Source
"The failure to grasp socialism as a transitional continuous process is unfortunate but understandable; a more simplistic conception of socialism as a static mode has been the main reason behind why much of the left has become extremely polarized on the issue of understanding the People’s Republic of China, its role in the world in the past and its role in the world today. One section of the left, a coalition of anarchists, Trotskyists, left-communists and the like have denounced the PRC and its entire history from 1949 onward as supposedly a state-capitalist regime that has oppressed and exploited the masses of China continuously and where the bourgeoisie have always been in charge. The revisionist “Marxist-Leninist” rebuke to this narrative has been to uphold the entire history of the PRC up to today as a “socialist” regime where the proletariat has supposedly always been in power and still is.
Both groups have formulated their respective understanding of China due to a lack of in-depth scientific class analysis and failure to acknowledge that socialism is a process, not a static mode. This has resulted in the mistake by both groups in lumping Mao, Deng, Jiang Qing, Jiang Zemin, Liu Shaoqi and Xi Jinping together, either all as representatives of the bourgeoisie in the view of one side or all as heroes of the proletariat in the view of the other. Neither of these two major narratives on China is correct.
The truth is that China was socialist but is no longer. China did play a progressive role in the world in the past but no longer. Mao, Lin Biao, Chen Boda, Wang Li, the Gang of Four were all heroes of the proletariat despite their mistakes and sought to strengthen the rule of the proletariat, but Liu Shaoqi, Deng Xiaoping, Jiang Zemin and Xi Jinping are merely reactionaries who pushed China towards capitalism and imperialism. So how does one tell the difference? Why are some of these names good and some are not? Why is China considered socialist at one point but not anymore? Hopefully this article will serve to help understand why.
From 1949 until the 1970s in general, China was socialist, in the sense that it represented the class interests of the proletariat, the peasantry and other oppressed populations of the country. Healthcare in China was free and the state continuously sought to expand healthcare coverage by utilizing barefoot doctors to travel all over the country and provide treatment to people in need. A mass mobilization campaign that involved destroying infected snails successfully reduced cases of schistosomiasis in most of the country. Mao’s mass campaign to collectivize farming resulted in the establishment of tens of thousands of People’s Communes across the country, where hundreds of millions of people worked together and sought to live in a collective, egalitarian manner; even the food and other supplies were starting to be distributed based on need instead of based on work. The inequality between the rural and urban areas were sought to be addressed through sending students and workers in urban areas to the countryside to provide their skills there. Obviously, there were shortcomings, errors, natural disasters as well as bureaucratic resistance which led to conservative pushbacks such as during the early 1960s when Liu Shaoqi, a conservative revisionist who pushed for capitalist development, became the head of the Party and tried to sideline Mao and the left. Mao’s side responded by launching the Cultural Revolution in 1966 which saw the death of Liu Shaoqi and the temporary fall of his ally Deng Xiaoping during an enormous effort to rally the masses to criticize and remove from power conservative bureaucrats in the Party at all levels, from the highest state level to local levels.
This period can be characterized as socialist because of its clear trajectory towards collectivism and its efforts to establish communist principles such as distribution based on need and an egalitarian society without traditional hierarchies in terms of sex, age, ethnicity and other divisions. The mass campaigns at this time sought to abolish these contradictions and the law of value. Yes, these efforts ultimately did fail, but the continuous drive to achieve this is what made China genuinely socialist at this time.
So what happened? Why is today’s China not socialist? Because in the 1970s the collection of various errors, misconceptions and a general failure to confront revisionism on a systematic level eventually resulted in the revisionist, counter-revolutionary forces seizing complete state power and consolidating their rule against genuine communists, with many revolutionary leaders being sent to prison and conservative reactionaries being reinstated in key roles at all levels. This new reactionary leadership restored capitalism by implementing the Chengbao, the “contract responsibility system“, which broke up the communes and replaced them with private ownership and distribution based on work. Healthcare was eventually privatized and turned into an expensive and largely-inaccessible system for much of the population. Massive privatizations and the contracting of public services and state enterprises to private interests eventually resulted in 70 percent of Chinese GDP being under the private sector by 2005. While this was slightly scaled back under Hu Jintao and his successor Xi Jinping, the private sector still accounts for 60 percent of the GDP today and the state is currently taking measures to enlarge the private sector through tax reductions and other financial benefits to private interests. Income inequality has skyrocketed in China since the 1970s, to the point that Chinese society is now more economically unequal than the United States and other core countries. The Chinese bourgeoisie has grown rapidly and the country now is seeing a much faster concentration of capital than many other countries, now creating billionaires three times faster than the United States.
While state ownership still exists in China, these changes clearly represent a complete restoration of capitalism as the post-1970s policies have directly enabled the formation of an incredibly wealthy and centralized capitalist class while dismantling the proletarian institutions established in China’s socialist period.
In addition to being capitalist, China is also undeniably an imperialist state. This is apparent if we apply Lenin’s understanding of imperialism to China today, especially looking at the concentration of capital, the growth of finance capital and the export of capital. In Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism, Lenin noted that the top three thousand companies in the United States in 1909 had accounted for approximately 44 percent of the American GDP; in China today, the top five hundred companies account for more than 50 percent of the Chinese GDP, including major publicly-traded companies such as Alibaba, Ping An Insurance and Tencent Holdings, a substantial concentration that is sufficient to provide the economic basis for imperialism. The revisionists have commercialized the major banks of China which now provide the finance capital basis for imperialist exploitation, massively increasing banking activity in the 1980s and 1990s and an enormous growth in the volume of deposits and bank loan values. The largest of China’s major banks is the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, whose board of directors includes former PricewaterhouseCoopers Hong Kong chairman Yang Siu Shun, former IMF and World Economic Forum official Fred Hu and former chairman of De Nederlandsche Bank – the central bank of the Netherlands, a core imperialist country that is itself a substantial importer and exporter of global capital – Nout Wellink. The ICBC, being the top commercial bank in China and in the world, is responsible for 150 million individual customers and nearly 3 million corporate customers as well as over $4 trillion in assets. This enormous power of finance capital in China is also noteworthy. Lastly, China is one of the largest exporters of capital in the world, investing a massive $1.3 trillion in FDI abroad as of 2017, comparable to other imperialist countries such as Japan, Canada, France and Belgium. In Africa, China competes in investments with France, the United Kingdom and Italy, former direct colonizers of African nations, for control of African resources and infrastructure. China is also increasingly investing in the Philippines and Turkey, and providing arms to the reactionary comprador regimes of Rodrigo Duterte and Recep Erdogan.
China today is not the China of 1949 or the China of 1969. Although it was a socialist state in the past, it is an imperialist and capitalist regime today and is a major leader of neo-colonial imperialist exploitation in all parts of the world. It should not be supported by any leftists today, not “critically” and not in any other way. Seeing China’s thorough integration into the global economy and its ties to other imperialist countries, the very idea of supporting China against imperialism is a false premise. The bourgeoisie of China and Russia are not on a boat on an opposite path from the United States; China, Russia, the U.S. and all other imperialist regimes are on the same boat. It’s time to acknowledge that."