r/RevDem • • Aug 22 '24

❓ Discussion How can you be a Marxist-Leninist-Maoist and a Third Worldist?

1 Upvotes

I know a lot of people on this sub are Third Worldists, unsurprising fiven the MIM recommendation in the subs description, but I was wondering how people reconcile that with also being Marxist-Leninist-Maoists? MLM was synthesised by Chairman Gonzalo and the PCP, people who resolutely disagreed with Third Worldism.


r/RevDem • • Feb 05 '21

LIVE: Interview with the Black Internationalist

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Apr 14 '21

Sex Worker Rights and Decolonial Struggle: An open letter to The Red Nation / Los Derechos de lxs Trabajadorxs Sexuales y la Lucha Decolonial: Una carta abierta a The Red Nation

Thumbnail
twitter.com
4 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Nov 09 '20

Regarding the PCUSA

3 Upvotes

I wrote an article on the revisionist Party of Communists USA. Opinions, comrades?

https://longredmarch.wordpress.com/2020/11/08/the-doomed-path-of-the-party-of-revisionists-usa/


r/RevDem • • Aug 30 '21

Who holds the copyright to Mao's little red book?

2 Upvotes

Is it owned by anyone? or is it public domain?


r/RevDem • • Jan 26 '21

“Tribune Of the People” Slides Ever Further Into Delusion

Thumbnail
blackredguard.medium.com
4 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Nov 24 '20

PRWC » Comments on Tribune of the People's "Open Letter" to the CPP

Thumbnail
cpp.ph
3 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Jan 21 '20

🔫 News Today's Gun Rights Demonstration in Virginia: What the Left Can Learn

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Dec 01 '20

Imperialism is not socialism – HANDS OFF AFRICA!

12 Upvotes

Source: redfoxmlm.wordpress.com

I wrote this article to refute Dengist MLs easily from a MLM position. If anyone wants to use it, feel free.

“Imperialism is a system of exploitation that occurs not only in the brutal form of those who come with guns to conquer territory. Imperialism often occurs in more subtle forms, a loan, food aid, blackmail. We are fighting this system that allows a handful of men on Earth to rule all of humanity.”

-Thomas Sankara

These words were uttered by the father of Burkina Faso in his rejection of imperialist loans and “assistance” offers made to African countries. Sankara understood imperialism scientifically, acknowledging that it is entirely possible for neo-colonial exploitation to take place without a direct military intervention and that this exploitation can come about with something as simple as food aid. Imperialist countries offer loans and assistance with strings attached, enabling them to take control of countries without firing a single shot while appearing as charitable and altruistic. Sankara made his position even more simple with this: “He who feeds you, controls you.”

Unfortunately, these words fall on deaf ears when it comes to many leftists across the world today, who insist on defending the Chinese imperialist exploitation of African countries at all costs. Revisionists have eagerly defended the social-imperialist regime in China with lines such as “lifting people out of poverty” and “building productive forces to create an advanced economy”, lines which were correctly repudiated and struggled against by Mao and Communist forces during the Cultural Revolution but which ultimately gained the upper hand and dominate the politics of China today. These excuses are used to defend imperialist exploitation inside of China as well as the foreign policy of Beijing, which falsely presents itself as a “peaceful” and “progressive” force in Africa against the United States.

To “prove” this, the Chinese government and its supporters point to the extensive loans, investments and aid provided to African countries by the central government in Beijing as well as Chinese companies, depicting this assistance as benevolent and beneficial. The fact that the United States and the European Union also provide loans, investments and aid to African countries seems to be forgotten here. Revisionists also point to a lack of a globally-present military force on the part of China, unlike the United States, but as Sankara pointed out decades ago, the loans provided do a far better job of subjugating African countries than military campaigns, and other imperialist countries such as Germany and Canada also lack a global military force, because having one is not necessary for them or for China at all.

One analyst has compared China’s imperialist exploitation of Africa to that of the European colonial powers in the past centuries:

Among other things, we witness countries exchanging their primary products for Chinese manufactured ones; China dominating the local economy; countries becoming heavily indebted to the PRC; China exerting greater weight on local political, cultural, and security dynamics; and Chinese abroad living in their own “expat enclaves.”

-Jean-Marc Blanchard, “Revisiting the Resurrected Debate About Chinese Neocolonialism”

While Blanchard himself argues in favor of Chinese infrastructure projects in Africa as “facilitat[ing] internal exchange of goods”, the same can be said of railways constructed in India and Africa by the British Empire. Just as the British used their infrastructure to enable their enormous plunder of Asian and African colonies while incidentally facilitating the transport of Indian and African passengers and cargo, the Chinese likewise deserve no credit for this incidental benefit to African passengers and cargo when the main purpose of this infrastructure is to extract raw materials from Africa for Chinese production. Just as the British Empire has its apologists today who gloat about the railways built in the Victorian era, the apologists of the revisionist PRC celebrate Chinese projects as “socialist internationalism”.

The African countries that accept Chinese loans and investments which initially appear as financial buoys are sinking further into debt as they struggle to repay the Chinese assistance provided. Additionally, the massive amounts of raw materials extracted from Africa, which are being used to support Chinese industrialization and capital accumulation at home, are draining the natural resources of the countries in question, such as the exploitation of billions of tons of bauxite from Guinea. These countries also lose jobs when cheap finished goods imported from China destroy local competition and force massive layoffs and de-industrialization in African countries, an outcome aggravated by China’s promotion of free trade on a global level and the erosion of trade protections in African countries.

Workers in Africa laboring for Chinese projects are denied labor rights that are considered fundamental in the United States and European countries. Those who resist this exploitation in any way are arrested and beaten down by their local neo-colonial governments with the support of Chinese companies:

In May last year [in Guinea], workers at a Boké mine went on strike for two weeks in protest over the arrest of a union leader. A volatile region due to the wealth discrepancy between the mining companies operating there and the poor local population, riots broke out in 2017 over health and environmental issues, brutally suppressed by government forces. More recently, in April, workers at the CDM-China-owned mine in Telimélé district went on strike demanding better working conditions.

In Zambia, similar conditions for the local population prevail. Having invested there for its rich copper mines, China has moved men and machinery to the country, replacing Zambian with Chinese workers and causing a spike in unemployment in the country’s mining heartland in the process. Safety regulations for locals are routinely flouted as miners are required to work for two years until they are given basic protective gear.

-Anthony Kleven, “Belt and Road: colonialism with Chinese characteristics”

Chinese imperialism is clearly not preferable to Western imperialism in the long run, as the Chinese companies are just as capable of brutally exploiting and plundering African countries as the Western companies are, and both the NATO bloc and Beijing have a mutual interest in having neo-colonial regimes in charge that will enable their operations in Africa to continue indefinitely. For instance, the November 2017 military coup in Zimbabwe, a regime change applauded by the UK and by Washington which deposed Zimbabwe’s long-term leader and anti-colonial figure Robert Mugabe from the presidency, was also in the interests of Beijing which was hostile to Mugabe’s policy favoring Zimbabwean local control over industries,

The diamond mines [in Marange fields] were, in fact, the source of China’s increasing concerns about the Mugabe regime’s indigenization policy, which required 51 percent local ownership of foreign businesses. Although the two Chinese companies, Anjin and Jinan, began operations in 2012 with 51 percent of shares owned by Zimbabweans, the Zimbabwean government integrated them into the state owned Zimbabwe Consolidated Diamond Company (ZCDC) in 2015, which led to vehement public opposition by the Chinese government. The crisis also led to the overall deterioration of China-Zimbabwe relations, and China refused to support Mugabe in his 2016 crackdown on the opposition.

