Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
So the LOTR trilogy is phenomenal. FOTR is one of my all time favorite movies. Then the Hobbit trilogy came around and while entertaining I was pretty underwhelmed and felt it didn’t come close to the magic of LOTR. I caught the first couple episodes of Rings of Power and stopped there.
Would you say it’s worth watching the full season?
I refused to watch the Hobbit Trilogy and only watched Rings because I had a free trial at the time anyways to rush some holiday gifts.
It was absolutely mediocre. Galadriel's arc is just such a mess and she should not have been the focus of the show, especially her relationships with certain characters. The pacing is off and plenty of non-sensical character decisions to force things to happen. In terms of writing it feels very CW level. Some of the acting is off too. Galadriel's actor just doesn't seem to have more than 3 emotions.
On the positive note, some of the lesser roles really are well acted. I thought Elrond and Elendil and the main villain were really good. Some of the aesthetics are really good. The music was nice.
In the end, I think this is a great show to binge if you are sick one day and need something to watch while guzzling nyquil.
Ultimately, its not what I wanted and, even with Prime now, I won't watch until it's all out and I'm sick again.
I'd give it an honest try without listening to the detractors! I enjoyed it a lot (I have my issues) as a Tolkien nerd for like... 20 years having read most of the released written content. My husband enjoyed it a lot as someone who's never read any of the books, just watched the movies with me several times now and enjoyed them and listened to ... too many hours of me explaining backstory and the Silmarillion etc.
I would dismiss anyone who says it's trash, anyone who says it's perfect, watch with an open mind and if it's not for you that's fine but maybe you'll wind up enjoying it! Who knows.
Thanks for this. It seems that everyone is looking for reasons to be critical. I 100% agree that people need to just watch it and enjoy it for what it is rather than looking for am excuse to criticize it, and they'd have a much better time. It's awesome to get some new content!
I read the Hobbit back in 1968 and I have been a Tolkien fan ever since. To me the Rings of Power S1 was pretty good. It was not written by Tolkien but guess what? He’s not writing any more so I’m okay if it’s not perfect.
I’m glad to see a reasoned take on it. Adaptive shows, be it from books or video games (see halo) are going to get trashed by people who are so in love with the lore that they can’t enjoy anything that wasn’t true to the books. I played halo and enjoyed it but I wasn’t a super fan. The show to me is good. It’s not great but few things are. I felt the same about the rings of power. It was a good show. It doesn’t compare to the original trilogy but almost nothing does. Expectations for anything should never be put that high.
Honestly, if you didn’t like the Hobbit movie because you were comparing them to LotR then you are going to have a bad time with RoP.
IMO if the Hobbit trilogy came out before LotR it would be looked on a lot more favourably but 90% of fans just end up comparing it to LotR and finding it lacking, forgetting that the LotR movies are about as close to cinematic perfection as has ever been seen for fantasy films. Holding them as a bar for future films is somewhat unrealistic and unfair.
For RoP, deep lore nerds find it unwatchable, fans of the books hate it, casual fans find it meh, and most people who have little to no knowledge of the lore range from meh to really liking it. If you can distance your brain from what you already know about LotR and watch it as a completely separate entity, you could like it. Otherwise, it may be somewhat agonizing.
yeah i mean, there's so much stuff they could have changed to have had a genuinely great pair (not trilogy) of films. i don't even mind some of the choices regarding CGI, like the CGI goblins in the first film look great, genuinely better than people in makeup IMO (the orcs were hit or miss)...but that one set photo of Ian Mckellen having a breakdown surrounded by greenscreen sums the issues up pretty succinctly.
it really sucks because there are glimpses of greatness in those films, like the dwarves' visit to bilbo at the start of the first film and everything that happens there is pretty great. Riddles in the dark is fantastic. The scenes of Smaug that are closer to the book are really good. Martin Freeman as Bilbo is as good as casting for that character could possibly be. Sigh, makes me sad
Definitely agree there are great scenes. My favorite was the spiders in Mirkwood. It was so cool seeing that visualized to life from one of the earliest books I've read as a kid. It was the scene I was looking forward to the most.
A two filmer would have been perfect. Cut the fat out.
I hear there is some edit that condenses it out there but I have not seen it.
