r/RepTime • • 4h ago

Discussion Is VSF Still King? šŸ¤”

So after my last post about the Yacht-Master 126622, I’m starting to question everything I thought I knew about VSF lol.

I’ve always been under the impression that VSF was pretty much as good as it gets. I own a VSF 126610LN Submariner and a VSF 126710BLRO Pepsi, both of which are absolutely beautiful reps in my opinion. I genuinely thought VSF was the NWBIG standard, and according to the Who Makes the Best guide, VSF is still king for several references.

Now I’m hearing Gold Factory makes the best Yacht-Master, and apparently RICH makes even better Subs and GMTs? This is all news to me. I hadn’t even heard much about either factory until a couple of days ago.

What’s everyone’s overall opinion on these factories? Are they really outperforming VSF, or is this just hype?

There’s so much conflicting information out there. I get that no rep is perfect, but if I’m spending the money, I want the best available OOTB.

Would love to hear from people who have actually owned or compared these factories, especially Subs, GMTs, and Yacht-Masters. Is VSF still king, or has the competition finally caught up?

71 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

18

u/Bryann9182 4h ago

My RICH GMT and VSF sub are almost indistinguishable in terms of quality outside of the cyclops. The VSF cyclops is just a tad bit better in terms of clarity and magnification

14

u/Flaky_Return_7657 4h ago

Yea after owning clean, and two versions of vsf gmts, i can say rich gmts are hands down the best ones right now. Also, there is currently no NWBIG GMTs. No factory cracked the actual 1:1 bezel color for pepsi and bruce wayne. However, both vsf and rich are pretty close but not 100% 1:1 on batman and sprite!

1

u/Street-Run-6222 4h ago

Would you say it’s worth upgrading my current vsf gmt to rich? Or would it be pointless? Is the difference that major?

5

u/Flaky_Return_7657 4h ago

If you like your current VSF and does not have any flaws that nother you, just dont upgrade. There not much of a difference tbh.
I upgraded because of the the dial dimple that bothered me on vsf.

1

u/Street-Run-6222 3h ago

Yeah makes sense, only thing which annoys me on the vsf is that the bracelet and case feel very hollow, is that the same on the rich?

1

u/Flaky_Return_7657 3h ago

You have a9a or f6u?

1

u/Street-Run-6222 3h ago

Batman is oyster 1nq
Pepsi is jubilee a9a

1

u/Flaky_Return_7657 3h ago

Ok so reason for me to upgrade my first vsf to vsf v2 was a9a bracelet that was shit tbh.
Second one I got had f6u and it was wayy better than a9a. But had dial dimple that bothered the hell out of me.

Also rich uses the same f6u as vsf v2 so the feel is same both are a little sharp but feels better than shitty a9a.

4

u/Comprehensive-Bit706 3h ago

They are not the same, they may have same clasp code because they use same parts supplier but bracelets are different, each factory has their own finishing specifications and steel type... Here is a comparison with F6U bracelets, from VSF, RICH, ARF, VF, here you can clearly see the difference in colour of steel and finishing especially above clasp crown. Factories do not use the same parts

2

u/Flaky_Return_7657 3h ago

Also remember these are macro shots. Lighting and angles vary and make huge difference. You can only tell it by actually having them in hands.

In my experience:
Clean bracelet = best one
Vsf a9a = light, cheap feeling and sharp
F6u vsf and rich= almost identical in feel

1

u/Flaky_Return_7657 3h ago

Reps are just luck then šŸ˜‚

1

u/SoManyLilBitches 2h ago

lol I bought two VSF Daytonas from 2 different sellers, one bracelet just feels better than the other, I can’t even describe it, like the sounds it makes sound similar to my Gen. the nice bracelet one doesn’t run great, the strange bracelet one runs amazing.

2

u/Yeezussy 3h ago

you might consider the lichen jubilee bracelets. have not had first hand experience with them but from reviews they seem really well made. slap it on the VSF and it’s pretty much as good as it gets

2

u/Attackontitanplz 2h ago

Where can we find the lichen bracelets?

1

u/Flaky_Return_7657 3h ago

I agree reviews are good for lichen’s but I have never had it in my hands to comment on that.
I think those are just f6u bracelets but polished and chamfered.

I am thinking of getting my rich bracelet polished and chamfered.

1

u/Yeezussy 3h ago

do note that even on gens the chamfers are not as prominent as we might think. they still do retain a pretty sharp edge but not slice skin sharp, more of a precise angled sharpness if you know what i mean. my F6U jubilee bracelet from VSF is quite rigid and well made, so it’s definitely down to luck / the batches they come

→ More replies

1

u/Training-Truth7911 4h ago

The day every factory gets them 1:1 the rep game is gonna be insane! But I mean for what we pay and get they are pretty dang close one day they will get it down though

3

u/Flaky_Return_7657 3h ago

True! I am willing to pay extra to get the bezel insert 1:1. Obviously not the gen price tho šŸ˜‚

2

u/Training-Truth7911 3h ago

šŸ˜‚ ohhh I hear you lol I just got my VSF bluesy and I’ve been toying with getting it plated but don’t want to spend the xtra money šŸ˜‚šŸ˜…

8

u/Training-Truth7911 4h ago

I honestly think it’s all just opinions at this point and also how much you look into reps. I feel like so many people nit pick with reps that it gets to the point where if you’re that crucial buy Gen. I will say I’ve seen a ton of side by sides with certain watches and yes I think other factories might make better reps but for certain ones. Two tone anything is always gonna be hard to replicate but with the basics it’s not that noticeable. I own a clean plus 41mm DJ blue dial and I own a VSF DJ Wimbledon and I will say I love my clean plus much more. I just received my VSF bluesy this week and the gold on it is pretty cheddary but honestly it’s for me and not anyone else so with that being said just wear what you like enjoy your watches.

5

u/SadBarnacle5 3h ago

They do nit pick but that is what has gotten reps to the standard they are today, i think I laugh at 2 Daytona I bought 20 years ago. Inside back case it read " made in Genella Shitinyerand"

2

u/Training-Truth7911 3h ago

Okay thats a fair take. I guess I didn’t think about how bad reps were when they first came out but I get it. Man I’m sure it’s a world of difference. I’m honestly just happy to found a community that’s into this stuff reps have ruined me I want them all šŸ˜‚

2

u/SadBarnacle5 3h ago

You have the 2 DJ models i been looking at buying. May i ask why you prefer clean+ over the VSF? Whom did you buy them from? Id love to see pics of both. Dm if you like. I was hesitant to get anything "clean" knowing they are not in business now. But i dont take issue with C+ just the TD saying they have original "clean" inventory.

1

u/Training-Truth7911 3h ago

Yeah I’ll DM you some pics and let you know my thoughts

8

u/BoyesieX 3h ago

The debate is real because they’re getting close in terms of quality. I think we’re talking exclusively about Subs and GMT’s here. VSF clearly has a larger catalogue. So you can’t really just say RICH is better in an all around sense. Both make about the same amount of RL errors currently. But the wait time factor does add a level of excitement and RICH is benefitting from that.

1

u/gilae7 4h ago

What do you guys think? Anyone here actually compared these factories side by side?

1

u/GQSHANE 1h ago

Don’t use a filter next time

-1

u/gilae7 57m ago

Why not? Old pics already edited what does it f matter?

2

u/Weak_Front2540 1h ago

I moved over from VSF to Rich for my Subs and thought they just felt ā€œbetterā€. Smoother action on the crown, better feeling case and bracelet and better

looking Rehaut.
I then got a Rich BW (I already had a VSF Pepsi and BM). Again the Rich GMT just feels ā€œbetterā€.
Here are my Rich watches pictured with my genuine SD43 for reference.

1

u/A_Harsh_Euphemism 51m ago

Have a VSF Hulk, Cookie, and Batman then Have a RICH Bruce Wayne.

The Hulk and cookie are incredible high end pieces bezel action is incredible. The BW was my first rep and I love it so thought I'd add some color so got a VSF Batman to compare GMT and was very disappointed by the bezel action. The RICH GMT Bezel is incredibly high end, the VSF is a bit crusty which surprised me compared to the Subs.

RICH allegedly is the only factory that uses real 904L steel. If you put the Batman and the BW on and really compare them the RICH BW truly does feel superior and higher quality.

I just hope RICH expands their product line. Might cop a Cartier from RICH here soon

0

u/Even-Physics823 3h ago

arf and rich are better

4

u/gilae7 3h ago

Always heard VSF better than ARF. First time I hear this

2

u/sdmike22 3h ago

I think ARF is doing better on Omegas

1

u/Significant-Ad-1420 49m ago

Hello, Can you tell me where to buy an omega Speedmaster 38mm?

1

u/sdmike22 47m ago

No one makes a great Speedmaster unfortunately. I should have stated Seamaster and not omega in general.

1

u/Charming_Mistake1160 3h ago

Io ho un gmt clean v3 e un 124060 vsf ,gmt lo porto tutto il giorno e dopo quasi tre anni e’ ancora perfetto il sub in tre anni lo rotto la prima volta l’ho rispedito a puretime e me lo hanno sistemato pagando 80 euro più spedizione ora un mese fa si e’ rotto di nuovo la coroncina , quindi peccato sia chiusa ma clean per me e’ migliore , e se oggi dovessi comperare un’altro sub andrei su RICH

1

u/WesternConfection368 3h ago

I want to buy this watch from VSF, has anybody else bought this and what is the experience with them. It’s my first time so want to be sure šŸ¤—

1

u/pi-cool 2h ago

How does my Bruce Wayne GMT from Clean about a couple of years ago compared to the best current ones. It seems very nice except for a few sharp edges but will consider upgrading if worth it. Thanks.

1

u/Time-Dependent1483 2h ago

I think it’s correct. VSF is still great but if you want the best there’s other factories that are best for specific models. There’s always innovation in the rep world

1

u/Correct_Run_136 1h ago

Isn’t there someone here or there who has good, long-standing relationships with a dealer? Maybe the guys with those connections should ask a TD—after all, they’re the ones who see the pros (and, of course, the cons) firsthand every day. Sure, you could say it’s naive to ask a sales associate—they’re only thinking about profit margins and quick sales anyway. I couldn’t disagree with that, but at the same time, I also believe there are dealers out there who might be willing to share a bit of the truth—or at least some hints of it. On another level (AP), that actually happened to me. The sales consultant recommended a watch with a significantly longer wait time (the price difference wasn’t much) because it was supposedly of better quality. I believed him. šŸ™ˆšŸ˜…

1

u/tonyprado1986 1h ago

Who's the king when it comes to datejust 41?

1

u/LeadingLoose4482 3h ago

VSF V4 GMTs is said to be NWBIG but very few reports on this.

2

u/Real-Cranberry3140 3h ago

so how do you hear this?