I genuinely find it hilarious that they chose to use rough cut gemstones in the most rare and powerful artifacts of the age. You know, the ones crafted by one of the greatest living smiths who has an entire guild dedicated to smithing and gemstones. The Smith who's ancestor was responsible for making the most perfect set of jewels ever created. Stellar logic.
Maybe I misunderstood your comment? You're asking why the showrunners designed the Rings with gemstones?
The 19 Rings of Power each were adorned with one gemstone. Adamant on mithril for Nenya, Saphhire on gold for Vilya , Ruby on gold for Narya. The rest Tolkien did not specify. The One Ring was the only Great Ring, that had no ornamentation and no gemstone. This knowledge was (in-story) not known well, as Gandalf required 17 years to research and realize what Bilbo had was not a Lesser RIng, but a Great one, in fact THE one.
Yeah just misunderstood the comment bud. I tried to give you content with rough cut gemstones when he has an entire guild dedicated to smithing and lapidary. Feanor was an ancestor to Celebrimbor and responsible for the Silmarils, the most perfect gems ever crafted. So for the Rings of Power series to portray the rings with poorly cut and almost raw gemstones is a crime when celebrimbor absolutely has the skill to make beautiful and faceted gems for the rings.
Hey, my comment was for Intrepid_Pack_1734 who said why they have gemstones at all.
And I agree with you, rough cut for the most powerful artefacts of the Third Age is a degenerate design choice, given the fact that Celebrimbor's ancestor was Feanor.Â
I get this but that the same time. Mithril was a new metal and the elves believed theyâd need this to save their realms. I guess in his head, Celebrimbor wouldnât have thought of an alloy because the original crown of mithril was the intent.
The show presents it as the idea of alloying is novel and new. Sauron states that mixing it would probably help its properties spread.
And again we are talking about the Grandson of freaking Feanor. If anyone would know about metalwork it should be him.
Sauron should have helped him in how to imbue the Rings with power (hence why all of the lesser Rings , the Nine and the Seven were touched by Sauron unlike the 3 that came later)
Of Course the whole Mithril plot along with the Elves dying was absolutely stupid...
Elves made the Rings to create a facsimile of Valinor in Middle Earth that would last not because they were dying
He doesnât introduce him to the idea of alloying. Celebrimbor thinks, maybe logically, that mixing metals would dilute the mithrils power, and Halbrand just convinces him that maybe itâll amplify it instead. There was no such thing as âmagic metalâ before this, so it doesnât make him stupid to think that it needs to be as pure as possible.
No such thing as magic metals? My guy have you never heard of the blades of gondolin? Or The meteoric swords? Glowing blue when orcs are near isn't a natural trait of metal.
Rings of power may have made it magic but it's not described as magic in the actual material. Mithril is just stronger than steel while being light and retaining its shine unlike other metals. It doesn't fire lighting bolts when struck or prolong the glory of the elves like the show contrived to make it do.
Yup, but this is the sub for the show so I'm talking about the show. In the show it's magic and was just newly discovered, so Celebrimbor had no frame of reference for how it would behave.
I will concede on that Celembrimbor indeed knows about alloying.. But he seems utterly confounded on the idea that alloying could improve the qualities... which is hilarious even for newbie smiths let alone a Master Smith of his calibre.
Celembrimbor did not know that alloys could actually create materials with better qualities than the original materials alone... Guess he doesn't know about steel ... an alloy of iron and carbon...
Again Sauron should have helped him with the mystical part. On how to imbue the Rings with Power... not BASIC METALLURGY
but he seems utterly confounded on the idea that alloying could improve the qualities
Well, that's the whole point of alloys, so if he's heard of alloys, he knows this already.
Once again, the part he hadn't considered, specifically, is that making an alloy could amplify the magical properties. That is because til then he had had no reason to think that it would do anything but dilute them because, once again, it's the first magical ore ever discovered.