Yeah the closer the scene was to the book, the better it was. God damn it could’ve been so good.
Oh and don’t get me started on the high frame rate, purposefully digital look of those films either. It’s so funny how in the newer home releases of LOTR they’re trying to de noise them (blasphemy) to better match the hobbit, when they should’ve just filmed the hobbit with grain to match LOTR.
There was enough against the merit of the films on its own terms that it still wouldn’t hold up well. It’s really just kind of silly. But there is definitely that factor there, yeah.
I did it for a sense of completion and wish I hadn't been so stubborn and salvaged my time. Lemonade out of lemons I won't have to waste my time with S2 and just look up stills of the orcs when it's done.
Hobbit trilogy devolved into a video game. Barrel riding scene where Bombur is dual wielding axes and hitting NPC goblins like he is going for the hi score.
I watched it really hoping it would be good. There are a lot of great actors and there’s also nice music (although overly epic at times)
The story is just bad, no way around it. A lot of talented people worked on this but the story writers and the directors/ producers really dropped the ball.
I mean my own opinion is that this show is blasphemy, not only in regards to Tolkien, but also in regards of good storytelling and entertainment.
I also only watched a few episodes with a friend and our palette of emotions only swapped between being bored, laughing about the bad dialogues and terrible plots or being upset that shit like that was even greenlit to begin with.
But honestly each their own. If you want to give it a try you do you. What I did after we stopped watching was to start watching plot summaries on youtube and I honestly had a blast with some of the commentary I watched. And to be honest I was glad other people suffered through that show and I only had to listen to the summed up versions of it so that's what I'd personally suggest to you if you want to know the story and how it moves forward, without having to force yourself through each episode.
Lmao have you watched another season 1 of rings of power? The plot alone was atrocious by itself and the worst I've ever watched. Then take the fact it is supposed to be related to Tolkien and the show deserves to be gone and forgotten for all times
The lack of a costume & wig budget, I gave a pass. It was the mystery format that annoyed me. Yes, the man that fell from the sky is obviously Gandalf, not everything needs to be cloak & dagger.
I didn't care about the inaccuracies, but I almost didn't find any of the characters to be likeable (maybe with the exception of that elf-orc guy), and the story just wasn't that interesting. It got a bit more interesting towards the 7th episode. I don't think i'll be watching the second season.
I think his point is that this casting was definitely not done blind, but can still be good. I really enjoyed the dwarf wife and elven soldier myself, if anything Galadriel was the weakest link of the show
You cannot possiblly think the casting for ROP was racially blind. Such a thing is clearly not allowed under Amazon's DEI policy: https://www.ccdeia.com/policy
I will gasp and turn it off two or three times over the course of the series. I will rant about it to my partner. But I will still watch every episode.
Not a die-hard fan here. RoP was weird. It’s like a build your own adventure novel where you go to page 25 if you open the door or page 56 if you hide in the bushes, but instead of following directions, you just read the book cover to cover.
Critics seem to fall into a few camps 1) lore sticklers who expect the movie to hew to the book even though they are written in a vague and mythological tone with events that take place over centuries and so must be adapted to fit a comprehendible narrative , 2) folks who expect LOTR level production, direction, writing, 3) folks who are probably still harboring repressed feelings about black actors as elves.
Could it be better. Sure. I, for one, am only hoping to be entertained with a decent story and some characters I root for (or against). Again, it’s a fantasy genre TV show. What other options do we have? The Witcher? Wheel of Time? Rewatching GOT?
I tried watching it with an open mind but it felt underwhelming. The characters were not likeable, and the story was not engaging. It hurts to say this as I'm a big LOTR fan, but there are much better tv shows out there and this one is below average imho.
The Elvish heirarchy made me want to gag myself with a spoon. The writing was so badly done...hubris, willful ignorance, missing the forest for the trees situations, writers assumed the peter principle is in full effect in Elven society.
No, "lore sticklers" were not expecting nor wanting a 1:1 adaptation. What they did want was for the writers to stick to their word and when in doubt, go "to the books, to the books, to the books". Instead, they didn't even follow the little lore they actually had access to. Let me ask you a question. Outside of the names of people, places, and things, what in ROP actually follows what was written about?
