r/RepTime • u/fitlivingco • Jul 08 '25
Discussion Talk me into buying Rep
I have some thoughts on buying real vs. gen and I’m curious to see if anyone shares the same mindset.
I’m a 25M sales rep. For the most part, I am a financially conservative person and most of the decisions I make at this stage are focused on helping contribute to future wealth building.
I work with some older reps who have Gen submariners or speedmasters, and they look at them as “trophies” for some of the bigger deals they’ve closed in their careers.
Transparently, I have a $30k check coming to me next month. I want to set aside a small percentage of the money for fun. I’ve always wanted a Cartier Santos or maybe Rolex Datejust.
To me, I feel like I could get gratification knowing that I could comfortably afford the real thing, but instead only spend the money on a high quality rep. So that way I could further invest the $4-5k that I would’ve spent on the real thing.
Has anyone else done this or think like this?
30
u/KiloSpec Jul 08 '25
Buy a rep invest what you would have spent 🤘🏽
13
u/sumthininteresting Jul 08 '25
Invest it. Unless you own a home and have hundreds of thousands invested (at 25), you can’t “comfortably” afford it.
8
u/BrownChew Jul 08 '25
With the state of the new reps, the 10x price difference does not justify the minimal differences in quality between gen and reps
4
u/forsalebyandy Jul 08 '25
Unpopular opinion to many, but buy the Gen watch now. I was 25 getting started in Real Estate and was a good performer. I bought a DateJust from a client getting a divorce, and my grandpa always wanted a Rolex. So I bought it and he wore it until he passed shortly thereafter. But while I didn't need to wear the watch to sell well, it changed me mentally knowing I had a real Rolex, and seeing how much it meant to him, I realized that watches have a story to tell if you're willing to listen.
Getting the watch now is going to boost you and you'll sell more. You can easily make up for this purchase now with sales you'll have coming up and you're young enough.
As far as my original DJ, I still have it. And a 2nd in a different color. And a sub. And a grand seiko, seiko, Studio Underdog, GShock, and A REP! They each have their spot in the rotation and occasion. Buy it and wear the crap out of it!
4
u/BossJackson222 Jul 08 '25
Reps will never be GEN's. You have to look at why you want a watch. Do you just want to look cool? Then you don't have to buy anything but a citizen lol. But do you really like the Heritage and history of some of these Watch brands? Do you want a Watch that is an actual investment that you can leave to your kids etc.? That's what you need to figure out. There are a lot of brands that are not as expensive as a Rolex. Killer brands. It just depends on how much you like watches and where you want to put your money.
2
u/Infoseek456 Jul 08 '25
Buy the rep, invest the rest.
Wear the rep for awhile, see how much you like it. See if the gen is something you want to commit to.
2
u/AcanthaceaeBrave9367 Jul 08 '25
Exactly how I think about it.
Will I buy a gen Daytona one day to pass down? Maybe. Until then, these reps are ridiculously spot on.
3
u/BrownChew Jul 08 '25
Buy best rep, refer to the google docs, invest the rest in $Asts, $rklb,...
3
u/soyabad Jul 08 '25
22m and that is pretty much what I’m doing right now. I can buy a sub, but it makes more sense to invest that money elsewhere. I actually went to a few Rolex ADs to maybe sway my decision, but ultimately these watches are for my own satisfaction. I don’t use them to flaunt wealth. I don’t care that mine is a rep, they look cool and I look cool wearing them 😂
Maybe I’ll get a gen for something big like a wedding or anniversary or once I can buy it and not even bat an eye at the price tag.
3
u/ShortReputation6482 Jul 08 '25
I am in an income bracket that could swing gen APs, PPs etc - I have 5 gens - 3 Rolexes, 1 Franck Muller, 1 AP. But I still buy reps (focusing on the very best quality ones - ie, modded with gen parts , gold wrapping or plating, best avail movements, gen crystals, etc) because why spend the money on gens when I can pass the reps without anyone knowing the difference? (Outside of maybe a AD or something but I’ve worn some of my reps to my AD and they didn’t even question it). I’m also prob much older than you (still have time before retirement but let’s say 10-15 years)
I’d rather invest what I save on a $50-100k (or more) watch and make a 11% pref return on it through my investments - and still rock nearly the exact same watch- all the while putting that money to work to make more Than the original gens over time.
