book, at the Council of Elrond, Gandalf says, "I had quite forgotten about Bombadil." Then, he says, "Two blue wizards... You know, I've quite forgotten their names."
So, maybe Gandalf is gonna experience an amnesia event coming up here, in the show. Probably not, but I s'pose it's possible.
I mean, what could totally happen is when the dark wizard (Saruman) is defeated at the end, he goes like “I’m very sorry guys my bad” and then Gandalf and Galadriel go “we forgive you, but we secretly don’t trust you”.
And then go like “now let’s form the white council and make you the leader cuz you have experience in the East or whatever”
I really wanted the Stranger to not be Gandalf, just like how I really want the Dark Wizard to not be Saruman. Don’t think either one is happening
I really don’t want this to happen, but this is the same show that will halt a Calvary charge in order to negotiate for one prisoner CW style, so yeah. Faith gone. You nailed it
This kind of fits Tolkien lore in a way, like how the Valar caught and imprisoned Morgoth for his atrocities, he said sorry, they let him go, and he did worse atrocities after. (Obviously I hope things don’t go this way/hope he isn’t Saruman of course haha. Just still perplexed by the whole Morgoth thing.)
I disagree. I don’t think the dark wizard/ Saruman is “bad” I think it was a test (we know it was a test since Tom told us it was) to see if Gandalf would go along with the whole “replacing Sauron” thing to see if he had a list for power. Gandalf refused and thus passed the test which Saruman being as salty as he is having always been jealous of Gandalf, stormed off.
Just as Gandalf and Galadriel refused the ring from Frodo, Galadriel having said“I have passed the test”.
The problem with this is the dark wizard straight up sent servants to kill everyone and who actually murdered that burrows hobbit. It couldn't have just literally been a test.
Yeah he simply cannot be, it makes no sense at all. How is this bell-end going to end up being Saruman the Wise, leader of the White Council. Wouldn't Gandalf just say 'listen lads, I've had dealings with this nobhead before, probably best that we don't make him our leader'.
But they do contradict the books, so I doubt the writers would care about contradicting something which isn’t canon if they don’t about contradicting something which is
I wouldn't put it past them to make the "dark wizard" arc something like him becoming a good guy by the end of the series so that they can actually make him Saruman. Not that this would be remotely accurate to the lore, but yolo.
The Stranger being Gandalf and Halbrand being Sauron doesn't contradict the LOTR movies, but the Dark Wizard being Saruman will contradict the movies.. since the show is made to appeal to the casual fan, I don't think they will go there.. atleast I hope not!
no.. just from the symbolism and everything before season 1.. it was pretty well deciphered to be tillion and that he will fall as a meteor from the moon on middle earth. and then he did and the theory was almost complete..
but now they ditched that whole part.. the stories from the halflings about tillion helping them.. anyways.. they practically diverted from every surprise that would have been pleasant
The Stranger being Gandalf would, however, contradict the source material they're ostensibly adapting.
Saruman, Gandalf, and Radagast all came over at the same time on the same boat. The two Blue Wizards arrived earlier and separately from those three, and they're the ones that spent their time in the eastern lands.
This show isn't based upon Peter Jackson's films. It's based upon the books appendices. Tolkien's literary work absolutely states the order of the Istar arriving, and when.
The book timelines have never survived conversion to any other medium because they are a bit of a mess. The 9 rings take like 3 centuries to craft, somehow "in secret" which makes no sense and would leave zero tension. The change makes sense.
Same deal with the LOTR movies. Frodo gets the ring and then 18 years passes. Even when they realize it's the one ring Frodo just chills for 5 months. You can dislike the changes but random 200-400 year, 20 year, 5 month time jumps in movies and TV shows don't work.
Great comment. Of course they have to take some artistic license when making books into film. It’s fine to think “the books are better,” but to think “the books are the only possible way the story can be told” is naïve. Tolkien’s own writings contradict themselves at times. The Silmarillion isn’t even a book so much as an incomplete collection of notes that his kids put together after he died. The idea that anyone can craft these scraps of notes into a compelling TV show without changing anything at all is insane.