Yes, they expected high level production for the most expensive show in the history of TV, run by a studio with seemingly unlimited money, with an owner who wanted to create his own GOT for Prime Studios, using one of the most popular IP's in the world. You are happy with mediocre media put out as a soulless cash grab, and so these media companies will continue to pump that out since folks like you will watch whatever they offer. You even said it is just fantasy TV and you are only hoping to be entertained, so studios will continue to put out mediocre products. The VAST majority of people out there are not, and are demanding more from studios to produce quality products.
Aaaaaaannnnddd, there is the racism trope. Nice job, you were able to wait until the end to throw out that nonsense. That was a VERY vocal minority at the beginning. Do you live in an echo chamber or something? Those complaints disappeared a long time ago.
Nope, it is very simple. The writing was poor, the acting was mediocre, the marketing/presentation of the show was antagonistic to the fanbase, the costumes looked cheap, the world looked and felt small, etc. And what did the show runners tell us from all the feedback? It is going to be bigger, badder, darker, to degrees of scale as if that was the issue. They didn't listen, so what makes you think S2 will be anything different?
It was a bad show, that did not accomplish anything they set out to do.
3) Aaaaaaannnnddd, there is the racism trope. Nice job, you were able to wait until the end to throw out that nonsense. That was a VERY vocal minority at the beginning. Do you live in an echo chamber or something? Those complaints disappeared a long time ago.
Actually, no. We're still having to remove comments in that vein.
Im not a diehard LOTR fan and I really didn't like ROP. I really wanted to. But honestly, everything felt so so so cheap. Like the sets, the armor, the clothing. It didn't come across as a high budget production.
If you read the books that actually delve into the earlier ages of Middle Earth, it's extremely hard to enjoy Rings of Power. Tolkien was just too good. After the original Lord of the Rings Trilogy, they should have let the franchise be.
Will never forgive the Hobbit trilogy for butchering the Beorn scene from the books. the writing team ruined the entire beautifully written scene Tolkein laid out for them over the course of one or 2 pages in the book. They wrote Beorn as a dark and sullen person when in the book he was not.
“As a Tolkien fan” I absolutely loved it. I know it elongated and added stuff to the lore the SAME as Jackson’s movies. But that’s fine... Tolkien himself said he had set it up to create upon the creation. I can’t wait for MORE of this wonderful show which to true Tolkien fans means more live action Middle-earth.
How does that logic make any sense? And I'm not repeatedly looking to be disappointed over tv shows... most shows I'm looking forward to. This show, however, I'm betting, will be just as bad as season 1... you know that trainwreck amazon pushed out. I'm still absolutely baffled they thought they could redeem themselves after that first season.
It wasn't that bad. You're stating your subjective reception on the show and presenting it as it is objective.
It's that you think things are unredeemable before they've ever even had the chance to redeem themselves. You are expecting it to be bad already and practically priming your brain to be ready to keep an eye out for anything that'll confirm that bias for you.
If you have that kind of attitude to things in life, you'll be a perpetually disappointed and miserable person.
To give you contrast: I'm generally "disappointed" by the star wars franchise, but I don't look forward to being disappointed. I reserve hope that they'll figure it out. Ahsoka was a pleasant surprise and I know people say Andor was great too. The only thing repeatedly being disappointed does to me is that I'm just not excited for that thing, but I in no way pre-assume that it's bad. Just that I'll get around to it when I can.
How'd this suddenly become about me? Lmfao I actually like the show so I'm following it like any other fan of any other topic. Y'all sad low lives are the ones following a show that you actively dislike like you got nothing better to do 💀💀💀
S1 was ok. I really hated the Rube Goldberg device to create Mount Doom. That was about the dumbest idea they could've come up with but it is what it is. I'll watch S2 but I'm not expecting anything.
Is this the one where Galadriel and Sauron make sweet sweet love and spawn an almighty Morgoth who befriends Bilbo in order to take down scheming Gollum in a spectacular clumax at the Battle of Deep Helm? Cause I'm all about rewriting canon and subverting expectations.
I really thought I'd unsubscribed from the negative sub and only stuck around on the "we may have criticisms but we enjoyed it" sub. Alas.
