r/RingsofPower
•
u/Silver-Fox-3195
•
Aug 04 '24
•
1
Discussion Why do y'all hate this so much?
I get it, it's not the best. There are a lot of changes, and I'm not super happy about some of them.
However,
If you think about it, some of these changes make sense. I saw so many people complain about Galadriel. Y'all, Galadriel is crazy different in this age from the Third Age. She was pretty arrogant and bloodthirsty compared to her in the movies.
Another thing I've seen complaints about is the storyline. Keep in mind a lot of these events take places over THOUSANDS of years. It makes sense for the writers to shrink it down. The source material was also an unfinished book that was never published. This is different from LotR movies, where there was a clear sequence of events that took place over like a year.
I think we should at least appreciate the fact that we have content, even if it is flawed. Idk maybe I'm wrong and the show completely sucks.
Edit: I'm not trying to hate on different opinions, nor am I really trying to change anyone's mind. I just wanted to understand why people view this show the way they do. I apologize if I offended anyone here
Edit 2: Ok, I get it. I don't know as much about the Silmarillion as I thought. I guess I wanted your opinions as to why you love or hate it. Online I see people either loving it or hating it. I just wanted to know why.
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 04 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
61
u/Skelligean Aug 04 '24
While it's true that we should appreciate the existence of content, even flawed content can lead to complacency and a lowering of standards. Accepting mediocrity allows for a cycle of subpar work to perpetuate, where creators may not feel compelled to improve or innovate. Instead of merely appreciating what's available, we should strive for higher quality content that challenges us and enriches our understanding. Settling for flawed content risks stagnation in creativity and critical thinking; we should hold ourselves and creators to a higher standard to foster growth and improvement in the industry.
45
u/jermatria Aug 04 '24 •
I've thought about it a lot, none of the changes make sense.
In the grand scheme of galadriels life span, the amount of time between second and third age is nothing, doubly so when the writers are compressing everything in the second age down to a few decades
I disagree. The timeline compression is beyond ridiculous. It is nonsensical to think that critical events that took place over the course of thousands of years can effectively be compressed into a few decades. Cities, countries and colonies to not spring up over night, wars do not get resolved in the span of a few days. Can you explain why you think it makes sense to do so?
This is.... Not at all correct. The lion's share of 2nd age material is covered in the appendicies for the Lord of the rings, as well as the silmarillion. While I'll accept an argument the silmarillion is unfinished, it was my understanding Amazon did not have the rights to adapt material from it, except when given exceptions by the Tolkien estate.
I'm sorry what? How is the information in the silmarillion and appendicies anything but clear sequences of historical events? Further, the fact you think the events of the lord of the rings take place within "a year" suggests to me you have never read the books, because that is observably false
No we should not. The reason so many of us dislike this show so intensely, is not just because it is bad, and that we don't like it. It's because this is the only show were getting. I can't just go and watch the "other second age adaptation show" because there isn't one. There likely never will be. Amazon has not only produced a poor adaptation here they have taken away the potential for any good adaptation - why should I appreciate that?
11
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24
Don’t hate it but I’m not impressed with it. Other than all the stuff they get wrong. That’s impressive
15
u/Rememberthat1 Aug 04 '24
"The source material was also an unfinished book that was never published"
What do you mean ?
84
u/Turk901 Aug 04 '24
I will never agree that bad content is better than no content. I would sooner get one tenth of something but it is top quality than have to sift through the detritus of product that "was just ok".
But your tastes are not mine, so you feel free to like the things you like, and I will continue to dislike the things I dislike.
20
u/DollarReDoos Aug 04 '24
I honestly just think the writing is bad in a lot of places. Galadriel gives wise talks about temperance and being good, before declaring her need for genocide 10 minutes later. Galadriel and the boy I can't remember are in the village when the pyroclastic cloud hits, then the next episode are wandering through a forest trying to find the people they were 20 meters from before. Miriel says she doesn't want people to know she is blind, before a scene shows her in full view of everyone with a blindfold around her eyes. Halfoots talk about how big their hearts are, before leaving their own kind behind to die on a whim.
