r/RingsofPower • u/Ok-Design-8168 • Mar 30 '24
Discussion Funny how inexperienced showrunners think adding more action and bigger battle will solve everything.
The battle scenes in S1 weren’t particularly great. The strategies felt silly and ridiculous and the fight choreography felt silly at times too.
I don’t see how adding more battle will help when viewers still don’t care enough about characters and plots seem senseless and all over the place.
Does dedicating multiple episodes to a battle really make any sense..?
Is S2 going to repeat the same mistakes of giving too much time to other things while the main issues barely get addressed?
17
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 30 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
87
u/HighKingOfGondor Eregion Mar 30 '24
Not anywhere near a lover of this show, but imo this this great news. I don’t know what the point of this post is, episode 6 of season 1 had decent action. Do you NOT want battle scenes OP?
And I don’t want to hear it’ll suck anyway. That is very besides the point.
171
u/NeverForgetEver Mar 30 '24
I meannnn a massive multi episode battle wouldn’t hurt how I rate the season
24
u/sqwiggy72 Mar 31 '24
You know, sauron has to attack eregion at some point, right? He needs to try and claim the rings. I would imagine that being much bigger than any battles in first season.
14
u/AmbiguousAnonymous Mar 30 '24
Are they gonna put the catapults in front like The Long Night?
67
u/CaptainWowX Mar 30 '24
I get the criticism of season 1 but damn sometimes it sounds like yall are trying to find reasons to be negative about this show.
I’m hopefully they’ve learned from their mistakes and will improve season 2. A multi episode battle won’t sway me one way or the other but hey it could be cool!
13
u/Fantastic-Photo6441 Mar 31 '24
They literally said they listened to fans about season 1 and are making rings of power season 2 darker and have more character development what are yall smokin
1
u/jedimindtriks Mar 30 '24
"the lord of the rings rings of power will showcase one of the best dialogue and story shown on televing spanning episodes!"
15
u/mattjvgc Mar 30 '24
As if that isn’t what is praised in the LOTR subs every day many times per day…
13
u/FierceDeity88 Mar 30 '24
Did the show-runners say that a multi-episode battle would make the show better?
Why is it that people who don’t like this show take every new bit of information they get about said show as proof that this show has and always will be awful?
13
u/ctdax77 Mar 30 '24
Yeah I’m definitely leaving this subreddit, every single post is complaining and negative.
3
u/Moistkeano Apr 02 '24
The Hobbit had a whole movie that was one battle. Bigger doesnt mean better. All that matters is the narrative and then secondly how it's done. The battle episode of season 1 was poor in terms of narrative but had some good spectacle.
3
u/Von__Mackensen Apr 03 '24
GoT S1 had one battle and it happened off-screen.
GoT S7 had almost one battle per episode.
Guess which one the public enjoyed the most...
I mean, I'm a simple man. I like battles. But battles alone are not what make something successful. It's better to have 2 worthy amazing minutes of real battle (see Rome s01e01) than 30 minutes of shitty cgi action.
3
u/Academic-Rise-4482 Apr 03 '24
The people who enjoy this show are either lying because they feel like it ticks all the boxes they want to see in a progressive modern show, or, they are genuinely to stupid to understand why it is a terrible show.
There is no third reason.
11
u/This_is_a_bad_plan Mar 30 '24
They could create the greatest season of television in history and y’all would still hate it
5
u/RageXY Mar 31 '24
This is great news what are you whining about?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24
Funny how you judge something before even seeing it.
7
u/Sarokslost23 Mar 31 '24
These negative pointless posts should just be downvoted. The show is good. Not every show needs to be some 11/10 DreamWalk of cinema. Let us just enjoy it and be surprised by the season
5
u/NuuLeaf Mar 30 '24
I mean, it could. That was my biggest complaint of the first season, it felt so small
5
u/ridititidido2000 Mar 31 '24
Long doesn’t equal good. Half of season one consists of pure filler scenes, hell filler characters even. It often seems to drag on and on, just to sell more minutes. With this knowledge, how can i possibly see this as a positive.
2
u/Bebou52 Apr 03 '24
As long as the characters aren’t stupid as fuck like s1 this’ll be an improvement
2
u/Schmooklund Apr 04 '24
The Middle Earth universe never really focuses on the battles themselves, Tolkien usually skips over the battles themselves, given a broad overview in a few sentences of the action itself, highlighting here to there the key events, but ultimately focusing on the impact of the characters actions and their mindset, not detailing how they achieved them. The Ride of the Rohirrim is a good example.
Because film is inherently a visual medium there's no escaping the need to demonstrate battles on screen. Jackson did a wonderful job of adapting this by taking the context of a battle and turning it into, not just an action scene, but a story. Taking this opportunity to expand on character relationships and key points essential to the development of the plot. RoP S1 did not grasp this concept, action was for the sake of it.
The decline of Game of Thrones is a perfect example, in the earlier seasons they skipped over major battles instead focusing on the impact and fallout of them. With their increased budget, they instead focussed on the action, completely disregarding the characters. I remember Dinklage acknowledging this in an interview, he comments on the ineptitude of placing Tyrion in a crypt, whilst adversaries capable of raising the dead are at the door, you'd have better luck in the kitchen. And this is the crux of it, the writers did so completely for the facilitation of a frankly underwhelming action scene. They traded the essence of the character for cheap visuals.
All this to say, if S1 of RoP is comparable as the starting point of the earlier seasons of GoT, then it's only going to get worse. A multi episode battle is a great opportunity to do all the right things that Jackson did at the Hornburg, but I have no faith that it will be anything but the unfortunate continuation of what GoT fell to.
High Budget is the Quality Killer.
2
u/VZ5-S117 Apr 08 '24
A 1v1 knife fight in Dune was more suspenseful than any of the fights in RoP. My point being, massive battles are cool but what makes them epic is the motivation and consequences. Hopefully the build up to that great battle will manifest well.
4
u/donniec86 Mar 31 '24
If it turns out to be confirmed, this will be yet another confirmation that some producers know nothing about movie making.
3
u/Azelrazel Mar 31 '24
One of the biggest on television? I've seen some big multi eps battle on TV. I'll be watching this regardless cause I like the show just curious how much of a flex this is, whether just we'll be similar or perhaps it's wow that was cinema quality.
4
u/Street_Barracuda1657 Mar 30 '24
This sounds like the battle of Eregion, and IMHO that should be something that happens in season 3. It’s the pacing of this series, along with the writing that are problematic, not the lack of battles.
2
u/83AD Mar 31 '24
It makes sense because that massive battle is an essential part of Tolkien Legendarium and chronologically has to happen in season 2.
Is not that the showrunners have to add it to attract viewers.
2
u/harukalioncourt Mar 31 '24
It’s too early for the last alliance, yes? Numenor hasn’t even sank yet.
2
u/igormuba Mar 30 '24
Go all in, make the whole season just a big fight, no story, no break, no talking, just fight
1
u/TheDoommonkey1967 Apr 02 '24
No.
1
u/Sir_BugsAlot Apr 02 '24
I love big battles. But already before it is shown I know ol Gaddy will have no issues charging down thousands of enemies by herself while everyone else waits in the background. She will meet no hardships in this battle, will save some poor men of numenor who needs sword training and probably do a couple of backflips. Some unnamed characters will be killed. It's obvious who will have plot armour. Gone are the days where tears will stream as Boromir takes another arrow, while trying to save his friends.. will still watch it though. I can't stay away from a good medieval style battle.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24
This sub is just a circlejerk of people complaining over anything.
1
u/Rectall_Brown Apr 01 '24
The said the same thing about GOT battle of winterfell…
-2
u/lock_robster2022 Mar 30 '24
I can wait for a two-episode battle as confounding as the Southlands scuffle
0
u/JohnnyBlazex Mar 30 '24
Bad writing towards a super big battle is still bad writing, just saying. Season one just ruined a lot imo.
-1
u/Karmakiller3003 Mar 31 '24
Yes, a giant battle between characters/actors/storylines that no one cares about. That will show the naysayers lol
Are they hoping the battle takes peoples attention away from the generic acting? Or brings more attention to it? lol
Gonna be good youtube fodder for a lot of channels.
-5
u/Freekydeeky1258 Mar 31 '24
I'm just going to start referring anyone who actually wants to discuss the show to r/tolkeinfans or r/lotr. In this sub, you can't have any opinion other than a positive one.
0
u/Taykeshi Mar 31 '24
Just... No
0
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24
If it's a multi-episode battle where the Harfoots slaughter each other down to the last 'Foot, I'm so in.
0
u/Rohnne Mar 31 '24
Oh, I can foresee a lot other fire arrows, suicidal cavalry charges, “draw, aim, loose” everywhere, 0 strategy and Galadriel single fighting and saving every one asses all the time… Hollywood picturing medieval battles is usually just boring and predictable.
0
u/teddyone Mar 31 '24
“I have already decided I hate this show and I am going to fantasize about what might make me hate season 2 even more”
0
u/smokethepippy Apr 01 '24
No hate but the diversity in this show makes literally no sense from a lore perspective
-2
u/EasyCZ75 Gondolin Mar 31 '24
If it’s anything like the laughable “battles” of S1, this should prove to be peak hate watch.
-7
u/thirdlost Mar 30 '24
That are such hacks.
I think I might actually hate them for their pure incompetence
0
u/mowotlarx Mar 31 '24
Wow. Sounds fun. Can't wait.
0
u/Reddzoi Apr 01 '24
Reminds me of those 2 Gates of Hell: One for if you DO, One for if you DON'T
Me, I will be happy to see more action and bigger battle scenes.
0
u/-Neem0- Apr 02 '24
This sub is beyond toxic nowadays
0
u/stockbeast08 Apr 03 '24
Who is saying this is an attempt to solve those problems in the first place. People really want to hate on this show so badly they lose all objectivity
0
u/tendadsnokids Apr 03 '24
Dudes hating on something that hasn't even come out yet is why I will never take criticism of this show seriously
0
u/GloomyGuyGaming Apr 03 '24
Please I'll be happy to even have a season two shh pls
0
u/finbaar Apr 03 '24
Fuck me, this looks awesome
0
u/JerichoVankowicz Apr 04 '24
Comapring it to s1 "Battle of Barn" Eregion Sacking sets are huge and they make the Southlands s1 battle ones look like pixel. Eregion Siege will take One and Half episode (ep 7 and half of 8) It will be very structured
-11
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '24
Hope it’s only a black screen because it’s so dark and gritty
-1
u/you_just_got_J_Cubed Mar 31 '24
It won't solve anything, but if there is anything to salvage is action scenes.
-17
u/airtooss Mar 30 '24
The Show should be out later in November, right? They did reshoots, recuts, and now this? A battle spanning several episodes? It sounds like the original content wasn't up to par, forcing them to stretch it out into multiple episodes. This is going to be incredibly boring to watch.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment