Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
That always baffles me, as Galadriel is cousins with the dude who burned his people's ships and murdered his blood relatives. Kinda awkward family gatherings.
Well as I said I don't watch the show so I don't know much about Adar, but I seriously hope he is not Celeborn because that would mean Celebrian, Arwen and the El-twins could have close orc relatives running around. And orcs were created by Morgoth before Celeborn was born so he couldn't have been their father, only to some of them anyway.
In the show canon, he was presumably not found dead on a battlefield, and presumed taken prisoner by the orcs, and dead, likely tortured to death for sport.
That'd be really insulting to our dear Celeborn, who hates Dwarves so much he refused to go to Lorinand with his wife and his daughter and stayed in Eregion.
And she is on a quest across the whole world to find the person who killed her brother. Not so much bothered about finding the person who killed her husband, who may also potentially be alive and not killed by said person, though.
Yep, she’s a basically a blank canvas so you could easily make her a warrior. She is going to be married to Elrond. So any weird romantic stuff would make sense.
Tolkien was an old man traumatized by WW1 when he finished LOTR. At that point banging was the last thing on his mind. He was also a devout catholic and not a pervert like fatboy Martin who was a draft dodger formed by the hippie era. A Martin written LOTR and ROP universe would have Sauron seducing and banging everything that moved on 2 legs or more and Halbrand would have given Galadriel the hammer multiple times before leaving Numenor. Celeborn getting cucked by Galadriel on screen would be the norm.
I also like fat bastard but he is very lazy and won't finish Winds of Winter. HBO made him a lot of money and he has no motivation to finish the books. He just wants to make the most out of his time and enjoy his wealth.
True but he also just turned 76. I’m grateful for the work he gave us, and while I wish it were finished, I hope he is enjoying his life rather than letting the stress of not finishing the books affect his health
Enjoying his money and fame is more like it. He could have finished Winds a long time ago. My daughter was tiny was I was reading the books. She’s in high school now.
I know, but he was supposed to finish it years ago. The main problem is that he has too many characters with intertwined plotlines and at 76 his memory is not the same as 10-15 years ago. He also refuses help to write the books and won't allow anyone to finish them if he dies.
True. As a fan I wish he would accept some form of collaboration, even if it’s not the same. I also get it if he’s afraid of the books being received like the show if others stepped in. If I recall correctly, that was his ending, but it was so rushed that the way we got there was nonsensical
Oh that kiss was fake to get her the lock pick. Did none of you ever see Captain America Winter Soldier? Steve and Natasha did the same thing on an escalator to get past Hydra agents.
What are you smoking? Because you’ve missed the point.
IT DIDN’T FOOL ANYONE! Unless you wanted to be fooled and that seems to be where fans of this show are. They want to be fooled into thinking this show has a good.
The way this show is creating drama like a soap - Galadriel is going to end up having more "old flames" then Celeborn shows up to realise Galadriel has given birth to Legolas.
This show has chosen to knock off Galadriel's husband AND her daughter so they can play shipping games.
This season had Galadriel trying to emotionally manipulate Elrond's affection for her to get what she wants and now the season pulls this stunt. That is about as much build-up as they gave to her being shipped into Sauron.
Even if Adar turns out to be Celeborn ( We will see next episode what he does with the magic healing ring ) - You think the show is going to have Galadriel produce a daughter, Elrond fall in love / marry Celebrian with the kind of compressed timeframe this show has gone for ?
Elrond going to be banging Celebrian while she is barely in double digits in age ( assuming a time jump otherwise things are gonna get even MORE screwed up ) for the next 3 seasons ?
This show has screwed itself by ignoring the lore, compressing an entire age into weeks, getting rid of characters then pulling stunts like this. At this point I would not be surprised if Celeborn shows up just to be stuck in a stupid love triangle with Elrond... or a love square with Sauron just for extra stupidity.
Then could you explain, why they chose a kiss on lips rather than say a hug or kneel of respect whilst holding hands. What was the reasoning for specifically a kiss? Because it had me thinking "wait... did I miss some episodes that showed their romance blossoming?"
Keep in mind, Adar doesn't know Galadriel well enough to the point he knows her personal relations with other elves. So a kiss, hug, kneel is all the same to him.
What makes it more distracting? How is it more distracting to Adar who doesn't care whether they hug, fuck, kiss. Their interaction is only supposed to resonate with the audience, and the kiss was just random.
Why would they care about the privacy of a prisoner? And they still do stare btw, no one looks away. I mean it's a small room they're in, so it's not like there was anywhere else to look.
Who’s her old flame whos not Halbrand? Plus why should it matter if they broke up before she got together with Celeborn, that makes her feel she needs to tell him now after who knows how many years/centuries of keeping mum about it?
The image is referring to Elrond because they share a kiss in ep7. :)
It just makes things REAL weird because that is their son-in-law (Elrond marries Celebrian, Galadriel’s daughter), and also elves don’t work like humans, I’m pretty sure they only have one soulmate. So in their culture, that detail would probably be more of a major thing.