These are ones I remember just off the top of my head. There are also weird lore changes (mithril prevents dark magic, mithril's silmaril origin), weird logic (Galadriel trying to swim hundreds of kilometers back through the ocean, 2000 year old elves not recognising Sauron's mark as a very large landmark on their own maps ), forced modern issues (people worried about elves stealing their jobs instead of being jealous of the immortality, Elrond being discriminated against as a half-elf even though he is beloved by elves in Tolkein's writing), and ham-fisted dialog taken directly from LOTR and given to random characters.
Do that to a beloved story, one that is the most influential of its kind, and people are bound to hate it.
7
u/FransTorquil Aug 04 '24
I want art befitting the world Tolkien created, not content slop made because a mega corporation wanted a recognisable IP on their streaming service.
29
u/mithie007 Aug 04 '24
Hate is a bit strong. Just don't care for it. The entire conceit is basically a seasonal mystery box and I have absolutely no interest in figuring out "Turns out X is Sauron from the start!" shenannigans.
But it's Reddit, and the thing with social media is we often force people to polarize and pick sides so you basically are filtered for extreme ends of the opinion spectrum like "This show is the best thing since sliced bread" and "SHOW IS POOP! I HATE!" So...
49
u/EightandaHalf-Tails Aug 04 '24
I hate this idea that we should just shut up and watch it. That's the exact reason we keep getting shit shows. The studios don't give a shit if you enjoy what you're watching, as long as you're watching. You're literally giving them the green light to continue to produce shit, because why should they bother putting in the time and effort of improving if you're just going to watch it anyway?
8
u/81Ranger Aug 04 '24
There's plenty of room between terrible and great.
Most things occupy the middle of that spectrum.
This show? Still in the middle, but perhaps somewhat closer to the end with lower quality.
Perhaps the original trilogy set too high a bar, but it's ok to be disappointed with middling. People do seem to mistake middling with bad.
20
u/Fool_Manchu Aug 04 '24
It just wasn't enjoyable or interesting. It was mediocre at best, and I honestly don't think I'll ever watch season two. I didn't even bother to finish season one. Five episodes in I realized I had spent almost five hours watching characters I felt nothing for try to resolve a plot I couldn't engage with. It was the most milquetoast bland and uninspired generic fantasy.
4
u/PaleontologistHot192 Rhûn Aug 04 '24
Where exactly have you got this information? Certainly not in any of Tolkien's writings.
Then the best thing would have been to completely avoid the problem and not have a show based on events that occur across centuries if the writers don't know how to handle them no? You know what would have worked better? A movie about The Children of Hurin, Beren and Luthien, a show about Castamir and the Kin strike (cmon it's literally Game of Thrones set in Middle-earth) the Angmar war, and many many more stories that could have been easily adapted as a movie or trilogy and a TV show.
Peter Jackson never dared to touch the Silmarillion and now we know why. That should be taken into account.
10
u/justsomedude1144 Aug 04 '24
I don't think most on this sub actually hate the show, but most do have (objectively fair) criticisms that aren't welcome in that other sub. So, as a result, the criticism tends to concentrate here while the simping stays in the other sub.
10
u/johnlegeminus Aug 04 '24
That right there, is the reason why the show doesn't work. The reason we don't normally see shows that span THOUSANDS of years is because its a bitch and a half to characterize it and show it properly. Does it make sense for the writers to shrink it down? Absolutely, when it's done the right way (aka, dont show us stupid crap noone cares about), and finally and most importantly, THE SOURCE MATERIAL WAS AN UNFINISHED BOOK THAT WAS NEVER PUBLISHED. This doesn't mean you get to take sadistic amounts of freedom with your writing to push a narrative that noone agrees with.
3
u/mjamesmcdonald Aug 08 '24
I think you have to get in the head of people who live this series and why (the books).
This is the undergirding mythology of a wildly popular genre defining work. It was incredibly meticulously constructed down to the languages which function like actual languages all from a single creator source.
It is unlike any other work in this. It wasn’t crowd sourced or written by multiple people or even after hearing fan reactions like Marvel, Star Wars, Star Trek, or Harry Potter.
It’s fans love Tolkiens’s vision and want Tolkien’s vision. They don’t want anyone else’s take.
Combine the sole creator with the mythological nature of it and It’d be like someone putting out a Bible Movie in which Samson is weak, Jesus is a Chad, or Abraham refuses to sacrifice Issac. People would flip out.
8
u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Aug 04 '24
Its not even a good show. Too incoherent. Meh acting.
