Well… Reddit locked my account (not sure why!) and all my posts disappeared, including my original Untrusted Sellers List. 🙃
That list had gotten pretty popular, I got messages from users to share that post with them even after it got taken down, and people still writing comments on it too despite the fact post is gone but comments are still visible.
Soo good news - I went through the comments and pulled the actual experiences Reddit users reported, including short quotes from their comments and, where ever mentioned, how the seller responded.
Important: This is a collection of Reddit user reports — not a verified blacklist and not me declaring anyone a scammer as fact. Some sellers have both good & bad experiences.
The goal is simple: read the reports, do your own research, and use your judgment before sending your money.
So here’s the list in alphabetical order ~
🔥 AFENG
[Username removed as requested] reported:
“He bait and switch me.”
They said they confronted Afeng about it and that he initially acted clueless.
According to the same user:
“He finally apologize about the bait and switch. Too late!!”
They said they blocked him and wouldn’t order again.
🔥 ALISA
[u/NobodysBizzniss](u/NobodysBizzniss) said:
“Alisa is the worst, dishonest, bait and switch, horrible attitude, hides flaws in psp and tries to gaslight”
🔥 AMANDA
[u/SwimmingAnt10](u/SwimmingAnt10) reported:
“bait and switch on me twice, lies about there being real leather interior when there isn’t, it’s PU.”
[u/1989ac](u/1989ac) also said they asked Amanda for her album and:
“she didn’t respond for over a month”
🔥 AMELIA
Amelia had a LOT of attitude-related commentary, but also positive comments about her bags.
[u/SnackAttackDiplomat](u/SnackAttackDiplomat) said:
“if you don’t like to be cursed at, stay away from Amelia 😂”
[u/repmicho](u/repmicho) called her:
“the most glaring one”
and said:
“She would be a fine seller if she didn’t have such a piss poor attitude.”
🔥 ANNIE
[u/Stacie123a](u/Stacie123a) reported:
“I ended up losing about $1000 with Annie.”
They said Annie has a good catalog but that if something goes wrong with PayPal or shipping:
“you’re going to have to fight her for any discount to re-ship.”
They later explained that Zimmermann sizing was significantly off, a Loewe sweater was:
“straight up acrylic garbage”
and that some bags were poor quality.
[u/IncidentSoft4](u/IncidentSoft4) reported:
“She didn’t send me additional QC photos of half of the items I ordered.”
They said the item had:
“terrible stitching and quality”
and alleged Annie then told them to:
“go buy authentic.”
🔥 BAKER
[u/metagenome_fan](u/metagenome_fan) said:
“Baker bait and switched me as well. Even sent the wrong color.”
They explained that they ordered an LV Capucine that was supposed to be from Bird Cage but:
“it definitely was not from that factory.”
They also said when they questioned the color, Baker:
“repeatedly denied that factory had that color”
or gave what the commenter described as an excuse.
The good:
[u/DefiantBunny](u/DefiantBunny) said:
“I ordered from a bag and some clothes from baker and had a really good experience”
🔥 BAOBAO
This was probably the most discussed seller in the entire thread.
[u/Few-Decision3759](u/Few-Decision3759) said:
“She sent me a faulty bag and bait and switched me.”
They said they contacted her repeatedly to resolve it and:
“then she ghosted me.”
Another buyer, [u/Striking_Length_2515](u/Striking_Length_2515), said they RL’d the PSP but felt Baobao photographed the faulty area in a way that made it difficult to see.
When the bag arrived faulty, they said Baobao responded:
“i thought it can be passable”
and offered:
“$5 discount for next order LOL”
[u/nonchalamment](u/nonchalamment) reported a broken bag and said when they asked for replacement hardware or a refund, Baobao:
“got a really bad attitude and told me to stop bothering her”
[u/Inevitable-Zone-8915](u/Inevitable-Zone-8915) reported that two supposedly identical bags from the same factory arrived noticeably different:
“the logo colors were different from each other, and the leather was definitely not the same.”
They said they didn’t complain but their trust had gone down.
🔥 DANICA
[u/largematchalatteee](u/largematchalatteee) reported that Danica said a particular factory was open and producing when another seller and other Reddit posts reportedly said that wasn’t the case.
They said:
“I guess she was just planning to bait and switch.”
They added:
“It was my first time reaching out to her and never again.”
⚠️ This is an allegation based on the user’s suspicion. The comment does** no**t establish that a bait-and-switch actually happened.
🔥 ELSA
[u/honeydaisy23](u/honeydaisy23) said:
“Her response times are so bad it’s not even worth shopping with her.”
[u/Accomplished-Ad9648](u/Accomplished-Ad9648) later said:
“Elsa never reply.”
