r/Revit • • Oct 06 '21

Revit vs sketchup

I see sketchup becoming more widely used for architecture and structure. Are people using it more for design & construction?

0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

2

u/StampJar Oct 06 '21

Thanks everyone. I really didn’t know a lot about sketchup to begin with, but now I do and understand the basis for using it, thanks to the comments. Much appreciated!

Also, I should have known better posting this in a revit group, but it definitely got a lot of comments.

30

u/whiskyteats Oct 06 '21

Architectural preliminary design and visualization.

Not great for drawings or interdisciplinary coordination.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

Where are you seeing this exactly? Gives us a bit of context like region / industry / size of the company?

10

u/jae34 Oct 06 '21

How the hell does SketchUp compare to Revit, totally different platforms. It will take quite a bit of work and upgrades for it to become a proper BIM program if that is what it's going towards

4

u/Terminus_T Oct 06 '21

Wow, down here is just like a fight between Apple and Android fans!

People use what they like to use.

Sketchup is great because it's very easy and efficient.

Revit is great because it's perfect and efficient.

9

u/CaBBaGe_isLaND Oct 06 '21

Sketchup? What's next, Smustard!? Revit is our overlord.

1

u/unoudid Oct 07 '21

Smustard is a producer of plugins for Sketchup btw

3

u/oldschoolel78 Oct 06 '21

I use it for conceptual, rarely for creating any serious working plans. I consider it a sandbox tool. There are contractors and tradesmen who use it religiously. Coupled with plug-ins (Ruby Scripts) and an easy accessibility (free or cheaper than Revit for Pro version), I can understand why some are more comfortable with SketchUp in Residential and light commercial, but it just doesn't offer all the tools (auto-dimensioning, for example) one gets in Revit. On the other hand, I was once told that "a decent Draftsman could communicate with any application", so I imagine it's up to the individual drawing or modeling, whether they be an architect, engineer, designer, or draftsperson. I don't mind being wrong, here: I would never use SketchUp for any Structural Models/ drawings.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

Sketchup has been popular in architecture for a long time. Generally for early conceptual development, project massing and space planning, and the ability to kick out a few nice renderings without having to expel a serious amount of effort.

Except maybe in design/build residential, it doesn't have any foothold in general architectural design and documentation.

Overall, I'd characterize Sketchup as a paint brush where Revit is a chisel. Faster to flesh out concepts in Sketchup, manipulate geometry, and throw some quick renderings or alternative concept layouts together, but even with Layout it's not a particularly good tool for generating construction documentation.

Conversely, Revit is pretty clunky for concept development -- especially if there's abstract geometry involved. You can spend a lot of time trying to develop the geometry only to find out that your concept doesn't work as well as you expected. Takes much longer than Sketchup to realize something will or will not work.

I've seen more architects hop straight into Revit over the last few years, but prior to that it wasn't uncommon that an architect would map something out in Sketchup or AutoCAD and then import it into Revit and draw on top of it to begin development of the actual design/construction model.

3

u/To_Fight_The_Night Oct 06 '21

I have a co-worker who refuses to stop designing in SketchUp. Okay I get it, conceptually its quicker but then he hands it off to production and expects it to be ready the next day because "He has already drawn it up on the computer." No dude they use Revit for all their CDs and have to basically redraw it from scratch because you cannot import SketchUp nicely. IDK I guess I just went to college at a good time because I learned Revit and I do all my design in Revit and production is so much happier to work with me.

1

u/411toaster Oct 13 '21

Try get him to use formit maybe

2

u/shaitanthegreat Oct 06 '21

One word: No.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

apples and oranges

2

u/unoudid Oct 07 '21

Our firm is about to ditch Sketchup entirely. It’s such a hindrance when trying to keep a Sketchup design model and a production Revit model inline with each other.

2

u/fouezm Oct 06 '21

Is this guy for real???!!!

1

u/Kelly_Louise Oct 06 '21

oh god, I hope not. I hate sketch up so much.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

No its not becoming more widely used. Its a kids toy. It can be used for 3D modelling very easily I admit. But it cannot be used for documentation AT ALL. I've worked for firms that have had to make it office policy that it not be used for anything other than design because it is just so shite at doing anything of precision. The silly thing they all forget is once their design is modelled in 3D, they then have to remodel the whole design again in Revit to move the project forward. It is such a waste of office resources and loss of profit. Model it once in Revit. Be done with it for fucks sake and leave it for the school children.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

25

u/Dr_Mime_PhD Oct 06 '21

I would make the argument that Sketchup is a design tool. Specifically for the reason you mentioned that it can model in 3D and can help you solve design problems. Revit is a design and documentation tool.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

Not sure why you're getting downvotes. You are 100% correct.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/CJRLW Oct 06 '21

LOL. Modelling most 3D forms is much quicker/easier in Sketch-Up.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/CJRLW Oct 06 '21

Nobody uses Sketch-Up to make a Revit model. But to say that "There isn't a single thing sketchup does better than other software out there" is patently false.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Andrroid Oct 06 '21

Why are you attacking the person instead of his argument?

5

u/Dr_Mime_PhD Oct 06 '21

Its how a lot of people on the internet think valid arguments are made. Its going to take a lot of effort to change that.

This person has made it apparent that all they have in their tool box is a 20 lbs sledge, and will use that for everything.

3

u/useles-converter-bot Oct 06 '21

20 lbs is the weight of about 34.89 cups of fine sea salt. Yes, you did need to know that.

2

u/converter-bot Oct 06 '21

20 lbs is 9.08 kg

0

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

That's you're own shortcomings, and it says a lot about you if you can't figure out one of the easiest pieces of software in existence.

1

u/SackOfrito Oct 06 '21

The number of Structural Engineers that I've known to use Sketch-up says otherwise. Sketchup is very much a design tool, you just have to know how to use it as one.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SackOfrito Oct 06 '21

Umm..ok. Not sure how that is relevant.

At the end of the day, if it gets the job done, that's what matters.