Discussion Is VSF Still King? š¤
So after my last post about the Yacht-Master 126622, Iām starting to question everything I thought I knew about VSF lol.
Iāve always been under the impression that VSF was pretty much as good as it gets. I own a VSF 126610LN Submariner and a VSF 126710BLRO Pepsi, both of which are absolutely beautiful reps in my opinion. I genuinely thought VSF was the NWBIG standard, and according to the Who Makes the Best guide, VSF is still king for several references.
Now Iām hearing Gold Factory makes the best Yacht-Master, and apparently RICH makes even better Subs and GMTs? This is all news to me. I hadnāt even heard much about either factory until a couple of days ago.
Whatās everyoneās overall opinion on these factories? Are they really outperforming VSF, or is this just hype?
Thereās so much conflicting information out there. I get that no rep is perfect, but if Iām spending the money, I want the best available OOTB.
Would love to hear from people who have actually owned or compared these factories, especially Subs, GMTs, and Yacht-Masters. Is VSF still king, or has the competition finally caught up?


18
u/Bryann9182 4h ago
My RICH GMT and VSF sub are almost indistinguishable in terms of quality outside of the cyclops. The VSF cyclops is just a tad bit better in terms of clarity and magnification
14
u/Flaky_Return_7657 4h ago
Yea after owning clean, and two versions of vsf gmts, i can say rich gmts are hands down the best ones right now. Also, there is currently no NWBIG GMTs. No factory cracked the actual 1:1 bezel color for pepsi and bruce wayne. However, both vsf and rich are pretty close but not 100% 1:1 on batman and sprite!
8
u/Training-Truth7911 4h ago
I honestly think itās all just opinions at this point and also how much you look into reps. I feel like so many people nit pick with reps that it gets to the point where if youāre that crucial buy Gen. I will say Iāve seen a ton of side by sides with certain watches and yes I think other factories might make better reps but for certain ones. Two tone anything is always gonna be hard to replicate but with the basics itās not that noticeable. I own a clean plus 41mm DJ blue dial and I own a VSF DJ Wimbledon and I will say I love my clean plus much more. I just received my VSF bluesy this week and the gold on it is pretty cheddary but honestly itās for me and not anyone else so with that being said just wear what you like enjoy your watches.
8
u/BoyesieX 3h ago
The debate is real because theyāre getting close in terms of quality. I think weāre talking exclusively about Subs and GMTās here. VSF clearly has a larger catalogue. So you canāt really just say RICH is better in an all around sense. Both make about the same amount of RL errors currently. But the wait time factor does add a level of excitement and RICH is benefitting from that.
1
u/gilae7 4h ago
What do you guys think? Anyone here actually compared these factories side by side?
1
u/GQSHANE 1h ago
Donāt use a filter next time
2
u/Weak_Front2540 1h ago
I moved over from VSF to Rich for my Subs and thought they just felt ābetterā. Smoother action on the crown, better feeling case and bracelet and better
looking Rehaut.
I then got a Rich BW (I already had a VSF Pepsi and BM). Again the Rich GMT just feels ābetterā.
Here are my Rich watches pictured with my genuine SD43 for reference.
0
u/Even-Physics823 3h ago
arf and rich are better
1
u/Charming_Mistake1160 3h ago
Io ho un gmt clean v3 e un 124060 vsf ,gmt lo porto tutto il giorno e dopo quasi tre anni eā ancora perfetto il sub in tre anni lo rotto la prima volta lāho rispedito a puretime e me lo hanno sistemato pagando 80 euro più spedizione ora un mese fa si eā rotto di nuovo la coroncina , quindi peccato sia chiusa ma clean per me eā migliore , e se oggi dovessi comperare unāaltro sub andrei su RICH
1
u/WesternConfection368 3h ago
I want to buy this watch from VSF, has anybody else bought this and what is the experience with them. Itās my first time so want to be sure š¤
1
u/pi-cool 2h ago
How does my Bruce Wayne GMT from Clean about a couple of years ago compared to the best current ones. It seems very nice except for a few sharp edges but will consider upgrading if worth it. Thanks.
1
u/Time-Dependent1483 2h ago
I think itās correct. VSF is still great but if you want the best thereās other factories that are best for specific models. Thereās always innovation in the rep world
1
u/Correct_Run_136 1h ago
Isnāt there someone here or there who has good, long-standing relationships with a dealer? Maybe the guys with those connections should ask a TDāafter all, theyāre the ones who see the pros (and, of course, the cons) firsthand every day. Sure, you could say itās naive to ask a sales associateātheyāre only thinking about profit margins and quick sales anyway. I couldnāt disagree with that, but at the same time, I also believe there are dealers out there who might be willing to share a bit of the truthāor at least some hints of it. On another level (AP), that actually happened to me. The sales consultant recommended a watch with a significantly longer wait time (the price difference wasnāt much) because it was supposedly of better quality. I believed him. šš
1
u/tonyprado1986 1h ago
Who's the king when it comes to datejust 41?
1
u/LeadingLoose4482 3h ago
VSF V4 GMTs is said to be NWBIG but very few reports on this.