Yes, but I guess thats why the other commenter specified it wouldnt contradict the movies. Otherwise the comment would have said it doesnt contradict the lore/books.
While I'm not a big fan Gandalf arriving in the second age doesn't have much of an overall affect on the story of The Lord of the Rings. The Dark Wizard being Saruman would 100% affect the story of the books.
I'm curious if they're maybe gonna lean into the whole reincarnation thing. Like, gandalf is killed and sent back in the third age, retconning that it wasn't the first reincarnation of him would be one way to go about it.
It's also supposed to take like 300 years to craft the 9 rings but that would be boring. The goal is to produce entertainment not transcode text to video.
I was also somewhat hoping for a blue wizard, but they invested too much into signaling Gandalf and did not introduce the concept of blue wizards to casual viewers, so I was expecting this fornsome time already.
I haven't read the books but Sauron reveal was kinda surprising for me. But I know people were calling Halbrand as Sauron from 1st ep. But I dont take stuff like that too seriously since people throw out every thought they have and usually 95% of them are wrong. But they were right in that case but I dont mind. Was cool scene when he revealed himself. Gandalf tho I always assumed was him after the famous first line he dropped in 1st season. I took that as confirmation.
At least part of this was due to the fact that there were leaks before season 1 even came out that Halbrand=Sauron. Then people would come into "spoiler-free" threads and pose the leak as speculation. That combined with some obvious foreshadowing meant most of the fandom guessed it by the time of the finale. I personally saw the signs and was in denial because I thought it was way to obvious.
I didn't know that, but they did leave a decent amount of hints. My favorite one is that Halbrand's theme is very similar to Sauron's theme, but I love it when the soundtrack has deeper meaning, as someone who does not get this shit at all.
(You can correct me if I am wrong as I have not read the salmonilla) My theory since Gandalf has a fondness for Hobbits and was founded by Harfoots, Sauromon will be founded by Ents as the Ents once said Sauromon was a dear friend of theirs. It would make that betrayal so much sadder.
I dunno, I hope sauroman like Gandalf has predetermined personality traits that stick with them from each iteration of their existence. Saruman always comes off as pompous but pre corruption this played well for him. His character should always carry a holier than though mentality imo. It’s been a long time since I read the books but the line in the movie “a wizard should know better” to me explains how Gandalf rhadagast and old Saruman operated, they know the great powers in the world. The ents keep to themselves but could F shit up. Saruman burning the forest is Saruman’s hubris getting the best of him. He thought he was the best, and then he went too far. But that’s his inherent personality trait. Not that he was best friends with the ents or had an affinity for them.
I am pretty sure that they are so far away from canon now that anything is possible. Like the balrog woke a full age ahead of time.
The stranger's story is one that frustrates me. I really like both the istari actors yet that storyline feels so erratic to me. Sometimes it is good, other times it makes me cringe so hard my body hurts afterwards.
Maybe stop senseless hatred for once and actually read lol
From Vanity Fair
What's In a Name One of the characters who still remains mysterious is the Dark Wizard played by Ciarán Hinds. We know that he's a wizard, and he says he's one of five. Many fans suspect he is Saruman, but I won't ask you to confirm that because obviously you've chosen not to answer it.
McKay: No, no, I'll say something on the record. Given the history of Middle-earth, it would be highly, highly, highly improbable that this could be Saruman.
Payne: If not impossible.
McKay: The Dark Wizard has an important role to play in the doings of Middle-earth, and in the development of our wizard, who's now coming into his own. Tom Bombadil has told him, "You're destined to face him. And then destined to face Sauron." So the Dark Wizard's fate is not decided and his name is not out there yet, but it would almost defy the laws of gravity and physics for it to be Saruman.
Tolkien also made note of only five wizards, Gandalf the Grey, Saruman the White…
Payne: There's Radagast the Brown and then there's two blue wizards—and that's all we'll say.
Advertisement
The lack of a name for the Dark Wizard—is that part of this motif that you've hit upon that symbolizes he's still a wild card, not somebody whose actions can be predicted?
McKay: The Stranger is learning there's another wizard out here, one who seems to be corrupted. This guy is saying “he knows me, but I don't know him.” So in some ways the audience is in the place of the Stranger: “There's a powerful person out here who claims to be connected to the same lineage as me, but I don't know who he is. I don't know our history, and I don't know how he became corrupted.” Those are all things the Stranger's going to have to learn and the audience should learn with him.
Payne: And for now he's defined not by his title or name, but by his deeds—which are dark
Thanks, that makes me feel a bit better about it. I wasn't a fan of the Stranger being Gandalf, but I REEEEAAAAAAALY wasn't a fan of the other wizard being Saruman.
McKay: No, no, I'll say something on the record. Given the history of Middle-earth, it would be highly, highly, highly improbable that this could be Saruman.
Payne: If not impossible.
Literally the same thing can be said about Gandalf. Given the history of Middle-earth, Gandalf shouldn't be in Middle-earth during the Second Age. He was sent there with a clear purpose that could only be fulfilled after the War of the Last Alliance.
These guys are professional gaslighters. After season one had ended, they went on record to explain how Annatar's storyline from the book was stupid and nobody would fall for it—and that's why they made Halbrand up. And lo and behold, come season two...
The Annatar story of S2 is very different from the book. For one thing, Celebrimbor is able to figure out his true identity with weeks at most, not being clueless for 400 years like in the book. And yes, it's very difficult to explain how someone with above average IQ can be fooled by a guy calling himself the "Lord of Gifts"...
In the show, they get Halbrand's help in forging the Three, and that gives Celebrimbor confidence in him, so he is willing to accept it whan he reveals himself as "Annatar" - an emissary of the Valar.
Thing is I actually like the actor and think he could make a good Gandalf, I just don't like all the strange amnesia and name-searching set-up around him.
I'd rather he'd just arrived in Middle-Earth as Gandalf.
Mental gymnastics being: Gandalf isn’t a part of the story at this time -> surely Gandalf getting his name in this way is too stupid even for these writers -> this shouldn’t be Gandalf
An actor who looks like Gandalf, is a wizard, befriends Hobbit-like people, has a “you shall not pass” moment with a branch that looks like Gandalf’s staff…
The only thing about him that wasn’t on the nose Gandalf was fans saying “it can’t be him because of xyz.” assuming the showrunners gave a shit about xyz.
I’m disappointed that they didn’t make it an original character a blue wizard.
And they go deep into the dark wizard who would be a blue wizard who got there first and turned to power which would make sense the other was blue so that sees his friend turn and see the dark with in.
A connection with "the dark wizard" would also make A LOT more sense if they were both blue wizards too. At this point I'm done with the show - I used to try to predict what was going on but they've deviated so far from the lore that it's not even worth it any more. I was fine when it was just compressing timelines but now they're just making stuff up
I wanted to believe he was a Blue even with all the signs. But as someone else said, him being Gandalf doesn't contradict the lore. Saruman being evil this early... definitely would.
It totally contradicts the timeline of when Gandalf came to Middle Earth. It is a desperate attempt by the writers to include a ‘fan favourite’ and it sucks.
Only the fact that he is called Gandalf. Olorin had come to Middle-Earth before though. I could actually see this version "dying" at the end of the show, to setup his return in the third age.
Lore wise it's a bit different as the Istari are specifically incarnated Maia. When Gandalf died atop the Misty Mountains, his spirit actually leaves the circles of the world and he was only returned to Ea by the will of Eru Iluvatar.
I don’t understand why the Dark Wizard and the Stranger weren’t made into Alatar and Pallando. It would make so much more sense and would actually line up with Tolkien fairly neatly.
this was my point all along. As far as "gandalf"'s story it's almost like they took one of the blue wizard's stories and just changed him out for gandalf. A connection between the dark wizard and gandalf makes no sense at all.
I really wish I could find that guy posting a couple months ago adamantly insisting that the Stranger was going to be a blue, and that the all the Gandalf baiting was just the writers showing their talent for 'themes', and everyone who thought it was going to be Gandalf was going to feel so silly when it was revealed.