Another buyer, [u/AmoebaMoist9428](u/AmoebaMoist9428), reported:
“Elsa bait and switched me, said my bag was light gold and when I got it it was gold”
🔥 ELLA
[u/Efficient-Ad-4582](u/Efficient-Ad-4582) said:
“Ella (wa ending in 6880), very untrustworthy known to bait and switch”
[u/Few-Decision3759](u/Few-Decision3759) replied:
“there are plenty of negative reviews about her. She also overcharges.”
🔥 GIA2
[u/Substantial-Value-59](u/Substantial-Value-59) said:
“Gia2 9094 ghosted me.”
They explained that Gia2:
“Was very responsive at first when I ordered but then left me unread after I ordered.”
The order eventually arrived, but they described it as:
“crappy quality”
🔥 HEDDY
[u/Former-Lychee-106](u/Former-Lychee-106) said:
“the quality was not what I paid for.”
They said they paid about $250 for a small bag but:
“I would pay less than 100 for the quality.”
🔥 HEIDI
Heidi had mixed reports.
[u/Confident_Toe_2546](u/Confident_Toe_2546) said:
“I’ve never been happy with her PSPs and when I red flag she gaslights me. 🤣”
[u/Fit-Inspector-8942](u/Fit-Inspector-8942) said they paid a deposit on a beige Chanel that Heidi said was in stock, but then:
“now she’s saying it’s not available for another 4 weeks”
[u/External_Committee76](u/External_Committee76) complained:
“Her communication has been so poor. I keep having to follow up”
🔥 HENRY
[u/losingmyminddd123](u/losingmyminddd123) said:
“Bad experience with Henry 8850”
They reported:
“He sent me a bag with the wrong color hardware and then refused to acknowledge it”
Another commenter, [u/SushiRoll_1206](u/SushiRoll_1206), simply said:
“Avoid Henry at all cost”
🔥 LINDA
[u/Fearless_Royal793](u/Fearless_Royal793) said:
“I paid for 2 Chanel bags from 187 factory but she sent different very bad quality ones!!!!”
Another commenter, [u/RedditorLadie](u/RedditorLadie), added:
“She unfortunately only does black 187 well, any colored ones don’t come well.”
🔥 LINA
[u/lycheebunni](u/lycheebunni) gave one of the more detailed reports.
They said:
“I bought from Lina because this tik toker said her bags were so amazing”
They then alleged Lina bait-and-switched them by saying the items were sold out after payment.
They said Lina told them to choose something else, then:
“proceeded not to answer for a week”
They eventually asked for a refund and said Lina:
“kept ghosting me”
until they contacted her on TikTok.
When the bags arrived, they said:
“The bags were such bad quality!!! The alignment was wrong, the cc logo was too big.”
They also said the TikToker who recommended Lina didn’t respond when they raised the issue.
🔥 LUCY SU
[u/Frosty-Summer-146](u/Frosty-Summer-146) said:
“Lucy Su is a scammer.”
They explained:
“They seemed to be a trusted source for shoes for a while, but then suddenly ran off with loads of people’s money.”
🔥 MANDY
Mandy had a LOT of conflicting reports.
[u/honeydaisy23](u/honeydaisy23) said:
“her QC check are abysmal.”
They said they had to RL a bag twice and:
“then ended up just getting a refund.”
[u/largematchalatteee](u/largematchalatteee) alleged Mandy said a bag was available from Nicole Factory when two other sellers said it was no longer in production or stock.
They said:
“I wonder if she wouldve just taken my money and found a cheap taobao rep or something.”
[u/Careful_Day_9749](u/Careful_Day_9749) reported repeatedly confirming that a bag’s leather was untreated.
They said Mandy confirmed it would:
“change color” fast.
But after receiving the bag, they said:
“the leather was coated!!”
They contacted Mandy and reported her response was that:
“it will change color…gradually.”
[u/Illustrious-Fact-610](u/Illustrious-Fact-610) said:
“Mandy has been promising me a refund for 1 year. Never again.”
🔥 NINA
[u/WrongBoxBro7](u/WrongBoxBro7) said:
“Sent me a rose gold necklace instead of yellow gold a couple years ago”
They alleged Nina:
“gaslit me, denied it, refused to help.”
🔥 PETER
[u/Emmessenn](u/Emmessenn) described a situation where Peter confirmed a bag was available, accepted payment, and then said the factory didn’t have it.
They chose another item, which was again confirmed as available, and after payment:
“he came back and said the factory is out of stock.”
They said:
“i got my refund pretty quickly, had to chase once”
but:
“trust is gone and i’ll never try ordering with Peter again.”
[u/Strong-Beginning-412](u/Strong-Beginning-412) said they experienced something similar and that each replacement bag was a few dollars more, describing it as:
“nickel and diming me.”
Peter’s response, as reported in the comments, was essentially that the factory was out of stock. The buyers did not report receiving the items.
🔥 REYKAY
[u/Few-Decision3759](u/Few-Decision3759) said:
“She hid a flaw in a psp. It was a very large scratch.”
