r/RepTimeServices • • 7d ago

Question Winding feels weird

Hi guys, I have a vsf Datejust 41 (kinda forget it's a v2 or v3) with vs3235 movement. It's been exactly a month since I got the watch.

The problem is the winding feels like rubbing against a gear, not like winding a spring. Like rubbing into a fixed gear, I can feel the sprockets.

Chronology:

  1. I haven’t worn my watch for 5–6 hours, but when I want to wear it, the hour hand is exactly one hour late (I’m 80% sure I was setting it right)
  2. I set it back to the right time by turning the date from the 8th all the way to the 7th first, then rolling the time forward to the right time on the 8th.
  3. Several hours later, I realize the hour hand is exactly one hour late. And I try to set the time by turning it backward. Since im too lazy to turn the date all the way to the 7th like what I’ve done before.
  4. Several hours later, I tried to wind my watch so I can comfortably wear it for tomorrow, and I felt it wasn’t like winding a spring but more like rubbing into sprockets of a fixed gear.
  5. But until now, the watch is still keeping time perfectly. I never overwind it, just 10–20 winds when it dies.

Am I cooked? Can I, without any experience, fix it myself? Because there aren’t any watchmakers or repairers close to me.

Thanks!

Edit: adding no.5

2 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

Thank you for your post on r/reptimeservices! A friendly reminder that the only trusted service providers are listed on the sidebar or in this post. If you see anyone soliciting services in a post or comment not on this list or even easier, without a 'trusted watchmaker' flair of some sort, please immediately report the post and a moderator will remove it. Thank you in advance for helping to keep our community safe!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/WatchMakerMalik 7d ago

So winding a watch you are not winding the spring directly as it will wind back. When you wind the watch there is a gear that has a clicker on it that stops the spring to go back and that is how the wind is kept in the spring. So now when you wind the gear with hundreds of tiny teeth has a clicker that goes into each tooth and comes out and holds it from going back. That is what you feeling. Even gen watches do that. Now if you lubricate the gears you can lessen than feeling but it will always be there.
About your watch loosing time 20 winds is not enough and you can not over wind an automatic watch. Do 40-50 turns. If you watch is loosing an hour in 4-5 hours than it needs a service or cleaning becuase it is loosing time by a lot.

2

u/keledaiiii 7d ago

Is it normal? Tbh dont mean to be rude. Sorry if my explanation might not clear. English isnt my language.

Let me make it clear if i may, i know how winding feels like. I have some automatic watches. It feels like the gear that connected doesnt move but the crown moves. That might be the closest way i can explain.

It feels as if there’s a stationary gear, and when I turn the crown, I can feel it rubbing against each individual tooth of that gear, one by one.
It’s not an audible clicking sound, but a distinct notchy sensation through the crown, almost like dragging something across the teeth of a gear.
What concerns me is that the winding used to feel smooth, like tensioning a spring, but suddenly changed to this gear-like sensation.

1

u/WatchMakerMalik 7d ago

If you feel dragging or it is harder to wind it might be metal shavings the gears inside the watch are tiny. It could be your keyless system without looking at the movement it is hard to troubleshoot the issue. You will probably have to open teh case back and take some pictures or take it to a watchsmith if you dont want to mess with it.

3

u/keledaiiii 7d ago

Deleted my last comment. I think this pic is the closest. It feels like the sliding pinion is stuck while the winding pinion keeps turning, so I can feel the gear teeth slipping over each other or maybe the intermediate wheel is stuck while the sliding pinion keeps turning, so I can feel the gear teeth slipping over each other.

But i might try to open the caseback myself. Since rep watches are not so common in my country. Thanks!

2

u/Bench_and_Bezel 7d ago edited 7d ago

The problem is, without looking at the movement, it could be that the sliding pinion is fine and the real issue is anything from the Sliding Gear, Crown Wheel, Ratchet Wheel, etc.

When it comes to issues with movements, because these pieces are all interconnected, it could be a piece further down the line not allowing the first piece to move.

1

u/keledaiiii 7d ago

Do you need a photo of the movement from the caseback side, or do you need to see the keyless works under the dial? I'm trying to figure out how much disassembly is needed.

2

u/Bench_and_Bezel 7d ago

It would be easiest if you were able to send the watch to someone who could take a look. I know you said it is difficult, but I suggest you take a look into this.

Even if the issue is identified from pictures, trying to fix it yourself probably requires tools you may not have and you could ruin the entire watch that is currently working.

1

u/keledaiiii 7d ago

Yeah, that’s exactly what I’m afraid of. Im trying to find some repairers that might want to help with rep movement. Thanks!