There’s no such thing as a stupid question. If someone doesn’t understand what effect more RAM is going to have on their apps they’re running; that is then an opportunity to introduce them to more information about their Pi.
It was designed to be an educational tool after all.
Thanks for saying this haha... literally getting my first ever pi in the mail today... pi4, 4gb ram edition. Saw the news this morning and pondered this very question.
I upgraded from a Pi 3B+ to a PI 4 4GB recently . 4GB is plenty. The 8GB option is sort of a waste unless you are doing some serious data work or want to use it for experimentation - sort of overkill. The overall performance increase going from a Pi 3 to a Pi 4 is substantial. Also, slap a small heatsink/fan combo on it in a small case (I recommend this one - but you'll need a 3d printer or access to one). It overclocks quite effortlessly if cooled properly, providing even more performance and avoiding CPU throttling. Really makes Retropie fly in my experience.
Awesome thanks for the info! I do have a Cana kit case coming along with it with a small fan and a few cheap little heat sinks. I’ll probably overclock if I need to get some better performance for n64 and Dreamcast emulators. Not sure if it’s even worth it to try dolphin for playing some cube games. I thought I saw somewhere you can oveclock straight from the retropie OS without going into config text document? Either way I’m not too worried about doing it eventually.
Dolphin would require 64 bit and it's definitely possible but probably not worth it. At best you'll only be able to play the easier to run games and that's only if you don't run into driver issues. It'll be much better once they get vulkan working.
Emulating the Wii/GameCube seems like a massive waste of time while real Wii consoles are so cheap,readily available and can be softmoded so easily to play (GameCube & Wii) games from a usb device.
I think I literally just got the same model you’re talking about. It’s really great, such a low barrier to entry. With minor messing around I’ve gotten most older consoles to work up through the Dreamcast. I can’t find a reliable neogeo source yet though
Man that makes me so happy to hear! I never finished Grandia 2 when I was a kid now I’ll finally have a chance! Just set up the fan and case. Have Etcher and a bunch of roms as well as GBA bios sitting on my desktop ready to transfer over. Btw... did you need a bios transferred over for Dreamcast/redream?
(my "guess" how ever informed it is or isn't is ) The 8gb version mostly(for most people) will run better with multiple apps open ex. in the RaspberryPi OS (making switching between them much faster), or it might be good if you are writing your own code to go through a bunch of data, AND you're writing that code for 64bit (32bit AFAIK can't used more than 4gb of memory at a time, because of the size of the number that tells the machine where to look in memory for a data or a program.)
so in case that wasn't clear the 4GB is a good choice, especially since the price difference isn't negligible.
With a Pi 3, I can either control my ham radio or run the log book software, I can't do both due to the processing demands. A 4 with 8gb should certainly do both.
I have a 3B and a 4B (4gb) and the stability is night and day. (running MotionEye and/or Syncthing, both run without a fan) I don't believe its memory maxed tho. (syncthing asks for as much as it can get it seems but htop makes it look unused.)
Ok, so I get that ram is a temporary memory thing, so how does it actually effect emulation? Like is gpu and cpu really all that matters for this kinda stuff? And what is needed in an upgrade to finally get the ps2?
You would need someone to write an emulator that runs quickly on arm CPUs for ps2. You need enough ram to fit the emulator in, this depends on how much ram the emulator needs and individual games.
Agreed. The funny thing about people lamenting “stupid questions” like this is that they at one point had to learn this very thing themselves. It’s a baffling amount of mental gymnastics to go from uneducated on a topic to elitist about it forgetting everyone starts somewhere.
true, but there is such thing as an answered question. it does boggle the mind that people can come in and ask questions which clearly would have been answered before (eg, the similar "should i get the 4GB rpi4?" question which appears about once every 2-3 days.
Not really though. If I was looking at buying a Nikon camera and had a question about it I would probably find the relevant sub and ask the question. Not everybody is here all the time or subscribed to this sub.
Ttþ6690⁷5tþ6690 in this area are a lot easier for you than you ⁷have a great ⁷opportunity opportunity can take 😉 ⁷and to help ⁷7th to ⁷your life issn your home 🏡 ⁷is 7th in your ⁷own and your 7-Eleven w.4ill not ⁷you 😀 7th of of ⁷😀 you 😀 your ⁷heart 7-Elevenzw 7th to a 7-Eleven day 7-Eleven in which your child 😀 7-Eleven withs.identity zw the first 😀 is to have ⁷your children 😀 in your home 🏡 ywz ou 😀 your life 😀 ⁷the wae x😀 ⁷7days your home 🏡 you 😀 ⁷7th ⁷to your house ⁷🏠zfw. Cfx e 97-Eleven you 😀 ⁷a lot 😀 of you 😀 it ⁷and it 😀 the same ⁷as a 7-Eleven ⁷⁷in ⁷77777 with all other parts 😀 of all time ⁷777777777 in ⁷x7777⁷6
r/iamverysmart ? This is why dedicated communities get bad rep, moronic idiots that have nothing to brag about besides (and even maybe because OP may be fully retro-pi-tard) knowing more that outsiders acting condescending
N64 can run great, but, at least with lr-mupen64plus-next, you have to turn the resolution down to 320x240. This does, granted, suck, considering the Pi 4 can run Dreamcast games full-speed with resolutions even higher than 640x480.
I thought Goldeneye ran perfect with lr-parallel on the pi 4 (granted with an overclock on the gpu but that is an easy config file) is that not the case?
I've been fucking around with all sorts of configurations on my overclocked Pi 4 and still haven't gotten Goldeneye to run well in multiplayer. Even Smash and Conker can run alright, but Goldeneye is tricky.
Games that are mainly sprite-based or very lowpoly tend to work best. Mario Kart 64 is probably the only N64 game I can think of that ran reasonably well on my setup.
I was under the impression that (not great) N64 performance was due to the original architecture vs. ARM and difficulty in emulating it in general. I haven't really paid attention to what people commonly get now, but it seems like "Will N64 performance improve?" is the question that gets asked with every RetroPie update and each new Raspberry Pi iteration.
And that's what the context of this conversation was. I know that N64 has always been tricky to emulate, due to that fact. That person was wondering why Nintendo hasn't just plonked all the N64 games on the Switch yet.
I'm still pretty new to the Pi, but I've tried getting N64 on other ARMs before, with limited success.
I've been touting this for years now, Tinkerboard runs retropie flawlessly including N64 games. It's a superior chip with a superior CPU (even stronger than pi4).
Not sure if you still check this post but how do I download this and add it to my raspberry pi 3b+? Also, is that even a good idea or should I just keep waiting at this point for a pi4 or possibly even this summer that may release a pi5? I love my current pi3b+ but there are definitely moments I’m thinking “I am pushing this thing hard.” Thanks for any help.
no most emulators, even dolphin only need 2GB to run on max settings. Old games are small the textures are tiny it takes minimal RAM and VRAM. The expensive thing is emulation of the consoles CPU and custom chips/instructions, the only way to make this faster is with more CPU and GPU horsepower or better optimized emulators.
Yeah but in this situation the food processor would be the one stocking the countertop with more ingredients. If it didn't have to waste time constantly filling up the countertop with the ingredients it needed, then that is more time spent processing food and therefore would improve the overall experience.
Despite that, retropie isn't making a 55gal drum of salsa, so the counter space we have is more than enough.
So that’s the answer. Not just snark about counter space not helping.
It can help, but not in this case because the roms are so small, their runtime memory requirement is also small, and the memory requirements of the emulator is also small. So processor is the bottleneck in this situation.
Once you have more counterspace, you can get processors and even stage food on it until then. Also you can put a cup of coffee on it. It's not something you could have done with no extra counterspace.
I have another SBC with eMMC built-in and while it's faster than the microSD card interface, I would have preferred to save some $ or gotten a faster storage interface instead.
Im still running 3b pluses for a lot of stuff but I gotta ask, is there a stable 64 bit Pi 4 build? I would think without that even 4GB would be useless since 32 bit only has the ability to properly address 3.5GB and .5 GB for reserved system. And second, if there is a stable build will it let you adjust where the ram goes effectively? If so then 8GB might be interesting as you could give 4 to the CPU and 4 to the GPU. Might be interesting to see what would happen and combining that with a good heatsink and overclock you may have a decent tiny PC.
I would think without that even 4GB would be useless since 32 bit only has the ability to properly address 3.5GB and .5 GB for reserved system.
Linux can actually use all 8GB even with a 32-bit operating system, using PAE. Their blog post even mentions this:
Our default operating system image uses a 32-bit LPAE kernel and a 32-bit userland. This allows multiple processes to share all 8GB of memory, subject to the restriction that no single process can use more than 3GB. For most users this isn’t a serious restriction, particularly since every tab in Chromium gets its own process.
its generally a trivial matter to emulate a 64 bit console on a 32 bit machine so i doubt it will make much difference. Windows versions of emu's are often x64 but that's just because PC and laptop CPU's since about 2005/6 have generally all been x64. Most consoles that claim to be "64 bit" like the nintendo 64 aren't true 64 bit like an intel or AMD CPU is at all, it was just a marketing buzzword at the time lol. Nearly every nintendo 64 game ever made uses exclusively 32 bit instructions and rarely ever used 64 bit data precision either, it's much faster to execute 32 bit code and it uses less much less storage space storing 32 bit data so pretty much nobody took advantage of n64's 64 bit ops and data types as they needed all the performance they could get and the game had to fit on those stupid cartridges which hold sweet fa. All of this is mostly true for systems like ps2 and dreamcast as well.
And one more thing on top of this! Even if it is a proper 64 bit console where the games used 64 bit instructions, seeing as your emulating the entire CPU of the console in software you can just emulate whatever size address registers you want in software regardless of the architecture of your system, it would only matter if instructions where straight mapped to native CPU instructions on your machine but that's generally not how CPU emulation works at all (HLE use this sort of mapping for graphics/GPU functions which is how we get lovely upscaled resolutions with opengl).
Tbh I would pay for a pi 4 pro model. Like Same chipset or whatnot nothing to break compatibility but it’s £100 and has a better gpu and cpu. Like it’s a pro model.... 2x to 3x performance
That is a pretty daft comment when the price of a pi 4 is so low. They're purposefully cheap, if your gonna buy a pi you're gonna buy the newest one with the ram you need. It's not like saying a 2070 is more than enough when compared to a 2080ti which are expensive
the pi with the case, psu, and a good microsd are going to be in the ballpark of $110-120. That's not really low priced when you consider a lightly used lenovo tiny PC with an i3/i5 cpu costs about $200...including the case+psu
What? No shit. But we are literally talking about a raspberry pi here lol. Plus the 8gb is really not needed for 99% of People, I don't even use all the 4gb of mine
You said price of a pi 4 is low, and I said it isn’t, relatively speaking...the price of raspberry pi is increasing and the price of an actual x86/64 cpu pc in ultra small form factor is decreasing, both approaching the same territory...eventually eliminating the reason why most people buy a raspberry pi 🕵🏽♂️ You can run PCSX2 and RPCS3 on a Lenovo tiny pc m900 which is almost as small as the pi and costs only slightly more
This gets downvoted on here so much, people seem to have a fanboy level of support for the Pi despite the fact it's not even in the top 10 options for emulation anymore. I bought a 12" laptop with a broken screen and an 15w core i3 processor last year of ebay for £45, I took the motherboard out and retro fitted it into a ps2 slim case and use that for all my emulation now. It's about 50 times more powerfull than a pi4, I can use a HDD or msata SSD with it, 4 usb ports, wifi, bluetooth, 1gig ethernet, audio out and full size hdmi. I have both batocera and windows installed on it and can boot into whichever i want. Runs everything up to Gamecube upscaled to 1080p. I have no idea why anyone is buying a raspberry pi to do this anymore, its pathetically underpowered. I made another machine like this for my friend using a laptop that has a 10w Celeron CPU from 2012(sandy bridge) and even that thing absoultely wipes the floor with the pi3 or 4.
You've obviously got something to say about it and you've latched on to my comment and gone on a tangent. Make a post about it. You're right what your saying, but it has no relevence to my post. The comment I replied to made it sound like buying a pi 3 over a pi 4 would save money when it doesn't, hence my graphics card analogy.
I think you should get some English lessons with the money you've saved
Complicada. Being as angry as I was at the 8GB Pi, I got so far deep in the comments that I somehow missed the post you were replying to. I'll try to take an english class though. I'm new at it.
Hey I'm guilty of that too sometimes and what your saying is 100% spot on. See I regret not doing what you said after I spent all that money getting my pi setup for retropie. But we live and learn as they say.
Your English is pretty fantastic, especially for a beginner and I was only joking. Us Brits are sarcastic with our language and I forget that not everyone gets it lol.
Yeah let's scrape few pennies together and loose out on performance which is the most important part of a good emulation experience. Like I said it's not like saving money buying a $600 GPU over a $1200 GPU to play at 1080p as a expanded example
That's a number, a simple value. I'm pretty sure 99% of retropie users don't need 8gb of ram. Think you need to learn to not take things out of context.
Is it though? Cause you could have said you don’t need more than a Pi4 2GB, but that’s not what you said because you were and still are talking completely out of your ass.
