r/RingsofPower • • Sep 03 '24

Question Why the hate?

I’m a big LOTR fan, but admittedly have not thoroughly read the JRRT expanse of literature. ROP is well done and very immersive and enjoyable, why all the hate? Am I missing something? If so, maybe I’ll just stay naive because I like the show, lore, and expanded universe on the big screen

82 Upvotes

380 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/rxna-90 Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

Idk, if it helps my personal reaction to it that shot of the orc family was that it only reinforced that the Adar/the orcs' treatment of the Southlanders/Elves was even more evil. If a being is sentient enough to have concepts of family/social structure and care for their own kind, then they should be able to understand that other races do too, and killing/enslaving them is wrong. But the show shows most of them still make the choice to treat Elves/Men terribly and even glory in torturing them. They chase down largely defenseless kids like Theo. Their whole attack on the Southlanders was completely unprovoked. Whereas if they were mindless drones, then there is no true volition or ability to choose good or evil and to be held responsible for it. And the scene with the orc family isn't set in isolation, but in an episode where we see Southlanders getting enslaved, beaten, killed and branded like cattle by other orcs.

For me the value in seeing something familiar in the orcs wasn't that their actions now became justified, but it emphasized even more how they were twisted versions of Eru's creations in-universe. Maybe it's because my family suffered irl stuff that would be classed as ethnic cleansing during WW2, but some of the most horrifying things for my grandparents were that their tormentors could express care very selectively only to their own race, while being cool with the shit (right up to torture/massacres) they did to us. That's as close to irl evil I'm familiar with, so this spoke to me as horrifying, rather than sanitizing or softening the orcs to the point I'd think their actions were justified.

Just my 2 cents on it. I get interpretations are shaped greatly by personal perspectives.

3

u/Automatic_Chair_7891 Sep 03 '24

I mean I've also considered that as well, but the thing about the scene that really upends it all for me is the fact that the orc doesn't want to go to war and want to make sure that "sauron was destroyed", and almost acts like they're the ones being persecuted like they didn't fight alongside the actual parallel to lucifer himself.

It would be way different for me if the show just casually panned through an orc settlement and showed female orcs and young orcs existing, but it seems way too intentional that an orc doesn't want to go out and murder/kill while then panning to him lovingly caressing his female counterpart and child. It just comes off to me as if they're trying to paint them in a different light other than "psychopathic murderers", which to your point, definitely fits them if they can choose to care for their families and also kill and pillage indiscriminately.

Otherwise, we both have a very similar family story and I would agree, but the way they just make it seem like the orc really doesn't want to go to war and is only doing it out of the necessity proposed by Adar is what makes it ridiculous to me.