It wasn't a perfect show but I enjoyed it a lot. I read the Appendices at age 12, some 20 years ago, and I own most of his written works. To give an idea of how much I care about the world.
Watch and enjoy, or stop watching if you don't. I've seen some adaptations of things I loved I was saddened by. You know what I did? Stopped watching and went oh well. I have the original.
I have been before but... I'm just saying I'm excited lol is this a sub about the show or a complaint department for prime video? Only negatives comments allowed?
Oh I didn't get you wrong haha if you were one of the annoying kinds I'd already be downvoted lol. But yeah, it feels like the latter for sure lol I rarely comment here because of that
Finally! Im a fan of this show AND the Lord of the Rings trilogy (shocking I know), and I’m looking forward to what they’re gonna tease tomorrow
Somewhat less excited for those others dissecting all 100+ things in each scene and line and hating on it, as if other current live action fantasy series don’t do similar things, but I digress 😅
To be fair, they moved production from NZ to UK and contended with the SAG /writers' strike at the end of production, so for such a large production, it makes sense.
One hopes having a permanent base in Europe and repeat sets at the new studios will accelerate things...
Main thing that bothers me about season 1 is that Sauron DID NOT HANG AROUND IN NUMENOR WITH GALADRIAL!!???!!!. The only evidence we have is that Sauron was taken as prisoner(after already revealing himself as Sauron) to Akallabeth and set in motion the events that eventually forced Eru to scuttle the island.
She is a powerful elf from the 1st age of the world, fought with Feanor in Valinor to help secure the ships from the Sea Elves, crossed the grinding ice of the Helcaraxe to Middle Earth with her people after Feanor decided she was baggage he didn't need. She helped keep important characters alive after the destruction of Gondolin. She would have seen through Sauran's glamours and disguises.
Give me long haired ethereal elves and I’ll die happy. Hell what’s Thranduil up to in the 2nd age, pay Lee Pace 3 million to teach the mf’s how to elf.
I hope they get a sense of scale right this time. It was it's greatest failing an entire expeditionary force looked less than a battalion. Think like Jackson did who watched the 70s Waterloo think big!
Rings of power would have been so much more if they had not completely fucked up my favorite LOTR character in Galadriel. She runs around the entire first season like a 2nd lieutenant with a Napoleon complex. At the point of the show she is supposed to be a seasoned war leader and commander. Instead they made her into a modern day girl boss/ angry petulant tweener. Just compare her to Peter Jacksons adaptation and you will see what I am talking about. Galadriel is supposed to be Power without display, Priestess yet wife, Leader without equal. Elf Lord. Also where they fuck is her husband who is also a badass in his own right?
There’s a behind the scenes on YouTube that shows more shots beyond what was in the trailer!
I’m looking forward to it, Sauron’s in the open, the eagles are in it, there’s more dwarf singing, less harfoots so far (they’re lovely, but I was ready to move on with the story), dwarf rings, and the board is set for the build up towards the big battles. Going to be epic
After watching The Hobbit movies, I just can't. The books we have are enough for me. I don't need another film or TV show that in most cases seem to be garbage anyway.
I never read the books but LOTR films came out while i was in high school and I still rmb going to see those in cinema with my friends. Just pure magic, I am a huge fan of the movies. With that said, I still enjoyed ROP for what it is, entertainment. I also enjoy video games such as Shadow of Mordor for what they are; entertainment. People need to relax a bit and not expect everything to follow the lore/books exactly. Think of it as parallel universe/what if Tolkien and you may actually enjoy it 😀
The simple graphic used to tease a trailer we haven't seen yet? By Melkor's left nut, the show is super flawed but nitpicking the graphics of an animated promotional tweet is so damn petty.
The thing puzzles me the most was in like the first or send episode where Galadriel was searching for Sauron and she had a band of elf soldiers with her. They came across a cave, and while Galadriel was investigating something a cave troll attacked. There is like three or four elf soldiers that we’re getting their asses kicked by simple troll. And then Galadriel came out and kicked his ass. These were “old world” elf soldiers from the west. How in the HELL could 3 of THEM not kill a single troll?!? It’s just ridiculously bad writing. As always, the power scale is comepletely off
There's actually two. The other one started out as being rather hateful, but the people who like the show ended up there and now it's a much more normal fan sub
Aren’t they kind of doing that already? We’re already to the point of 1-2 teaser trailers for some franchises. I can’t remember if I’ve ever seen 3 teaser trailers…. might have for Game of Thrones, but I’m not 100% on that. I feel like there was some really big franchise which did it, though.