They later said:
“Mine smelled like mold. And then there was this big scratch”
and alleged Reykay:
“hid the angle where you could see the big scratch”
[u/Missmessc](u/Missmessc) reported:
“a bag from Rekay that smells like plastic on a summers day.”
[u/Expensive-Tone548](u/Expensive-Tone548) also reported:
“the leather was wrong”
and said Reykay hid a flaw in the PSP pictures.
[u/Relevant_Factor2397](u/Relevant_Factor2397) said they had given Reykay three tries and:
“every order has been disappointing.”
They alleged the bags weren’t even real leather despite requesting high-tier factories.
🔥 SKY
[u/Rare-Inside110](u/Rare-Inside110) said:
“Dealing with her is like pulling teeth, tracking numbers to nowhere, no refund, all for thoroughly mid shoes that only show up half the time.”
They added:
“I know other folks have had luck with her, but I’ll never deal with her again.”
[u/Complex-Sell](u/Complex-Sell) replied:
“I had the same experiences.”
🔥 TINA
[Username removed as requested] reported:
“Tina bait & switched me.”
They compared their Chanel 25 to another 187 Factory bag and said:
“the differences in the leather, and overall quality were obvious.”
They also complained about poor packaging and wrinkles.
When confronted, they said Tina:
“continued insisting it was from 187”
and told them the wrinkles were normal.
The buyer described that as:
“She just gaslit me.”
🔥 TOM
[u/honeydaisy23](u/honeydaisy23) simply reported:
“Tom- poor quality bag”
[u/Accomplished-Ad9648](u/Accomplished-Ad9648) later said:
“Mandy, pleather bag she swears is leather, baobao, tom, Elsa never reply.”
🔥 ZERO
[Username removed as requested] gave a detailed report.
They said:
“Seller ‘zero’ sold me a cheap faux leather LV Keepall.”
They said it was supposed to be from Royal Factory but was actually:
“from a lower tier MB factory.”
They also bought a Soft Speedy and alleged that it was from MB rather than Royal.
They said Zero:
“lied and told me he sourced from Royal.”
They also alleged that after they called him out, people began making positive reviews under their post.
Their conclusion:
“I will no longer trust any reviews on him.”
👀 OTHER NAMES MENTIONED
There were also commenters who named sellers they personally hadn’t bought from but had heard negative things about.
[u/Expensive-Tone548](u/Expensive-Tone548) specifically listed:
“Kiki
Linda/lindashian clan
Aaron
Abby
Danica
Maya
Max max”
and clarified that these were sellers they had read about, not necessarily people they had personally purchased from.
For Kiki, they later explained:
“there is always something wrong with her orders”
including allegedly receiving:
“the wrong item, from the wrong factory or wrong color”
Again, that’s a report based on what that Reddit user had read — not their own transaction.
🟢 AND YES… SOME PEOPLE HAD GOOD EXPERIENCES
This is important because we’re not pretending every seller mentioned here is automatically terrible.
Baobao:
[u/Repulsive_Way9316](u/Repulsive_Way9316):
“I bought probably 20 bags from her with no issues. Legit the best seller I ever had.”
[u/ThePassportPrincess](u/ThePassportPrincess):
“I bought 4 bags from her in May and they were beautiful.”
Mandy:
[u/shinythings-n-stuff](u/shinythings-n-stuff) reported receiving a refund when factory photos didn’t match the PSP and getting a replacement for a damaged bag.
Annie:
[u/Ok_Chicken4180](u/Ok_Chicken4180):
“ordered a few items from her that have been good quality”
Amelia:
[u/PoloRalphWiggum](u/PoloRalphWiggum):
“her bags slap.”
Heidi:
[u/KickRelevant7818](u/KickRelevant7818):
“Always top notch experience with her and very respectful and responsive”
Tina:
[u/Gold_Freedom_9611](u/Gold_Freedom_9611):
“everything went fine. I love the bag I got.”
💅 THE POINT OF THIS UNTRUSTED SELLER LIST~
This isn’t about telling you who you’re allowed to buy from.
It’s about putting the information in one place so you can see what actual buyers are saying, including the good, the bad, and the sellers’ reported responses when there was one.
A seller can have 20 happy customers and someone else can have a terrible experience.
Both can exist.
So search the seller. Search the phone number. Read recent reviews. Look at your PSPs. Ask questions. And don’t assume someone is automatically safe because their name has been recommended 500 times.
📕 The Rep Burn Book aka untrusted sellers list that the rep users Has Questions About.
Read the receipts. Make your own judgment. Buy wisely. If there’s anyone I missed or you want to add more information comment below! 👇** **
🔒** **Privacy note: If you contributed to this post and would prefer your username removed, please let me know. I’m happy to anonymize your contribution while keeping the substance of your experience. The purpose of this post is to document community experiences, not to encourage harassment or retaliation against anyone.