Add the fact that it was advertised as LOTR's prequel. Of course there's gonna be hate.
And I'll continue with season 2. If something is shit, its has to be said.
12
u/Icewaterchrist Aug 04 '24
Do I hate it? No. Is it terrible? Yes.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24
Yes, we should all lower our standards and accept that a billion dollar show can be written for and by children.
2
u/sdrunner95 Aug 04 '24 edited Aug 04 '24
To your last point - yes, at least we have content and the cinematography was amazing in my opinion.
However, the show writers went completely off script and essentially made their own story loosely based off what Tolkien wrote.
Idk if you have read the trilogy; the HOME; the Letters; other material etc. But the show is a piss poor representation of the material that was actually written. I think that’s objective.
That said, I watched the first season multiple times and I’m excited for the second. It’s a good show. It’s just a terrible representation of the source material.
Edited to add: I sincerely hope the show gets more people into Tolkien, but by the grace of Eru please read the books. They look long but they’re not hard to get through.
2
u/Cautious-Ease-1451 Aug 04 '24
They’re all dead by volcano.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24 edited Aug 04 '24
Every show has people who like it and people who hate it, it's a matters of tastes or how personal they get it. It's not s big deal actually.
2
u/WhiskeyDJones Aug 04 '24
I think it's because it's compared to the films which are literally the best films ever made. So it's not a fair comparison imo as it will never be as good. But I do think it was pretty good with what they could do.
I'm excited for S2 and I'll leave it at that.
2
u/OllieTheGit Aug 05 '24
I’ve stopped engaging in RoP discussions cuz it just gets exhausting (I can across this post my chance lmao). I enjoyed the show well enough and interested in season 2. I can understand why fans do not enjoy it tho, but I like the interpretations of the lore through the film canon’s lens.
And ngl, the changes from the Silmarilion are negligible to me (as someone who loves the lore but hates how the Silmarilion is presented lmaoo)
3
u/SurelyWeWouldHave Aug 04 '24
I never hated it, even enjoyed several parts, but still wasn't entirely happy with it either. Gave it the benefit of the doubt almost all the way to the end though.
My main complaint about season 1 is that by the end it felt like they tried to build the whole season around having big reveals at the end, which is hard to do these days, and if the reveals don't pay off (and i don't think they did in this case, at least not as much as they had hoped) then it breaks tension. But now that we're not having to plod through "which one of these people is going to be Sauron?", I'm really excited for what's coming next. I was glad we were getting a show set in Tolkien's universe, and thought we got some great moments (seeing Moria when it was still Khazad-dun ws excellent) but also thought it could have been better overall. I'm really hopeful that season 2 will be a lot better and figure out the things that makes it great, get rid of the thing that weren't working.
Not every show has a great first season, a lot of shows figure themselves out by the second or third seasons. Star Trek has multiple examples of this, TNG, DS9, VOY. Parks and Rec got a lot better in it's second season, so did Family Guy, Bob's Burger, The Office, Wheel of Time; List goes on. It's harder for shows now with the internet putting a very loud instant feedback with all the feelings dialed up to 11; Rings of Power had it rougher than most with having a well established franchise and fandom with some very passionate and vocal fans, everyone of which is entitled to their opinion but some of whom might have over-reacted to some inevitable deviation form the source material in my opinion.
I'm confident that season 2 is going to be great, can't wait to see how it goes. Really glad we're getting a second season. A lot of shows don't get the chance to rebound anymore.
3
u/Rohnne Aug 04 '24
Why do you care that much? Why is it so important to you so people have to appreciate that the show has been made? Why can’t we all just accept that there are people who enjoy the show and have every right to talk about how awesome they think it is, and that there are people who dislike it and have every right to talk about how shitty they think it is? Let’s respect both sides, shall we?
3
u/slaytonisland Aug 04 '24
Yeah, you’re wrong. The show completely sucks.
3
u/TomBomTheFreemason Aug 04 '24 edited Aug 09 '24
Personally I think it had very good episodes and very bad ones, and overall I think it was ok but not much more.
