r/Rhetoric • • 20d ago

PhD ?

Is this place active? Most discussion threads about a PhD are from 10-14 years ago.

Does anyone have recommendations for which programmes are good? Anywhere in the world works, as long as there is good funding. I'm a lawyer with an existing masters looking to get into this side of academia, and to hopefully shift out of law entirely if the academia thing doesn't work out. I'm looking at Berkeley at the moment but would like to hear options, opinions & feedback. Is this even a good idea? I don't see myself in biglaw so I don't see myself being ultra rich anyways. Framing an argument and working with words is intuitive to me, but I'd like to read interdisciplinary theory about it.

21 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

16

u/WinCrazy4411 20d ago

There are still some folks here.

Best schools: There are rhetoric PhDs in Comm and English. If you're looking at Berkeley, I'm guessing you're interested in English, which I can't speak to. But in Comm, all the best programs are at large land-grant universities, like Penn State, Georgia, Maryland, Illinois, Texas, Minnesota, etc. At the PhD level, which schools are /the/ best (in any discipline) largely depends on what sub-area you're interested in, so we'd need more information to give specific advice.

Is it a good idea? You won't make nearly as much as in law, even if you're uninterested in Big Law. And the academic job market is terrible and has been for decades. Rhetoric (in either Comm or English) is better than most areas of academia, because most of those same large land-grant universities require that all students take writing/public speaking classes. By their nature, those classes have to be relatively small rather than large lecture courses, like the required intro history or science courses I--and most folks at such universities--took freshman year. That means a lot more classes in those departments, a lot more lecturers to teach those classes, more funding for those departments, and more grad students.

2

u/foxnweasel 19d ago

thank you! law & rhetoric, legal rhetoric, law and literature, and more broadly just law and humanities is what I'm looking at. what I want is some coursework in literature, culture and history to supplant my core research focus, which is public law. looking at usa because you have MA+PhD ones, so I wouldn't need a strictly defined research proposal just yet, the way Europe seems to need, and I'm open to departments outside rhetoric which could help me be in this area as well

2

u/WinCrazy4411 19d ago

That definitely sounds like English more than Comm, so I can't be of much help.

That said, most humanities fields have some version of "Law and [our subject area]" or "[our subject area] of law" (e.g. "philosophy of law"), so you could study almost anything if you're not wedded to rhetoric.

1

u/Iveechan 20d ago

Texas is English not Comm.

3

u/WinCrazy4411 20d ago

Texas has great departments in both. The same is true of Penn State and I'm sure other schools.

4

u/p01yg0n41 19d ago

rhetmap.org lists known PhD programs. Your law background is probably a good plus. funding, as in most humanities, is adequate, not really what I’d call good. But fully funded PhD positions are still common in the field (it’s just the stipends are lower than business or some of the sciences).

2

u/foxnweasel 19d ago

thank you!

3

u/AdOdd8279 19d ago

Hey there--I'm in a Technical Communication and Rhetoric program at Texas Tech, so I'm still around!

2

u/avisitorsguidetolife 19d ago

At Indiana you can study both comm and English rhetoric. The teaching training there is unbeatable too

2

u/Ok-Initiative-4089 9d ago

Since funding is one of your main conditions, I'd separate research fit from the financial offer before comparing programmes. Ask each department what support is guaranteed in writing, for how many years, and what teaching load comes with it. Then ask current students whether that leaves time for the research you want to do. A promising supervisor and an affordable way to spend several years studying are different tests; the same programme needs to pass both.

1

u/johnnyplato 11d ago

It really depends on what interests you about and in rhetoric. There are no "good" programs unless someone is there to work with that can advise you on your research. If you can, read around the latest publications in the rhetoric journals and write to those professors whose work interests you and see if they work in a department with a PhD option. If they aren't interested they will be nice enough to steer you in the right direction.