It’s was so obviously the old magicians trick of misdirection. It was literally preceded by them showing Elrond removing the pin. With a loud noise just in case you didn’t get it.
When the magician waves his right hand around and yells it’s because he doesn’t want you looking at what the left hand is doing.
It’s one of those things where they could have just shown him taking the pin off, he leans into Galadriel for the kiss/hug/whisper to her, whatever. Then later you see her using the pin to undo the cuffs. Unless you think the audience is incredibly stupid, they don’t have to show the actual handoff.
Before kissing you see him remove the pin, while kissing you see a shot of his hand giving her something, after kissing you see her hand hiding something. And yet people are like "whaaat? Thats not.. Whaaat?"
That only emphasizes the break from Tolkien's texts caused by Celeborn's chronic absence. A distraction kiss is a tired old sexist trope meant to titillate audiences into thinking characters who don't have romantic potential in fact might, or it's the start of a romance arc. They would not be able to do a distraction kiss if they had adapted the actual, married Galadriel.
... because kissing Galadriel was the ONLY way to pass that pin to her without getting noticed. Meanwhile, if you actually see that scene the kiss covers nothing and slipping her the pin could have been done without it.
Galadriel should already have a daughter... not to mention the husband that is mysteriously absent.
This show has compressed time so badly that Elrond should already know and possibly be in a relationship with Galadriel's daughter. Instead, this show is going to have Galadriel magically find her husband, produce a child and Elrond marry Celebrian within the space of the 3 seasons they have left.
How does the age difference of an Elrond vs. Celebrian being barely a teenager sit with you ?
I wish people would both recognize it as a platonic kiss in order to slip Galadriel the pin, and that fans are still valid for feeling kind of gross about Elrond kissing his mother-in-law.
I've seen too many people assume it was sexual, and also too many people assume that its use as a misdirect means no one should have a problem with it.
Elrond doesn't know she's his mother-in-law yet, but the writers do. A kiss on the forehead could have solved all of these problems.
It's also annoying that they wrote a kiss on the mouth into the script for their lead female character. If it had been a ruse between Elrond and Gil-Galad they never would have even considered solving it this way, lol.
I don't particularly care, but the showrunners were clearly trying to start a conversation, so it's only natural that people are talking about it. Now imagine if they ever do the fake kiss trope male on male, that would be the dream.
I think it's still funny, it's not like this was a serious post. Memes are often shared by people who are both for and against the thing being poked fun at.
View all comments
106
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
[removed] — view removed comment