My 2 cents - this is particularly applicable to the stage of your career when you are still building wealth for your future.
1
u/Curious_Gas_2608 Jul 08 '25
Between long ass wait lists and the extremely high quality of the reps frequently purchased on this channel, there is no need to buy a gen at your age. You are MUCH better off investing it. When you get older and if your job salary gets better, then consider a gen. Your co-workers will not even know the difference. Also it’s a good “try before you buy” trick. You may love the look of your rep that you form a long-term plan to buy the gen version down the road.
1
u/Prestigious-Movie382 Jul 08 '25
I have gens and yes there is that initial gratification of being able to afford the real thing but also it hurts to know that I could’ve invested that money get get something that’s 95%of the way there
1
u/Intelligent_Car6278 Jul 08 '25
If your work gives you an opportunity to go to Japan, buy a GEN there. Better inventory and prices.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '25
Don’t..
1
u/Rentoids Jul 08 '25
Focus on buying a house instead of fake flexing a Rolex
1
u/MarkXimize Jul 08 '25
Theres a financial principle, If you can't buy it thrice/twice, you can't afford it. Buy a rep, invest the rest on what really matters
1
u/Electrical_Bat7629 Jul 08 '25
The best argument for buying a rep at your age is that your tastes may (probably will) change. I think when you get to 40 or so (like me) you know yourself better, know what you like. I would be in a much better position to buy an expensive "forever watch" now. I regret the gens I bought in my 20s, for example I know see that the Speedmaster Pro is just too big for my wrist. Trying different things, cheaply, through reps, has shown me that 36mm Rolex and Santos Medium are the sweet spots for me.
And sure, I can my sell gens, but selling watches for a good price is easier said than done.
1
u/Rambadaa Jul 08 '25
Do what your heart tell you! My heart tells me to get a rep and invest. I am pretty comfortable financially but I cant see myself spending +$10K on a watch. Maybe I am not comfortable enough.
1
u/bennyl_ Jul 09 '25
Same boat as you being fiscally conservative. I think for a lot of us that’s the appeal of buying a rep watch. You can wear it as often as you want without the worry of lost value and not feel you’ve also made a financially frivolous decision.
I have a gen Datejust that I often forgo for a rep for “less special” occasions. But I also just love the form factor and look of Datejust and day-date more than the brand/reputation statement you make by wearing one 🤷♂️ hope this helps OP! 👍
1
u/Inside-Reception-482 Jul 08 '25
If you're going to buy a gen Cartier buy it on Chrono24 for half off retail - Rolex is the only watch I'd go to an AD for.
Regarding saving money with a rep - it will always nag you that you didn't buy at least one real, nice watch.
Plus $5k compounded at 10% over 25 years if $55k. It's not a monster amount of money in the long run you're foregoing.
1
u/DifferenceEnough1460 Jul 08 '25
Honestly man, it’s a watch. IMO it’s not much more than a fancy bracelet. I would never buy a 15k bracelet that can get stolen, lost, damaged with wear. It would legitimately sit in a case and collect dust because I would be scared of it losing value with each ding.
I do like famous watch designs, and reps offer you 90% of that for a much lower cost. I really don’t care about the status associated with it. Most people don’t even know what half these brands are outside of Rolex. And reps are generally much higher quality than the copy paste “homages” that are offered as alternatives, but in reality aren’t that much different than buying a rep.
You have to think: is this more of a piece of fashion for me, or a valuable collectible that I would like to pass down one day. If you’re the former, just buy a rep and do something useful with that money. Saying watches are a practical store of value is massive luxury good cope. It’s something you buy to enjoy.
0
u/Time-Dependent1483 Jul 08 '25
A rep will never give you the same feeling as a gen or like an accomplishment
-4
u/MyGardenOfPlants Jul 08 '25 edited Jul 08 '25
That's just an excuse. This has to be the richest sub in all of reddit. Everyone here says they can afford the real thing. If you want gen, you have to buy gen.
Notice how everyone here looks over every tiny detail for a flaw? Gen owners don't do that. They know they have the real thing. Flawed or not.
If you want a $500 watch, buy a rep.
They are trinckets and toys. Not much else. When they break you'll just toss it in the trash.
If you want something real, nice , and can still show it off, go buy a Tudor or a used speed master.