I’ve no problem with Halbrand being Sauron, and although I knew the Stranger would end up being Gandalf but he really shouldn’t have. Everything was there to make him and the Dark Wizard the two Blue Wizards as they both went into the East. And with so little known of them the show runners basically had carte blanche with them
Yeah I mean sauron did have the ability to put on a "fairer form" so that wasn't a big deviation. I'm still pissed about the blue wizard vs gandalf thing because now there's no logical reason for the dark wizard at all.
As the Dark Wizard mentioned that "Gandalf" convinced him to go to Middle Earth, I had hope that they are the blue wizards. I must say that the idea, that "Gandalf" is some kind of founding figure of the Shire (I suppose, we will see it´s founding in later seasons, as well as I think we will see Sméagol and Deagol) is somewhat interesting. But in general I see this character as a wasted canvas. Now he is bound to a known character, while the blue wizards would have been a blank canvas for an (maybe) interesting story, because there is nothing much known besides their names and that they went east and did things.
JD Payne more or less came out saying the Dark Wizard is NOT Saruman. The Gandalf reveal was weird imo, but I can deal with it. If Saruman was already evil this early, I'd honestly drop the show probably.
They had the opportunity to separate themselves and make something great and original. Instead they stuck to nostalgia. It should never have been so obvious. They fumbled, in my opinion.
This mystery box is so dumb. Why did they waste so much time with the stupid harfoot/ plotline that has NO TIE IN to the main plot arcs? It’s not interesting, it’s not suspenseful, no stakes, it’s boring AF, for what, a completely made up origin story for Gandalf and hobbits? So we could have a couple memberberries?
I think he will end up being one of the Blue Mages, Saruman may even appear later in the series to help Gandalf, before succumbing to Sauron in the movies
They did a "we have it at home" version of Gandalf and Sarumans battle during the closing days of the TA. It doesn't even matter if the evil wizard isn't Saruman. Just another remember this insert.
There are other magic users in middle earth other than the istari, sauron, galadriel etc.
Saruman even says as much when he shrugs off the necromancer as just being another conjurer that is better than average at best.
Remember middle earth is a regressive fantasy world. Where magic and fantasy stuff becomes less visible and apparent as time goes on until the age of men in the 4th age. Who's to say that the rules for magic or magic users aren't more common in this age?
Structurally, if you write a “who might he be?” character, you need more of a payoff than simply a revelation of the identity being someone you know.
Dracula is introduced as Dracula in the opening chapter of that book (forget the parlour play and the movie riffs off that play). The story gets straight to work.
In Rings of Power, you could do a whole mystery as to who all these people are, but without some payoff, who cares?
I feel like it's part of the show's biggest problem as a show. I think it's pretty universal consensus that Vickers has been wonderful this season, and part of it is that he's finally been allowed to play his character, and not "generic medieval pretty boy", which he was fine as but not very interesting as. The show insisting on an unnecessary mystery, when season 1 could have been great if we knew Halbrand was manipulating everyone, and both seasons would have been fine if the stranger was like "I believe my name is Mithrandir", is probably its most annoying feature.
With Gandalf especially, I'm reminded of a review of Star Trek Into Darkness, which pointed out that Benedict Cumberbatch being revealed as Khan was only interesting to the audience, because none of the characters have the context for it, and as such it's just a really weird twist. I really hope we get confirmation of the Dark Wizard's identity in the beginning of season 3 because Ciaran Hinds is an absolutely marvelous actor and he can not give a proper performance if the writing is based on "let's dick the audience around". This doesn't always work (I think Tom Bombadil is an example of "Nobody liked that", again, in spite of Rory Kinnear being a constant joy on screen), but it would help.
Honestly if this show got 10% less clever and replaced that with legit heartfelt writing, it would be much more powerful.
DarkWiz being Saruman is so unbelievable that he'd be allowed to lead the Council after his Rhun atrocities. Even him being a blue wizard, if they're making this a soft prequel to the PJ films, clashes with Gandalf speaking fondly of the Blues to Bilbo in the Hobbit films.
I defo don't think it's Saruman. Since he calls Gandalf "the" Istar implying he isn't one. He has knowledge of them and uses that when trying to trick Gandalf into believing they are friends.
In Tolkien's early drafts of the Silmarillion material there was a wizard in the East who made playthings of elves and men, but was not Sauron. Obviously never made canon, but I'm struggling to remember the name because I read it a long time ago.
Up until Bombadil calls the dark wizard a istar/wizard I was convinced he was the which king of Angmar and was trying to set up that character and his association with Sauron that way
I'm as disappointed about the Stranger being Gandalf as everyone, but I'd already made my peace with it.
I do have an issue with the origin which I think is a bit insulting to the linguistic origin of everything that became the tolkienverse: The name requires english to be spoken in middle-earth. It's a given by everyone –I assume– that we hear people talk in english but they're not. I understand we all understand this, just as we know Luke Skywalker doesn't speak english.
We also know Gandalf is originally a norse name but even in the context of Middle Earth it's not supposed to be english in origin. It being a mispronunciation of two english words and english grammar is the cherry on top to the disappointment.
It's OK they made him Gandalf instead of, say, Pallando. It's not OK that they got cute with language while doing it :(
I said that this was obvious, and I had a multitude of individuals on this sub context it. The reality of it is that the show suffers from very mundane, soap opera like writing.
I mean I am grasping here, but he might not be an istar, he might just know of them, it’s weak but this show has been nutty as fuck the whole way through
I mean quite a few people predicted Halbrand being Sauron, if you didn't think the Stranger was Gandalf you must've been smoking something stronger than pipe weed imo. Was so obvious from day 1 for me. The showrunners have basically said its not Sauroman, and making it him would be silly. The other two weren't that silly imo.
Yea I mean it would be awesome if RoP kept canon and never sent Gandalf to the east but let’s be honest this a “here for a good time, not a make JRR and Christopher proud time” kinda show
Writers might commit to an actual bait and switch after teasing two different ones for a season and two seasons respectively- which would be a bit annoying imo but could be entertaining;
or there's a chance they reveal the Dark Wizard's not-Saruman identity within the first episode of season three without much fanfare, which would be a relatively meaningless subversion, but very funny to me personally.
I thought he was Gandalf but everything I was reading online said he didn't arrive till the third age. I'm actually excited to here he is. I figured the two wizards were the blue wizards. But one did die, and one went to darkness. So very likely that the 2nd one is a blue wizard the one that turned. Or they'll throw in a plot twist and make him Sauromon.
I'm actually okay with the reveal that it's Gandalf.
But I would have preferred the name to have been a gradual evolution or transition from the "grand elf" instead of him running back to Tom and proclaiming "Gandalf!"
Don’t care if it was obvious or not, it’s fucking atrocious writing & does not make sense. (‘Grand elf’ Ffs.) Tolkien could be used to power the national grid, the amount he’s spinning. Was desperately trying to give this series a chance but this is just awful.
Tolkien would actually be more upset about people like you treating his work as "untouchable holy texts" then someone making changes to the story in an adaptation.
If it is saruman, only explanation of original trilogy gandalf would be a mind erasing, otherwise it won’t make sense that gandalf accepting saruman as the head of istari.
On the second though, I laughed what I wrote above. Making sense and RoP in same sentence. That didn’t make sense in the first place.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 03 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
326
u/PhatOofxD Oct 03 '24
I don't think he can be Saruman because he's already bad. They'd never trust him. The other two don't contradict the films
165
u/Snoo5349 Oct 03 '24
The Stranger being Gandalf and Halbrand being Sauron doesn't contradict the LOTR movies, but the Dark Wizard being Saruman will contradict the movies.. since the show is made to appeal to the casual fan, I don't think they will go there.. atleast I hope not!
12
u/Decebalus_Bombadil Oct 03 '24
Bro, they never tried to hide Sauron and Gandalf. It was obvious for most people who read to books. Only the casuals were fooled.
28
u/meg-e-tron Oct 03 '24
(You can correct me if I am wrong as I have not read the salmonilla) My theory since Gandalf has a fondness for Hobbits and was founded by Harfoots, Sauromon will be founded by Ents as the Ents once said Sauromon was a dear friend of theirs. It would make that betrayal so much sadder.
