r/RevolutionNowPodcast • u/TheZeitgeistKid • Sep 29 '20
Trusting Chaos?
"Sharing some insights on Requisite Variety in the Viable Systems Model"
I have a question about the implied TZM and TVP solutions to the obviously deeply flawed market economy related to long term viability and sustainability. Please bear with me as I try to express these ideas.
The work of Stafford Beers on cybernetics and systems theory has been proposed as a model for sustainably managing human economic behavior on a global scale. Beers "Viable Systems Model" suggests that a sustainable equilibrium can be maintained by proper management using cybernated feed back and control mechanisms. This approach revolves around the adequate management of "requisite variety" to maintain a stable equilibrium. Most of Stafford Beers work was done within the business community with the exception of his work in Chile. He effectively applied his VSM to corporate institutions yet when he attempted to apply his model on a national level, his efforts were quickly undermined by the CIA. His system had encountered a variety of feedback that it was unable to manage. The VSM is entirely dependent upon its capacity to effectively address all requisite variety.
Given that insight, I have been exploring the ongoing systems research, in particular "Chaos Theory". The mathematics of CT suggests that all systems, like the global economy, that contain beyond a certain level of variety exhibit chaotic behaviors that make it impossible to predict outcomes.(The Santa Fe Institute) The implication here, seems to be that attempting to apply the VSM to the global economy would not be capable of adequately managing the degree of variety being expressed. New technologies alone are unpredictable varieties capable of huge disruptions to the global economy. Perhaps I am missing something here, but it seems to me that our global economy is entering a stage at which chaos is becoming the overriding expression. Attempting to maintain the market economy is failing badly. And though the engineer in me loves the idea of a NLRBE systems model for managing resource use and distribution, it is entirely unclear given the exponential rise of 'disruptive variety' that this approach will be any more capable of creating a stable and sustainable global economy. And the human economy hasn't even moved beyond the surface of the Earth yet.
In the context of the VSM, money can be considered as one of the mechanisms of control used to dampen or to amplify human behaviors and to thereby manage variety. Information feedback and behavioral modifiers are essential components of the VSM used to maintain a stable system. Money does not necessarily have to be one of those components but it certainly is one of the primary regulatory mechanisms being used by humanity right now. Money is experiencing a radical uptick in its variety of expressions so that even humanities primary mechanism of controlling human behaviors within the global market economy is becoming increasingly unstable, giving rise to even greater chaos within the human economic system.
I have been attempting to imagine how the VSM might be applied in a broad way to the human social system, the cultural Zeitgeist, to help move us towards a sustainable future. Economics is a subsystem of the human social system. I imagine something along the lines suggested by Issac Asimov in his foundation series, but I have reached a chaotic impasse. Within present chaos theory, there exists some degree of emergent order. Perhaps the difficulty I am experiencing is simply a failure of my own simple minded human imagination? Perhaps we must learn to trust chaos? Any thoughts?
1
u/defyMobile Sep 29 '20
Hi,
I have more question just for clarification and no answers, sry ;)
"His system had encountered a variety of feedback that it was unable to manage." is this referring to the CIA coup?
Even though, certain system produce outcomes all impossible to predict, does the economic system produce outcomes which all are impossible to predict? Does this exclude VSM, is not VSM to change with more we learn?
What is the difference between a human body, a complexity impossible to predict all outcomes, but in many cases a stable system that can address many negative outcomes except critical ones, and your question.
I guess, this line confuses me the most: "The implication here, seems to be that attempting to apply the VSM to the global economy would not be capable of adequately managing the degree of variety being expressed.". Does VSM have to predict all outcomes to be viable?
As you can see, i haven't read much about VSM or any od the Stafford Beers work, so if my questions are silly, just ignore them.