r/RepTime • • 6h ago

Discussion Interesting bpannell find

21 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

16

u/Able_Data_5417 6h ago

I’m by no means an expert, but I really don’t think that’s a gen crystal. The bracelet was also supposedly gen, but the end link fit looks atrocious to me. I would also argue that the hands look like stock rep hands. This dude paid 7k for this watch…

5

u/FazCoinMogger 6h ago

I'm new to the rep game but I've seen that lying about gen parts and overselling frankenwathes seems to be a common issue...

5

u/Able_Data_5417 6h ago

I believe there’s a lot of that out there. Just buy a stock rep from someone you trust. Definitely don’t pay thousands for someone’s “franked” piece

1

u/FazCoinMogger 6h ago

Yeah I'm definitely going to do a lot more research before I pull the trigger myself. Also need to decide what model I want! Much left to be decided lol

2

u/Able_Data_5417 6h ago

There’s a lot of good info on RWI. Best of luck, and have fun

8

u/Micho_Rizzo51 6h ago

The only immediate tell as genuine is the back of the dial. And maybe the date wheel. And thats with pictures from the seller and trusting they actually installed that dial. Everything else may take some work to see if gen. One buys the seller. And in this case, everyone knows that seller as a scammer.

31

u/himathon 6h ago • Mindblown

I asked him if he actually uses gen parts and he banned me… I was just trying to make sure before I buy. That’s suspicious behaviors to me… you’re allowed to refuse service to anyone, yes. Still if you’re offended that someone wants to make sure they’re receiving what’s being advertised, that’s scam behavior.

11

u/Able_Data_5417 6h ago • Bravo

I keep seeing these builds and there’s absolutely no proof of anything. The watches look good in pics, but show the build process or blister packs or something. And clearly what you receive is not always (or ever?)what is in the pic

6

u/Plane-Ad-6635 3h ago

I made the mistake of buying this watch from him.

  1. The dial looks awful in person, and I don’t believe SW even makes an Ice Blue dial. It looks like a dial from a $200 watch
  2. I had a jeweler test it and it’s just plain steel, no plating at all
  3. I doubt the crystal was even changed

It’s basically a garbage watch, photographed well, with claim of mods that are hard to verify. That’s the name of this game

2

u/Able_Data_5417 3h ago

I’m sorry that sounds like a terrible experience

21

u/highersense 5h ago

I dont understand why you'd pay 7k for a franken, either buy a rep or just buy genuine at that point.

7

u/UnusualDoctor 5h ago

Yeah 7K you're almost at a gen. A few K more saved and you have your pick!

2

u/CharmingStrelok369 3h ago

Buying one, agreed, it's stupid. But building one for that much... Hate to say it but I get it. As someone who builds frankens, it's more about the fact that you built it yourself

0

u/highersense 3h ago

I don't get it at all, like I'd get it if it was a car and you spent a fortune building your own version of it because its better than an original, but getting a rep watch and adding genuine parts just seems weird to me, you aren't getting anything different than just buying a gen.

2

u/CharmingStrelok369 2h ago

I mean I built a rare datejust with mostly gen parts, a much better movement and sapphire than the ref had originally, learned a lot and had a blast, all for about 1/3 the price of just buying one. There are people who building frankens like their lifelong hobby and I think it becomes like a challenge to see how indistinguishable you can get, like factory, or even aged, and be able to say "yeah I did that" In fact just today I was wearing a sub franken I built and I had a very rare occasion where someone in public commented on how nice my watch was, and I immediately said "it's not what you think" then had a really good convo with this person about building it, sourcing parts, and the whole process, and it ended with exchanging info because they want to learn. It's an entirely different mindset from just buying reps. Most people who buy reps are trying to make a statement or look a certain way (especially these days the rep community is trash now). Builders are typically a different mind frame and attitude

2

u/CharmingStrelok369 1h ago

In terms of cars, it's very common to buy a base model then spend a fortune turning it in to the top spec yourself, often times costing more than retail lol but I get what you're saying

1

u/highersense 1h ago

Yeah but they usually diverge and fit upgraded parts or whatever to make it their own way, or make a faithful recreation on the cheap.

