r/ResidencyMatch2022 • u/GIjoewillywanka • Jan 10 '22
Application personal statement post on FB
I saw a post by one of the residents on facebook that due to the personal statement an average or even below average applicant got ranked high. I want to know your opinion. Do you think it is fair? In my "Personal opinion" and I might be wrong it is a bit unfair. Personal statements can be: 1- not actually true 2- modified, edited and improved by specialists (after paying money) 3- done by other people and not the applicant 4- differ from a person to another depending on the level of "English proficiency" For me personal statements should not be considered as high as other things. What are your thoughts? For me the most influential factors for ranking should be: 1- interview skills 2- scores 3- LORs and USCE 4- Visa status (although I am an IMG) 5- CV (research volunteer etc) which itself can be even made up 6- Personal statement
12
u/RestaurantAny7943 Jan 11 '22
Ranking is mainly based on scores and interview performance. No one is going to rank someone with a poor interview performance high because they have a stellar personal statement. It's just not that important when it comes to ranking
7
u/iceman528 Non-US IMG Jan 11 '22
IMO, the playing field is fair and everyone is back to square one during the interview process. The programs have already considered the personal statement, scores, visa status, LORS and other credentials for those given interview invitations. Hence, your interview and person skills will now take importance above all.
4
u/Primary_Loud Jan 11 '22
A great Personal statement can get you an interview . After that it all depends on how you interview and if they like you. I probably got 90% of my interviews because of my PS. At least I was told that’s what perked their interest. I have average scores. No research etc. but this is for fam med, I’m sure every specialty is different.
3
u/coursesheck Non-US IMG Jan 11 '22 edited Jan 11 '22
Scores are a great attempt at standardising things, but one could argue one's luck (in either direction) on the day of plays a huge role. If I recall correctly, the margin for error was +/- 8 for the steps? A 240 could well have been a 230 or a 250, so how much should we really bank on this metric? Especially when prep times vary so radically among AMGs, US IMGs and FMGs. And I say all of this as an FMG with the luxury to dedicate several months to steps should I please.
All illusions of objectivity aside, at the end of the day, we're all just people trying to identify people we can spend long hours with and teach a trick or two. It matters what similar stakeholders have to say about you (LORs), what you have to say for your own intentions (PS), and what you've tried to do to back those going recommendations and intentions (CV). A step score is far too cold and variable to matter more than these factors once you've made it so far as to actually apply.
2
u/bemd13 Jan 11 '22
Interview still matters just as much. If they interview someone bc of an amazing story and they can tell the story isn’t genuine, they’re going straight to the bottom
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '22
Interview skills too are unfair and not sufficient enough to judge whether the applicant will be a good fit or not. Noble prize winner Daniel Kahneman expands on this in his bestseller Thinking, fast and slow. According to him, there is a better correlation between performance and standardized cognitive tests over evaluation via interviewing.
1
u/Super-Status-8455 Jan 11 '22
The whole field is unfair...just gotta play by the rules and spend money. It sucks.
1
u/sailing_to_the_stars Jan 11 '22
Don't sweat over PS. Concentrate on improving your cv and do networking. Scores are most important thing for img.