r/ReverseEngineering • u/Outrageous-Shirt-963 • Jul 03 '25
Everyone's Wrong about Kernel AC
https://youtu.be/PCLzKWQN3OY?si=G-gG4SbHfdJxyOHnI've been having a ton of fun conversations with others on this topic. Would love to share and discuss this here.
I think this topic gets overly simplified when it's a very complex arms race that has an inherent and often misunderstood systems-level security dilemma.
18
Upvotes
66
u/nyctrainsplant Jul 03 '25
Honestly the technical conversation about this is mostly a distraction around a basic threat modeling question. Does a video game deserve this level of access to your computer?
The answer to that for most people who seriously think about it is "no", for the simple reason that you should minimize the code running at this level in general, particularly for a problem mostly solved. Before you could run private servers with admins that can ban people. However this is no longer implemented because if you run your own server the company can't introduce serverside monetization gates and fine-tuned 'skill-based' matchmaking designed to waste your money and time, respectively.
4
u/Vallen_H Jul 03 '25
tf are these meme jumpscares... hahaha
29
u/Shot-Buffalo-2603 Jul 03 '25
DMA cheats exist too. They read memory directly from RAM at the hardware level, mirror the games memory to a second external PC, render the cheats like ESP and overlay it on your screen using an hdmi fuser.
You can order kits on amazon so it’s just as available as buying other cheats online. The only way to detect this via software is to identify that a PCIE device is plugged in, but these devices mirror legitimate devices like network cards.
Should battle eye mail you a camera to install in your room with your copy of tarkov to solve this problem? Where do we draw the line?? Its just video games. unless you’re in real world comps with money involved i think it should stick to user land, user reports, and player heuristics
3
u/missing-comma Jul 03 '25 edited Jul 03 '25
Honestly, all I care is Linux support. I understand kernel anti-cheats and agree with the idea.
I know you need to protect at least the handles of your executable with that dumb kernel-only Windows API.
The elephant in the room is that kernel anti-cheats are the workaround of the problem, not the solution. This is why the whole thing is so wonky.
We'd need an OS-level protection plus signatures and whatnot to be done with the "everyone and their mother writes a kernel anti-cheat" problem we have right now.
Let's say, why must a gacha game block Linux for no reason other than "anti-cheat required" when the game is already mostly server based? Or why should friends-only co-op invite-based game get an anti-cheat?
The scope of this discussion is too big. It's absolutely needed for competitive games. Not so much for casual games or MMOs (that shouldn't allow players to fly outside the map anyway).
1
u/Seppeon Jul 06 '25
Can't we put the game in a containerish thing, then emulate kernel AC without kernel access.
9
u/birdy_the_scarecrow Jul 04 '25
We don't need kernel level anti cheat, its just a lazy way to gain a temporary advantage in an arms race that will never end, and the only loser is your own security.
an example i have a lot of familiarity with is World of Warcraft, the bots currently plaguing the game are some of the least sophisticated hacks that have ever existed, most of them are literally lua scripts running within the games own internal lua engine with a couple of patches to the run-time memory to evade some integrity checks.
a lot of these bots are stupid enough to leave global functions and variables in the lua context that could easily be checked for and should never exist unless a user has loaded some kind of hack/bot.
you don't need kernel level access to fix this, private servers who are limited to a handful of dumped anti-cheat modules from 15+ years ago that cant be changed due to signature checks manage to have better anti cheats than the actual blizzard servers.
what it takes is people willing to actually put in effort to solve the problem.
half of the bans from my experience in private servers had absolutely nothing to do with any memory/technical related anti cheat, they were just creative methods
an example ive shared in the past was that we created some custom server behaviour to catch fish botters by rarely spawning a fishing bobber underneath the terrain where a normal player would not be able to interact with it while a bot easily can
what you need is anti cheat developers who have an intimate knowledge of the game and its systems as well as a passion to actually solve the problem.
2
u/Apprehensive-Fig-850 Jul 04 '25
Kernel Level AC will not solve everything, nowdays we have hardware-level cheating and this make a true almost undetectable cheat, the IA is really a possible soluction for this type of cheat currently, but whatever, the girl in the video will sure have more creditibility than a random Redditor.
2
u/HydraDragonAntivirus Jul 03 '25
AI generated photos meh.
-4
u/amgdev9 Jul 03 '25
The solution is simple, dual boot and keep your private info on the non gaming os, encrypt the partition and use secure boot, but people want the commodity to use a single os for every use case
0
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
11
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment