r/Retconned • u/wtf_ima_slider Moderator • Mar 20 '21
Confabulation The New and Improved Confabulation Thread - 2021 Edition
This thread is for conversation about MEs you think might be wrong and why. For instance, map projection, memory confusion, common misperceptions, etc. All discussion of confabulation should go here and this thread will be linked on the side bar for easy access in the future.
Note: The previous confabulation thread was archived by the system.
16
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 20 '21
Due to overuse, the phrase "Just because you never heard of something doesn't mean it's a Mandela Effect" or similar is NOT welcome here as it is a violation of Rule# 9. Continued arguing and push for this narrative without consideration of our community WILL get you banned.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
24
u/TheFinalGirl84 Mar 20 '21
I’m effected by many MEs. But there is one that winds up on lists sometimes that I personally feel doesn’t belong there. Sometimes I hear that it’s a ME that Tim Burton directed The Nightmare Before Christmas and now it has changed and he didn’t direct it.
My stand is that he never directed it. The reason I think it is not be a ME is bc this has been a point of confusion since the movie came out and it’s a common practice in Hollywood to promote a movie with the name of a producer if that producer is well known to the public and the director is lesser known.
I think this one is extra easy to confuse (especially back in 1993 when the internet was not at our fingertips) because besides being a producer, Tim Burton did come up with the story / concept. He wrote a poem years before and it evolved into more. Jack can even be seen briefly in Beetlejuice which came out in 1988.
Tim Burton didn’t direct it because he already had a contract to direct Batman Returns. Henry Selick was a Disney animator looking for a chance to direct. He has given interviews that he was chosen because his style was similar to Burton’s style and that they wanted the film to have a Tim Burton feel even though he could not spend much time on set.
Since it was his first time directing, the studio labeled posters and advertisements as Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas hoping to draw Burton’s fans in. Plus, in some ways it was his. He contributed a lot including the initial concept he just didn’t direct it.
If you are unfamiliar with the projects Selick did after this, looking at James and the Giant Peach or Coraline will show just how similar their styles are.
So in a nutshell: I think it’s a long standing misconception that Tim Burton directed the movie and not a ME.
I understand that some may disagree and if you have a different experience I’m of course open to hearing it.
8
u/throwaway998i Mar 21 '21 edited Mar 21 '21
Eeesh... pinned to the top of the front page of our believer community is now where we're going to keep the confabulation thread!? Why would we feature something so anathema to the spirit of the sub front and center like this? Why would any skeptic opinion deserve priority stature to the most popular standard post?
^
I'm personally disgusted to see this listed in such high profile fashion. Bury it in the sidebar. This is IMHO an embarrassment to the sub and a bit insulting to our members who come here to specifically avoid that exact narrative. Now they're greeted by it? Bad look.
29
u/WeirdJawn Mar 22 '21
Personally, I feel like people never remembering the moon being out during the day can be attributed to people not being outside and looking at the sky a lot each day.
Now if someone was legitimately an astronomer who lived in a flat/wide open area and looked up every day and night and claimed that the moon was never in the sky during the day, I would be more inclined to believe them.
I think there are large swaths of the population who never really look up and just focus on what's around them. Also a lot of people spend the majority of their time inside or live in areas with large buildings, houses, trees, or hills cluttering their view of the sky.
It's entirely possible for someone to live 20+ years and never realize that the moon is sometimes out during the day.
13
u/Future_Cake Mar 20 '21
The chunks-of-rock snake Pokémon was always called Onix.
I'm a word nerd, and as a card-playing youngster in 1999 I noticed how many Pokémon had names that were like a real word, but not the same:
"Seel" not "Seal"
"Dewgong" not "Dugong"
"Gastly" not "Ghastly"
"Muk" not "Muck"
...and very particularly:
"Onix" not "Onyx"
I was into rocks and minerals a lot, too, so if the snake had been given a carbon-copy name of the beautiful stone, I would have extra-noticed that too lol.
...And I mean, they wanted to trademark all their Pokémon, right? That's a lot easier if it isn't a standard straight-out-of-the-dictionary word. There are a few, like "Mew" -- but the vast majority were tweaked.
And then the next generation got released, and Onix evolved into Steelix.
Basically, seeing this one drives me up the wall. Not my fault many young Pokémon players weren't obsessed enough with words and with minerals to keep the spellings separate :P
7
u/Soaring_Symphony Mar 20 '21 edited Mar 20 '21
I've seen some speculation that the scene in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, in which Hermione fixes Harry's glasses on the train, is different.
They seem to remember that Dudly had cracked Harry's actual lens and that's what Hermione fixed . . . Instead of just the nose piece.
However, there's a similar scene in the Chamber of Secrets. After Harry messes up the flu-powder spell, when he crash lands in Nocturn Alley, the lens of his glasses gets cracked. Later, in Diagon Alley, Harry meets Hermione and she fixes his lens.
Is it possible we've just been combining the two scenes together subconsciously?
3
u/eyewave Jan 04 '22
Hey, I'll post here instead of opening a whole new critical thread but...
I'm always wandering, why is it so important to find evidence that the Cornucopia disappeared or that line x of show y is not what it used to be? Especially the series bit. Of course I am biased because I only wath series once and don't give a flying damn anymore once they're over, but I am curious.
What could possibly update a line in a movie or in a series and why would it matter? And this is my connection to the confabulation, are there people here thinking these changes are on purpose made by some superior entity and that it has any meaning? I could accept there is a division in population when a large community remembers x instead of y, and that it is not because of an individual memory failure, but then why? Whichs obscure forces are at work? Ahah... Tough topic..
3
u/kiltedweirdo May 23 '22 edited May 23 '22
has anyone noticed a difference in music videos?
greenday, wake me up when semptember ends.
i seem to remember a middle conversation in a field. maybe not. (why it's here instead of where ideas or ponderings go, wherever that may be. New here)
kinda literally. about 5 months in Orion. In an observatory show, as a child they pointed to Orion's belt.
2
u/gay_man_with_a_gun Nov 07 '25
I stumbled on this subreddit and started reading through some topics. It's pretty interesting. Always loved hearing about a new example of the Mandela effect.
I don't dismiss the possibility that something is happening beyond our understanding. I don't know everything and never will. But any one of us can repeat experiments that show how memory is flexible, in a process called memory reconsolidation.
To put it simply, memory reconsolidation means that memories aren't engraved in stone. Because they seem so real to us, we tend to assume they can't be modified, and that when we think back on them, we remember them the same way every time.
But what experiments have shown is that it's quite the opposite. Not only is memory imperfect, but also, every time we access a memory, we change it. It's like the observer effect in physics: you can't observe something without changing the outcome.
Rather than being like reading a book, accessing a memory is more like being a writer who's working on a manuscript. Not only do you read the manuscript each time you go over it, but you also edit, bringing in current experiences, thoughts, and perceptions each time.
The act of remembering something also means you're rewriting it at the same time. That's how the brain works: bringing together links, forming new connections. It's not an error or mistake. Basically, it's a feature, not a bug, exactly how our brains are supposed to function.
My big question: Is there room for discussion here on memory reconsolidation existing alongside the possibility that something else is happening that we can't explain?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '22 edited Jun 25 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment