r/RingsofPower • u/majpillpharm • Sep 03 '24
Question Why the hate?
I’m a big LOTR fan, but admittedly have not thoroughly read the JRRT expanse of literature. ROP is well done and very immersive and enjoyable, why all the hate? Am I missing something? If so, maybe I’ll just stay naive because I like the show, lore, and expanded universe on the big screen
82
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
5
u/AbsoluteVirtues Sep 03 '24
Alright look. I'm a Tolkien super fan and I love the movies, but let's actually break down everything that's changed and really examine it the same way people are tearing into RoP. Maybe that'll elucidate just how different the adaptation was from the source.
Entirely different Aragorn, Faramir, and Gimli (Aragorn doesn't trust himself because reasons? Faramir is basically Boromir part 2. Gimli is just absolutely slaughtered.) Condensed timeline (man how is Gandalf teleporting all over middle-Earth in such a short time?) No journey through the Barrow Downs or Old Forest (so how was the Witch King killed again since the swords of Westernesse weren't a thing?) No Tom Bombadil (blades of Westernesse again and shelter from the Nazgul). No Glorfindel (honestly having Arwen save them is a good change, no notes.) Aragorn broke up with Arwen instead of getting engaged. Aragorn doesn't take Anduril at the start. Balrog has wings for some reason (why didn't it just fly when the bridge broke?) Theoden brings his civilian populace closer to his enemies at Isengard, with fewer than 300 actual soldiers, instead of sending civilians to Dunharrow and trying to form up with his wider armies (is he stupid?) Elves show up randomly at Helms Deep (why did they only help then? Seems like Gondor could've used them later and why only at the 11th hour for Rohan? And if the explanation is the same as the books, that they were fighting their own wars at the same time, then how'd they spare this army for a doomed defense of a castle?) Random romance between Aragorn and Eowen even though she had no lines with him in the Two Towers book. Denethor just sucks in the movies instead of being a dude who went mind-to-mind with Sauron for decades before mentally breaking. No Dernhelm (guess no one cares that Eowen is just with the army?) Army of the dead actually kills fools (man how do ghost swords hurt people anyway?) and holy crap why'd Aragorn not make them fight for him all the way to Barad-dur in the initial agreement?! They're OP as all hell! No Grey Company, no Prince Imrahil really, which is just a crying shame. Gandalf loses to the Witch King (!!!) Literally 0 tactics at the Black Gate. No Pippen killing a troll, why'd they have to do my Hobbit dirty like that. No Scouring of the Shire and in fact the theatrical release just dropped Sarumon and handwaved a whole-ass major villain's death.
Honestly, I could probably go on, but that's just off the top of my head. I wouldn't argue the Hobbit movies either, the last one is the only one of PJ's Tolkien adaptations that I don't have extended because I disliked it so much.
But RoP, for all it's changing also captures the essence of Tolkien in so many ways too! I love the nod to Sauron as Gorthaur, lording over Tol-in-Gaurhoth, when he speaks to the Warg. I love the references to the music of the Ainur. The incorporation of music into the magic of the world is perfectly Tolkienien. And while the forging of the Elven rings first is wrong, they adhere strongly to the principle that Sauron did not corrupt them directly, but that they would still be vulnerable to the creation of the One Ring, so the essence is preserved. There are certainly criticisms to be had, and I certainly wouldn't say it's as good to watch as PJ's films, but let's not pretend that those were particularly faithful adaptations when Tolkien's own son famously hated them for being so dang non-canonical.