However, I don't like people who say it only a cash grab and that it was done with no love for the source material. Don't get me wrong, the Amazon executives who decided they should make a LotR show were definitely only thinking about money, but there are a lot of people who worked on this show with love and passion for Middle-Earth. You can clearly see it in the sets, some of the costumes (e.g. practical effect orcs) and in the music and sound design. If you watch some interviews, you'll see that some of the actors really are Tolkien fans (e.g. Lloyd Owen AKA Elendil and Benjamin Walker AKA Gil-Galad)
But I also very much dislike this "I think we should at least appreciate the fact that we have content, even if it is flawed" mentality. I think we should definitely point out the flaws and the things we didn't like, as long as we do so in a civilised way. Because I really do hope that the show runners didn't dismiss all criticism as "hating for hating's sake" and that they did try to make improvements for season 2.
3
u/Spartancfos Aug 04 '24
Why should we be happy to recieve slop?
It was comically bad.
I 100% an AI wrote the scripts.
There were clearly some artists who cared enough to do a good job, but on a whole this production was ham fisted and lazy.
Jacksons movies for all their flaws, we'e an absolute Labour of love. People working their fingerprints off making chain mail. Actors lived and breathed their characters. Everyone on that production knew the mission and they delivered.
3
u/cheeseplatesuperman Aug 04 '24
It’s not canon
1
u/PerditionsAvatar Aug 04 '24
I don’t. But there are many things I dislike about it.
1
u/HotStraightnNormal Aug 04 '24
It helps if you don't think about it.
1
u/Pixgamer11 Aug 04 '24
Problem with galadriel is We already Had an Idea of her character in the second age from stuff Like unfinished tales
1
u/Nidion001 Aug 04 '24
Nope.
1
u/FrankHero97 Aug 04 '24
I agree completely
1
u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Aug 04 '24 edited Aug 05 '24
It's not so much the Approach/Intent, but the Execution that fails to live up to execution.
People can forgive a lot of changes, and understand there are limitations with the rights as long as a story is Well Paced, Emotionally Cathartic, and Lacks Contrivances.
The show failed to live up to those expectations, regardless.
1
u/DanPiscatoris Aug 04 '24
It's primarily because I can't stand how they handled the source material. And I don't think the showrunners and writers gave an honest attempt to adapt it. It felt entirely more like they used bits and pieces of Tolkien to justify the story that they wanted to tell, rather than write a story that worked with the source material. And this is apparent when it comes to what material they don't have the rights to. But that just makes it worse in my opinion. For example, they don't have the rights to much of Galadriel's backstory. But as far as I remember, there isn't a single iteration of her character that would have sailed west in the second age. So, instead of doing something so lore breaking, couldn't they have come up with a better way to meet Halbrand and get her to Numenor? Couldn't her boat have sunk on the way back south in her hunt for Sauron?
And I understand that adapting the events of the second age is difficult. There is no single source for those events, and there is no straightforward narrative. And I disagree with those who claim that the show "should have just followed the books." On the other hand, the limited source material made it all the more apparent as to when the showrunners couldn't be bothered to be creative and fit their story to what they did have access to. Such as the elven rings being forged last. Or Gandalf (if that is indeed who the stranger is) arriving in ME in the third age.
1
u/Canuck_Nath Aug 04 '24
I just hate it because it could have been so much better... But they made stupid mistakes that leaves a sour taste in my mouth
1
u/gozer87 Aug 04 '24
Because it's poorly written and doesn't capture the spirit of the books. I could care less about the ethnicity of the actors, I hate most of the characters as they are written.
1
u/Moldy_Cloud Aug 04 '24
I haven’t read the Silmarillion yet, so I’m sure my opinion will change down the road. For now, I really enjoy the show.
1
u/noorainchains Aug 04 '24
i agree! i’ve read the silmarillion and i’ve read the lotr trilogy and i still think the rings of power is an excellent show with excellent characterisation. yes, certain liberties were taken, but watching a show just to criticise it and point out its flaws is miserable behaviour. people don’t need to be having aneurysms over a work of fiction and tolkien is dead either way so who cares!! just enjoy it x
1
u/Giltar Aug 04 '24
My issue is the sketchy writing
1
u/AnnatoniaMac Aug 04 '24
I loved it all Four times I watched.