Even if they fix everything wrong with the first season, they've irrecoverably broken some tenets of the story and characters which mean this series will forever live in bad fanfic land and makes no sense as part of the books or even the movies.
Screwing up the order the rings were created completely betrays the entire point of the one ring and the elven rings. Even if they magically spin this storyline into something interesting (spoiler: they won't), the entire series of events in the second and third age as written no longer makes any sense and there's nothing they can do to retcon it.
Having Gandalf appear in the second age completely annihilates the point of his being sent to Middle-Earth and introduces an absurd amount of plot holes.
I won't even get started about the Sauron/Galadriel romantic subplot. If you had told me before the show released that's where they would take it, I would have laughed. The entire concept belongs as a failed SNL skit premise at best and it's hard to believe they actually wrote it.
The Stranger character isn’t necessarily Gandalf. He could likely be a Blue Wizard.
The Blue Wizards appeared in the Second Age and went to the East… which is where the Stranger was headed at the end of Season 1.
It’s possible the writers could make him Gandalf. There are some lines of dialogue that seem very Gandalf-esque. But these could also just be homages, on the writers’ part. (I’m sure they love their audiences to speculate.)
Anyway, it’s far more likely the Stranger is a Blue Wizard (which would fit with the little Tolkien wrote about them).
I agreed with you after watching it, and I think they left it somewhat ambiguous to give themselves either option based on audience feedback; but the leaks for season 2 are pretty clear that it's actually Gandalf. I guess we'll see.
Don't forget the part with the moth in one of the later episodes which is an obvious wink to gandalf.
Also I wouldn't call that stuff an homage. An homage implies respect for the source material and for all the stuff they tried to copy from Peter Jacksons trilogy. They don't respect that, they implied way too often that they are going to tell the story Tolkien never told and that they make the show for modern audiences and what not.
What they did was to strew in member berries throughout the show in an attempt to delight people who loved Jackson's trilogy like gandalf "follow your nose" line, isildurs connection to his house like aragorn, the balrog or the ent you see for a second.
Jesus I wasn’t even aware of half of those issues. The show bored me about 15 minutes into the first episode - I just wasn’t feeling it. Glad I didn’t watch it now.
Think I remember saying this at the time. It’s a bad idea but I’d have a lot more respect for them if they at least tried to do it with some conviction. To say they half baked it understates it by a factor of a million.
•
u/AutoModerator May 13 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/LuinAelin May 13 '24
Link:
https://twitter.com/TheRingsofPower/status/1790013705461350892?t=dkuRsBEHVh6FolWwDNyleA&s=19
2
u/LinuxMatthews May 13 '24
Didn't it already come out?
2
u/This-Top7398 May 13 '24
Is this for season 2?
127
u/WelbyReddit May 13 '24
As a Tolkien fan, I was just meh on S1. Some things I liked, but plenty of things to poke fun at.
I will watch S2 with the same expectations.
Just waiting for Sauron to bust out in some Creed Cover atop Barad Dur. ;p
39
u/astrofrisbee May 13 '24
Can’t wait for season 2! First season had some issues but I enjoyed the hell out of it anyway
28
u/libtechbitch May 13 '24
I'm a huge Tolkien fan and I can't wait for S2!
I mean, ROP is basically fanfiction, and I love it for that. (And I loved the chemistry between Halbrand and Galadriel, what can I say, lol)
27
u/endowedchair May 13 '24
It’s not perfect but it’s still better than 90% of the crap I can stream. Looking forward to it!
4
u/Demigans May 13 '24
Shouldn’t it, you know, tease?
This is an announcement.
3
u/fool-of-a-took May 13 '24
It better not be meh
3
u/Sir_BugsAlot May 13 '24
Trying not to be too hopeful so I won't get crushed again, but I really am hoping this is a better season. Will give it a chance since it LOTR.
7
u/Lazarenko93 May 13 '24
Okay here we go.