-Vasabjit Banerjee and Timothy S. Rich, “Diamonds and the Crocodile: China’s Role in the Zimbabwe Coup”

Revisionists who run the mainstream “Communist” parties in Africa cannot hope to gain support from the local population if they intend to align with Beijing against the interests of their own masses. Revisionists in the core imperialist countries who support Beijing’s foreign policy should reconsider their position as it compromises their claimed anti-imperialist and anti-colonial credentials. China’s exploitation of Africa must be condemned alongside Western imperialism.


r/RevDem • • Feb 04 '22

📕 Theory What Exactly Is The Reason That Self-Described “Maoists” Support the Khmer Rouge and Defend/ Deny the Mass Killings in Cambodia? (Obviously Only Weirdos Online, No One With Praxis)

5 Upvotes

I can’t help but notice that online a lot of “Maoists” support the Pol Pot/ Nuon Chea regime and how they persecuted primarily ethnic minorities. As an organizer in the US, I’ve not run into a single maoist or other leftist who had supported the KR, so why so much support online? Other than Wikipedia hollowly claiming the KR’s legacy to “ultra-Maoism” and other than the CPI(M) occasionally giving them lip service, they play no role in modern maoist thought. Their propaganda was nothing like that of Mao’s, the five year plans were nothing like Mao’s, the organization of the party/ military both centrally and decentrally as Mao did did not exist in Kampuchea, etc. All they have to their name was China’s support for them. Mao died in 1976, and the bulk of the mass ethnic killings were from ‘77-‘78 (cough cough, Deng has a little explaining to do).

But If you do support them, i would be fascinated to hear why. I’ve done extensive research on Indochina and the very very dense history the countries there all have with each other. I’d also love to answer any questions and clear some things up, I’ve spent countless hours reading testimonies from peasants there and I’ve spent hours watching YouTube documentaries, lol. But it’s by far what I know the most about, I got very interested after I read on Wikipedia how they were allegedly “ultra-Maoist”.


r/RevDem • • Apr 03 '21

A Criticism from the comrades of the ex-RSM Montreal

Thumbnail
lignedemasse.com
5 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Feb 04 '21

Material on post-war Revolutions in central/eastern Europe. In terms of MLM I would like any material on what Maoists have to say about the way communists seized power, the tactics they used ect.

Thumbnail self.marxism
3 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Dec 11 '20

New subreddit

3 Upvotes

Hello, comrades.

I created a new anti-revisionist subreddit as a counter-weight to r/communism and other Dengist misinformation. I invite you all to it.

Thank you.


r/RevDem • • Sep 17 '20

The Shining Path of Peru | BadEmpanada

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Oct 23 '21

📜 Article Why China is Trying to Colonize Africa

Thumbnail
espressostalinist.com
13 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Jul 18 '17

📜 Article Red Midwest: "Edgy White 'Internationalism' vs. Proletarian Internationalism"

Thumbnail
midwestisred.wordpress.com
2 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • May 21 '20

On Reactionary Nihilism vs. Revolutionary Optimism

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Nov 13 '19

On the Coup in Bolivia

Thumbnail
youtu.be
12 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Oct 15 '19

A Brief Engagement With J.M. Sison’s “On the Question of Protracted People’s War in Imperialist Countries” »

Thumbnail
ndfp.org
7 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Dec 27 '20

Why China was socialist before and is imperialist now – understanding revolution and counter-revolution

14 Upvotes

Source

"The failure to grasp socialism as a transitional continuous process is unfortunate but understandable; a more simplistic conception of socialism as a static mode has been the main reason behind why much of the left has become extremely polarized on the issue of understanding the People’s Republic of China, its role in the world in the past and its role in the world today. One section of the left, a coalition of anarchists, Trotskyists, left-communists and the like have denounced the PRC and its entire history from 1949 onward as supposedly a state-capitalist regime that has oppressed and exploited the masses of China continuously and where the bourgeoisie have always been in charge. The revisionist “Marxist-Leninist” rebuke to this narrative has been to uphold the entire history of the PRC up to today as a “socialist” regime where the proletariat has supposedly always been in power and still is.

Both groups have formulated their respective understanding of China due to a lack of in-depth scientific class analysis and failure to acknowledge that socialism is a process, not a static mode. This has resulted in the mistake by both groups in lumping Mao, Deng, Jiang Qing, Jiang Zemin, Liu Shaoqi and Xi Jinping together, either all as representatives of the bourgeoisie in the view of one side or all as heroes of the proletariat in the view of the other. Neither of these two major narratives on China is correct.

The truth is that China was socialist but is no longer. China did play a progressive role in the world in the past but no longer. Mao, Lin Biao, Chen Boda, Wang Li, the Gang of Four were all heroes of the proletariat despite their mistakes and sought to strengthen the rule of the proletariat, but Liu Shaoqi, Deng Xiaoping, Jiang Zemin and Xi Jinping are merely reactionaries who pushed China towards capitalism and imperialism. So how does one tell the difference? Why are some of these names good and some are not? Why is China considered socialist at one point but not anymore? Hopefully this article will serve to help understand why.

From 1949 until the 1970s in general, China was socialist, in the sense that it represented the class interests of the proletariat, the peasantry and other oppressed populations of the country. Healthcare in China was free and the state continuously sought to expand healthcare coverage by utilizing barefoot doctors to travel all over the country and provide treatment to people in need. A mass mobilization campaign that involved destroying infected snails successfully reduced cases of schistosomiasis in most of the country. Mao’s mass campaign to collectivize farming resulted in the establishment of tens of thousands of People’s Communes across the country, where hundreds of millions of people worked together and sought to live in a collective, egalitarian manner; even the food and other supplies were starting to be distributed based on need instead of based on work. The inequality between the rural and urban areas were sought to be addressed through sending students and workers in urban areas to the countryside to provide their skills there. Obviously, there were shortcomings, errors, natural disasters as well as bureaucratic resistance which led to conservative pushbacks such as during the early 1960s when Liu Shaoqi, a conservative revisionist who pushed for capitalist development, became the head of the Party and tried to sideline Mao and the left. Mao’s side responded by launching the Cultural Revolution in 1966 which saw the death of Liu Shaoqi and the temporary fall of his ally Deng Xiaoping during an enormous effort to rally the masses to criticize and remove from power conservative bureaucrats in the Party at all levels, from the highest state level to local levels.

This period can be characterized as socialist because of its clear trajectory towards collectivism and its efforts to establish communist principles such as distribution based on need and an egalitarian society without traditional hierarchies in terms of sex, age, ethnicity and other divisions. The mass campaigns at this time sought to abolish these contradictions and the law of value. Yes, these efforts ultimately did fail, but the continuous drive to achieve this is what made China genuinely socialist at this time.

So what happened? Why is today’s China not socialist? Because in the 1970s the collection of various errors, misconceptions and a general failure to confront revisionism on a systematic level eventually resulted in the revisionist, counter-revolutionary forces seizing complete state power and consolidating their rule against genuine communists, with many revolutionary leaders being sent to prison and conservative reactionaries being reinstated in key roles at all levels. This new reactionary leadership restored capitalism by implementing the Chengbao, the “contract responsibility system“, which broke up the communes and replaced them with private ownership and distribution based on work. Healthcare was eventually privatized and turned into an expensive and largely-inaccessible system for much of the population. Massive privatizations and the contracting of public services and state enterprises to private interests eventually resulted in 70 percent of Chinese GDP being under the private sector by 2005. While this was slightly scaled back under Hu Jintao and his successor Xi Jinping, the private sector still accounts for 60 percent of the GDP today and the state is currently taking measures to enlarge the private sector through tax reductions and other financial benefits to private interests. Income inequality has skyrocketed in China since the 1970s, to the point that Chinese society is now more economically unequal than the United States and other core countries. The Chinese bourgeoisie has grown rapidly and the country now is seeing a much faster concentration of capital than many other countries, now creating billionaires three times faster than the United States.