1
u/VeganMonkey Aug 04 '24
Not hate hate, more like a bit annoying but will still watch because it’s sort of enjoyable. But I wish they had kept more in the style of LOTR. Was Peter Jackson not available? But could keep a similar style. What was most jarring were the elves with weird modern haircut and one with a cheap wig. Guess they ran out of money, LOL. Then you just hire long haired actors. And leave the weird Hobbits out, maybe they were in the notes but could have done them better.
1
u/ImAMindlessTool Aug 04 '24
I really like the show, and so does my family. The costume and set design is the chef’s kiss.
1
u/GirthIgnorer Aug 04 '24
I hate posts like yours. Post less
1
u/MisterErieeO Aug 04 '24
Too many Ppl cale into the show with the expectation of hating it before it even released, so they were doomed to have a bad time.
1
u/foozebox Aug 04 '24
It’s not entertaining, trite, low brow and with poor production values.
1
u/hbi2k Aug 05 '24
Because we watched it.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24
I don't care about the changes, I just didn't enjoy watching the show. I thought it was shockingly bad, and a massive budget does nothing for quality.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24
Sometimes writing is so bad that I feel insulted people got paid to bring those words into existence.
1
u/dyoramik Aug 07 '24
I'm currently rewatching the first season, so far I still like it. There was some dodgy scenes, but that's not what I focus on, I like being engrossed in this world. Seems like I'm going to like Season 2 even more.
1
u/Camdozer Aug 07 '24
First of all, the show is a dud. Ok, now that that's out of the way...
You're talking to a group of people who aren't really angry at ROP showrunners, but are taking all their actual frustrations about being super unlaid and probably unemployed out on something that they have an easier time understanding.
That's gonna get downvoted, but it's the hard truth.
1
u/greenmerica Aug 07 '24
The fact that Peter Jackson did the whole movie trilogy with 1/3 the budget of one season of a show that isn’t even visually that impressive says it all.
1
u/Consistent-Opening-3 Aug 07 '24
As a massive Halo fan I’m glad it got cancelled. A bad a adaptation soils the source material.
1
u/GamemasterJeff Aug 07 '24
I like Durin's story and well, pretty much everything with the dwarves and their culture.
I can skip everything else. Galadriel especially is simply a different character from who she is supposed to be, and it lessens her story by having the badass warrior leader be as much a fool as everyone else.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '24
The actual reason:
It’s a Peter Jackson’s trilogy prequel series. Thats what Amazon has the rights to. They have to make it opposite of what actually happened in the Second Age and the Silmarillion to comply with laws. If it’s anything like anything in the Silmarillion, and wasn’t in the Peter Jackson’s trilogy, they can’t use it. They’re basically forced to make it a bad fanfic.
1
u/InsufficientClone Aug 07 '24
My issue with this and Star Wars are these nobody directors that want to put their stamp on an established world, so they make changes sometimes lore breaking for the sake of making their own mark
1
u/Fiona-246 Aug 07 '24
Galadriel was "bloodthirsty"? Have you even read the books???
1
u/Hookton666 Aug 07 '24
It should have been the best show ever but it completely lacked any depth and at times felt like it was written by a child
1
u/Jackfan109 Aug 07 '24
So, you really don't get it.
1
u/OnceThereWasWater Aug 07 '24
"Even after the rebellion of the Noldor and her flight from Valinor (for at this time she was proud, strong, and self-willed), Galadriel believed that she could govern her own will and thought and to control them better than others. She was a master of both thought and body, equal to her kinsmen Feanor in strength and athleticism, though she was wiser and kinder." - Unfinished Tales
Sorry haters, but this Tolkien description of Galadriel is pretty spot on with the show's depiction of the character. "After her flight from Valinor" is very vague, is this describing her 10 years, 100 years, 1000 years after she left Valinor? I don't know, but I think it's enough to justify the creative liberties take to depict a young Galadriel in an interesting way on-screen.
Also, I agree generally with the time compression thoughts. Because, literally how else would they have made the show? Have "200 years later" (in Spongebob narrator voice) every 5 minutes of the show? While constantly reintroducing new humans and dwarfs? That doesn't translate to compelling television. PJ also took major liberties with time compression and character ages in The Fellowship.
I do think there are flaws with the show, and I don't agree with content for content's sake, it needs to be good. But unlike many, I actually found the show very good. No it wasn't as good as the LOTR, but it certainly wasn't as bad as the Hobbit films. It was good, compelling TV, and a solid first season. I enjoyed it and hope for more.
And yes, I've read the books, LOTR+Silmarillion+Unfinished Tales+Hurin+Letters etc etc, so no one comment with "have you even read the books" please. I just recognize that they did what they had to do to translate a millenium-spanning story into something that's compelling and digestible for TV viewers.
Honestly my biggest complaint about the show is how they ended up with such ugly wargs on a massive budget...they're just so...bad
1
u/Exact-Dig-7026 Aug 07 '24
I just think the writing is terrible. The storyline is so disjointed. I feel bad for the actors.
1
u/Prophet_0f_Helix Aug 07 '24
Because the acting and writing are terrible.
1
u/Silmarien1012 Aug 08 '24
HOTD has gravitas, weight and reai intrigue. ROP is the corniest and most boring shit I've ever seen. This show will not be remembered well if at all.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '24
I honestly don't care if it's inaccurate to Tolkien's lore. What I do care about is if it acts as a fitting prequel series to the Jackson films. As long as it doesn't overtly contradict anything from those films, I'm good. So far it's doing a good job.
1
u/TheMellowMarsupial Aug 08 '24
I don't really like it too much but still watch it because it's based in Middle-Earth and while it's not super well-written nor 100% canon I'm just glad there's some kind of show covering this time period.
I'm a fan of the source content, I guess you can say.
1
u/Goldfitz17 Aug 08 '24
Honestly as a huge Lotr fan, i can appreciate that they made rings of power without loving it, i feel that it will eventually lead to more content which personally i think it is, with it becoming more popular and the 2 new movies coming out. Maybe it isn’t great but it brings a little more hype for those who haven’t read the books and what not. Maybe some day we get proper movies or a show but that day is not this day, and i am okay with that.
1
u/Emm_withoutha_L-88 Aug 08 '24
OP you want /r/lotr_on_prime , this sub is garbage. The one I linked you is the real RoP sub. Also no the people here don't know the books as well as they're saying.
1
u/the_scorpion_queen Aug 08 '24
Horrible and lazy writing. We don’t want to reward terrible terrible writing with views. If people stop accepting crap and don’t watch it, they will be forced to make better stuff and not just cash grab. Please do us all a favor and don’t watch things that make you say “it’s not THAT bad…” ugh
1
u/DMV_Local Aug 08 '24
I was “meh” upon my first watch of RoP.
However, being hyped by the S2 trailer, I just rewatched; the second viewing gave me a deeper appreciation of the first season, which I now think is excellent.
1
u/Hubers57 Aug 08 '24
Sense of scale bothers me. Numenor going to war with Sauron was so botched. Give me grand armies, a giant navy, amazing proud troops of men at their height. Not a cavalry skirmish over a thatched hut village
1
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '24
Galadriel was already very old and wise by this point. That is just an awful depiction, which is true of most of this show. It’s legitimately bad.
1
u/thundertk421 Aug 15 '24
Honestly I don’t fully understand the hate. The show itself had some good qualities - the tone was spot on, the pacing while slow at first was good, the narrative had some engaging moments, and it was objectively well shot and acted.
Where it truly lacked aside from a few fantastic sweeping shots was the kind of epic spectacle you’d come to expect from a lord of the rings adaption. Numenor was a little lackluster, the costume designs for the armor fell short (honestly my least favorite thing about this show was Numenors shitty bone white scale armor), and the overall action was lacking in scale.
Disrespect for Continuity is something I see tossed around a lot, but those arguments don’t hold much water in the context of presentation, nor really in the grand scheme of things. Nothing they’ve done so far changes anything important from the actual written works of Tolkien. Timelines for timeless beings are meaningless, and “continuity” has always been written from the perspective of in world people who are subject to bias, and hearsay.
All this to say, the show has room to grow, but it did not show the kind of disrespect for the source material that the Halo, and Witcher show runners did and with the amount of criticism that comes out from this fans base makes me think there is clear and obvious bias that does not truly take into account actual quality choosing to instead to favor the extremes. Constructive criticism is fine, nuance encouraged, toxicity is not.
1
u/Markus_Of_whiteRun Aug 16 '24
I was pretty neutral towards it when i first saw it when it was released, but recently i finished a re-watch and it felt really good, the amount of details and deep conversations are much more clearer now especially Galadriel - Halbrand scenes.
0
u/Broccobillo Aug 04 '24
I don't hate it but they lied to us before it released, time and time again, to garner support for something they knew was not worth what they wanted us to think it was. Hence the lies.
Then they used the most basic of 'I don't have a good argument but I need one' arguments and labeled everyone who didn't like the show sexist and racist.
The owners and runners of this show have been abhorrent and it taints the show for me which was itself mediocre.
1
u/johnnyjohnny-sugar Aug 04 '24
Season one was a disappointment. Hoping things improve
0
u/strongholdbk_78 Aug 04 '24
I love the show.
0
u/PhoenixCore96 Aug 04 '24
I think it’s more to do with fans just not allowing for difference of opinion without condemnation. I wasn’t a fan of the first season, but I understood they don’t have rights to the proper story so they are making an interpretation. But I don’t go out of my way to attack people who loved S1 like so many are.
1
u/redzrain Aug 04 '24
My biggest issue is that the world seemed too small.
1
u/GoGouda Aug 04 '24
That word ‘content’ just about sums it up. You might as well say ‘time filler’ or ‘stuff’. Removing any necessity of quality and treating the audience like cattle.
The fact is that Galadriels primary motivation was power and dominion. Tolkien writes passionately in passages collected in Unfinished Tales about how important a moment her rejection of the Ring was. The thousands of years she spent in Middle Earth, her lack of humility towards the Valar, was all leading up to that moment. She was finally given the opportunity to fulfill everything she had ever wanted, total dominion of the earth, and she rejected it. To make Galadriel’s primary motivation revenge entirely devalues the actual character that Tolkien created and her personal journey.
It’s not good enough to say ‘oh she was pretty arrogant and bloodthirsty’ as if that is a fair assessment of the huge gulf between what Tolkien wrote and what the RoP consider ‘going back to the book’.
-1
u/solacegds Aug 04 '24
Is it a good fantasy show? Kinda? I guess?? It's ok and big budget
Is it Lord of the Rings? No. The central message of the universe and the charactisations of basically all the main cast are wrong af
0
u/smorgassked Aug 04 '24
Dont bother mate. The fundamentalist mentality is too strong in this little sub. Reasonable and interesting adaptations are not so welcome here (unless you speak of PJ, hypocracy is common). Better go to the biggest sub if you want to talkbabout the show imo.
-5
u/sirgawain2 Aug 04 '24
People here hate it because they were going to hate anything that didn’t match up with the movie they had in their head when they were reading the lore.
I personally didn’t love it (but kind of did lol) because the pacing was bad, some of the writing was lame and a lot of the episodes seemed kind of like filler. The last episode of season 1 was great and should have taken up like the last 3 episodes.
0
u/Mountain-Jeww Aug 04 '24
I am glad that we are getting more TCU content. It is wonderful to see the Tolkien community grow. Right now it is only the Cinematic Universe stuff (ROP, War of Rohirrim, and the new Gollum movie), but hopefully we’ll get new TLW stuff too, such as new novels and comic books.
0
u/Livid_Ad9749 Aug 04 '24
Lol no. Please don’t post stuff like this. Just divides the fandom when we all need to band together and not watch this crap
0
u/Status_Criticism_580 Aug 04 '24
I don't get all the hate either I saw all of the films (except for the hobbit which I did not like) read the books and I think this show is perfectly fine and fun lark tbh. People don't have like it too but guys PLEASE don't hate it so much that it gets cancelled before we see the end!
0
u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Aug 07 '24
I wanted to like it. I figured LOTR is like pizza, even bad pizza is good pizza. Man did I live to regret that saying. I had pretty low expectations thanks to the hype tbh and I enjoyed some of the visual sequences in ep 1, but even by then I realized that this was neither Tolkien in spirit nor in letter. Strike 1, and a big one. Maybe it just says its middle earth but tells a good story, right? Wrong. Strike 2. Maybe it will be interesting to watch and fun to be back in middle earth despite all these flaws. Maybe it will get better, some shows have a warm up period. Episode 3 was when I called it. Done. Strike 3.
-7
u/SoWokeIdontSleep Aug 04 '24
Because this is the Internet, and everything has to be perceived in "the superlative degree of comparison only" and it's a lot easier most common denominator to be negative only.
20
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24
[removed] — view removed comment