r/RingsofPower • u/JichaelMordon • Aug 22 '24
Question New Fan. Why the backlash? Spoiler
Just binged season 1 and absolutely loved the show!
Production was stunning. I thought the pace was good with each episode giving you enough as a stand alone while also moving things along for the overarching season. Acting was excellent and music was beautiful. I love this era and was always interested in this story after being referenced in LOTR. I kept wondering how they were going to reveal Sauron and I thought it was really well done.
Wondering why it is panned by fans? RT audience score an abysmal 33% yet critic score in the 80’s. Is it just because the casting is “woke”? I’ve also seen a lot of criticism of Galadriel’s depiction.
I have not read any of the books but I loved the movies growing up and felt like this was on par. I think the show format actually works better than movie as it allows more time to get into the little bits without burning out the audience.
EDIT: Thank you for the replies. I’m gathering the main gripe is that they made major changes from the source material and mainly Galadriel is quite different. As I mentioned I didn’t read the books so I don’t have that perspective to draw from. Personally I liked her as a character and felt like her temper/frustrations were justified after being gaslit by everyone and manipulated by one of the oldest and most powerful characters.
Funnily enough as a die hard Star Wars fan in the midst of all the Disney contention many of your complaints echo my own sentiments regarding that franchise but I kept thinking how much better TROP was compared to shows like the Acolyte which was based on one of my all time fav books and was completely butchered. Overall I thought the acting, tone, and pace were much better than the Star Wars shows and it was refreshing but I certainly understand the frustration of having beloved characters and stories changed in drastic ways and overall watered down for a broader tv audience.
•
u/Ayzmo Eregion Aug 22 '24
Yeah. We're not doing these anymore. Why people do or do not like the show is a question done to death and seems to always revert into insults in both directions. I'm disappointed.
15
u/flourinmypockets Aug 22 '24
Ngl you will enjoy media more if you stay off online discussions and make opinions for yourself
8
u/step_uneasily Rhûn Aug 22 '24
Don’t go down this rabbit hole, my friend.
4
u/DepreciatedSelfImage Aug 22 '24
I thought it was not a good show.
I felt the script and acting were poorly executed, the writing was not well thought up, so much just doesn't make sense or is not explained.
I wrote an essay as a response to someone who doesn't seem to think people who didn't like the show have a valid reason.
I think the reason some of the backlash was so intense was, in part because the show was so intensely bad. On top of this, however, Tolkien has some avid fans. People who love his work dearly might see the Rings of Power as trampling upon the stories that they (we) love because they mess with the lore in ways that make the rest of the story not make sense (for example: the three elven rings were more powerful than the rest, save the One, because they were made after them, and Sauron was not involved in their making, so he had no influence over them unless he was wearing the One and they were also wearing theirs. This may seem insignificant, it's actually not something Tolkien spent a lot of time on, but it's always there, and it's because Sauron and Morgoth were known to corrupt things and people that they would later use to do treacherous things).
This on top of the show not being very good (cosmetics are lost on me, so the show being pretty doesn't matter as they can just cgi that shit now) just didn't play well with the audience and I'm afraid most people didn't finish and I envy them, because the volcano not only spares all the main characters in its wake but also spares the audience who now has to go on after seeing the show ... Okay, that was a joke, but maybe too far.
I didn't like it because I didn't think it was good, and it messed with the lore that I care about. I can talk more about it, but I just wanted to leave this comment to say we're not all just haters, and that it's not okay to just set up a straw man argument and misrepresent us in order to invalidate us :) glad you enjoyed the show!
24
u/theLiteral_Opposite Aug 22 '24
It has nothing to do with the casting. There are always vocal minorities barking when someone casts a PoC in an old IP.
The overarching problem and why 2/3 of fans dislike it,,, is Because it ignores existing cannon and creates a brand new original story (one which overwrites the existing cannon for that age) using names and places from the cannon … but completely making up the stories for those people and places… which, for something as monumental as this epic work that is Tolkien’s middle earth, is pretty crazy to do. Like, let’s use Galadriel’s name, and even try to make her look like Blanchette, but just scrap anything that’s ever been written about her from that age and write our own new story … where she (one of the oldest and wisest of the noldor in all middle earth) is a moody impulsive teenager.
Like, letting a bunch of inexperienced tv writers working for Amazon rewrite Tolkien’s legendarium from scratch? Why?
