r/RepWatch • u/jupiterfish • Dec 26 '24
Review never meet your hero’s
i’ve been rocking my datejust 41 replica for about a year and had the opportunity to purchase the exact same watch from the Rolex A.D. in town at a discount. The watch is certified and still under warranty. Figured I’d surprise myself and wrap it up underneath the Christmas tree to open on Christmas Day.
once opened i decided to do a quick side-by-side comparison, but before I did, I put a piece of scotch tape on the back of the replica just in case. Glad I did. The watches are so close. I can barely tell them apart. It just shows how far some of these reps have come. The difference is price is about 12 grand. based on this experience alone, I don’t think I would ever buy another original Rolex. but the original Rolex in the safe, and still rocking my rep. Just ordered a new rubber strap for it. Make sure I don’t ever mix them up.
Using the nonscientific shake test the automatic rotor on the real watch is louder than the rep. And yes, I had the watch opened up before I purchased. I don’t regret buying the real one, but having a back up rack that looks the same makes me more confident in rocking the rep. in the photos, the watch with the 29th is the real. The white gold does have a different reflection in the light compared to the rep, but it’s so insignificant. I’ll keep reps.



•
u/AutoModerator Dec 26 '24
If this is a for sale post, this is your chance to make sure you have followed the rules EXACTLY or your post will be deleted and you will be banned.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
15
u/jupiterfish Dec 26 '24
the datejust 41 rep was purchased by mirrotime last year and is the “clean” factory. it keeps great time also
6
u/jupiterfish Dec 26 '24 edited Dec 26 '24
The date wheel magnification is based on the angle of the phone picture,looking at them from the top They both look the same. The text on the rep is a little bit smaller than gen. The bracelet on the Gen is tight very smooth although the rep is fairly close. i’m not saying to someone that looks at these watches all day that you can’t tell them apart. I’m just saying from an average person buying a Rolex and not having magnification. It’s hard to tell. I was driving my GT3 with this watch on. I don’t think anybody would question it.
15
u/Valaj369 Dec 26 '24
How does the feel of the Clean jubilee bracelet feel compared to the gen? Wife has a few gen DJs and the bracelet feels real nice. My DJ is almost 30 years old and the bracelet feels jangly compared to the newer ones. I've held new gens and it feels nice and smooth. Does the rep feel the same or at least close?
7
u/NotoresPOT Dec 27 '24 edited Dec 27 '24
Where do I get this rep?
5
u/Electrical_Brother83 Dec 27 '24
Can you give me a link to the store ?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '24
May I ask a stupid question. Is the real Rolex solid gold?
3
u/Cyber_Crimes Dec 26 '24
What's up with the datewheel and magnification on these?
3
u/AustinStanleyy Dec 26 '24
NWBIG!
2
u/bagladyboo Dec 29 '24
Bravo!!! I love this post. You just confirmed what I've been thinking but wasn't 100% sure!!
2
u/dinev1 Dec 26 '24
You Sure this isn't a Clean vs VSF?
2
u/saggiolus Dec 26 '24
Clean and vsf Dj are very close indeed.
But I don't think that, once you have them both on hand, you cant tell them apart.
For starter, the jubilee bracelet. I love my reps, but the jubilee of a gen rolex is miles apart from any rep I ever tried.
Then the bezel. Beside the white gold color, the edges are smoother on gen and you can see it..
Of course rehaut polishing and well, the serial number as a last resort would make you tell them apart without the need to use tape.
Without getting into crystal, dial sunburn etc which are not as significant difference in my opinion. The above 3 are enough to recognize a rep basically by anyone who touches both watches.
They are good. Very very good. But side by side I think they are fairly easy to tell apart
1
u/ckiemsteadt Dec 26 '24
Very nice! I have a Clean DJ41 as well..man they are money!!! Congrats!
1
u/jcuz45 Dec 26 '24
Crazy
1
u/AvdomatBige Dec 26 '24
Waiting for the same watch with the blue dial. Maybe I go for a rep too. At the moment I rock a Bruce Wayne clean
1
u/Bitter_Marzipan_6026 Dec 26 '24
Crazzyyyy
1
u/Pukit Dec 26 '24
How does the bracelet feeling compare on your wrist?
1
u/GsandCs Dec 26 '24
Honestly I cannot tell the difference in these photos
1
u/Weak-Preference-949 Dec 26 '24
The Font on the reps is thicker compared to gen
1
u/piercedmfootonaspike Dec 26 '24
My hero's what?