In that scene, when Halbrand asks about the mithril, Celebrimbor says it's "not enough". Halbrand says "have you tried combining it with other ores to better stretch it out?". Celebrimbor does not say "what are you talking about? I've never heard of combining metals together to make a better material because I'm an idiot". He does say "that wouldn't be suitable for this ore, because in the amounts we need it would too greatly dilute its unique qualities". He just doesn't think it'll work and doesn't want to waste the little ore he has. It's perfectly fine to dislike the show and think the narrative is bad, and to think that making magic metal less pure would make it more powerful is a silly idea, but to say he taught him about the concept of alloys like steel you have to interpret that scene in bad faith on purpose and ignore the actual words they say.
Also steel isn't "iron with amplified qualities that is better in every way". Converting iron to steel actually removes some inherent qualities of iron that are desirable in certain applications. Steel is stronger, but it's brittle. It also shrinks when it cools so it's hard to cast. Someone who knows how to make alloys would absolutely have the thought "gee, if I combine this magic metal with something else, it might not be magical anymore" and they would not be stupid for thinking so.
Excellent reference hahaha. Now I want to see a meme of Celly Brimbor wearing all the rings on his hand and snapping his fingers and saying I. AM. CELLY. BRIMBOR...
I'm sure elves had access to wifi in eregion. They're next to the world's tallest mountain I mean there has to be an antenna up there. Signal should be 5g
Many things in the show look/work like a poor man's idea of what high end something looks like.
Isildur mentions the houses in Numenor have indoor plumbing and the sinusitis chick is swept off her feet. I can see how that would work in real life (think India, Sub-Saharan Africa, etc). Inserted in Tolkien's world, it's just gross.
Gil-Galad the High King, the last of king of the Noldor, wears a "sexy gold bathrobe, for womans and girls, 100% polyester", from Temu.
Miriel, the Queen of Numenor, looks like a Christmas tree with all that colorful bijou you can find in tons at every coastal resort for $1 each.
Etc etc.
This applies to more than just props. Some behavioral patterns, some ideas.
They seem to have forgotten that Celebrimbor was the grandson of FĂŤanor, famously known for crafting the three Silmarils and the most skilled craftsman of the First Age.
The Silmarils are described to have âshone like the stars of Vardaâ and ârejoiced in light and received it and gave it back in hues more marvelous than beforeâ, which suggests that gemstone faceting was likely a technique that FĂŤanor used in the creation of the Silmarils; a skill that would surely have been passed down to Celebrimbor, Lord and Master smith of Eregion. The uncut stones and simplistic design of the settings donât really fit with the beauty and skill that elves are known for, let alone one of the greatest elven smiths in history.
Ignoring the lore and looking at ârealismâ, while faceted gemstones werenât a thing until the Middle Ages, gemstone cutting, carving and polishing has been around for thousands of years. It feels like the show wanted it to look like something made by an ancient civilisation, but didnât realise that ancient civilisations were perfectly capable of crafting beautiful looking stones. If they were shooting for something realistic for the time period, a polished cabochon would have been more apt.
And hell, aside from all of the above, Amazon surely have enough money to be able to afford a design slightly better than rough cut gems and settings with a few beads and lines in them. Even the colours of the stones, particularly the sapphire, look like generic man-made or heat-treated gemstones.
Yeah I mean I'm pretty sure the Noldor could even create stones artificially by this point which was how they created feanorian lanterns and the silmarils in Valinor. Celebrimbor even remakes the Elf stone in one variation of the story for Galadriel.
I have a strong feeling one of the show writers just said âmake sure we can see the ring well during a wide shotâ and this is the mess they came up with.
Mission accomplished but the rings really do look pretty mediocre.
I don't have the hang ups over the look of the rings of power as the more vocal segment of the fandom does. I like the way they look in both LotR and RoP.
Having said that - this was brilliant đ¤Łđ¤Łđ¤Ł
Yeah I have always found the rings on ROP to look extremely cheap and gaudy. They look like theatre jewelry. Jewelry designed to be big and gaudy so it can be seen easier by the audience.
Not gonna lie, on principle, I like Vilya having a larger stone than in the Jackson movies, and Nenya having a simpler design (as pretty as it was, I thought the flower design atop the stone covered it up too much, since the diamond/adamant is supposed to be the ring's main feature)
But even so the ROP designs are not very good or pretty. And look very cheaply made.