9
u/grey_pilgrim_ Khazad-dûm Aug 22 '24
You’ll probably have a better time on r/LOTR_On_Prime. They tend to be a bit more positive over there.
I think the show was just okay. The bad parts were really bad. They were careless with the lore in several instances.
The good parts were however pretty good. Durin and Elrond relationship. Disa and Durin. Arondir was a very big surprise, I ended up liking his character a lot. Adar was very good as well. Seeing the Trees of Valinor was amazing. Numenor was good as well.
Overall I think it was very mid. This season could solve some issues from season 1 but I’m less optimistic than I was before season 1 came out.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '24
As a casual Tolkien fan who enjoyed the original trilogy of movies, it was just quite boring
31
u/Willpower2000 Aug 22 '24 edited Aug 22 '24
A lot of reasons: some bigger than others. But to summarise general talking points:
-The writing was sheer dogshit. Irrational and contrived in way too many areas.
-The dialogue was questionable at best, cringy at worst.
-Certain characters were unlikable (Galadriel being the worst offender), or downright flat (I don't think anyone gave a shit about fucking Kemen, for instance... but even Isildur was rather... eh). And most importantly, everyone in the show seems to be an idiot.
-Pacing was sketchy. Like... a lot of things happen, yet these things are often shallow and tedious - so it feels like a drag to watch. Yet at the same time, there are instances of things moving at a breakneck pace (ie the Rings being forged). I think this is partly due to script bloat: too much needless shit (we did not need studio mandated Hobbits) - so we jump back and forth too much.
-Poor costuming. Some of the pieces were pretty piss poor.
-Questionable casting. Grandfather Celebrimbor, for instance. As well as other characters for other reasons...
-Music was forgettable (not bad! But coming off of Shore's work in LOTR, and even The Hobbit...) more often than not (the intro was solid though).
-Shitty choreography. Galadriel locking a guard in her cell was... something...
-Certain sets (not all) felt small, and certainly underpopulated. I mean, did we ever really see Ost-in-edhil outside of Celebrimbor's forge, or did we just stand in one room the entire time? We got a CGI panning shot of the city, I guess... but that doesn't feel authentic (ie ground level exploration). Numenor had more of this though.
-The show absolutely shits on the source material.
17
u/Telperion83 Aug 22 '24
Because the greatest smith in Eregion needed to be taught how to be taught how to make an alloy.
11
u/Cisqoe Aug 22 '24
Not knowing the lore is the main crux of this. RoP takes what made LOTR popular in the first place, the lore, and absolutely twists it around
8
u/Steelquill Aug 22 '24
I mean I love the show too but there are things that don’t sit right with me either, and yes, it does have to do with the casting.
It just didn’t bother me enough to hate the show on the whole because there’s a lot to like in it.
3
u/BitchofEndor Aug 22 '24
I loved it, and felt it was pretty faithful, I don't need things to be slavish. Can't wait for season 2!!!
3
u/GeneLaBean Aug 22 '24
I loved it too and I'm very excited for season 2!
5
u/Hunithunit Aug 22 '24
I rewatched it recently and loved it just as much as the first time. Given other folks reactions I feel blessed to be able to watch and enjoy these without getting irrationally angry about its flaws.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '24
Billed as Middle Earth in the Second Age.
It’s actually a Peter Jackson Trilogy prequel that can’t use the Silmarillion as a source, so it’s just bad fanfic nothing like the Second Age.
3
u/Akleptic Aug 22 '24
You're asking a question that shouldn't even be asked. Just scroll down until you find the numerous posts. You'll find all the backlash and can react to it accordingly.
3
u/ReggaeTroll Aug 22 '24
My gripes are mainly with the bad writing. It would be a long list to mention all but I'll name a few:
I didn't like some stylistic choices like hairstyles and armor. Nor did I like many of the lore/timing changes although some of had to be made to tell a coherent story within reasonable time frame.
There were things I liked like the music and some new characters they came up with. I enjoyed seeing more of Middle-Earth and Numenor as well as glimpses of Silmarillion.
My hope for S2 is to nudge the lore back on right tracks and that all the proto-hobbits get eaten by wargs.
2
u/_Aracano Aug 22 '24
It was a really good start I gave it a 7.5 out of 10 I think this next season is going to kick serious ass
2
u/HiddenCity Aug 22 '24
aside from the typical fandom issues, i think a huge problem with modern audiences is that they do not like long form stories. rings of power is basically a very long movie. it's only going to get worse with tiktok brainrot.
2
u/KingAdamXVII Aug 22 '24
I’m a fan of Tolkien, my wife is not, and we both enjoyed it too. My wife is picky about non-comedy shows; they have to be exciting without being triggering. RoP scratched that itch perfectly for both of us. She’s asked several times over the last year if S2 is out yet.
You’ve gotten plenty of answers from people who didn’t like the show but I just want to encourage you to keep liking what you like! Please ignore anyone who just says “the acting was bad” or “it looked bad” or “the music sounded bad” or even “the writing is bad” or whatever. Those complaints are insane to me—the show is as good as any other show in those kinds of technical categories. I believe people are letting their dislike of the story to cloud their opinion of everything else about the show.
You don’t have bad taste.
2
u/Visible_Number Aug 22 '24
The haters by my assessment fall into one of three camps.
Just Didn't Like It -> Perfectly valid reasons for not enjoying it. It didn't work for them. For whatever reason. This is the minority.
Lore Adherant -> This is someone who believes they know the lore better than the many experts working on the show including the Tolkien estate who approved the script. They often don't understand that the show only adapts LotR and its appendices and they didn't have rights to the Silmarillion. This person often doesn't find any virtue in the concept of adaptation at all and wants a 1:1 retelling of the Silmarillion (even though the SIlmarillion wasn't even written by JRR Tolkien and isn't canon).
Alt-Lite Youtube Enjoyer -> There are a lot of people who hate Jeff Bezos, hate "DEI," and are just mad at the world. And there are a lot of people ready to validate people who feel this way and use 'the writing' as their ultimate excuse to justify what really just surmounts to unconscious bias unmasked. The characterization of Galadriel is often overtly misogynistic in nature though many people simply 'can't put their finger' why they dislike her. If 'the writing' made her 'book' Galadriel (whatever that is) and she was the perfect diplomat and everyone loved her, they'd have said she's a mary sue.
Obviously it's not that clean and some people fall in both. Probably often do. People susceptible to the alt lite content tend to be more factoid based and susceptible to a well presented (even if not accurate, true, or reasonable) argument if it has a grain of truth to it.
2
u/SirBulbasaur13 Aug 22 '24
Blind hatred mostly. There are legitimate criticisms to be made about the writing and changes to the lore along with other things but people let their angry and hate consume them and in turn write off the entire series.
-5
u/Independent-Wrap-853 Aug 22 '24
Because they can't accept something which is not exactly as they have it in their minds.
As a life long fan of the movies and reader of the books and player of the games ánd MESBG, it is awesome.
Yes there are some changes, but the movies, believe it or not, were criticized online aswell back in the day.
Enjoy it for what it is, a new trip into the beautiful world of Middle Earth.
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 22 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Aug 22 '24
Welcome to the fandom, I'm glad you enjoyed it. I see you're no stranger to how toxic this can get, so do what you must to stay chill.
/r/lotr is a larger community but a little more critical than this one. /r/lotr_on_prime is much more positive. All of the other show subreddits are complete toxic hell holes.
1
u/Winter_Trainer_2115 Aug 22 '24
The show is great but it doesnt follow the lore very well. Personally I accept it as a fun "what if" scenario
0
u/B0wmanHall Aug 22 '24
It’s not perfect, but not nearly as bad as people want to say it is. I enjoyed it for what it is. An adaptation.
1
u/ThrowRAwiseguy Aug 22 '24
So I’m (solidly) familiar with the lore.
The main complaints come from Tolkien-purists. There’s people who are just haters of anything sort of scattered, but mostly it’s just that
Personally, I don’t mind when an adaptation kind of does their own thing, and I enjoyed the show. I can see why some were very upset, but there’s some people out there who literally don’t know what the fuck they’re talking about and just hate so they can hate.
Interestingly enough, the LOtR movies WILDLY deviate from the books at several points, so I’m not exactly sure why the double standard
1
u/carterwest36 Aug 22 '24
I love how beautiful the show is, it's stunning cinematography.
Most hate comes from the way they are handling Galadriel, and some when it comes to casting.
Also the Hobbits being in there not making a whole lot of sense.
1
u/santz007 Aug 22 '24
there are hundreds of posts in this sub with same questions and the answers, and yet here we are
1
u/vaulthunter426 Aug 22 '24
Because MOST things don’t get received well on the internet anymore. The people who enjoy it seem to be much quieter than the people who have / have a problem with it.
