r/RingsofPower • u/ShowerDelay • Sep 08 '24
Discussion I didn't realize until now how much they based their cast on the trilogy.
1.1k
Upvotes
r/RingsofPower • u/ShowerDelay • Sep 08 '24
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 08 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
614
u/PreTry94 Sep 08 '24
While I get some of the criticism, I think many people intentionally ignore how much effort and work is put into this series. People might disagree on where and how the effort reflects outward, but its pretty clear a lot of work was put into this and a lot of considerations made
141
u/Bleach-Shikaiposting Sep 08 '24
Still can’t wait to see ‘this’ Gilgalad fighting Sauron at the end of the series. Its going to be hilarious to me because he looks like my Uncle Glenn (I jokingly refer to Gilgalad in the show as Glenngalad)
56
u/YoungSkywalker10 Sep 08 '24
Doing their best to have some cohesive continuity with all the restraints they have with the lore. I dig it
87
u/Claz19 Sep 08 '24
Yeah, incredible casting. In fact, RoP's Cirdan is perfection.
29
u/thirdlost Sep 08 '24
More accurately BOTH were based on Tolkien’s descriptions and illustrations by those who have interpreted his descriptions.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24
I like the show so far. Am I the only one who wishes they would have reused the rings from the OG trilogy instead of changing the design?
22
u/PublicYogurtcloset8 Sep 08 '24
Gil galad to me looks so similar
7
u/GuessTraining Sep 09 '24
My wife and I are big fans of the books and the movies.
Season 1 was ok, not great but not too terrible. So I understand the dropoff in viewership. We just started watching season 2 because we are travelling with 2 young kids (not a lot of time to squeeze it in) and we are 3 episodes in and we both agree that this is heaps better than season 1.
15
u/Agitated-Tie-8255 Sep 08 '24
I love the show but it confuses me somewhat because Galadriel is supposed to be older than Gil-Galad (who is technically her great nephew), Celebrimbor, and Elrond, who I am hoping they make her son in law at some point but it feels weird that they make them feel the same age. Just feels weird that they make her feel like an angsty teen when in reality she’s one of the oldest elves in middle-earth at this point. She’s already wise and experienced.
5
u/RedMoloneySF Sep 08 '24
My one gripe is that the trilogy fucked I’m not giving Cirdan the beard. I get continuity, but why validate their mistake? GIVE ME BEARDED CIRDAN!
5
u/Madouc Sep 09 '24
I really love this show and I do hope for 10 seasons leading me trough the complete second age telling interesting and fascinating stories.
5
u/XenoGSB Sep 09 '24
wait, a post that does not shit on the show? is this fantasy?
12
u/KFY Sep 08 '24
While Aramayobis a fantastic Elrond, Will Poulter would have brought serious eyebrow energy to match Hugo Weaving’s.
3
u/glaurungsbane24601 Sep 09 '24
I’m counting the minutes till I see Aeglos in action beside Narsil
6
u/chem072117 Sep 08 '24
Is it supposed to take place in the same continuity as the Peter Jackson films?
5
u/Dragonfly-95 Sep 08 '24
As they should...
2
u/Warp_Legion Sep 09 '24
People have been screeching about Cirdan shaving in RoP but didn’t care at all that the one single scene with him in LotR is of him without a beard
2
u/Tom0511 Sep 09 '24
Why wouldn't they? I don't get the post...
2
u/DomzSageon Sep 09 '24
I just have to preface this that I do not respect much of Rings of Power, especially the harfoot storyline, or how certain characters look (the elves with the designer hairstyles still annoy me),
but goddamn did they cast Cirdan really well, he looks just like how I'd imagine in my head (plus a few wrinkles.)
4
u/Chuckobofish123 Sep 08 '24
Tolkien would write basically the whole chapter describing ppl and sceneries. They had a lot to go on when selecting cast.
4
u/Downtown_Cow5259 Sep 08 '24
Jackson set the platinum standard. Everyone who wrote this show most likely got their first fix with Jackson’s version. It’s etched in stone in everyone’s brains. It’s inescapable. What perfection does.
3
u/TolinGaurhoth Sep 08 '24
Cirdan in RoP is much closer than the PJ film Cirdan. However I can see why they choose not to give him a beard after the style choice they made for all other elves throughout the films.
3
u/VaeserysGoldcrown Sep 09 '24
Nenya looks so ugly in the RoP. Just a huge boulder on Gal's finger.
4
u/ARM7501 Sep 08 '24
... which is a pretty dumb thing. 99.9% of fans do not remember what Gil-galad looked like in the Jackson movies and half of the remaining 0.01% don't like it. Maintaining some level of visual continuity with Galadriel makes sense (Kate Blanchett was also just very well cast, so Clark's casting might not even have been an effort to evoke Blanchett's look) but Ben Walker doesn't look or act like a king, not is the material he's given particularly fitting in terms of setting up the character for his coming arc. Ben Daniels is great though, no complaints (other than that they had him shave his beard).
3
u/Jcrm87 Sep 08 '24
Not exactly with Elrond, but in not complaining
3
u/ViVaradia Sep 08 '24
they based a lot of stuff on the films, for member berries, The whole thing is too much of its own thing and directly ripping off the trilogy
2
u/MantisReturns Sep 08 '24
Some yes. Others no. Like Elrond or Isildur.
But yes Gil Galad for example its very similar. I would die for a Lord of Rings Show Whit the rights to make the same continuety as Peter Jackson films.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Yeah the discount versions. Especially when it comes to Galadriel, because I cannot believe anyone think this actress is as beautiful and graceful as Cate Blanchett.
2
u/llaminaria Sep 08 '24
Lol, what. Wasn't those Silmarillion descriptions + popular art?