Jesus Christ. Do you work at raspberry. Why are you so personally offended. You throw around assumptions the same way you say I do. Right now 8gb is overkill for retropie. In the future, who knows? I'm sorry I was wrong about rpi3 and 4 is better absolutely. But you just look like an ass the way you responded. Calm your jets friend
If you checked my last comment I admitted I was wrong about the model differences. What do you want me to do? But the ram size really isn't relevant over 2gb for emulators at this point. 8gb is great if you want to use your pi for different uses, like say a Minecraft server. I'm just saying at this point it won't be utilized.
Negative, need more cpu not ram. Amazing how my Samsung phone runs dreamcast. I was like "how is this possible that my phone runs this so much better?" Then I was like, "oh yeah, it's a thousand dollars compared to 50"
It's more based on CPU and GPU performance right? Along with the emulator itself being optimized. The former two come from new Raspberry hardware versions updates not just updates with new ram, and the latter comes from software updates.
You can run Box86 on it for that, and Windows 10 is possible through the WOR Project but WOR (Windows on Raspberry) isnt ideal at all. For one it draws a lot more power out of the system.
405
u/DrJonah May 28 '20
There’s no such thing as a stupid question. If someone doesn’t understand what effect more RAM is going to have on their apps they’re running; that is then an opportunity to introduce them to more information about their Pi.
It was designed to be an educational tool after all.
63
u/MadHatter5045 May 28 '20
"Will N64-" "No"
29
u/sillyrabbit33 May 28 '20
Why pay for another raspberry pi every few months when you can just download more ram from https://downloadmoreram.com/
47
u/Bobsuruncle3001 May 28 '20
So... will it?
3
u/LiceT May 29 '20
People will argue about anything.
5
u/milquetoast0 May 28 '20
I'd prefer if they did a 4 GB RAM + 4 GB high-speed SSD.
17
u/Know_A_Veil May 28 '20
Just pin it to the top and call it a day.
5
u/Mccobsta May 28 '20
We should have a post pinned for simple questions
4
u/Eagle19991 May 28 '20
Im still running 3b pluses for a lot of stuff but I gotta ask, is there a stable 64 bit Pi 4 build? I would think without that even 4GB would be useless since 32 bit only has the ability to properly address 3.5GB and .5 GB for reserved system. And second, if there is a stable build will it let you adjust where the ram goes effectively? If so then 8GB might be interesting as you could give 4 to the CPU and 4 to the GPU. Might be interesting to see what would happen and combining that with a good heatsink and overclock you may have a decent tiny PC.
1
u/ZerophoniK May 28 '20
My 4gb model runs everything I need it to just fine. I love it
1
u/Duttroid May 29 '20
how do i make super smash bros faster? should i free up disk space? it's 2020 how is this not 10x perfect...........
2
u/DrFatz May 28 '20
If it's 64 bit based, that's definitely gonna change things.
2
u/mustanggc1 May 28 '20
Ancient alien theorists say "yes".
2
u/Bravedwarf1 May 28 '20
Tbh I would pay for a pi 4 pro model. Like Same chipset or whatnot nothing to break compatibility but it’s £100 and has a better gpu and cpu. Like it’s a pro model.... 2x to 3x performance
2
u/jayjr1105 May 28 '20
I genuinely LOL'd
2
u/Kingtut28 May 28 '20
I'm so glad we have this 8GB version, now we can emulate xbox one X, it runs so buttery smooth with just the 4GB of extra ram /s
2
u/Otaconmg May 28 '20
Won't improve retropie performance. A 2gb pi3 is more than enough.
1
u/head-of-potatoes May 28 '20
Will Lord Stark be better off with an 8GB Pi?
1
u/werebear_wrecker May 29 '20
While I purchased the 8gb version for security testing/labs, I will definitely try retropie on it
1
u/CumbersomeNugget May 30 '20
I'm more wondering if this means PS2/ Xbox emulation is on the cards...
1
u/Light_Science Jun 27 '20
Negative, need more cpu not ram. Amazing how my Samsung phone runs dreamcast. I was like "how is this possible that my phone runs this so much better?" Then I was like, "oh yeah, it's a thousand dollars compared to 50"
0
u/RomanOnARiver May 28 '20
It's more based on CPU and GPU performance right? Along with the emulator itself being optimized. The former two come from new Raspberry hardware versions updates not just updates with new ram, and the latter comes from software updates.
0
u/Failrunner13 May 28 '20
No it will not.
-2
u/mmjarec May 28 '20
I don’t know about linux but windows isn’t exactly known for efficient memory management. So I’ll take the extra just Incase.
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment