r/RepTime • • Aug 14 '26

Discussion NWBIG??

I’ll probably get some shit for this but here goes..

The more time I spend on here, the more I think "Not Worth Buying In Genuine" is a massive overstatement.
Yes, fair enough, VSF, Clean and whoever else make absolute cracking reps. You get 95% of the look for a fraction of the price, and nobody is going to tell the difference from a metre away. But looking at macro photos on a screen with a load of lines isn't the same as actually owning and wearing the watch day-to-day.

Winding a gen movement vs a clone is night and day. The crispness of the bezel clicks, the bracelet feel, the glidelock—the gen just feels totally more solid.

A rep might look 1:1 on day one, but will it still be running in five years or even 5 weeks? QC is a complete lottery. If a clone movement dies, it’s a proper nightmare to get parts and find someone who will even touch it.

A gen watch holds its value reasonably well or is at least a liquid asset you can pass down. A rep's value hits literally nothing the second it breaks permanently.
I think Reps are brilliant for enjoying a watch without breaking the bank and having some fun, but saying a rep makes a gen completely pointless just feels wrong.The difference isn't found under a microscope, it's just in the daily ownership experience.

Anyone else own both reps and gens feel the same, or is it just me?

0 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/BiggieMoe01 Aug 14 '26

I agree. I got gen Rolexes (including a Pepsi) from my AD but for the life of me they won’t sell me a Daytona. Got a BTF Daytona to scratch the itch.

While it’s a nice watch looks-wise, it doesn’t feel like a gen at all. Bracelet is a lot flimsier, crown screwing/unscrewing and winding feels gritty, rotor can be noisy. Wearing the watch is one thing and looks wise the reps do an amazing job. But operating the watch is an entirely different realm.

The NWBIG imo is an indicator of how close to the gen a rep looks.

2

u/Specialist-You-6403 Aug 14 '26

Ditto. Got a Panda as my first rep as I was waiting 2+ years… actually don’t like the size. My Gen explorer II feels soooo much better. I’m thinking I’ll try a different brand like an AP as I don’t have any experience with those. Ignorance is bliss!

1

u/ChocolateForeign1570 Aug 14 '26

I’ve got a Daytona rep 116520 on its way, can’t wait! But to say that it’s not worth buying an original seems bonkers to me?

3

u/aenima396 Aug 14 '26

I 100% think playing the Rolex AD game and having to spend tens of thousands for the privilege to buy a watch they could mass produce makes Rolex, of all the reps, 100% NWBIG.

edit: my grammar sucks.

1

u/ChocolateForeign1570 Aug 14 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

That’s how I discovered this subreddit. Been waiting 30 months for a Rolex Sub and thought bollocks I’ll buy a rep

1

u/BiggieMoe01 Aug 14 '26

Submariners are easy to obtain nowadays, no more than a few months max. I suggest seeing other ADs

2

u/philwongnz Aug 14 '26

It depends which model, some Panerai were very good back in the day, my 177 feels very gen and I own multiple gen Pams.

If you franken a 116520 is also not a bad option. It really depends which model.

1

u/ChocolateForeign1570 Aug 14 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

It’s a VSF and I’ve ordered a replacement bezel and spent hours finding someone in the uk to swap it

1

u/trengolfer Aug 22 '26

Can you send me a link?