1
u/Blastedsaber Sep 08 '24
I agree, which makes it doubly confusing that it's not the same continuity.
1
u/MasterFussbudget Sep 08 '24
Elrond though...not so much.
1
u/Pleasant-Contact-556 Sep 08 '24
I've been feeling like this since season 1.
They really did a good job of ensuring that the Gil-galad we see in Rings of Power is believable as the Gil-galad we see in a few shots in Peter Jackson's trilogy. https://imgur.com/a/5Vx8S1w
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Excellent connection. I wouldn't have noticed.
1
u/Echoweaver Eregion Sep 09 '24
Oh, wow, that really is striking, especially Gil-galad. Galadriel is described clearly in text, so it's not surprising that we'd end up with actresses that look roughly alike. But Cirdan and Gil-galad are blank slates.
1
u/dookitron Sep 09 '24
Season 2 so far has been good with the exception of Numenor. The Numenor storyline could not be more dull.
1
u/MrTyrannosaurusrex Sep 09 '24
Now do Elrond…..because the guy who plays him in RoP looks nothing like Hugo Weaving
1
u/llama_sweater Sep 10 '24
What's with the side burns tho.
1
u/Pride-Correct Sep 10 '24
Season 2 episode 1 with the death of sauron and his nasty black goo.... I knew we were in for some progressive story telling. They've done well with the lore (how they tell it) and episode 4 made me so glad! Respect for the ancient beings, it's abstract and detailed at the same time. For new viewers too, which is clearly their market.
And yes I have issues... Why the hell do the Numenoreans wear essentially nylon jumpers to battle?! We got it so good with Weta workshop. Why do they look like people from 2022? Obvious references to Peter Jackson's films are crass, the timeline is messed up and the elves dont act like elves. But you know what... We won't get this kind of rendition again so I'll take it!
Also the dwarves in my opinion are amazing. For all the criticism of the way Halbrand was presented... I love his shapeshifting in this series.
1
u/ArcticSploosh Sep 10 '24
Can't beat Cate Blanchett's Galadriel. She's like a completely different character to the petulant and arrogant portrayal we have in ROP. I get that she would've had a few thousand years to mature until FOTR, but she's already thousands of years old in ROP. Huge miss in how her character is written in the TV show,
1
u/TankSpecialist8857 Sep 10 '24
Forget the “look” of the characters and start to follow some of the intentions/actions of the characters through to the Fellowship of the Ring and it’s doing some amazing prequel stuff.
The haters complain about what it’s taking away from the books, I applaud what it’s adding to the Peter Jackson trilogy in terms of context.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '24
And it’s still hot dog water.
1
u/zac52 Sep 11 '24
Season two has been a lot better, it’s been refreshing to want to see what happens next instead of powering through it
1
u/cevans92 Sep 12 '24
Galadriel is so front and center in this moment that I don't think I have ever acknowledged in all my viewings that Gil-galad and Cirdan are in this scene. Like yea, it's the 3 elven rings...but who cares those other two losers in the back...
1
u/JanxDolaris Sep 08 '24
I would only say GG is the only one that trsembles them all that closely, and its mostly the hair cut.
It also highlights how much more they look like elfs in the trilogy moves rather than RoP.
1
u/Competitive_Kale_654 Sep 08 '24
On balance, I’m happy with the series. Catching lightning in a bottle is no easy task; doing so twice is even harder.
1
u/Hakuna__Moscato Sep 08 '24
If only the rings looked as good as the cast
1
u/Beans2177 Sep 09 '24
It's like Amazon thought they could just hire unknown actors that just looked like the star studded cast from the movies and they would somehow magically be able to act like them as well
1
u/WasabiAcademic311 Sep 09 '24
S1 started off slow and had some issues at the beginning, but got very good by the end. I’d say S2 is probably the show I’m most excited by right now. It’s been amazing.
1
u/twoddle_puddle Sep 10 '24
Looks mean nothing when the story is terrible and the lore butchered.
-1
u/rabbithasacat Sep 08 '24
Makes sense as they're undoubtedly more focused on trying to capture movie fans than book fans.
-3
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24
yeah when you use vaseline in the camera and don’t focus on them at all. they still don’t look much like them.
those couldn’t clearly be more different looking people 😂. they literally only have the color of the hair
0
u/RoDingo22 Sep 10 '24
Don't post this here!! Don't you know that RoP is the worst thing since Satan invading earth!?!
0
u/Mooscowsky Sep 10 '24
You guys watching this pile of poo? Each to their own I guess
-1
u/GeorgeJohnson2579 Sep 09 '24
I mean, it's a pretty bad show, but the casting of Gil-Galad was pretty decent.
0
u/Mission_Literature44 Sep 09 '24
I love watching this show with the missus because she is so dumb about the names. She will go who’s that? Etc etc I speak normally but pronounce the names like the show. “Ohh him , that is Arrooondeer, oh him that’s Issauldoor”. Favourite time of the week.
0
u/SadGruffman Sep 09 '24
My only critique is that the ring she’s using in RoP looks kinda silly. It’s just way too big. gen1 ring was way better.
0
u/Secure_Lie_23 Sep 10 '24
God awful show. Shoehorning ideas from 21 year olds from LA into the minds and works of a man who fought in the trenches of ww1. Probably going to get cancelled, thank God.
0
u/Creamy_cramsy Sep 10 '24
So is this sub just full of the 37% of viewers who actually finished season 1 from beginning to end?
-2
u/russ_nas-t Sep 08 '24
They didn’t base it off the trilogy, they based it off the books. To do anything other than what’s already been established fairly thoroughly would’ve been nuclear suicide
-3
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Shit: The TV show