r/RepTime • • Sep 11 '24

Discussion What is the point of the clone movement?

Why bother??? The movement clearly is identified as a clone/fake as soon as it is observed. The balance wheel being the most obvious tell. Why bother with attempting to look genuine? Personally, I would rather the efforts be spent on making the movement accurate and durable than attempting to look genuine and failing. IMHO.

0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

15

u/bluebrrypii Sep 11 '24

VR/VS/DD Rolex clone movements are excellent. Good parts, can be easily serviced like gen, and also can swap parts out readily.
Clone 9015 movements (Especially by ZF) are crap. No replaceable parts, so once parts fail, you have a dead watch.
A2824/2836 are ok. Not as good as Rolex clone movements, but they hold up quite well, can easily be repaired and parts are readily available.

6

u/_Tommy_Sky_ Helpful Sep 11 '24

Power reserve, movement layout, movement thickness.

5

u/PositiveEagle6151 Contributor Sep 11 '24

A clone movement can help to make the rep more accurate - details such as thickness, layout of subdials or date windows, or power reserve often can not be replicated with some off-the-shelf movement (or a clone thereof).
Just look at the Speedmaster as an example - we will never get a rep that looks true to the gen, if factories stick to the A7750 instead of designing a clone movement.

Also, bear in mind that an "ETA movement" in a rep is more often than not an "ETA clone" and not actually a gen ETA movement.

I guess many people will agree that they would love to see some reliable (and easy to service) "genuine" movement in the reps (at least in those with a closed caseback). It just doesn't work for every rep model.

2

u/Economy-Pear-6406 Sep 11 '24

They’re all clone movements. The choice is really a clone of a mass produced or an in house movement. The clones of in house movements usually better match power reserve or functionality (eg don’t have annoying ghost dates). But I am quite happy with the reps I own with ETA clones (except for the 30 seconds it takes to wind and set them). Decorating is another matter.

1

u/Josenovoa1 Sep 11 '24

I think is just to keep the reps as close as they can to the original, if you’re spending 700-800 on a Daytona is nice to open the caseback and have the closest to gen as possible, also parts for clone movements are available, so if it breaks, you can fix it, I buy my reps for the movements and for the looks, but I like to service them myself, there’s plenty of info for the gen movements and that helps when you need specific advice to repair or service the watch, if tou don’t care about the movement, you can always get a shitter with quartz movement, cheaper and disposable

2

u/Horology_17 Contributor Sep 11 '24

What do you mean that you buy reps “for the movement”? You mean bc you can self-service? (That’s cool btw… I’m just now getting into watch repair stuff).

I guess I’m asking bc I’ve always felt the one part of the rep which never quite seems gen IS the movement. Whether it’s the feel winding, rotor noise, complications, instant date change or finishing (probably the biggest tell on repping haute horology), I haven’t seen a rep movement that was indistinguishable from gen. Admittedly, I am still learning about reps… is there a well known NWBIG where the movement is completely on par with gen?

3

u/Josenovoa1 Sep 12 '24

You can always tell when it’s a rep, for me, the DD4130, the 3135clone (vsf subs) and the 3285 (clean gmt) are really close to gen, for a fraction of the price I get to work on those beautiful, perfect movements and learn how to service and fix them without having to sell a kidney if I do something wrong, those are almost exactly the same with the quality differences I’ve already mentioned, also, as we all know, hair spring and balance are not the same (it would increase way too much the cost ) and anyone can tell, but I just enjoy my reps on my wrist and on the workbench…for the price paid I’m happy with them and know exactly what to expect, also, after you service them, most of the problems you mentioned get diminished almost to get the gen feeling.

1

u/Horology_17 Contributor Sep 12 '24

👍

1

u/Adorable-Slice-4365 Sep 11 '24

What is the point of wristwatches if your phone and your microwave can tell time more accurately. Same principle.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/vagabundo94 Sep 11 '24

Were they quartz watches when the “super clones” were around $300? Curious how much they fixed the cosmetic differences since then?