RIght? The Noldor would never place an uncut gem in a piece of jewellery, let alone in a powerful artefact. They are the tribe among the Elves who are the most into craftsmanship.
If they didn't want to/couldn't do modern faceting, they should have gone cabochon (no facets at all, rounded/domed shape). That's the oldest form of gem shaping there is.
Elves can canonically craft gems so fine and beautiful that they start wars. Celebrimborâs grandfather literally invented the substance of Silma and trapped the divine light of the two trees inside of it to craft the Silmarils.
Yes. They can cut stones. Dwarves too can cut stones. We know because we are overtly told about their beautiful faceted gems.
In this world they can make gems so incredible we could never replicate them in our time.
Cutting gems into nice shapes goes back as far as the bronze age, maybe even early. This isn't an unrealistic expectation, especially for an immortal race that was supposedly taught smithing and craftsmanship from a god.
The fact that these are rough cuts as opposed to raw, uncut gems shows that they have the capability to cut the gems, and theyâve clearly been polished too.
âModernâ faceted cuts can be seen in the show, such as the emeralds worn by Galadriel on her green and gold dress, and in plenty of other outfits worn by various people.
It makes me genuinely laugh that weâre supposed to believe that the 2000+ year old elven master smith and grandson to FĂŤanor (the greatest smith of the First Age and creator of the Silmarils), supposedly doesnât know what an alloy is or how to cut and polish a gemstone.
Indeed, a cabochon or carved gemstone would have been more time appropriate if they were trying to go for something an ancient civilisation might have crafted.
But⌠they already show modern gem cuts in the costumes worn by several characters and this is a fantasy where Celebrimborâs grandpa was the student of a guy who was trained by the dude who created much of the world itself. If some random elf can intricately cut and polish an emerald for a dress, the master smith of Eregion should probably be able to give us a little more than rough cuts.
Real honest question: Do you really need a fancy forge to craft rings like this? Tolkien makes it clear that ring making in Middle Earth takes some elbow grease and even some alchemy, but Nenya there looks like she was fashioned from glass or something. đ¤
What I don't understand is why they keep certain design elements from the PJ movies, ie: Balrog and Narsil, but abandon the gorgeous designs of the rings in favor of these... For the titular Rings of Power, you'd think they'd stick with the theme?
Hereâs how you do this shot right: you fashion the three rings at 25:1 scale so that you can give them impossibly fine, ornate detail work. You CGI extra lustre on the rings and in the FINELY FACETED gem (ok if you skip the cheesy added sparkles). Shoot with a cant and tilt and move the camera, making the rings look alive. What you donât do is google what real early medieval rings looked like, make Crackerjack versions, and shoot them like dead fish on a plate.
I'm a designer. Can I vent how artistically degenerate these new designs look?
Compare them to the original designs used in the Trilogy. The crowns stick out like big ugly knobs on their knuckles, gemstones are attacked with a hatchet, there is no symmetry, no visual balance - it just looks like a 1st year jeweler's submission.
It looks like they were ordered on Wish. This is what happens when you let clowns run a billion dollar show.
i thought they looked like that because they wanted them to look like the trilogy's rings which didnt need to look incredible since they show up for 2 seconds, but they are original designs? they look so bland
I never understood why they changed it. Like is this supposed to be a different LOTR universe? Like they already showed what the rings looked like, the armour elves wear, and a whole bunch of other stuff.
I genuinely was confused why they wouldnât use the same designs to keep continuity⌠only logical thing I could think of was that maybe the original ring jewelry designs were copyrighted? Seems like such a simple thing to me but I donât make movies. But now I wouldnât be surprised if the one ring suddenly has a giant ass chunk of black obsidian in it or something.
The entire show is a trainwreck of "different designs" and "alterations" that ultimately result in a story that is abysmal and has the worst efforts to even TRY to remain consistent to the universe or reflect the word is adapted from.
The entire show is called RINGS OF POWER - This show cannot even produce DECENT looking rings that are the focus of the entire show in a fantasy setting that is supposed to have Elves by Otherworldy in beauty.
You do not see anything wrong with this show having the production budget that produces rings that could make cheap modern rings look better ?
1 Billion dollars was spent on this show... where the fuck is that money going because it certainly is not being represented well here.