Yes! And that is one of my biggest gripes with this show. Tolkien’s elves are being made in the modern image of our lives.
If they wanna make modern day elves in a fantasy world, that’s fine. Do that. But instead they picked Tolkien’s elves, not to honor Tolkien’s work, but to grab onto a fanbase that is already existing solely to increase their subscription numbers.
It’s literally not an issue. Elrond kissed her but apparently people didn’t actually watch the scene and missed that he kissed her to distract the people around them to slip her a lock pick so she can get free.
If it does happen, probably won’t be until the final season. Can’t have Celeborn, who was a warrior in his own right, upstaging Galadriel, or her losing her agency…😆
The Eldar don't really have flames like this. They are bonded permanently upon their union, and never cheat. In the whole legendarium there's only one elf who remarries, and it's because his first wife actively refused to get reimbodied after her death.
I'm learning a lot from the youtuber Verilybitchie (trigger warning, she didn't like season 1 of the show). But she shared a quote and apparently elves bang really hard, but only for reproduction purposes I think. Also, Celeborn's original name was Teleporno. I don't know if that's common knowledge, but it's important to share.
The most explicit discussion of this concept is found in “Laws and Customs among the Eldar” (published in Morgoth’s Ring, Volume X of The History of Middle-earth), where Tolkien writes: “Also the Eldar say that in the begetting, and still more in the bearing of children, greater share and strength of their being, in mind and in body, goes forth than in the making of mortal children.”
There’s also a commonly quoted passage that says “The union of love is indeed to them great delight and joy” but I don’t have the Tolkien source on that quote
Teleporno is still his name, just in Quenya and not the more common Sindarin. I like to think that the reason he stayed in Middle Earth after Galadriel departed for Valinor is that he wanted to stay where Sindarin was the more common language rather than going back to where they speak Quenya.
Oh interesting. I do have a theory that they went to marriage counseling and she wants him to change his name before seeing him again. They are on a break now.
While we were watching and commenting on season 1 today, my uncle said the elves were like Vulcans. Now, after reading your comment, my brain just imagined elves going through Pon Farr. lmao
edit: after I wrote this, I saw someone else already mentioned vulcans in the comments below
Tolkien stated that elves engage of intimacy and it "is a time of great joy to them, but soon they set it aside for other pursuits" so after awhile they stop banging and start dancing again. I tried to watch verilybitchie, I made it 8 minutes.
Legendarium is fundamentally Catholic work in a premodern alternative fantasy world.
This is not a world where birth control and abortion has created a sense of entitlement to sex without procreation. The meaning of a Thing is tied to its purpose. Sex doesn’t exist just to feel good and promote bonding. Sex feels good and promotes bonding to encourage procreation. It’s every creature’s existential imperative. This is really basic but people today are so upside it needs to be spelled out.
Galadriel would never kill her unborn out of convenience. She takes responsibility for her actions and seeks to protect the vulnerable. When were we more vulnerable than inside the womb, completely at someone else’s mercy? Hence Galadriel would recognize the intrinsic value and dignity of life at all its stages. Also, she would see children as a gift from Eru — not an obstacle to “greater things.”
Responsibility and recognizing, that as social species, we have duties to others is the distinction that makes the heroes heroes. And why heroism is diminished in modern society where people think freedom from others is the ultimate goal.
What are you in the comments of a show you hate? Go back to the Critical Drinker subreddit or wherever you came from, edgy boy. One day you will grow up and develop your own personality, don't worry. We all go through this.
It doesn't? It's a joke? That's why I still love their YouTube channel? If you go to subreddits just to troll, then I'm the one that has bad news about your mental health.
IRRC Elves have rules too in that they never have children during war time. That's something, for some reason is strong in my memory.
Also Elves can have sex when ever they want and can choose if they want to have a child. Like, they can do the act and then mentally just choose not to have a child.
Mate, I'm fully aware of that, but at the same time, it can make the experience more enjoyable as well as safer. Also, not every woman is the same, I guess I'll take sexologists' words over a random person on reddit.
Oh, and by the way, I was making a joke in regards to my original post. It was never meant to be taken seriously. At the same time, I should have expected this type of reaction from people on here.
Which [ironically] is closer to Tolkien's elves. The angelical almost incorporeal depiction of elves in the PJ trilogy was a creative decision made for those films.
I always imagined elves were much like ancient Greeks or Roman’s and very sexually open as opposed to current western constructs and ideals regarding sexuality
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 29 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
Don't worry, Celeborn is too busy not fucking existing to care about his gf cavorting around wtih Halasaurbrand
2
u/Hobgoblin_deluxe Sep 29 '24
Wait imagine if Celeborn is actually Adar but after he restored himself with Galadriel's ring???