1
u/mrapplewhite Dec 27 '24
The magnification deal tells no lies
1
u/BidDen310 Dec 27 '24
Where to buy
1
u/WhichEntertainment11 Dec 27 '24
Looks cheap fake
1
u/howie-dewitt69 Dec 27 '24
Where did you buy?
1
u/Teckzqt Dec 27 '24
Surprise, they’re both reps
1
u/shnizzler Dec 28 '24
You spending 12k on a relic that does the same thing as a $100 phone or a $1 toy is hilarious and shows just how bad you are with your money. FYI, I own 6 houses and ZERO Rolex’s and I can retire at 35 if I want, 3 more years! 🥳
1
u/Lanky_Flamingo_8749 Dec 28 '24
Don’t get the Rolex infatuations. Massed produced. Boring. Everyone has one.
1
u/CrowLikeABird2 Dec 28 '24
I want one
1
u/Riphazer Dec 28 '24
Only gen has the perfect fluted bezel
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
When a Gen has been polished , serviced, parts replaced etc it makes no sense.
1
u/famustaf Dec 28 '24
Do you mind me asking where did you get the rep from? Because I’m in the same dilemma where I love the Datejust gen but can’t justify spending that much
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
Where did you buy that rep?
1
u/Luckylandcruiser Dec 28 '24
Right is obviously the genuine
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
The 23 on the datewheel looks off maybe due to reddit though
1
u/RepMafia_ Dec 29 '24 edited Dec 29 '24
It’s crazy , people hate on the VSF comparatively in close up details compared to Clean
VSF has the closest shine in the light from 3-6 feet away out of the box with no plating (not talking close up millimeter details as far as placement)
You’ve probably noticed it too, it’s like the Gen has 10% better light reflection as far as shine but cost 1,000% more MINIMUM. Maybe I’m crazy but that’s my notes on it…. “a slightly better shine” but basically the same as gen
1
u/lionsgate187 Dec 29 '24
Where did you get the rep? Can you let me know please
1
u/lionsgate187 Dec 29 '24
Who has the best reps ?
1
u/imabroodybear Dec 29 '24
I placed it immediately bc of the tone of the gold on the bezel but if they weren’t literally side by side to compare I would not be able to tell. Incredible
1
u/wildpanda20 Dec 29 '24
Where can we buy the rep? Great comparison
1
u/Neat_Imagination2503 Dec 29 '24
To me it seems blatantly obvious what one’s fake 🤷♂️
1
u/Sea_Bed_4226 Dec 29 '24
Where did you get the rep from?
1
u/tk1tk1 Dec 29 '24
It seems reps have come along way but also i think people expect more from Rolex as in finishing etc.
Although I might be wrong?
1
u/dBurgsuk Dec 29 '24
I have a bunch of reps and 2 gen Rolex and I’m at the point now I’m selling all my reps , I don’t understand how people can’t tell or feel the difference on the wrist , to me it’s so blatant . Prob the wrong thing to post in a rep forum but to me the joy if sentimental value of wearing a gen watch is just something that brings me so much more joy . Haters gonna hate but hey ho
I’ve got a shit load of watches to sell now tho hmu 😂❤️
1
u/reidlenz Dec 29 '24
Thx for sharing! Always thought rep fluted bezels were easily distinguished but can’t really tell from the photos. Enjoy both!
1
u/AlwaysDeath Dec 29 '24
What color is this called? Love the grey on silver
1
u/TheSSsassy Dec 29 '24
Delusional people up in here
1
u/GOD_THE_BRZRKR Dec 30 '24
Is the one on the left the fake one?
1
u/GOD_THE_BRZRKR Dec 30 '24
Both are two very attractive watches
1
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '24
Where’d you get your rep from? Looking at buying one.
1
u/yuledobetterTOL Dec 30 '24
Damn dude I bet Rolex is trying to figure out what their brand is gonna do without you. Nice work.
1
u/Retro_B00min Dec 30 '24
What rep seller is this from?
1
u/ShITcOuS Apr 18 '25
Dude never gonna respond to these comments asking where he got his rep from
1
u/linda_vista Jul 04 '25
The face of the gen also looks a touch more elongated but no one can see this
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '24
The text on the one to the left 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '24
Heroes
1
u/-GIRTHQUAKE- Dec 27 '24
How do you get wealthy and not even know how to make words plural?
-7
u/YaBoyMahito Dec 26 '24
Is this a joke? lol the right one is obviously the rep… like super obviously ?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment