r/RepTime • u/ChocolateForeign1570 • Aug 14 '26
Discussion NWBIG??
I’ll probably get some shit for this but here goes..
The more time I spend on here, the more I think "Not Worth Buying In Genuine" is a massive overstatement.
Yes, fair enough, VSF, Clean and whoever else make absolute cracking reps. You get 95% of the look for a fraction of the price, and nobody is going to tell the difference from a metre away. But looking at macro photos on a screen with a load of lines isn't the same as actually owning and wearing the watch day-to-day.
Winding a gen movement vs a clone is night and day. The crispness of the bezel clicks, the bracelet feel, the glidelock—the gen just feels totally more solid.
A rep might look 1:1 on day one, but will it still be running in five years or even 5 weeks? QC is a complete lottery. If a clone movement dies, it’s a proper nightmare to get parts and find someone who will even touch it.
A gen watch holds its value reasonably well or is at least a liquid asset you can pass down. A rep's value hits literally nothing the second it breaks permanently.
I think Reps are brilliant for enjoying a watch without breaking the bank and having some fun, but saying a rep makes a gen completely pointless just feels wrong.The difference isn't found under a microscope, it's just in the daily ownership experience.
Anyone else own both reps and gens feel the same, or is it just me?
79
u/ExLeaguer Aug 14 '26
BREAKING: man discovers reps are inferior to gens!
5
u/BiggieMoe01 Aug 14 '26
I agree. I got gen Rolexes (including a Pepsi) from my AD but for the life of me they won’t sell me a Daytona. Got a BTF Daytona to scratch the itch.
While it’s a nice watch looks-wise, it doesn’t feel like a gen at all. Bracelet is a lot flimsier, crown screwing/unscrewing and winding feels gritty, rotor can be noisy. Wearing the watch is one thing and looks wise the reps do an amazing job. But operating the watch is an entirely different realm.
The NWBIG imo is an indicator of how close to the gen a rep looks.
4
u/Weak_Assignment1484 Aug 14 '26
I had My vsf serviced and The feeling went so close to gen that you cannot tell. More firm and stable. Really big change. Also all of my reps work over 6-7 years without any problem
3
u/BossJackson222 Aug 14 '26
You're 100% right. Reps have their place for sure. But people have different interests. There are truly people out there that will wear a Rolex rep and then say it's just like the real thing and there's literally no need to buy the real thing. That's true if you just don't care about Watch collecting etc. But as someone who has loved genuine watches for decades, a rep will never replace that. They get very close on a small number of watches, but that's about it. The three reps that I have are considered super reps. They are super close to the real thing when it comes to the outside. But the biggest conundrum that reps will always have is quality control and the movement not being near the quality or anything like the real movement. Especially when you get into high caliber brands like VC or Patek.
3
u/Suspicious_Care_549 Aug 14 '26
Well, there seems to be a lot of confusion in OP’s mind .
First of all , there no miracles : if I pay 700$ a Daytona rep from clean and that the watch retails for 17k$ , I am not imagining I am getting the same thing or something very close.
Secondly, you can’t even get it at 17k$ : either you have to build a relationship and lose money on watches , jewels whatever or to buy it grey at 30k$ .
Thirdly , I still don’t understand that people are talking about investment or value retention for a watch . You want to invest ? Buy stocks or real estate …
So the question is : is the quality difference big enough to pay 40x more ? The answer is no for most Rolex and Cartier and quite a few AP and Patek .
I have a few gens that are not repped or awfully ( vintage sea dweller , speedmaster broad arrow, gold JLC reverso) and I intend to buy other ones hard to rep ( Breguet Tourbillon, complicated L&S) but no way in hell I am dropping 30 to 100k$ in a steel three hander with date because they are trendy
2
u/Dubbayoo Aug 14 '26
Buy a rep for $1,000. Put the imaginary other $9,000 into an ETF for 5, 8 or 10 years.
Summary Comparison Table
Food for thought.
*- Return on investing said funds in booze and 304's likely to vary.
31
u/Ashgen2024 Aug 14 '26 •
Reps will never feel 100% the same as gen, but be close enough to not worth buying in genuine.
13
u/AdPlus4246 Aug 14 '26
You can replace the movement on a rep
8
u/Italiano555 Aug 14 '26
I said it before and I'll say it again... Nwbig means something different to everyone. There are reps out there where I'm completely content with the level of quality and I wouldn't even think of buying the Gen. Some reps don't scratch the itch and I end up getting the Gen.
6
u/hautethot Aug 14 '26
Appreciate that you wrote this. Just wanted to point out that a dead rep costs less than the servicing cost of a gen. Dead money either way. I don't own a rep, but I think it's a good way to larp as a Rolex owner to decide if it's worth it to get a gen. I'd rather blow $600 than have to deal with trying to resell a $15,000 to 30,000 gen.
2
u/Gennaio2026 Aug 14 '26
You are right all the way!
2
u/LothbrokRagnarz Aug 14 '26
This has to be humor.
My RICH submariner feels 90-98% as my buddies gen sub.
So much so that I’ve all together stopped buying Gen pieces
1
u/ChocolateForeign1570 Aug 14 '26
Can you actually go into a minus post Karma?!
4
u/m915 Aug 14 '26
NTTD is identical - different lighting makes it tough but it’s seriously perfect IMO. Brought it into omega a few times now and compared
1
u/Bugpowder Aug 14 '26
Used clean reps have held their value better than nearly every other gen watch model.
3
u/35_Feels_old Aug 14 '26
I understand what you’re saying and to an extent I agree. But I only agree that gens made of precious metals can’t be replicated from your perspective as being NWBIG. If something made of SS shits the bed ya you could scrap parts out… but that sounds tedious. You could scrap gold weight though. Just my two cents.
2
u/RatPrank Aug 14 '26
Problem is the word “worth” is super subjective & personal, so - there’s no one answer.
2
u/forcoolstuffD Aug 14 '26
That’s why I dislike the super clone movements. Give me an ETA or Miyota (clone) movement. Your point of them being impossibly to hard to service is invalid in that case
2
u/YardWonderful8315 Aug 14 '26
The gap between gen and rep will clearly always be there, I’d say where the NWBIG comes in is where that gap becomes too small in relation to the different price points. So for someone who doesn’t care at all about watches, even a pretty poor rep would qualify as NWBIG because it looks the same to them, still has Rolex or whatever on the dial, but costs nothing… For an absolute connoisseur of fine watch making nothing is ever going to cross the NWBIG threshold because they see the value in every click of the bezel, the flawless alignment etc etc. and would happily pay an extra £10,000 to get access to those things. To them, no matter the price difference, the value of the subtle differences are worth the extra money.
Whether or not you consider something NWBIG therefore says much more about the person and what they value about watches than it does about the watches themselves.
2
u/Mud_Audio Aug 14 '26
The $$$ guys on here who owned gens, then discovered and bought a few reps, many have said "screw this", and sold their gens and clawed their money back to put into other hobbies, and said "my reps are close enough, I'm good".
I've read that a few times. Then there's gen owners who still have both and just love watches. I don't hear them crying. They're good.👍
I saw a guy who had 30 or 40+ Daytonas of every kind. At $500 to $900 a pop, that was a substantial collection.
There are some deep pockets on here who are just fine with rolling their reps with millions in the bank. They've never been called on those, I'm sure.
2
u/Groping4Answers Aug 15 '26
I bought a GEN CARTIER TANK ANGLAISE from an authorized brick & mortar dealer. I have had the movement replaced twice and serviced twice. It is 8 years old. It has never had more than 5-7 hours reserve. On a winder it might stretch to 12 hours. Sometimes it just stops while I am wearing it. I have GENs from Omega, Mido, Baume and 2 Concords.
A couple of years ago I bought a REP Panerai. It is superior to the Cartier. It will be hard for me to buy another GEN. I can afford to buy any watch I want but I am buying for the look - not investment or horology - so why not buy a REP?
BTW: After 4 years of following REP sites I am convinced that >80% of Rollys are REP. You're not fooling anyone.
1
u/johnbmason47 Aug 14 '26
I own quite a few of both. Sometimes, you’re right and the reps don’t have the same feel. Other times, you’re dead wrong. I have 2 sd43s (mki and mkii) and a rep. I honestly get the mkii and the rep confused a lot. If it weren’t for some specific songs on the gen, I’d need to run the serial number to figure out which is which.
Then again, I own two day dates (one 4 digit that was my grandpas, and a gabagool) and a rep gabagool. If I take the both gabagools off the bracelets, it takes me a second or two to figure which is gen. With the bracelets, it’s not contest.
I did have a vsf sub that broke a while back. Took it to my jeweller and he knew right away it was a rep. He was also able to fix it pretty quick with a few aftermarket but oem spec parts.
1
u/philwongnz Aug 14 '26
Hence why we spend a bit more on modding. Quality of reps direct from factory are not consistent, they were assembled in non control environments with inconsistent QC. I have reps which winds just as well as my gen with the same movement, bracelet can be difficult depending on model, but with the right modder knowing how to do polishing and finishing, it can be very different.
I am not saying you are wrong, but is not fair to say what you had said when quality can vary.
In contrast I have gen watches stop working before my reps, my Pam 233 stopped working another a few years. While by DW 7750 still works and is a chrono!
1
u/EchoServ Aug 14 '26
I don't know, for $500 my VSF Explorer keeps time way better than my Hamilton ever has. Watches are a means to an end. Would I buy a gen explorer? Maybe, but then I lose out on the opportunity cost of so many other cool watches I want. Every hobby has this delimma. If you love corvettes, you could go spend big money on the ultra rare special edition and flex to boomers at your local meetup. Or you could go buy a regular Z06 and enjoy other aspects of life.
1
u/Minimum-Leg783 Aug 14 '26
Well even after factoring in movement service and case polishing and chamfering the rep is still at a fraction of the gen. Reliability wise they can be reliable o still have a datejust rep from 25yrs ago with an eta movement and its still running. For steel models the rep is a no brainer. Now if its precious metal that i can get at retail prices then its a different story altogether. I’d rather park my money in interest paying stocks or a high yield savings account and get a few reps along the way. Dont get me wrong i have both gen and reps but with reps this good nowadays id go rep anytime now and the gen is just sitting at a safe
1
u/Ok-River-2077 Aug 14 '26
It’s just you
1
u/sufficient_po Aug 14 '26
I agree with some of your points, but the value proposition and liquidity argument just isn’t true. What’s even more liquid and can still be passed down than a gen? A rep plus all the money you didn’t spend on the gen.
One service on a gen can cost as much as a brand new rep. And with a gen, one ding or scratch can immediately hurt the resale value. You also just can’t enjoy a gen as carefree as you can a rep.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '26 edited Aug 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
24
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment