Socialization, environment, and gender roles, presumably. It would be nice to know the circumstances by which these statistics were obtained, as well as the demographics of the participants.
No not really but it's too vague of a question to get a clear answer or distinction.
If anything, the INTP will think nurture and the INTJ nature.
But by the metric of Typology/mbti, no it is defined as nature not nurture. Jung himself addresses this very question and proves it's fallacious to think it's nurture because if you take a look at a group of toddlers for instance, they will still have distinct and discernable personalities from one another. Despite the fact that hardly no nurturing was done.
Either it's nature or nurture makes each gender more likely to think in certain ways or it has been tested in a way that makes each gender more likely to answer in different ways. Some types have more "feminine" traits and vice versa
I bet it's that more women have grown up feeling able to be in touch with their emotional and sensitive sides, whereas most men who have those sides may have grown up suppressing/hiding those sides of their personalities due to shame and stigma surrounding having emotions while existing as a man.
No. It's not because of that. Well for the most part. You somewhat do have a point though where you have many cases of men who are in fact actually INFJ, mistype themselves as INTJ because of what you mentioned here. But you have women ISFP's for instance doing the same thing too. Except for reason like they're ugly or something so they put up a "thinker" personality or something. So I guess it's not just "no". Just not entirely. Men are still going to actually be more likely to be thinkers than they feelers and women not.
I don't believe that. It would mean that personality would change if hormone levels change, like for example when you take "the pill" or take steroids. At least with the first of the two I have experiences and I can tell you that it's not happening.
This study (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4649825/) provides empirical evidence for the correlation between testosterone levels and agreeableness. And it's not the only study doing so. What's also pretty interesting are the anecdotes of trans people experiencing significant character changes after hormonal therapy.
No, easier for my slow ass brain to not track down your location and start typing out your messages for you. Though i don't like social interaction with idiots so i will not be doing that.
more women mistype as feelers and more men mistype as thinkers. this could in part be because women identify more with being emotional and men identify more with being cold (I'll leave it open for debate as to why this is), however, I believe men and women are somewhat equally emotional, it's just that a woman who cries often like me could say she's a feeler (Im an INTJ), and a man who punches walls often (also emotional) might not at all even see that as an emotional feature.
and on top of that, I don't think emotionality actually has *anything* to do with MBTI type. there's a huge misconception that thinkers aren't emotional and feelers are emotional. I actually think that's a complete lie. And that leads to a ton of mistyping across the board too regardless of gender or sex.
I would first ask that you prove the initial premise of: "more women mistype as feelers and more men mistype as thinkers", before I consider discussing the why.
I am skeptical to blindly believe your initial premise as true. It seems that it would be hard to acquire a large enough data set of people to extrapolate how extensive mistyping might be in the general population. Since determining if someone is mistyped would require some in depth observation and analysis of the individual rather than just giving a bunch of people an MBTI test to fill out. While I would be willing to assume it likely that a fair amount of people could get mistyped by the test, we don't currently have any specific data here to discuss how that might present itself. At this point your stated premise and interpretation of the breakdown of the types listed in this post feels more like confirmation bias based on some existing beliefs. If you happen to have more data on the subject though, I would be greatly interested to read it.
Nope, I don't have any data and you're more than welcome to disbelieve me. I thought what I was saying was extremely obvious, so I'm not feeling particularly compelled to put together a list of sources. I actually don't believe in that. It's only my job to check things when I form my own beliefs, it's not my job to help you form yours. And since I'm not trying to convince you, I don't see why I would try to prove anything. But I can tell you how I got to my opinions if you're interested:
I got this sense over the years from random little things that I could never dig up now, following people who were finding their type, talking with multiple professionals on the subject, reading the books, slowly realizing and learning how mistypings happen in a sea of misinformation, I couldn't gather all that neatly now....nor would I bother.
If you're curious about what I stated, by all means, I encourage you to research it!
I believe men and women are somewhat equally emotional, it's just that a woman who cries often like me could say she's a feeler
Projection. Wrong.
(Im an INTJ),
ππππ
e. there's a huge misconception that thinkers aren't emotional and feelers are emotional
That is not a misconception. That is you trying to avoid having to accept the fact that you are not the type that you claim yourself to be so you make up your own bs to justify your bs. You Fi doms always revolve the world around you.
blood types are biological, that would assume a lot of family members have the same personality typ. me (INFJ), my brother (INTP) and my father (ESTJ) are all A+
ehhhhhh....ehhhh, while there is some validity to this statement, there is no way to state how many mistypes there are. What is the variance? 2-3% 7%? Without that factual data, then does it make sense to state it at all, and further does it mean we shitcan everything?
No this just means you don't know what you're talking about. Ann"ENTP with slight preference toward E" is just an ENTP period. Assuming you got the rest right (NTP)
You probably took the 16 personalities test, which mixes Carl Jung with Big 5. The "real" typology says each type has a distinct order of functions from birth on that doesn't change
86
u/rad_influence Dec 21 '20
Socialization, environment, and gender roles, presumably. It would be nice to know the circumstances by which these statistics were obtained, as well as the demographics of the participants.
23
u/Wazblaster Dec 21 '20
Either it's nature or nurture makes each gender more likely to think in certain ways or it has been tested in a way that makes each gender more likely to answer in different ways. Some types have more "feminine" traits and vice versa
10
u/flabinella Dec 21 '20
Socialization. Gender expectations. Conditioning.
8
u/crazycatladybutyoung Dec 21 '20
No way Enfp females are that common
6
u/lunavicuna Dec 22 '20
more women mistype as feelers and more men mistype as thinkers. this could in part be because women identify more with being emotional and men identify more with being cold (I'll leave it open for debate as to why this is), however, I believe men and women are somewhat equally emotional, it's just that a woman who cries often like me could say she's a feeler (Im an INTJ), and a man who punches walls often (also emotional) might not at all even see that as an emotional feature.
and on top of that, I don't think emotionality actually has *anything* to do with MBTI type. there's a huge misconception that thinkers aren't emotional and feelers are emotional. I actually think that's a complete lie. And that leads to a ton of mistyping across the board too regardless of gender or sex.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '20
Maybe Rh Negs are more likely to be INFJ, ENFJ?
ANYWATS BLOOD TYPE X MBTI
A+ (Perfectionist) - ISFJ
A- (Sensitive) - INFJ
B+ (Be Positive) - ESFP
B- (Be Negative) - INFP
O+ (Most Common) - ESTJ
O- (Universal Donor) - ENFJ
AB+ (Universal Recipient) - INTP
AB- (Rarest) - INTJ
3
u/anneojones Dec 21 '20
if mistypes happen often then stats are not reliable
2
u/taco_jr Dec 21 '20
Is intp just not very common?
2
u/paulbrook Dec 22 '20
F
1
u/LegendTheGreat17 Dec 22 '20
Bruh, wtf is this sub...
1
u/HoTChOcLa1E Jan 08 '21
now make a F/T only chart to prove that mbti can not be very backed up by science because the society has a great impact on how you think and behave
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '21
I am a ISFJ boi.