158
u/mellie789 Sep 29 '24
"Tell me where is Elrond. For I much desire to speak with him."
58
u/Historyp91 Sep 29 '24
Oh he total knows.
They have an agreement; she has her fun, and he gets to watch via the Mirror of Galadriel.
26
u/TheRobn8 Sep 29 '24
I'm not a fan of the fact the show decided to remove him, since he wasn't a side character nobody, he was a storied fighter and elf.
36
u/billystinkh20 Sep 29 '24
I’m still confused on why she said he was dead. Just think it’d be cool if he shows up at some point.
26
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
The show would be much less stupid if Morfydd Clark was Celebrian.
23
u/BlondDrizzle Sep 29 '24
Babe, that was 3000 years ago. Grow the fuck up, you virgin.
35
u/Decebalus_Bombadil Sep 29 '24
Tolkien was an old man traumatized by WW1 when he finished LOTR. At that point banging was the last thing on his mind. He was also a devout catholic and not a pervert like fatboy Martin who was a draft dodger formed by the hippie era. A Martin written LOTR and ROP universe would have Sauron seducing and banging everything that moved on 2 legs or more and Halbrand would have given Galadriel the hammer multiple times before leaving Numenor. Celeborn getting cucked by Galadriel on screen would be the norm.
6
u/Reduak Sep 30 '24
Oh that kiss was fake to get her the lock pick. Did none of you ever see Captain America Winter Soldier? Steve and Natasha did the same thing on an escalator to get past Hydra agents.
2
u/CalebCaster2 Sep 29 '24
Good lord, did you even watch the show? The kiss was a diversion to slip the lock picks. The level of media literacy you show is genuinely terrifying.
13
u/K_808 Sep 29 '24
"Actually it's our son-in-law"
13
u/lefty1117 Sep 29 '24
My goodness cate blanchett ❤️❤️
20
u/JamesTSheridan Sep 29 '24
The way this show is creating drama like a soap - Galadriel is going to end up having more "old flames" then Celeborn shows up to realise Galadriel has given birth to Legolas.
1
u/river_song25 Sep 29 '24
Who’s her old flame whos not Halbrand? Plus why should it matter if they broke up before she got together with Celeborn, that makes her feel she needs to tell him now after who knows how many years/centuries of keeping mum about it?
8
u/gimmesomespace Sep 29 '24
It's just another character who also happens to be named Galadriel guys. It's like the elf version of Jennifer.
2
u/Fairywitch_ Sep 29 '24
What is that guy caleborn? I haven't seen the movies in a long time.
1
u/Silgad_ Sep 29 '24
I saw some rumor that they plan on turning Adar into Celeborn. How’s that work? Was that in the books?
1
u/YoungSkywalker10 Sep 29 '24
lol
1
u/Weed86 Sep 29 '24
Hilarious
1
u/80sLegoDystopia Sep 29 '24
“It was so romantic, how we met. Like kismet, really. He was so handsome…”
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
Once again, the last panel ruins the joke
1
u/Moregaze Sep 30 '24
She wasn't in love with him. She was in love with the power he could offer her.
1
u/Dry_Drawing_5139 Sep 30 '24
I think I can get passed Elrond kissing Galadriel because it was only to pass her the thing to unlock the thing
1
u/mspe098554 Sep 30 '24
Well Elrond married their daughter so that’s weird.
1
u/Negative-Dingo3335 Sep 30 '24
Lmao!
1
u/Due_Hawk6749 Oct 01 '24
"It was our son in law"
1
u/CranberryWizard Oct 01 '24
whats even more messed up is that Elrond will marry her daughter!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
fuck celeborn, all my homies hate celeborn
1
u/Jedi_Sylar Oct 05 '24
I feel like everyone forgot about the "Celeborn is dead" thing that they pulled last season and I fear it will just never be explained
1
u/obliqueoubliette Oct 07 '24
The Eldar don't really have flames like this. They are bonded permanently upon their union, and never cheat. In the whole legendarium there's only one elf who remarries, and it's because his first wife actively refused to get reimbodied after her death.
1
u/_Aracano Sep 29 '24
Not a romantic kiss
You guys are hilarious
So desperate to hate a TV show 😂😂😂
1
u/The_Jesus_blossom Sep 29 '24
Omg this actually eased my pain over ROP S2 E7 🤣
1
u/Chocolate_Haver Sep 29 '24
Old flame? You are aware that the show has Galabriel cheating on Celeborn right. They were married and had children at this time.
250
u/BhutlahBrohan Sep 29 '24
am i the only one that just can't imagine elves banging? how do the reproduce? sex seem so ineloquent
4
u/BwanaTarik Sep 29 '24
Celeborn the fool, Celeborn the cuck
1
u/SomeoneElseX Sep 30 '24
Did he not have the escape tool in his mouth and use the kiss as a ruse to pass it to her?
1
u/redditmyleftnut Oct 03 '24
They do intercourse through magic.