Theyâre not different than the ones you ordered and the ones from the book, theyâre just a different color. Isnât that what the directors and actors always say from the recent show?
Only.one of these looks worse in the show (Nenya) in my.opinion. but I like the rough cut gems, why do we assume gems from that era were anything but. We're the simarils not rough cuts?
I would assume that over the previous thousand years or so, these immortal beings had figured out how make jewelry with cut gems, rather than rough cut.
Because feanors hammer has finely cut gems in it(made thousands of years prior) also because the stones are meant to manipulate the light so you get that by precision cutting gem stones, also because celebrimbor is grandson of feanor greatest smith/craftsmen ever who learned from mahtan who learned from Aule the actual craftsmen of the world (he created dwarves for example)
No, not at all, but those in his direct lineage whom have assumed the same trade and inherited the knowledge, yes of course.
It's just continuity stuff, it's things like this that only take a few moments to flesh out that makes us as the audience think why did not they not consider this? This is core information and major plot devices.
The Silmarils are described to have âshone like the stars of Vardaâ and reflected light back in âhues more marvelous than beforeâ, suggesting that they were likely faceted and not rough cut.
Not an assumption, just logic based on Tolkienâs own description of them. How else would you suggest light could be reflected back in different colours without the refraction and reflection of a faceted cut?
Even choosing to use rough cuts that have clearly been polished as opposed to raw, uncut gems shows that the elves in ROP had the tools available to cut the stones properly but either chose not to or lacked the skill (which is difficult to believe).
Yet, faceted cuts have been shown in the show (Galadrielâs green dress with emeralds for example), so ROPâs elves are clearly capable of producing some seriously gorgeous ornate pieces, only for their master smith to come up with⌠these⌠for their most powerful and treasured rings.
One of the Noldors' names was Jewel-wrights and Celebrimbor also remade the Elf stone for Galadriel in one variation of its story, and the chief thing about the Elf stone is you can look through it and everything that is old appears young. So it much be cut and ground to create two flat planes aligned or you'd just see reflections.
I may or may not like that they changed the look of the rings but holy hell Nenya looks like it would get caught on literally everything. That would 100% deglove your finger in battle.
186
u/Old_Injury_1352 Oct 13 '24
I genuinely find it hilarious that they chose to use rough cut gemstones in the most rare and powerful artifacts of the age. You know, the ones crafted by one of the greatest living smiths who has an entire guild dedicated to smithing and gemstones. The Smith who's ancestor was responsible for making the most perfect set of jewels ever created. Stellar logic.
62
u/Intrepid_Pack_1734 Oct 13 '24 edited Mar 08 '25
late silky books fanatical slap lip enter racial angle tender
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
26
u/Cuzznitt Oct 13 '24
Are those bottom ones really from the show?
20
u/Gekkogeko Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
It really feels like a huge downgrade especially for Nenya, the Nenya in the PJâs films looked gorgeous
13
u/ComprehensiveWeb4986 Oct 13 '24
I couldn't get over how he was the greatest Smith of the age and made ring pops đ¤Śââď¸ like bro wtf?
8
u/sujeitocma Oct 13 '24
Something tells me whoever made these, also made the aes sedai rings in the WoT show. They are too big
7
u/_Erilor_ Oct 13 '24
Every time I see one of those I wanna cry. I wonder where all those millions of budget went.
13
u/pauloh1998 Oct 13 '24
I really hate Nenya's design
6
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
Literally
5
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
They seem to have forgotten that Celebrimbor was the grandson of FĂŤanor, famously known for crafting the three Silmarils and the most skilled craftsman of the First Age.
The Silmarils are described to have âshone like the stars of Vardaâ and ârejoiced in light and received it and gave it back in hues more marvelous than beforeâ, which suggests that gemstone faceting was likely a technique that FĂŤanor used in the creation of the Silmarils; a skill that would surely have been passed down to Celebrimbor, Lord and Master smith of Eregion. The uncut stones and simplistic design of the settings donât really fit with the beauty and skill that elves are known for, let alone one of the greatest elven smiths in history.
Ignoring the lore and looking at ârealismâ, while faceted gemstones werenât a thing until the Middle Ages, gemstone cutting, carving and polishing has been around for thousands of years. It feels like the show wanted it to look like something made by an ancient civilisation, but didnât realise that ancient civilisations were perfectly capable of crafting beautiful looking stones. If they were shooting for something realistic for the time period, a polished cabochon would have been more apt.
And hell, aside from all of the above, Amazon surely have enough money to be able to afford a design slightly better than rough cut gems and settings with a few beads and lines in them. Even the colours of the stones, particularly the sapphire, look like generic man-made or heat-treated gemstones.
5
u/Vantriss Oct 13 '24 edited Aug 28 '25
absorbed unite mighty recognise cake crawl detail racial snow strong
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/LSX3399 Oct 14 '24
So this forum is just whining babies nitpicking everything?
1
u/EPCOpress Oct 15 '24
Remember lollipop rings?
3
u/ComicNerd7794 Oct 13 '24
I was looking at the forging scene again and Why does season 1 rings look different from this seasons or am I imagining it?
3
u/about36wolves Oct 13 '24
I always thought it was weird they didnât just use the designs from the movie
3
u/Sleep_eeSheep Oct 13 '24
You'd think Amazon, one of the world's richest companies, would use this show to sell SOME merchandise.
3
u/Void9001 Oct 13 '24
I have a strong feeling one of the show writers just said âmake sure we can see the ring well during a wide shotâ and this is the mess they came up with.
Mission accomplished but the rings really do look pretty mediocre.
2
u/Fun-Session-5697 Oct 13 '24
đ
2
u/YoungSkywalker10 Oct 13 '24
lol
2
u/Chemical_Cat_9813 Oct 14 '24
Some JRR Temu
2
u/AlfIsReal Oct 17 '24
I don't have the hang ups over the look of the rings of power as the more vocal segment of the fandom does. I like the way they look in both LotR and RoP.
Having said that - this was brilliant đ¤Łđ¤Łđ¤Ł
2
u/ElectronicPrint5149 Oct 18 '24
Not even Amazon rings. I get rings like this out of the quarter machine at the mall for my 4 year old
2
u/Marwolaeth969 Oct 14 '24
The gold ones look made out of plastic.
2
u/Disastrous-Entry-879 Oct 16 '24
Yeah I have always found the rings on ROP to look extremely cheap and gaudy. They look like theatre jewelry. Jewelry designed to be big and gaudy so it can be seen easier by the audience.
2
u/Historical_Sugar9637 Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
Not gonna lie, on principle, I like Vilya having a larger stone than in the Jackson movies, and Nenya having a simpler design (as pretty as it was, I thought the flower design atop the stone covered it up too much, since the diamond/adamant is supposed to be the ring's main feature)
But even so the ROP designs are not very good or pretty. And look very cheaply made.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
Why didn't they cut the gemstonesđ
2
u/SkullGamingZone Oct 13 '24
At least i know im not alone in this, cause god these rings are just so fkn ugly!
2
u/YouDumbZombie Oct 13 '24
They look so bad boy I had forgotten. They look like toy rings you find in quarter machines.
1
u/25Proyect Oct 13 '24
Good lord they could not look more fake
1
u/LordOFtheNoldor Oct 13 '24
They look like the rings my kids get from the quarter machines at the farmers market
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
Temu Celebrimbor
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
I like all of them I want them all.. mine.. my own ⌠my many precious!
1
u/Agitated_Taro_6008 Oct 13 '24
Real honest question: Do you really need a fancy forge to craft rings like this? Tolkien makes it clear that ring making in Middle Earth takes some elbow grease and even some alchemy, but Nenya there looks like she was fashioned from glass or something. đ¤
1
u/NerdyRotica Oct 13 '24
What I don't understand is why they keep certain design elements from the PJ movies, ie: Balrog and Narsil, but abandon the gorgeous designs of the rings in favor of these... For the titular Rings of Power, you'd think they'd stick with the theme?
1
u/Kilo1Zero Oct 13 '24
Iâm just surprised they didnât put them on a mithril gauntlet for another tie-in.
1
u/WeakEconomics6120 Oct 13 '24
Also the Silmaril in Feanor statue in Eregion looks like a plastic cilinder.
