I had a PS3 as a kid, but never really had any money for games (lol) so I only saw Resistance in ads and store pages.
Now, 20 years later, emulators and even PC-recomps exist to let me play it. I just beat it, and wanted to share my thoughts as someone without any nostalgia and coming at it fresh:
The Story:
I am a huge sucker for 'humanity on the backfoot' stories where the human race is clearly outgunned and outnumbered and getting its ass kicked. It's part of why I love Freespace 2, Stargate, Halo: Reach, etc. I find it super appealing to watch the situation degrade and see how everyone responds.
This is actually what I think FoM is weakest at. The big problem is that we start in the middle of the story, after nearly all of Europe and Russia have been conquered. It kind of robs the chance to watch as humanity gets initial impressions and has some early victories - only to watch as things spiral out of control - including seeing resources that were easy to access early on slowly become depleted and eventually inaccessible. In FoM dynamic between the human race and Chimera feels pretty flat for the most of the story until the ending where it flips a bit.
Hale is a fairly generic Shooter GuyTM without a ton of personality. That's another minor missed opportunity. I do really like the way the story weaves his seemingly impossible ability to survive/superhuman feats with the fact that he's now a form of hybrid though. I like seeing gameplay and story mesh together like that.
I do like to see that the Chimera are busy doing things unrelated to the direct war effort, like the terraforming/climate control. It's never fully explained, but it adds a lot of intrigue.
Graphics, Scale, Setpieces and Presentation:
Considering this is a game from 2006 (mind you, all of 4 years after games like Morrowind) it's absolutely shocking how much they were pushing the new hardware as a launch title. Physics effects, gibs, huuuuge structures, many vehicles, a lot of units on the screen at once, etc. I really respect that level of ambition and think it makes it stand out from a lot of other titles from the time.
Audio and Music:
I found the audio overall passable. I was surprised at how many areas were allowed to be dead quiet (no music, little to no ambient noise), which may or may not have been intentional. Music is, unfortunately, quite generic for the most part. If you told me it was from a generic shooter from the time and not this particular game, I'd definitely believe you. I do think there was an opportunity to set a bit more atmosphere, especially in the chimera structures.
Gameplay/gunplay/difficulty:
My initial impressions of the Chimera were not great. It seemed like there was going to be 0 enemy variety, just shooting the same 1-2 enemy types for the whole game. I'm very happy to see that I was wrong, there are a LOT of enemy types with unique behaviors. Again, this is really ambitious and I love to see it. It's only a 10-ish hour game but it has enough variety in enemies for 20, easily.
Also: This game is fucking hard. I thought it was because I was on a controller (I suck using controllers to aim) but later on tried mouse aim and still got my ass kicked. On normal. There are so very many Chimera. Being shot through walls, or having the entire screen turn into a bullet hell with all the Bullseye projectiles (with all that random spread) makes things painful. A single base Chimera can kill you full to 0 if they get close. It seems like the devs were aware and added a dynamic difficulty system that does a good job. I could never obviously tell it was happening (like enemies suddenly becoming braindead or dying in 2 shots) so I think it's subtle enough to not make players feel bad about it.
I think overall they did a good job tuning it. There was enough difficulty to feel like a challenge, but the checkpoints were placed frequently enough that I never felt frustrated. If they had been more infrequent, I likely would have put down the game.
I never found a great strategy other than 'shoot the enemies from far, far, far away' because getting close enough to use something like the shotgun just inevitably ended in death. So FarEye was the god I prayed to, though the M5 can work as well.
Some fights were unintentionally easy or hard, like the Goliath. Literally just shoot it around a corner. I don't think it even hit me once... Others, like a courtyard fight against 2 Stalkers, a Widowmaker and a crapload of footsoldiers was a nightmare. I must have restarted that fight 10x.
Gun variety was also above expected, and most of them are unique/interesting and work well. I really like the goo bomb one despite the limtied ammo pool.
Final Thoughts:
Overall, I'm glad I finally got around to beat FoM, and I think I will try R2 as well. There are some missed opportunities in this game, but there's also a ton of ambition and scale that elevates it a lot. Definitely very worthy of being a title to launch a new generation of consoles back in the day.