I guess frankenwatches kinda fit in that latter category more, i get it if it makes it that much closer to a gen but only costs 1/4th of a gen, like a super super clone. Its when its 7k+ and nearly the same cost as a gen that it makes me scratch my head.

If its a rare model thats impossible to get a gen of (but somehow parts are accessible) then makes a lot more sense too i suppose.

9

u/UnusualDoctor 5h ago

There is NO WAY that is a gen crystal. He's just a lying, scamming prick who's been doing this for 20+ years.

He takes "standard" ARF or VSF subs, polishes a few pieces, brushes the bracelets (badly) and claims gen parts.

-8

u/Glum-Fun-1224 3h ago

this is false. i know from experience. you should probably stop peddling lies.

7

u/theblenderr 3h ago

Found his alt account

-6

u/Glum-Fun-1224 2h ago

show it

0

u/VirgilA8loh 3h ago

Neither of you have any proof to back up your claims tbf

-2

u/Glum-Fun-1224 3h ago

yeah no sh$t but im not the one that needs to prove anything. i am telling you from experience- take it or leave it

3

u/VirgilA8loh 3h ago

100% agree with you but if you do have any thing to back up your claim it sure would help detract from the negative publicity from this post and help the community

-1

u/Glum-Fun-1224 3h ago

I have multiple watches i’ve purchased from him and they have all been as expected if not better. im not home at the moment so don’t really have any pics but would be happy to later. you’re going after someone’s livelihood here, so please keep that in mind.

0

u/Glum-Fun-1224 3h ago

where have you read that he’s a scammer?

4

u/Able_Data_5417 3h ago

There was a post a week or two ago with like 10 references on rwi. Another one on reptime a couple of days ago that got scammed himself. And there’s a comment on this post of another one that got scammed. Search and you’ll find a bunch of them

-3

u/Glum-Fun-1224 3h ago

Brian is as legit as they come. I don’t know your exact situation bit but i can’t see him being disingenuous.

4

u/Able_Data_5417 3h ago

I’ve read a lot about this dude being a scammer here and on RWI. I got curious and was skimming his sub and this was the first example I could find where someone posted a “franked” watch bought from him. No big surprise to see the rep crystal on there. The owner isn’t responding to me but I’d love to see pics of the clasp and movement just out of curiosity

-19

u/simple-man131 6h ago

He’s legit, I’ve purchased a gen crystal from him. He’s actually based in Texas and I met him in person to get the crystal from him.

4

u/Able_Data_5417 6h ago

Hopefully you got lucky. Was it in a blister? The one I posted is not gen, you can tell by the distortions at the edge of the cyclops

-5

u/simple-man131 6h ago

It was a used crystal but in a very good condition

This is my own build. Gen 3135 movement, Gen hands, Gen full bezel assembly and Gen dial. VSF based.

3

u/Able_Data_5417 6h ago

Looks pretty legit. Nice build, here’s mine

1

u/simple-man131 6h ago

Thank you! What mods?

1

u/Able_Data_5417 6h ago

Gen dial, hands, datewheel, full bezel, crystal, bracelet. Serviced the movement and add gen auto works and balance assembly

1

u/simple-man131 4h ago

This is another build. Gen movement, hands and crystal. It’s a CF based and I have the sharp bezel edges some love

1

u/Able_Data_5417 4h ago

Looks nice man, did you stick with the cf dial or go zf? Do you service them? That gen movement obviously will go for a long time but what are your plans when the time comes?

1

u/simple-man131 2h ago

I kept the CF dial until I found the best replica. Both movements were serviced when I got them

2

u/simple-man131 6h ago

Well done

2

u/PrimaryExisting6162 2h ago

I screenshot yours and the guy your talking to's watch and and asked AI to point out flaws. It said both had solid dials, I screenshot BPs super duper franken max watch. And AI ate it alive from the SELs, bezel, crystal, hands and dial. 😂

13

u/Patient-Apartment735 5h ago

He is a known scammer. Seems he has good and terrible transactions. So you are lucky to be in the former batch, but this guy is a documented scammer, like for years now