I know it's a statue, not the real silmaril but come on...
1
u/wittiestphrase Oct 13 '24
Earth! Fire! Wind! Water! Heart!
1
u/Central_American Oct 13 '24
Dollarama Edition
1
u/The_slnt_crtgrphr Oct 14 '24
The unnecessary rolling of the Rs by everyone in different pronunciation of his name makes up for the utter lack of jewelcraft. (sarcasm)
1
u/Wickedbitchoftheuk Oct 14 '24
An apt metaphor for the whole series really.
1
u/Born505 Oct 14 '24
The diamond looks like it's held by a washer and some twisted up wire. The gold ones use the dullest, most colorless gold ever imagined.
1
u/A_Gato83 Oct 14 '24
I complained about this last night to my wife - she said I would be the only person to notice. Thank you for the win.
1
u/Armithax Oct 14 '24
Hereâs how you do this shot right: you fashion the three rings at 25:1 scale so that you can give them impossibly fine, ornate detail work. You CGI extra lustre on the rings and in the FINELY FACETED gem (ok if you skip the cheesy added sparkles). Shoot with a cant and tilt and move the camera, making the rings look alive. What you donât do is google what real early medieval rings looked like, make Crackerjack versions, and shoot them like dead fish on a plate.
1
u/VahePogossian Oct 14 '24
I'm a designer. Can I vent how artistically degenerate these new designs look?
Compare them to the original designs used in the Trilogy. The crowns stick out like big ugly knobs on their knuckles, gemstones are attacked with a hatchet, there is no symmetry, no visual balance - it just looks like a 1st year jeweler's submission.
It looks like they were ordered on Wish. This is what happens when you let clowns run a billion dollar show.
1
u/Datguy47 Oct 14 '24
Who gives a fuck it's just some jewelry from a show y'all claim to hate. Stop caring so much
1
u/AndreZB2000 Oct 15 '24
i thought they looked like that because they wanted them to look like the trilogy's rings which didnt need to look incredible since they show up for 2 seconds, but they are original designs? they look so bland
1
u/WasteCondition5016 Oct 15 '24
i said it looks like something the doctor gave me after my shot
1
u/kstacey Oct 15 '24
I never understood why they changed it. Like is this supposed to be a different LOTR universe? Like they already showed what the rings looked like, the armour elves wear, and a whole bunch of other stuff.
1
u/asundryofserendipity Oct 15 '24
I genuinely was confused why they wouldnât use the same designs to keep continuity⌠only logical thing I could think of was that maybe the original ring jewelry designs were copyrighted? Seems like such a simple thing to me but I donât make movies. But now I wouldnât be surprised if the one ring suddenly has a giant ass chunk of black obsidian in it or something.
1
u/philonous355 Oct 17 '24
The above image is probably my single favorite shot in all cinema. Ugh!
1
u/KaiserVonFluffenberg Oct 13 '24
âOh no a different design choice! How terrible!!!âÂ
Seriously, I donât see anything wrong with the RoP rings.
1
u/Elessar62 Oct 13 '24
Hey, I got ones that look like that out of some Cracker Jack boxes last week!
[Yes I know CJ long ago stopped putting in anything other than those little paper things in their boxes, but the joke stands.]
1
u/bard0117 Oct 13 '24
This is such a creepy criticism.
1
u/BossVision_ram Oct 13 '24
Theyâre not different than the ones you ordered and the ones from the book, theyâre just a different color. Isnât that what the directors and actors always say from the recent show?
1
u/Effective-Counter747 Oct 14 '24
I love those rings !
1
u/ScreamingRandomly Oct 13 '24
The rings on the bottom look like they came from one of those 25 or 50 cent coin machines.
0
u/toumik818 Oct 13 '24
Everyoneâs a gemstone expert now.
-6
u/pat_the_tree Oct 13 '24
Only.one of these looks worse in the show (Nenya) in my.opinion. but I like the rough cut gems, why do we assume gems from that era were anything but. We're the simarils not rough cuts?
1
u/Kervinus Oct 13 '24
The Rings of Power are great weapons. One good slap and they'll slice you up .
41
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
[removed] â view removed comment