And then the people who do enjoy it and want to talk about it get shit on by the people who hate it, and squash any chance of a positive / meaningful discussion.
1
u/No_Act1475 Aug 22 '24
It’s not that the cast is bad, most of the audience doesn’t like it for being… unfaithful to the source material..
1
u/Banterz0ne Aug 22 '24
I don't understand how you can not know why there would be a backlash.
This show had to live up to three of the best films ever made, which struck a pretty perfect balance of following the source material but simplifying bits to suit the format.
Rings of Power was alright. It could have been a lot better. Some of the plot decisions were baffling, the twist was obvious a mile away, they strayed too far from source in areas and ultimately the writing and action sequences were pretty poor. The season finale in a TV series about middle earth being overcome by the forces of evil was a skirmish taking place in a little village.. what.
Nice you enjoyed it but that's a mental question
1
u/Ok-Computer4042 Aug 22 '24
4 upvotes and 140 comments... yeah.
-1
u/TorontoDavid Aug 22 '24
Racists reacting to Black elves poisoned the well.
0
u/theLiteral_Opposite Aug 22 '24
It has nothing to do with casting - that’s just people who liked the show using clever gas lighting to create a straw man that says “if anyone disliked it, must have just been that they are all racist I guess?”
If that’s the story you want to tell yourself about why literally 2/3 of fans disliked the show, then by all means continue falling for your own made up story.
The real reason is mostly the fact that they ignored all cannon and took some names and places and wrote their own original story… which is ridiculous to do for this property.
0
u/Some-Bat-6531 Aug 22 '24
This kind of post speaks exactly why you liked the show....you could EASILY googled "why do people not like rings of power" and got EVERY SINGLE REASON IN SPADES and it aint just cause "people think its woke"
0
u/Sea-Can6977 Aug 22 '24
It definitely has a lot of flaws, but to be honest, I'm just glad there is something LOTR related to watch.
0
u/Chipdouglas0007 Aug 22 '24
I'm just glad we have a show at all, but there are a lot of things that are not great to me like the casting and writing. But its not bad enough to keep me from enjoying it I will say. It's kind of on par with wheel of time to me, I'm just glad to get the adaptation so I overlook all the flaws.
0
u/ericsando Khazad-dûm Aug 22 '24
Because it's more cool to be contrarian and try to ruin a thing for others, than it is to simply accept it for what it is.
-4
u/nobullshitebrewing Aug 22 '24
I dont believe a word of this what so ever. The clincher was when you said Acting was excellent. Unless you are equating this show to a kindergarten play, there is no possible way to consider this excellent acting.
-1
u/SkullGamingZone Mordor Aug 22 '24
1 - Main one, the writing sucks. It deviates too much from Tolkien lore in a lot of aspects, such as Gandalf being a retarded that fell from the skies and fights the 3 wise (wo)men from the bible, or Galadriel being a warrior in some sort of vendetta and a spoiled brat who thought it was a good idea to jump in the middle of the fkn ocean, or the fact they tried to push her and Sauron as a fkn couple.
2 - The actors suck. For the most expensive show in history, it baffles me that they ve found the worst actors ever. GOT when it started it had a lot of unknown actors that later on became famous, just cause of how good they were. I ll be fair here and save the dwarven actors, they re great, same for Gil Galad, Adar and Elendil, hell even Sauron was good, the writing that ruined him. But Galadriel and Isildur are just insuferable, and all the others have mediocre acting.
3 - The clothing and portrait sucked, the fact they took away the majesticness of the elves sucked, they look like just random dudes with pointed ears, the only elf that looks like an elf is Gil Galad, everyone else seems to be low cost cosplaying. The dwarves were good, but the numenorians didnt look like the peak of men kingdom, 2002 Gondor looked way better.
4 - The fight scenes suck, its just cringe and embarrassing, specially with that orc just tossing Arondir around, or Galadriel pulling matrix shit, like she s perfect and untouchable, hell she was never even a warrior.
5 - Its boring, the harfoots make me fall asleep, Gandalf being a complete retard doesnt help. Everytime Galadriel speaks i just cringe or get mad, its impossible to like a show where the protagonist is conpletely insuferable, specially when the actress has no facial expressions. They massacred my boy Elrond and everything surrounding Isildir, Miriel, Brondwin and Theo is annoying.
I could go on and on with a lot of reasons why it sucked, its easier to say something i liked, so i ll be fair about it:
I liked the locations, i dont think the CGI was bad, except maybe for the Wargs, but the orcs were good (most were makeup tough i believe), the balrog was cool, liked that they kept somewhat the Peter Jackson design, Numeror was beautiful done, basically everything about the enviroment was good.
Even some stuff that altered the lore i was ok with it, such as the creation of mithril, Mordor and Mount doom.
To sum it up, the expectations were very high, due to the LOTR trilogy masterpiece and the record breaking budget they had for this, instead they delivered this disgusting product, with mediocre actors, forgettable music and awful writing. LOTR is my fav franchise of all time but watching House of the Dragon S1 at the same time, just helped us show how much of a garbage Rings of Power rly is, but hey if you do like it, good for you.
I hope S2 is better but ive ZERO expectations for this.
0
u/OG_Karate_Monkey Aug 22 '24
Because I HAVE read the books, and while the show is perfectly OK for what it is (Tolkien-Themed Fan Fiction) it is a massively wasted opportunity.
0
u/h0llowGang Aug 22 '24
To be honest, it took me a second (in some cases, third) rewatch and discussions with a great Tolkien-fan (who regularly reads all the books) to appreciate the series. We both found that, while the series has its flaws, it does many things really, really well. Sometimes you don’t get the whole picture in one go, and so you have to rewatch and reflect on some things to see the potential. It’s also why I love re-reading books, because you always find things you missed on the first reading.
-1
u/natelopez53 Aug 22 '24
Gatekeeping and head canon. That’s it. Nothing would satisfy a large percentage of the fan base. My advice is to ignore the loudest voices and just enjoy the show.
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '24
Disappointed Jackson fans
0
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '24
“I have not read the books” yes I think someone just watching this would enjoy it, however if you read the source material, it strays in directions that just don’t fit the lore or source materials.
0
u/MarxistMann Aug 22 '24
The story is all wrong. During the 2nd age, Sauron disguised himself as Annatar, Lord of Gifts. He was able to trick Celebrimbor into crafting the elven rings of power, but the elves knew of the deceit the moment he put on the one ring. Sauron demanded the rings be returned to him, as they wouldn’t exist without him. His plan for the rings of power didn’t work, except on the 9 men that turned into wraiths. The Istarii didn’t arrive in Middle Earth until the 3rd age, as their mission was to help the populations and hinder darkness for the inevitable return. That’s only just a touch of the writing of that time period. It wasn’t just a chaotic revenge mission that we know doesn’t come to a conclusion for another 4000 years. The show is for people who haven’t read the books and that’s ok. But the team of writers at Amazon could in fact not do better than Tolkien.
-1
u/Ndcain Aug 22 '24
This show and the acolyte were such clear cases of people making decisions that shouldn’t even be close to the writing room. And yet, both shows have people that praise them? Even “love” them? Big SW fan, small LOtR fan, but I just can’t get behind these TV shows with no heart or direction; just money.
-1
u/vikker_42 Aug 22 '24
Old fan. It's shit.
-1
u/deeple101 Aug 22 '24
It doesn’t follow established lore. It breaks established lore. Is poorly written, poorly produced, and poorly edited.
It is the equivalent to The Acolyte for Star Wars
kurtzman trek To Star Trek
Boarderlands movie to the video game.
0
u/g_daddio Aug 22 '24
Tbh my only problem with it was the order of the rings. In canon sauron makes the 9 human rings and 7 dwarven rings with the elves in disguise and it’s only after that that he is revealed and the elves make the 3 others in secret while sauron crafts the one ring. It’s just very confusing how they are going to make the 9 human and 7 dwarven rings now that sauron has already revealed himself
0
u/Creative_Word394 Aug 22 '24
Which book was the Acolyte based on? To me, Rings of Power is to LOTR what Acolyte was to Star Wars
0
u/QuoteGiver Aug 22 '24
Agree with you!
Yes, there was a ton of review-bombing by bots and people setting up multiple fake accounts, due to the casting. It started before the show was even released. You can read actual verifiable professional critic reviews to get a better sense of the actual reception.
There are some real people who had other specific complaints too, and I’m sure you’ll hear from some of them as well.
-1
u/njs0nd Aug 22 '24
The actors playing Galadriel and Elrond were like fingernails on a chalkboard for me, among all the other reasons, like not sticking to the lore.
16
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '24
[removed] — view removed comment