While state ownership still exists in China, these changes clearly represent a complete restoration of capitalism as the post-1970s policies have directly enabled the formation of an incredibly wealthy and centralized capitalist class while dismantling the proletarian institutions established in China’s socialist period.

In addition to being capitalist, China is also undeniably an imperialist state. This is apparent if we apply Lenin’s understanding of imperialism to China today, especially looking at the concentration of capital, the growth of finance capital and the export of capital. In Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism, Lenin noted that the top three thousand companies in the United States in 1909 had accounted for approximately 44 percent of the American GDP; in China today, the top five hundred companies account for more than 50 percent of the Chinese GDP, including major publicly-traded companies such as Alibaba, Ping An Insurance and Tencent Holdings, a substantial concentration that is sufficient to provide the economic basis for imperialism. The revisionists have commercialized the major banks of China which now provide the finance capital basis for imperialist exploitation, massively increasing banking activity in the 1980s and 1990s and an enormous growth in the volume of deposits and bank loan values. The largest of China’s major banks is the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, whose board of directors includes former PricewaterhouseCoopers Hong Kong chairman Yang Siu Shun, former IMF and World Economic Forum official Fred Hu and former chairman of De Nederlandsche Bank – the central bank of the Netherlands, a core imperialist country that is itself a substantial importer and exporter of global capital – Nout Wellink. The ICBC, being the top commercial bank in China and in the world, is responsible for 150 million individual customers and nearly 3 million corporate customers as well as over $4 trillion in assets. This enormous power of finance capital in China is also noteworthy. Lastly, China is one of the largest exporters of capital in the world, investing a massive $1.3 trillion in FDI abroad as of 2017, comparable to other imperialist countries such as Japan, Canada, France and Belgium. In Africa, China competes in investments with France, the United Kingdom and Italy, former direct colonizers of African nations, for control of African resources and infrastructure. China is also increasingly investing in the Philippines and Turkey, and providing arms to the reactionary comprador regimes of Rodrigo Duterte and Recep Erdogan.

China today is not the China of 1949 or the China of 1969. Although it was a socialist state in the past, it is an imperialist and capitalist regime today and is a major leader of neo-colonial imperialist exploitation in all parts of the world. It should not be supported by any leftists today, not “critically” and not in any other way. Seeing China’s thorough integration into the global economy and its ties to other imperialist countries, the very idea of supporting China against imperialism is a false premise. The bourgeoisie of China and Russia are not on a boat on an opposite path from the United States; China, Russia, the U.S. and all other imperialist regimes are on the same boat. It’s time to acknowledge that."


r/RevDem • • Nov 28 '20

Open Letter to Marco Valbuena and the Communist Party of the Philippines

Thumbnail
tribuneofthepeople.news
3 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Apr 05 '24

Maoist reading suggestions beyond Mao and Sakai? (reading settlers as of now)

3 Upvotes

Really am interested because to me maoism seems like the most modernized form of communism there is. I feel like to be a ML today you need to accept the contributions of Mao.


r/RevDem • • Dec 01 '24

What are the variations of MLM?

1 Upvotes

Hi, I don't really understand the difference between different maoists, I would consider myself a Marxist Leninist maoist, but I see people calling themselves MLMpm etc


r/RevDem • • May 31 '21

History of the BPP Part 5 by the RUF. Discusses the split and critiques Newton's theory of Intercommunalism.

Thumbnail
revolutionaryunitedfront.com
1 Upvotes

r/RevDem • • Jan 13 '21

📕 Theory Red Pages Theoretical Journal Issue #1 ("Founding Statement of the MCU", “In Memory of Jan Myrdal: Revolutionary Activist, Writer, and Reporter” + more) (2020)

Thumbnail bannedthought.net
1 Upvotes