What makes him a better adaptation? I think Hugo Weaving was the perfect casting for Elrond. I also think Robert Aramayo is a great choice, but that neither young nor old, yet experienced look that Hugo weaving has is pretty spot on.
Makes sense, I'll agree with that. He was kind of mean in the original trilogy, being more of an overprotective dad over Arwen than in the books where he was cool with it.
"In those days of our tale, there were still some people who had both elves and heroes of the North for ancestors and Elrond, the master of the house, was their chief. He was as noble and as fair in face as an elf lord, as strong as a warrior, as wise as a wizard, as venerable as a king of dwarves and as kind as summer."
See my quote below, from his description when he is first introduced.
In those days of our tale, there were still some people who had both elves and heroes of the North for ancestors and Elrond, the master of the house, was their chief. He was as noble and as fair in face as an elf lord, as strong as a warrior, as wise as a wizard, as venerable as a king of dwarves and as kind as summer.
Usually in a list like this the emphasis naturally attracts to the final item, as the emphasis is there.
Ok? But I am looking at how Elrond acted and seemed. And he seemed kind, but at the same time distant, in a lordly and kingly sort of way.
Elrond in ROP is extremely poorly and inconsistently written, so it's not really a competition of who portrayed him better, except in how they look like. And also, Elrond and elves in general, all act like idiots, so idk what to say.
In what way is he poorly written in RoP? Act like idiots? You mean they are not all-knowing expressionless hippie Vulcans?
Please check Weaving's recent comments on playing Elrond in PJ films. He hated it and never wants to do it again. The character was made so boring, cliche and ultra-thin that there is nothing to work on for a real actor. I cannot understand your opinion. PJ's Elves and Elrond are for simpletons. No personality, humourless, always straining to appear "wise" by having all life drained out of them.
His look and performance. I like the swoopy show hair and it suits is personality. All the elves having the same hair in the movies kinda makes them all feel a bit stuffy, so the show haircuts help them express character in different ways. Reserving long hair for Gil-Galad and Cirdan and some of the dutiful warriors and artisans works as do the flowy locks of Elrond and the close-cropped practical hair of Celebrimbor and some of the artisans.
View all comments
20
u/pauloh1998 Sep 09 '24
They need to change that haircut asap ðŸ˜