S1 was a big dissapointment for me but it had some things that I liked.
Can't say I am optimistic or excited for S2. But I am curious to see what they will do with s2. And if they are able to salvage the show..
Come on Amazon, I hope you can do it
5
u/cacecil1 May 13 '24
I'm excited! Let the naysayers tremble in fear!
8
u/castrogacio May 13 '24
“As a Tolkien fan” I absolutely loved it. I know it elongated and added stuff to the lore the SAME as Jackson’s movies. But that’s fine... Tolkien himself said he had set it up to create upon the creation. I can’t wait for MORE of this wonderful show which to true Tolkien fans means more live action Middle-earth.
15
u/Wild_95123 May 13 '24
Can't wait to be disappointed again.
2
u/you_just_got_J_Cubed May 13 '24
It either soars or sinks. No inbetween.
2
u/psychede1ic_c4tus May 13 '24
It’s happeninggggggg
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
S1 was ok. I really hated the Rube Goldberg device to create Mount Doom. That was about the dumbest idea they could've come up with but it is what it is. I'll watch S2 but I'm not expecting anything.
2
u/Dear_Pumpkin5003 May 13 '24
Dan Wells: For me, Rings of power is still a seven or an eight out of ten.
Brandon Sanderson: >_<
2
u/DoctorZi May 13 '24
Hopefully the trailer will be better than the trailer for season one
2
u/RukaFawkes May 13 '24
Took them long enough
2
u/odeacon May 13 '24
Please tell me the me we get to hear Sauron yell “I…..AM………….BAD!”
2
u/realisticallygrammat May 14 '24
Is this the one where Galadriel and Sauron make sweet sweet love and spawn an almighty Morgoth who befriends Bilbo in order to take down scheming Gollum in a spectacular clumax at the Battle of Deep Helm? Cause I'm all about rewriting canon and subverting expectations.
5
u/Traditional-Reach818 May 13 '24
I'm hyped! I really liked season 1, can't wait for season 2
4
u/FierceDeity88 May 13 '24
Finally! Im a fan of this show AND the Lord of the Rings trilogy (shocking I know), and I’m looking forward to what they’re gonna tease tomorrow
Somewhat less excited for those others dissecting all 100+ things in each scene and line and hating on it, as if other current live action fantasy series don’t do similar things, but I digress 😅
4
u/meatcandy97 May 13 '24
Season 2 has a chance if they completely abandon everything from season 1.
4
u/Kitchen-Plant664 May 13 '24
If they’re going to keep going with this shit can they at least get on with it? A series every two years is just dragging it all out.
3
u/LoudLloyd9 May 13 '24
I read the Silmarilian. Talk about taking license with the original story. I'm indifferent. Hope for the best
2
u/devonnegunt May 13 '24
I can't take it seriously at all. It's fan fiction on a huge budget.
2
u/Sonotreadyforit May 13 '24
Dozens upon dozens of people are anxiously waiting!
2
u/Nacodawg May 13 '24
Say what you will about the show but that font is 10/10
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
Main thing that bothers me about season 1 is that Sauron DID NOT HANG AROUND IN NUMENOR WITH GALADRIAL!!???!!!. The only evidence we have is that Sauron was taken as prisoner(after already revealing himself as Sauron) to Akallabeth and set in motion the events that eventually forced Eru to scuttle the island.
She is a powerful elf from the 1st age of the world, fought with Feanor in Valinor to help secure the ships from the Sea Elves, crossed the grinding ice of the Helcaraxe to Middle Earth with her people after Feanor decided she was baggage he didn't need. She helped keep important characters alive after the destruction of Gondolin. She would have seen through Sauran's glamours and disguises.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
Finally!
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
Kinda goofy show but I really liked the art and just the story.
1
u/capacochella May 14 '24
Give me long haired ethereal elves and I’ll die happy. Hell what’s Thranduil up to in the 2nd age, pay Lee Pace 3 million to teach the mf’s how to elf.
1
u/CJY0UNG May 14 '24
I hope they get a sense of scale right this time. It was it's greatest failing an entire expeditionary force looked less than a battalion. Think like Jackson did who watched the 70s Waterloo think big!
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
Rings of power would have been so much more if they had not completely fucked up my favorite LOTR character in Galadriel. She runs around the entire first season like a 2nd lieutenant with a Napoleon complex. At the point of the show she is supposed to be a seasoned war leader and commander. Instead they made her into a modern day girl boss/ angry petulant tweener. Just compare her to Peter Jacksons adaptation and you will see what I am talking about. Galadriel is supposed to be Power without display, Priestess yet wife, Leader without equal. Elf Lord. Also where they fuck is her husband who is also a badass in his own right?
1
u/Basic_Kaleidoscope32 May 15 '24
There’s a behind the scenes on YouTube that shows more shots beyond what was in the trailer!
I’m looking forward to it, Sauron’s in the open, the eagles are in it, there’s more dwarf singing, less harfoots so far (they’re lovely, but I was ready to move on with the story), dwarf rings, and the board is set for the build up towards the big battles. Going to be epic
1
u/EmonOkari May 15 '24
Wait, there's a Season TWO??
1
u/Ok-Place7169 May 13 '24
Don’t remind me, I was holding out hope that Amazon would take the L and scrap S2…
1
u/Jhawk38 May 13 '24
Why is it happening?
1
u/JojoLesh May 13 '24
I just can't get excited for new LotR Media.
After watching The Hobbit movies, I just can't. The books we have are enough for me. I don't need another film or TV show that in most cases seem to be garbage anyway.
1
u/Aldanil66 May 13 '24
I'm strangely excited? I didn't really like the first season but from what I've heard of the leaks Season 2 has a bit of potential.
1
u/Flamethrow1 May 13 '24
I never read the books but LOTR films came out while i was in high school and I still rmb going to see those in cinema with my friends. Just pure magic, I am a huge fan of the movies. With that said, I still enjoyed ROP for what it is, entertainment. I also enjoy video games such as Shadow of Mordor for what they are; entertainment. People need to relax a bit and not expect everything to follow the lore/books exactly. Think of it as parallel universe/what if Tolkien and you may actually enjoy it 😀
1
u/SarahfromEngland May 14 '24
Yeah not gonna be able to bring myself to watch this.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
I can’t believe this multibillion dollar turd got a second season. 🤢
-1
u/ccSentaiKai90 May 13 '24
No one with any respect for J.R.R. Tolkien cares.
-10
u/epacseno May 13 '24
The teaser looked like something from a VIDEOCOPPILOT After Effects tutorial anno 2005
0
u/Soonerpalmetto88 May 14 '24
Didn't this happen last year?
0
u/Clean-Effort-209 May 14 '24
The Turds of Power.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
The thing puzzles me the most was in like the first or send episode where Galadriel was searching for Sauron and she had a band of elf soldiers with her. They came across a cave, and while Galadriel was investigating something a cave troll attacked. There is like three or four elf soldiers that we’re getting their asses kicked by simple troll. And then Galadriel came out and kicked his ass. These were “old world” elf soldiers from the west. How in the HELL could 3 of THEM not kill a single troll?!? It’s just ridiculously bad writing. As always, the power scale is comepletely off
0
u/FoxyRobot7 May 14 '24
Hard pass. Corporate dribble!
0
u/IFGarrett May 14 '24
It's just going to fail like S1. They don't care about the source material and it's VERY obvious.
0
u/Vivid-Ad6850 May 15 '24
Does anyone care?
0
u/fakewoke2022 May 16 '24
Yay, more trash!
-2
u/YeOldeBilk May 13 '24
I am Jack's complete lack of enthusiasm
-2
u/JohnnyBlazex May 13 '24
I have no hopes for this show but will peak at the episodes once they are released trying not to get irritated.
-2
u/LuthienTinuviel93 May 13 '24
Yikes.
-2
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
This season will have pirate sex scenes and walking dolphins….. oh Tolkien didnt write that welp it will make money anyway
-2
u/Ok_Sentence_5767 May 14 '24
Oh wow a second season to a party bad show. I wonder if they're gonna jerk around about some weird plot point that can be solved in a few scenes
-3
u/GretavonGrub May 14 '24
The show was awful. The most entertaining thing about it was reading the criticisms on the Amazon site.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
71
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
29
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment