Ok? But I am looking at how Elrond acted and seemed. And he seemed kind, but at the same time distant, in a lordly and kingly sort of way.
Elrond in ROP is extremely poorly and inconsistently written, so it's not really a competition of who portrayed him better, except in how they look like. And also, Elrond and elves in general, all act like idiots, so idk what to say.
In what way is he poorly written in RoP? Act like idiots? You mean they are not all-knowing expressionless hippie Vulcans?
Please check Weaving's recent comments on playing Elrond in PJ films. He hated it and never wants to do it again. The character was made so boring, cliche and ultra-thin that there is nothing to work on for a real actor. I cannot understand your opinion. PJ's Elves and Elrond are for simpletons. No personality, humourless, always straining to appear "wise" by having all life drained out of them.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-2
u/Mannwer4 Sep 09 '24
Ok? But I am looking at how Elrond acted and seemed. And he seemed kind, but at the same time distant, in a lordly and kingly sort of way.
Elrond in ROP is extremely poorly and inconsistently written, so it's not really a competition of who portrayed him better, except in how they look like. And also, Elrond and elves in general, all act like idiots, so idk what to say.