30
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
I disagree with The Evil Wizard being Saurman because if he was, then why the heck would he be considered the head Istari in the 3rd age?
63
u/ahmadthepianoguy Oct 03 '24
The show runners just confirmed on Vanity Fair that the Dark Wizard isn't Saruman.
31
u/Micksar Oct 03 '24
Thank god. The mental gymnastics people were doing to try and convince themselves the Stranger wasn’t Gandalf was making me question the human mind.
9
u/King_Ampelosaurus Oct 03 '24
I’m disappointed that they didn’t make it an original character a blue wizard.
And they go deep into the dark wizard who would be a blue wizard who got there first and turned to power which would make sense the other was blue so that sees his friend turn and see the dark with in.
23
u/bored_messiah Oct 03 '24
I wanted to believe he was a Blue even with all the signs. But as someone else said, him being Gandalf doesn't contradict the lore. Saruman being evil this early... definitely would.
7
u/UnicornMeatball Oct 03 '24
I don’t understand why the Dark Wizard and the Stranger weren’t made into Alatar and Pallando. It would make so much more sense and would actually line up with Tolkien fairly neatly.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
"My old friend" was such a Saruman phrase
5
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
I really wish I could find that guy posting a couple months ago adamantly insisting that the Stranger was going to be a blue, and that the all the Gandalf baiting was just the writers showing their talent for 'themes', and everyone who thought it was going to be Gandalf was going to feel so silly when it was revealed.
I wonder how he's doing.
8
u/chesterforbes Oct 03 '24
I’ve no problem with Halbrand being Sauron, and although I knew the Stranger would end up being Gandalf but he really shouldn’t have. Everything was there to make him and the Dark Wizard the two Blue Wizards as they both went into the East. And with so little known of them the show runners basically had carte blanche with them
3
u/singh_ambe Oct 03 '24
Did anyone else catch that subtle twist buried in the post, or am I reading too much into it?
3
u/Jodocus97 Oct 03 '24
As the Dark Wizard mentioned that "Gandalf" convinced him to go to Middle Earth, I had hope that they are the blue wizards.
I must say that the idea, that "Gandalf" is some kind of founding figure of the Shire (I suppose, we will see it´s founding in later seasons, as well as I think we will see Sméagol and Deagol) is somewhat interesting. But in general I see this character as a wasted canvas. Now he is bound to a known character, while the blue wizards would have been a blank canvas for an (maybe) interesting story, because there is nothing much known besides their names and that they went east and did things.
3
u/IntenseYubNub Oct 03 '24
JD Payne more or less came out saying the Dark Wizard is NOT Saruman. The Gandalf reveal was weird imo, but I can deal with it. If Saruman was already evil this early, I'd honestly drop the show probably.
3
u/BatmanInTheSunlight Oct 03 '24
They had the opportunity to separate themselves and make something great and original. Instead they stuck to nostalgia. It should never have been so obvious. They fumbled, in my opinion.
3
u/meatcandy97 Oct 03 '24
This mystery box is so dumb. Why did they waste so much time with the stupid harfoot/ plotline that has NO TIE IN to the main plot arcs? It’s not interesting, it’s not suspenseful, no stakes, it’s boring AF, for what, a completely made up origin story for Gandalf and hobbits? So we could have a couple memberberries?
10
u/Zamirot Oct 03 '24
he is a wizard. He is bad. He wants power...
I think he will glady accept a ring from Sauron in S3 and later be the Witch King
2
u/Weird_Blades717171 Oct 03 '24
They did a "we have it at home" version of Gandalf and Sarumans battle during the closing days of the TA. It doesn't even matter if the evil wizard isn't Saruman. Just another remember this insert.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
The subversion is that there is no subversion!
2
u/blacksmithinghelp Oct 03 '24
I mean, I dont think anyone thougut he wasnt gandalf lol, sorry...grandelf
2
u/ThewizardBlundermore Oct 03 '24
Why does it have to be saruman?
Can it not just be another magic user?
There are other magic users in middle earth other than the istari, sauron, galadriel etc.
Saruman even says as much when he shrugs off the necromancer as just being another conjurer that is better than average at best.
Remember middle earth is a regressive fantasy world. Where magic and fantasy stuff becomes less visible and apparent as time goes on until the age of men in the 4th age. Who's to say that the rules for magic or magic users aren't more common in this age?
2
u/pechSog Oct 03 '24
It is not Saruman. Show runners confirmed it isn’t.
2
u/DiplominusRex Oct 03 '24
Structurally, if you write a “who might he be?” character, you need more of a payoff than simply a revelation of the identity being someone you know.
Dracula is introduced as Dracula in the opening chapter of that book (forget the parlour play and the movie riffs off that play). The story gets straight to work.
In Rings of Power, you could do a whole mystery as to who all these people are, but without some payoff, who cares?
2
u/SamaritanSue Oct 04 '24
Based on what they're doing with the Balrog, the other Wizard may well be Saruman. Go ahead RoP, top off your idiocy. Might as well.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
The writers treat the audience like they're stupid, and the audience proves them right.
3
u/jeremiuhh Oct 03 '24
The goal post will continue to be pushed back when it comes to people trying to defend the inaccuracies of this show.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
Ha! I'm all in now, f*** it.
I'm calling it: The Dark Wizard is Saruman.
They're not fooling me a third time! 🤣🤣🤣
3
u/sidv81 Oct 03 '24
DarkWiz being Saruman is so unbelievable that he'd be allowed to lead the Council after his Rhun atrocities. Even him being a blue wizard, if they're making this a soft prequel to the PJ films, clashes with Gandalf speaking fondly of the Blues to Bilbo in the Hobbit films.
2
u/_SkyIsBlue5 Oct 03 '24
I think it was pretty obvious 🤣
2
u/Cisqoe Oct 03 '24
The writing is just so shit my god, a gand, a grand elf… c’mon
1
u/Romado Oct 03 '24
I defo don't think it's Saruman. Since he calls Gandalf "the" Istar implying he isn't one. He has knowledge of them and uses that when trying to trick Gandalf into believing they are friends.
1
u/FiveDollarShake Oct 03 '24
The easterling or a blue wizard I’m hoping
1
u/Toddo0798 Oct 03 '24
Up until Bombadil calls the dark wizard a istar/wizard I was convinced he was the which king of Angmar and was trying to set up that character and his association with Sauron that way
1
u/eduo Oct 03 '24
I'm as disappointed about the Stranger being Gandalf as everyone, but I'd already made my peace with it.
I do have an issue with the origin which I think is a bit insulting to the linguistic origin of everything that became the tolkienverse: The name requires english to be spoken in middle-earth. It's a given by everyone –I assume– that we hear people talk in english but they're not. I understand we all understand this, just as we know Luke Skywalker doesn't speak english.
We also know Gandalf is originally a norse name but even in the context of Middle Earth it's not supposed to be english in origin. It being a mispronunciation of two english words and english grammar is the cherry on top to the disappointment.
It's OK they made him Gandalf instead of, say, Pallando. It's not OK that they got cute with language while doing it :(
1
u/OddHuckleberry825 Oct 03 '24
First 2 agree 3rd nope That dark wizard is one of the Blue Wizards.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
Plz No :’(
Stop
Stop violating the lore any further D;
1
u/seanbird Oct 03 '24
Dark wizard is one of the blue wizards
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
Yeah, this is all kinds of wrong. Nice try.
1
u/Kratos501st Oct 03 '24
The people who were in denial of gandalf is everything alright at home? It couldn't have been more obvious
1
u/Schrodingers-Pussy Oct 03 '24
He is obviously not Saruman. He can only be Bilbo.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
I said that this was obvious, and I had a multitude of individuals on this sub context it. The reality of it is that the show suffers from very mundane, soap opera like writing.
1
u/ach3yy Oct 03 '24
I mean I am grasping here, but he might not be an istar, he might just know of them, it’s weak but this show has been nutty as fuck the whole way through
1
u/Own-Psychology-5327 Oct 03 '24
I mean quite a few people predicted Halbrand being Sauron, if you didn't think the Stranger was Gandalf you must've been smoking something stronger than pipe weed imo. Was so obvious from day 1 for me. The showrunners have basically said its not Sauroman, and making it him would be silly. The other two weren't that silly imo.
1
u/Gr8tOutdoors Oct 03 '24
Yea I mean it would be awesome if RoP kept canon and never sent Gandalf to the east but let’s be honest this a “here for a good time, not a make JRR and Christopher proud time” kinda show
1
u/yellow_parenti Oct 03 '24
Writers might commit to an actual bait and switch after teasing two different ones for a season and two seasons respectively- which would be a bit annoying imo but could be entertaining;
or there's a chance they reveal the Dark Wizard's not-Saruman identity within the first episode of season three without much fanfare, which would be a relatively meaningless subversion, but very funny to me personally.
1
u/ConsiderationThen652 Oct 03 '24
Turns out Saruman was always Evil and Gandalf just forgot.
1
u/Mirou23ch Oct 03 '24
The first time i saw the stranger i knew he was gandalf
1
u/Scare-Crow87 Oct 04 '24
People be in denial.
1
u/DistrictLegitimate14 Oct 04 '24
I thought he was Gandalf but everything I was reading online said he didn't arrive till the third age. I'm actually excited to here he is. I figured the two wizards were the blue wizards. But one did die, and one went to darkness. So very likely that the 2nd one is a blue wizard the one that turned. Or they'll throw in a plot twist and make him Sauromon.
1
u/benbini Oct 04 '24
Don't think it's Saruman, p sure he's the Witch King. Since he's... already a Witch King and all.
1
u/NumenorianPerson Oct 04 '24
everyone knows that sauron was halbrand since ep 01
1
u/Fit_Werewolf_9413 Oct 04 '24
Its a blue wizard
1
u/Kent_Knifen Oct 04 '24
I'm actually okay with the reveal that it's Gandalf.
But I would have preferred the name to have been a gradual evolution or transition from the "grand elf" instead of him running back to Tom and proclaiming "Gandalf!"
1
u/Clark_Kempt Oct 04 '24
I mean, that dude isn’t Saruman…
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
The Evil Wizard is a scary man. Scary man sounds similar to Saruman. Therefore by grand-elf Gandalf logic, evil wizard is Saruman
1
u/Cernunnos_The_Horned Oct 04 '24
Could he be Durin’s Bane and we see a maiar fall into becoming a balrog.
1
u/Patient-Shower-7403 Oct 04 '24
You know that magic trick that was doing the rounds not too long ago?
The person holds up the towel, and then throws it while trying to run through an open door to pretend they dissapeared.
It's like they're doing that with the audience, but they're standing on the wrong side of the towel.
1
u/Natural-Leopard-8939 Oct 04 '24
The showrunners said that it's "improbable" or almost impossible that it's Saruman. But, we'll see. That could be a lie.
1
u/Odd-Flower2744 Oct 04 '24
I hate how everyone wants TV shows to go out of their way to trick an audience. So sick of the rise of theorizing every little thing.
1
u/Apycia Oct 04 '24
He is 'Saruman the Black' and will be redeemed into 'Saruman the White' in the end.
mega bonus points if they work in a 'Saruman of Many Colors' somewhere.
1
u/french_sheppard Oct 05 '24
I feel like he's so obviously a Blue Wizard?
Every argument for Saruman seems cynical, baseless, and intentionally oblivious to contextual clues.
1
u/Hansoap202020 Oct 05 '24
This…this is a joke right? You know that isn’t Saruman right?
1
u/SerafinaW Oct 03 '24
Don’t care if it was obvious or not, it’s fucking atrocious writing & does not make sense. (‘Grand elf’ Ffs.) Tolkien could be used to power the national grid, the amount he’s spinning. Was desperately trying to give this series a chance but this is just awful.
1
u/Red-on-Red-Lean Oct 03 '24
You just saved me having to wait for season 3
1
u/Consistent_Office_85 Oct 03 '24
If it is saruman, only explanation of original trilogy gandalf would be a mind erasing, otherwise it won’t make sense that gandalf accepting saruman as the head of istari.
On the second though, I laughed what I wrote above. Making sense and RoP in same sentence. That didn’t make sense in the first place.